File Sharing Doesn’t Deter Artists From Making Music

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A new report says that file sharing does NOT deter artists from making music. That being said, if you do continue to use P2 for your *cough*Linux distros *cough*, remember to support your favorite artist by buying their music if you like it. :)

Further proof that the recording industry’s oft-repeated claims of the downfall of the entire music industry hold no water: a new report finding that filesharing has led directly to "reduced costs of bringing works to market and a growing role of independent labels." In other words, in the past decade, we have seen more music from independent outlets and at lower prices – something that consumers and music fans should all be happy about.
 
DIE Record Industry DIE!!!!

This should also weed out the Justin Biebers from the Billy Joels. No more stars but real musicians!!!
 
What I don't understand is that when the music and movie industries get their wares pirated, they go hard on the file-sharers with these massive, highly publicized and derided lawsuits.

When the PC gaming industry gets their wares pirated, they just bitch and moan and stop developing games for the PC and focus on the consoles instead. :rolleyes:
 
A lot of artist make music because they love it. Either way, most of the money they make is from touring and merchandise. Between the publisher and recording company getting their slice, artist have never made the majority of their money in record sales to begin with. Music piracy has not hurt artist themselves as much as it has the recording industry.
 
It doesn't? Well then what do I have to do to get them to shut the fuck up?!
 
A new report says that file sharing does NOT deter artists from making music. That being said, if you do continue to use P2 for your *cough*Linux distros *cough*, remember to support your favorite artist by buying their music if you like it. :)

Of course it wouldn't deter any true artist from making music, as true artists create art first and foremost for themselves and the sake of creation.

I also personally applaud your last comment, on supporting your favorite artists, as "big name/label" artists aren't the only ones effected by piracy etc.

Independent/small label artists are actually hurt the most, because they've not the money to just throw around for equipment, studio time, pressing etc. It's the more underground and independent artists that actually get nailed, where-as some giant pop star etc. isn't going to feel any monetary "pinch", and if they did, the only reason they would care, is because they're not in it for the music, but for the "fame" and money.

True musicians/artists don't do it for money, hence, they're the ones who should be supported so that they can continue to create and release more music. Especially since it's really the "smaller"/independent artists who tend to create truly the best music, because, again, they write music for the right reasons: to create good art.
 
Art existed before it was profitable. Art will continue to exist after it is profitable.

And artists starved back then, too, even without the aid of piracy. I know they want to tell us that piracy is all that is wrong, but history (and humanity) show us that they are dead wrong.
 
Support bands by going to their shows/concerts, the don't make shit off of that .99 cent song you just got off of iTunes.
 
What I don't understand is that when the music and movie industries get their wares pirated, they go hard on the file-sharers with these massive, highly publicized and derided lawsuits.
Though, the industry is going crazy about this stuff nowadays, piracy has always existed.

What did people do before the internet? People had stereo's with two tape decks, to make recordings of tapes, or just record the music straight from the radio. As for movies, that's why people owned VCR's, or sometimes even two VCR's.

Piracy just got far more convenient with the internet.
When the PC gaming industry gets their wares pirated, they just bitch and moan and stop developing games for the PC and focus on the consoles instead. :rolleyes:

This will largely be ineffective. Piracy has existed on console systems, just not the way people would expect it. In the 90's, console piracy was mostly done with emulators. Today, it's all about hacking the console. The more games that don't make it to PC, the more people will buy a console just to hack it.

Just a thought, the reason console systems are so hackable today, is because they're becoming very PC like. At what point won't we see the Xbox 720 come preinstalled with Windows 8?

Xbox 360 --> Sata connector is used to flash the DVD drive.
Wii --> SD Card is used to install the hack.
PS3 --> Uses USB port for hacking.
 
In some cases I wish piracy did deter people from making music.

tumblr_lhzjcfbDmm1qg2qszo1_500.png


nuff' said.
 
The overall creation of music increased indeed, but the share of independent labels/artists are the ones that caused that significant increase, and the major record labels have their "share of creation" decrease slightly. Which they blame on piracy. LOL

How then do the independents get incentive to create more through file-sharing (which is one of their primary forms of publicity AND distribution) if the RIAA consider it as the cause of "reducing music creation"? LOL
 
In some cases I wish piracy did deter people from making music.

tumblr_lhzjcfbDmm1qg2qszo1_500.png


nuff' said.





You sir win the internets.


To the article, I should remind you all that the bands and singers recording industry is worried about, be it Justin Bieber or Brittne Spears, they ARE NOT artists. They are PRODUCTS, empty conveyor belt crap sold to the massed and recording industry is scared they wont get all the money they could get from it before pushed aside and replaced with another product.

Artists however are in it for musics sake, even if its not necessarily profitable they still want to write.
 
As long as chicks dig guys in bands, guys will be in bands whether they sell music or not.

People talk about the quality of music declining but it's just not true, there is now just more mainstream drivel that's shoved down your throat by reality TV and whatever pop music TV shows there are these days. If that's the extent to which people investigate music they deserve what they hear.

High quality music is still in abundance, hell it even makes the charts when it's good enough.
 
