15 Web Browsers Tested and Benchmarked

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The fellas at Legit Reviews have gathered up 15 web browsers and pit them against one another in what can be best described as a "browser benchmarking battle royal!"

We hope this testing helped you out and helped you learn or discover something you didn't know about web browsers before reading this. Our testing shows that in all of the benchmarks except for one that the fastest Microsoft Windows based browser is once again Google Chrome. Chrome 11 is the fastest public web browser and Chrome 12 is the fastest beta web browser that you can download today to use today
 
Benchmarking browsers: About as useful as benchmarking motherboards?

Chrome is pretty impressive, though...
 
I stopped worrying about browser speed way back when I got my 15mbps (now 25mbps) Comcast cable internet and my Phenom II x3 720 and 4GB RAM.

If browser speed is something you're still looking into, perhaps it's time to upgrade your computer and/or internet.
 
I stopped worrying about browser speed way back when I got my 15mbps (now 25mbps) Comcast cable internet and my Phenom II x3 720 and 4GB RAM.

If browser speed is something you're still looking into, perhaps it's time to upgrade your computer and/or internet.

But...but...I need my browser to be able to get 60FPS in Microsoft's Fish Tank!
 
But...but...I need my browser to be able to get 60FPS in Microsoft's Fish Tank!

lol

I will say this though: Firefox needs to fix their browser's slow start-up on cold boot. 20+ seconds is a little ridiculous. But once you get it to start the first time, it's fine for the duration of your computer being on.
 
Am I the only one who found opera performing neck and neck with the best amusing since still no one cares about opera? :p

All things considered, this was amusing information at best. No real need to benchmark browsers on todays computers tbh. That said, I use three browsers myself and it is based on how they feel for the task.

Chrome - General web browsing/forum posting. Gives me adblock and gmail extensions and generally feels smoother in my day to day browsing stuff.

Firefox 4.0 - Web streaming since I watch quite a bit of Sc2 streaming and such. Reason being its adblock does a better job of eliminating video ads. I don't mind allowing a few ads to support the website/streamer, but when ads pop up mid battle there is nothing more irritating. I am a big fan of JustinTV now since they streamer can choose ad time and good ones Do so between matches. Also on Android because it Rocks the Hell out of that crappy default one.

IE - For basically the few shitty work sites I am forced to use because their IT staff are lazy retards.
 
How could they not compare CPU utilization and memory consumption? Compared to how fast browsers load a page, these are far more significant. Not to mention how page load times are affected by either of these things.
 
How could they not compare CPU utilization and memory consumption? Compared to how fast browsers load a page, these are far more significant. Not to mention how page load times are affected by either of these things.
That's a good point. Browsing should be something you can do while waiting for that encode to finish.
 
How could they not compare CPU utilization and memory consumption? Compared to how fast browsers load a page, these are far more significant. Not to mention how page load times are affected by either of these things.

Because unless you have a completely crap computer, no browser uses enough of either to make any difference.

"Oh Noes, my browser is using up 100mb of my 8000mb of ram..What ever will I do? ;)
 
Because unless you have a completely crap computer, no browser uses enough of either to make any difference.

"Oh Noes, my browser is using up 100mb of my 8000mb of ram..What ever will I do? ;)

Because I typically have 100 windows open on my crap laptop, and each of them have scripts running, flash, ads, etc. And in the background I typically have 2 virtual machines running and some other software, typically just under 4gb. And battery life is important. And responsiveness is important. etc.
 
Clearly you've never been to www.droiddoes.com

Nope, but just went there on this mediocre laptop.

4gb of ram, dual core pentium.

Running Grooveshark
Outlook 2010
One Note
Chrome with 5 tabs including that.
Google calendar sync
Rainmeter etc etc

Still only using 57% of my ram, no noticeable performance loss. Again, if I wanted to scrutinize every bit of ram, sure that site is extremely heavy at 400mb. That said, I didn't buy hardware to have it idle.
 
Because unless you have a completely crap computer, no browser uses enough of either to make any difference.

"Oh Noes, my browser is using up 100mb of my 8000mb of ram..What ever will I do? ;)

Oh Noes, my computer costs $2000 that I use to browse one web page at a time with. If only there was an android site capable of making that investment count for something....
 
Because I typically have 100 windows open on my crap laptop, and each of them have scripts running, flash, ads, etc. And in the background I typically have 2 virtual machines running and some other software, typically just under 4gb. And battery life is important. And responsiveness is important. etc.

