Cellphone Alert System Announced in NYC

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Alright, I know you guys are going to have an opinion on this one. What do you think, good or bad idea and why?

There will be three levels of messages, ranging from a critical national alert from the president to warnings about impending or occurring national disasters to alerts about missing or abducted children. People will be able to opt out of receiving all but the presidential alerts, Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski said.
 
Only if it is a free message that doesn't take away from limited messaging plans then I see no reason why this would be a bad idea. But people will still complain anyways.

+1 vote for me. A lot of people have a cell phone in this day and age and being able to get news out quickly and more effectively for disasters may save people's lives.
 
+1 good idea, it saved a lot of lives in Japan. We can learn from that at least, if nothing else.
 
-10 What does this system cost to set up, what about the costs of use, upgrade and the cost of maintaining the service, and where are they getting the money to ensure it's funded properly, also given the horrible state of New York's finances, I really can't see the justification for spending more money for what really seems to be a system of limited use and impact.

More spending on things that aren't needed.
 
This seems to be of limited use for all but natural disasters and other short-notice emergencies. Otherwise, who's going to be glued to their phone for Amanda Alerts? (IDK what the real name is, forgot) Natural disasters aren't a bad idea, though. Something like "Tsunami, get to high ground!" could be a life-saver.
 
This seems to be of limited use for all but natural disasters and other short-notice emergencies. Otherwise, who's going to be glued to their phone for Amanda Alerts? (IDK what the real name is, forgot) Natural disasters aren't a bad idea, though. Something like "Tsunami, get to high ground!" could be a life-saver.

Well, the theory is that you'd notice your phone ringing as much as you would for any other call or text message. Which is probably a heck of a lot more these days than say the emergency broadcast system on radio/TV (wuite possibly much more coverage during the average work day).

Of even more benefit, is that if it is done right, the granularity for a geographically specific message is one cell tower as opposed to the broadcast area of a radio or tv station.

From a technical standpoint, it could be a nice solution. However, the EBS has been around my entire life, and I can recall it being actually useful about twice. Granted, I don't live in an area prone to tornadoes or other common dangerous weather.
 
I would think they could reuse the spectrum that pagers used to use and those things ran forever on one triple a battery and I am pretty sure the infrastructure to support pagers back then wasn't to expensive to maintain.

I would like to see the option to turn the chip off completely though. Not being able to disable it would annoy people.

Also politicians could misuse this which should get them sent to jail. (Vote for ME!)

Not a bad concept if they get the details right then pretty cool stuff.
 
I think there will be an app that will kill this quickly , it is great for emergency situations , but how long till its infringed appon and other shit gets opted in...one more step in forced media...cant ever get away.
 
I see no need for this. Are there benefits? Sure. But I am adamantly opposed to any increased linking of our lives with the government. While I'm not a tin-foil-hatter who believes that the intent of this is malicious, this type of thinking will lead us down a path we probably shouldn't be going down.

I'm curious as to what "chip" they are referring to, that's supposed to be mandated on phones to enable this. I had assumed GPS for location-based alerts, but the article isn't specific enough.

Also, you can't really compare this to the TV or radio alerts as those are not linked with your personal information. If this were a pager device that you could purchase anonymously and receive updates based on location, then it'd be cool, but linking directly with your phone is where it becomes questionable.

Finally, never trust the government. EVER. "The chips will not allow government agencies to collect information about the phones' users." Yeah, I'm sure.
 
Since I don't have a text messaging plan, does this mean I'll be charged for each "alert" ?

Does this mean that the government will be able to override the block I have on text messages ?

How long until the these "alerts" start having a political spin put on them ?
 
man theres a lot of paranoid people on here lol

Miami-Dade County has had a text messaging alert system for a couple years now, I have only maybe gotten 2 texts from them in the past 4 years, one was a tropical storm warning and the other was a severe thunderstorm warning...
 