In some cases I wish piracy did deter people from making music.

tumblr_lhzjcfbDmm1qg2qszo1_500.png


nuff' said.

They are both pop music, just one is 100x more pretentious and has dillusions of being "art". They both make me cringe, perhaps the friday one is more honest in it's stupidity, but that girl is really really irritating...

Still theres way better music that that now, and there was similar pop music to her in the 30s/40s/50s/60s/70s/80s/90s, so it's not surprising there's similar music now :p
 
Still theres way better music that that now, and there was similar pop music to her in the 30s/40s/50s/60s/70s/80s/90s, so it's not surprising there's similar music now :p

But with the lip syncing and computer enhancements of today, no one in the past can match the lack of talent we have today.
 
I love how so many people claim that artists create music because it should be free, it's art afterall, and it's what we love to do.
Sorry, no, it's a job to almost all of us. It just happens to be fun, not 9-5 in front of a desk, require a uniform, or anything like that. Is it my calling? Maybe. Do I do it "for the love of music" and think it should be free? Nope. If you love your job, why don't you do that for free?
Also, no one ever considers the amount of time it takes for a performance, let alone the cost involved. For a one hour show, a lot of bands put over 400 hours into it. Add in the cost of our instruments, practice space if you have to pay for it, etc., it's a costly job too. Just like any other job, it takes training/education and experience (in this case, practice) to perform.

For the most part though, everything else is spot on. Most money is made from ticket sales (as long as the band get a cut of them. Often when under a major label they don't) and merch (which include CDs!) sales.

TL;DR: just because people love to do something, doesn't mean that something should be free. :)
 
But with the lip syncing and computer enhancements of today, no one in the past can match the lack of talent we have today.

Milli Vanilli?

Look who is writing this modern crap. Most is all old artists from the 60s/70s who cling on with their industry connections, and continue to compose this trash. In this industry it's nothing to do with ability or talent, it's who you know and how much you suck up to your superiors. Pop music like her and led zepplin (they are the same thing) is all about marketing. It doesn't matter what they sound like, or look like, as long as you market them in a way that people will respond to.

Pitch correction as a plugin is a new thing, but its been going on for much longer than that. Since multi track recording came about there has been the ability to do 300 goes at something until it gets done right. I know someone who worked at a studio in the late 70s/80s who tells me tales how they cut up 25 tapes of vocal cuts, taking the best word and splicing the whole thing into a decent vocal track. Because the singer just couldn't sing. But they were marketed as a singer, so a singer is what they had to be.

Plus one of the earliest examples of auto-tune done badly was known as the "cher-effect"
 
Actually, it wasn't done badly, DeathP, it was intentional - to be used as an effect, not a correction.
Also, there is a difference between auto-tune (which actually alters the pitch the vocalist hit) and tape cutting (the vocalist still actually hit the note, just not on the right take). Tape cutting also happened to instruments and such as notes were missed, or they wanted to change the structure of the song, even.
 
Independent/small label artists are actually hurt the most, because they've not the money to just throw around for equipment, studio time, pressing etc. It's the more underground and independent artists that actually get nailed, where-as some giant pop star etc. isn't going to feel any monetary "pinch", and if they did, the only reason they would care, is because they're not in it for the music, but for the "fame" and money.

True musicians/artists don't do it for money, hence, they're the ones who should be supported so that they can continue to create and release more music. Especially since it's really the "smaller"/independent artists who tend to create truly the best music, because, again, they write music for the right reasons: to create good art.

Wrong. The smaller the group, the more benefits it gets from publishing its work on the internet, as they get so much exposure FOR FREE they would never have a single chance to have otherwise.

The fact is that piracy means many stuff...and publicity is along them. There are groups you would've never found out if it wasn't via youtube and then p2p or torrent to get the whole album. Thats why its so important and useful for not known groups, becaue they can raise interest, get more people to know them and thus get more chances to play in public: as thats how music should be understood, in a stadium @ live concert...but 80% of the groups today suck that much I wouldn't go even if they paid me, as I do appreciarte my hearing.
 
Prava, you're correct. However, in doing just that, using "piracy" to get their name out there, they dilute their brand (yes, bands are brands, no matter how big or small). Then, when they finally get bigger, they find their products hard to sell.
 
Actually, it wasn't done badly, DeathP, it was intentional - to be used as an effect, not a correction.
Also, there is a difference between auto-tune (which actually alters the pitch the vocalist hit) and tape cutting (the vocalist still actually hit the note, just not on the right take). Tape cutting also happened to instruments and such as notes were missed, or they wanted to change the structure of the song, even.

Tape cutting is still a process where you can make on a record a series of events that didn't transpire. So it's a "false" representation of what happened. Someone doesn't need to get it right once, they just have to get each single word and breath right eventually. It's not like that vocal actualy happened, so it's the same as auto-tune. It just lowers the bar a little on the engineers side.

Plus there was always the Eventide H910 Harmonizer (1974) and speed altering techniques etc.
 
