spacing guild
[H]ard|Gawd
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2010
- Messages
- 1,356
I have more respect for Star Trek than Star Wars because it's a more intelligent and thoughtful series. Star Wars is about titilating the imagination - lightsabers and golden cities and space battles - whereas Star Trek is about serious human issues that just happen to be set in space.
Star Wars obviously has the vaguely Christian notions embedded in dark side versus light side but that plays no deep role in anything, just a backdrop for a father-son story in the movies.
Father-Son conflict is one of the deepest themes of human existence. Titan myths about Uranus, Cronus (his son) and Zeus (the son of Cronus) who ascend to power by conquest over their fathers are early examples. Star Wars also contains deep themes concerning Joseph Campbell's Monomyth, which describes the path of the hero...from Moses to Neo, all heroes follow a similar, singular path:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monomyth
The Allegory of the Cave from Plato's Republic is the inspiration for Luke's "descent into the cave" to confront Darth Vader...
Padme Amidala is modeled after Dido from The Aeneid.
Lucas even borrowed from Triumph of the Will...although Nazi propaganda, it's recognized as a master work of movie making.
Star Wars also uses other Greek and Roman mythology...the warrior being told by a sage that something bad will happen..and despite the hero's best effort, that thing comes true...which begs the question...if the hero wasn't told of it, would it still have occurred? If Cronus wasn't told one of his children would usurp his power (he began eating his children)
would there still be a Zeus wishing to defeat his father? Would Padme have died if Anakin didn't fear she would? Prompting Yoda's line: "Let go of those you fear to lose."
I could go on and on about the subject.
But I dig Star Trek, also. Deals with everyday human issues...sometimes epic. I miss Q lol.
But Star Wars was specifically designed to be sweeping and epic...sacrificing some of the human element for the big picture.
Um, that's all I have to say about that lol.