I have worked on a fairly simple philosophy for years when it comes to computers. I use a computer until I am regularly maxing out its capability. When the work I need to get done, is clearly greater then the capability of the machine I am working on, then it is time to upgrade. I know people would love to continue using that 10 year old pos, but really at a point you have to realize progress moves forward, not backward. There is a reason why in business the lifecycle of client hardware in a properly run environment is no more then 5 years. It being realistically 3 years before being rotated to a lower demand task for 2 years until it is phased out.

So if you really are running that much, then I am afraid you are long overdue for an upgrade my man. If it is for work, then your work should be providing said upgrade. Perhaps a little documentation to show your workload needs vs the hardware capability to the bean counters is in order. Either way, the web browser is a minor thing at best and a heacy website is a heavy website in all browsers.

Droid does example..
Chrome 80mb, I was wrong earlier that was grooveshark at 400mb.
Firefox 4 - 79mb
IE 8 - 81mb

so..a variation of 2 mb between in Ram usage.
Cpu utilization - 0-5% when the active window and using that site...Again..Well believe what you want. I see no reason to continue arguing this. There isn't an argument to begin with. Use what you feel suits your tasks better, honestly it is just that simple.
 
I have worked on a fairly simple philosophy for years when it comes to computers. I use a computer until I am regularly maxing out its capability. When the work I need to get done, is clearly greater then the capability of the machine I am working on, then it is time to upgrade. I know people would love to continue using that 10 year old pos, but really at a point you have to realize progress moves forward, not backward. There is a reason why in business the lifecycle of client hardware in a properly run environment is no more then 5 years. It being realistically 3 years before being rotated to a lower demand task for 2 years until it is phased out.

So if you really are running that much, then I am afraid you are long overdue for an upgrade my man. If it is for work, then your work should be providing said upgrade. Perhaps a little documentation to show your workload needs vs the hardware capability to the bean counters is in order. Either way, the web browser is a minor thing at best and a heacy website is a heavy website in all browsers.

Droid does example..
Chrome 80mb, I was wrong earlier that was grooveshark at 400mb.
Firefox 4 - 79mb
IE 8 - 81mb

so..a variation of 2 mb between in Ram usage.
Cpu utilization - 0-5% when the active window and using that site...Again..Well believe what you want. I see no reason to continue arguing this. There isn't an argument to begin with. Use what you feel suits your tasks better, honestly it is just that simple.

Well, I upgrade when it's clear that only new hardware will accomplish what I need. Before upgrading, I take a look to see how it can be done through efficiency, and this is usually a practical option.

For example, the way I use FF wastes a ton of memory (and some CPU), because I keep one window open for each project or "topic" and each one might have 20 tabs of material I'm using. In this case, a tab manager might reduce FF's footprint by a gig or so, if I could find one I liked. OR MAYBE browser that can minimize waste of memory and CPU effectively (like opera and chrome) would be nice, but I prefer using FF.

So, having a ton of windows multiplies the nominal CPU utilization that you're quoting, and the time spent waiting when it's pegged. And like I said, I also have some heavy softwarezes running at the same time. I'm not about to plunk down another $2k for a beefier laptop when I can make that same order of magnitude difference with tweaks, or know-how.
 
If browser speed is something you're still looking into, perhaps it's time to upgrade your computer and/or internet.

WRONG!

I don't care if you have the freaking McLaren of supercomputers, IE8 is the biggest pile of steaming code MS ever produced. It's horridly slow even on fast systems.
 
Nice benchmarks on Chrome but can anyone explain why Chrome always shows me broke image icons? I don't use any extensions or addons.
 
WRONG!

I don't care if you have the freaking McLaren of supercomputers, IE8 is the biggest pile of steaming code MS ever produced. It's horridly slow even on fast systems.

Perhaps I should also add "on a clean non-spyware and searchbar infested computer" because there's nothing wrong with IE8 on any computers I've ever installed for my company and family.
 
Web browser speed generally isn't an issue. Though I have to admit, earlier FireFox releases were extremely bad. Nowadays, you're not going to worry about it.

#1 Is there anything noticeable slow about the browser, especially with specific web pages? My favorite site to test this is WoWInsider, as it can really suck in a huge amount of CPU and memory. Especially if you aren't ad blocking. Though, this is largely useless since most web browsers have moved away from being totally shit.

#2 How's the compatibility? Some sites don't work correctly in FireFox, but do in Internet Explorer. Despite what Acid3 says, more web sites tend to work with IE.

#3 How's the plugins? Probably the only reason I stick with FireFox is for the plugins. Besides Chrome, no other web browsers have plugins. Chrome's plugins isn't as refined as FireFox's either.