As the poster above said, a lot of paranoid people. If you really want to be paranoid, realize that current phones allow the microphone to be turned on remotely without your knowning. Current phones can be traced by their ESN already. Current phones allow the government to drop in on your call thats being broadcast.

This is a good idea that could save lives. I'm suprised this wasn't done sooner. I sure as hell would like to know ASAP if there was a natural or terrorist disaster in my town and how to avoid/survive it.
 
New Tom Clancy novel:

Terrorists hack into the SMS alert system, warning residents of an impending attack and letting telling them to move to a specific "safe" area. Guess the rest.

Seriously though, although it's a bit tinfoil hat, I hope there would be decent security around this. A fake message could cause a huge amount of panic and disruption.
 
as long as it is only used for severe emergencies it will be ok. think of the public service thing on TV. pretty much only gets used for bad weather. as local TV fades away, cell phones are the largest medium.
 
I would like to note that the system here requires you to opt-in (submit your phone # on a webpage), seems the system they are proposing uses your location... which I will admit is kinda scary...
 
-10 What does this system cost to set up, what about the costs of use, upgrade and the cost of maintaining the service, and where are they getting the money to ensure it's funded properly, also given the horrible state of New York's finances, I really can't see the justification for spending more money for what really seems to be a system of limited use and impact.

More spending on things that aren't needed.

Most likely, it could be easily added to the current emergency alert system. A phone call to the tower owners and they send out a SMS to everyone connected. I am sure that money will change hands on this, but, it is actually something that provides benefit to the taxpayers. Much of what politicians do benefits a tiny minority. This would benefit the majority. Not all tax spending is bad, just most of it. ;)

I do agree, that it should prolly be something they hold off on until they get the state's finances in order though.
 
Your phone already knows where you are because it's maintaining a connection to your service provider's network "cell".

I'd appreciate this service if it had a chance to warn me about impending dangers, as long as it remains free of abuse.

"Tsunami inbound ETA 4 hrs, evacuate to Ontario"
...
"JK LOL"
 
Speaking as a new yorker, my opinion on this matter depends on one critical thing...

Can I text it back and get a response?
 
Most likely, it could be easily added to the current emergency alert system. A phone call to the tower owners and they send out a SMS to everyone connected. I am sure that money will change hands on this, but, it is actually something that provides benefit to the taxpayers. Much of what politicians do benefits a tiny minority. This would benefit the majority. Not all tax spending is bad, just most of it. ;)

Yeah this something I immediately thought they would employ. Doesn't make sense to create another whole new system when you have something similar in place already. Plus, just like with the EAS system in place now, it shouldn't cost much of anything to maintain.
 
I think it's rather smart, at least for geographical based alerts, as long as it's used together with local landlines too. The radio EBS signal is rather useless today.

Not sure what the Amber alerts are for, or rather how useful, and I don't see why the president should have a right to send a message at his level. At this level, I'm sure he can achieve much more with the current TV special broadcasts, and in way more (needed) details than a phone call. A broadcast for a single type of practical alert should be more than enough, anything else is just paranoia from watching too many American TV series...
 
The initial idea sounds great, but we all know how our great governmental system is. Will it be abused? I'm about 98% positive it would. oBUMa are attention seekers, without it they'll shrivel up and die off.
The government will do this and hackers/programmers will find a way to turn it off. Then the cycle will start over. People will be rooting their phones just to get rid of that one annoying thing (if it can be turned off during a root).

I have the amber alert on my phone. I get a txt message if a child is abducted within so many miles away from my current location. I do have the option to shut it off if I wanted to and this cellphone alert system should be the same way. If I want to turn it off, I should be able to FULLY turn it off to receive no alerts. Doubt that will happen though.
 
Doesn't sound bad.. but I'm afraid it could turn into one of those "America's Most Wanted" type of scenario, where everyone within an area where a suspect is deemed to be possibly hiding gets an SMS with a picture and stats. I don't know, but doesn't sound improbable.