#4 Cross platform experience. I like how FireFox is on everything, but the kitchen sink. It makes it easy to transition from a Windows machine, to a Mac, to Ubuntu, and even my Android cell phone. Even the plugins work! Too bad very few browsers do this.
 
Perhaps I should also add "on a clean non-spyware and searchbar infested computer" because there's nothing wrong with IE8 on any computers I've ever installed for my company and family.

There's nothing wrong with it, but it's certainly not something I'd want. In the past, I'd get viruses and spyware just from visiting websites. Not sure how it is today with IE, but I was very happy to move onto another web browser to avoid that. Then there's the lack of features, and plugins. It makes me feel like I took back control of the web.
 
Perhaps I should also add "on a clean non-spyware and searchbar infested computer" because there's nothing wrong with IE8 on any computers I've ever installed for my company and family.

WRONG! Try again.

We'll have to agree to disagree. Even the benchies bear this out which I knew well before they did the shootout. IE8 sucks - badly.
 
lol

I will say this though: Firefox needs to fix their browser's slow start-up on cold boot. 20+ seconds is a little ridiculous. But once you get it to start the first time, it's fine for the duration of your computer being on.

Mine starts up nearly instantly even after a cold boot. It starts up within 6 seconds on my old Athlon XP 1600+.
 
WRONG!

I don't care if you have the freaking McLaren of supercomputers, IE8 is the biggest pile of steaming code MS ever produced. It's horridly slow even on fast systems.

Come on dude, it's still far better than IE 6. A steaming pile of shit though it may be...the BIGGEST? I don't think so. That title belongs to IE 6. And it always will.
 
Come on dude, it's still far better than IE 6. A steaming pile of shit though it may be...the BIGGEST? I don't think so. That title belongs to IE 6. And it always will.

I don't know. IE6 seemed to work pretty well for the time. I remember two from MS I did not like. 4.01 and 8. I think the others felt more responsive. Course, no, I wouldn't recommend 6 now.
 
It makes me happy that IE9 is now minimum performance for modern browsers.
 
I don't know. IE6 seemed to work pretty well for the time. I remember two from MS I did not like. 4.01 and 8. I think the others felt more responsive. Course, no, I wouldn't recommend 6 now.

Well the problem with that is that IE 6 is still in use, as old as it is. And it has no support for tabs.

I stand by the fact that IE 6 is by far the worst. At least IE 8 has sandboxing in Windows 7.
 
I was hoping it was going to be about mobile browsers. Let's bench browsers in the low ram, low cpu power arena where it actually matters some.
 
But...but...I need my browser to be able to get 60FPS in Microsoft's Fish Tank!

Heh, yeah....about that:

IE_fish.jpg
 
I use all three major browsers ever single day, but....

Here's what sucks about Chrome...with only a single instance of Chrome open...this is what you see in your task manager:

chrome_wtf.gif
 
I use all three major browsers ever single day, but....

Here's what sucks about Chrome...with only a single instance of Chrome open...this is what you see in your task manager:

chrome_wtf.gif

That's what happens when you split everything into its own process. Be prepared to see that in Firefox in version 7 or so. Perhaps later. They've been working on Electrolysis for years now, but it got implemented first in the Fennec mobile browser due to being more important for performance enhancements on the weaker hardware.
 
Big news from microsoft...
They haven't found a security flaw in Internet Explorer for at least two days now.
 
Web browser speed generally isn't an issue. Though I have to admit, earlier FireFox releases were extremely bad. Nowadays, you're not going to worry about it.

#1 Is there anything noticeable slow about the browser, especially with specific web pages? My favorite site to test this is WoWInsider, as it can really suck in a huge amount of CPU and memory. Especially if you aren't ad blocking. Though, this is largely useless since most web browsers have moved away from being totally shit.

#2 How's the compatibility? Some sites don't work correctly in FireFox, but do in Internet Explorer. Despite what Acid3 says, more web sites tend to work with IE.

#3 How's the plugins? Probably the only reason I stick with FireFox is for the plugins. Besides Chrome, no other web browsers have plugins. Chrome's plugins isn't as refined as FireFox's either.

#4 Cross platform experience. I like how FireFox is on everything, but the kitchen sink. It makes it easy to transition from a Windows machine, to a Mac, to Ubuntu, and even my Android cell phone. Even the plugins work! Too bad very few browsers do this.

and those things like wot, no-script and add block in opera is what?
 
Big news from microsoft...
They haven't found a security flaw in Internet Explorer for at least two days now.

Trollin', trollin', trollin', keep them doggies trollin, makin' up pure lies!

It's only been two hours!:D
 
Back
Top