There is however value in knowing when a kid is abducted in your area, or that an earthquake is coming, or that a tornado is descending or even if there is a guy on the subway, with a mystery box, holding hostages.

I think we'll have to see it in execution to really make up our minds... too many unknowns.
 
Presidential Alert: Be sure to drink your Ovaltine.

Son of a bitch.


I don't like it. I wouldn't mind seeing an opt-in alert system, but nothing forced. Why can't people just go about their lives without someone trying to invade their personal space.

I like my bubble, and I don't like others in it.
 
I find it to be a logical, and needed, addition to the EMS we already have in place.

I dont have a TV or radio (except internet radio with no EMS). Being able to recieve EMS alerts could save more then my life.

I've heard the EMS activate for other then a test a total of once in my life. Tornado in the Ca Bay Area that never touched ground. Was still good to know to avoid the area and/or seek shelter.
 
New Tom Clancy novel:

Terrorists hack into the SMS alert system, warning residents of an impending attack and letting telling them to move to a specific "safe" area. Guess the rest.

Seriously though, although it's a bit tinfoil hat, I hope there would be decent security around this. A fake message could cause a huge amount of panic and disruption.

Well, the current Emergency Alert System seems to be doing just fine security wise, so I don't see why this would be any different. Its not like theres a central hub running an unpatched version of windows server 2003 or something.
 
Well, the current Emergency Alert System seems to be doing just fine security wise, so I don't see why this would be any different. Its not like theres a central hub running an unpatched version of windows server 2003 or something.

the current EMS system is kinda useless for me. Though amount of time my OTA TV spends watching antenna TV is rather minimal. Radio is a bit more useful, but as of late, nothing good has been on the radio, so I don't even leave that on...
 
the current EMS system is kinda useless for me. Though amount of time my OTA TV spends watching antenna TV is rather minimal. Radio is a bit more useful, but as of late, nothing good has been on the radio, so I don't even leave that on...

You are not alone in not watching OTA or even listening much to the radio, which is prolly why they are pushing this.
The EAS was/is a good idea, and extending it to cell phones does makes sense. If it is used in the same way the current EAS is, then I have little issue with this. I have never seen or heard of any abuses of the EAS.
An opt out would be nice, but would defeat the purpose of the system. Warning the most number of people they can about immediate dangers to their safety from storms, earthquakes, tsunamis, acts of war, etc.. Besides, just like the TV and radios alerts, you can always ignore them, or turn off the device relaying them to you.
 
In New York City, riders on the subways — the target of speculation and multiple terrorist plots over the years — won't be able to receive the alerts, at least for now.

Well, that kinda defeats the purpose (for the national threat portion). Those who would probably want this the most would be those riding the subways. I know solving this issue is not an easy one on either end (carrier and NYC), but it's definitely an issue if you're going to implement a force opt-in for all your citizens.
 
You don't need personal alerts in a subway or any public infrastructure equipped with thousands of speakers, you'll get any warning collectively.
This new system is not replacing but complementing the existing measures, to make sure as much people as possible, even people outside a public area or not listening to radio/TV, will get the alert.
 
Well, the theory is that you'd notice your phone ringing as much as you would for any other call or text message. Which is probably a heck of a lot more these days than say the emergency broadcast system on radio/TV (wuite possibly much more coverage during the average work day).

How much is the ESB even used? Now thats a program that could possibly be replaced by this. the EBS didnt even issue an alert on 9/11. If there was ever a time the ESB should have issued an alert shouldnt it have been then?

wiki:
During the September 11 attacks in 2001, "... the EAS was not activated nationally or regionally in New York or Washington during the terrorist attacks on the nation.
 
I will oppose any and all new programs until we get a balanced budget amendment to the constitution.

It is time to restore fiscal sanity to this country.
We simply do not have the $$ to pay for this, no matter how good the idea may seem.
 
Back
Top