Tape cutting is still a process where you can make on a record a series of events that didn't transpire. So it's a "false" representation of what happened. Someone doesn't need to get it right once, they just have to get each single word and breath right eventually. It's not like that vocal actualy happened, so it's the same as auto-tune. It just lowers the bar a little on the engineers side.

Plus there was always the Eventide H910 Harmonizer (1974) and speed altering techniques etc.

With tape cutting, at least they DID get the note right once. Now they don't even have to do that.
I built an H910! Those things are amazing on snares!
 
Prava, you're correct. However, in doing just that, using "piracy" to get their name out there, they dilute their brand (yes, bands are brands, no matter how big or small). Then, when they finally get bigger, they find their products hard to sell.

Depends how you understand "sell". As a classical musician myself (as a hobby) all the job I've done for months gets shown and judged in 1 hour, and thats it. So, if I could publish my work on the internet to get exposure, I would love to play in a full huge concert/stadium, because music is a conversation between you and the public, a pulse, a....well, either you have felt it or not, there is no way to describe how one feels when you are "connected" to the public.

The problem we have now is that the model we currently have is obsolete. A decade ago all musicians required a publisher in order to be able to afford a decent amount of marketing: you either had the funds to do it, or you would never ever leave the neighbourhood. Also, studios were expensive as hell, and nobody could afford anything.
Now, publishing music is as easy as it gets: not only you can get as much exposure as you would ever dream of using internet, you can also record your own work (better or worse, but you can) and show it.

So, I believe the system is going back to its origins. We are going back to the live concert as the only way of creating revenue, as publishers aren't needed, we don't need people in between, no need for it.
Of course, those that are in the business hate it...because they don't want to lose the power they have, but its a battle they can't win, because "no podemos ponerle vallas al campo" (we can't build fences into the country).
 
I don't believe in giving it away. I put a lot of money and time into my craft. Same as anyone else working any other gig. I just happen to make my money performing music - a job I love. Why should I have to give any of that away?
Yes, I get "exposure". So what does that buy me? Assume that these people don't buy our CDs, it's very unlikely they'll come to our show, as well, as our productions are very limited. They then won't buy T-Shirts, posters etc. as they are only available for purchase at our shows (for now). So instead, why not offer our tracks for download at a reasonable price? Why must it be FREE?
My "understanding" of "sell" is to give you something (a show, a T-Shirt, our CD), and you give me money. I'm pretty sure that's the basic definition of selling something (this for that).
I agree the old model is long since dead. Selling an album with 15 tracks - 2 of which are good - is not the way to go about it. Selling individual tracks, at a price point that makes sense, is how it should be.
And yes, you can record at home. My band does. We can also throw a pretty crappy mix down on it. We can't master it. We can't press our CDs, our cases etc. So we have to outsource all of that. Then we're supposed to post it up on the internet for free? Sorry, but no. Especially since our shows involve 40+ people on stage, countless crew for the production, setup and tear down that adds up into hundreds of hours themselves, rental for the venues etc. We rely on merc sales - again CDs included in this - to help us break even or come out ahead. Sure, we give away some things - the odd promo CD etc. But we're not making a business model of just throwing everything we make out there for free.
We're actually also doing an experiment this fall. We're doing a pay-what-you-can with no minimum for one run of our shows. This is giving a ton of people in the Seattle area who are all about this to put money where their mouth is, and pay for the show (since a LOT of people argue that's where bands "really make money" and such). It'll be interesting to see how that turns out. I bet we pull in less than when we charged $20/ticket, but that's my own guess.
 
No matter how much money, thought, effort, or time that musicians put into their craft, they should find a new craft if nobody is willing to pay money for it. No matter how strongly anyone feels in either direction about piracy, they can't magically make anyone crave their art enough to pay for it

Especially when consumers have literally hundreds of years' worth of music to choose from already. With every passing year, with every song released, music has less and less intrinsic value. There's no scarcity of art outside of the artificial scarcity that publishers and laws create, and there's nothing that hasn't been done before.
 
No matter how much money, thought, effort, or time that musicians put into their craft, they should find a new craft if nobody is willing to pay money for it. No matter how strongly anyone feels in either direction about piracy, they can't magically make anyone crave their art enough to pay for it

Especially when consumers have literally hundreds of years' worth of music to choose from already. With every passing year, with every song released, music has less and less intrinsic value. There's no scarcity of art outside of the artificial scarcity that publishers and laws create, and there's nothing that hasn't been done before.

You had me in reluctant agreement right up until the end, of course there are things that haven't been done before, there are infinite variations and progressions that can be made musically.

But your other point I kind of agree with. As a musician I'm providing a service, if people don't want to pay for it then there is little I can do, it's like the people who clean windscreens at the lights, no one solicited their service and no one has commissioned my works, while it's possible to gain them for free I just have to accept your can't stop the flow of information and maybe appreciate people want to listen to me.

Then it's up to my, or maybe an industry that would potentially represent me to have the business sense to monetise it. Facebook lets half a billion people access it's product for free, if the music industry can't find a way of monetising so many people wanting it's product without trying to force them into payment for an outdated limited license system, it deserves to die.
 
No matter how much money, thought, effort, or time that musicians put into their craft, they should find a new craft if nobody is willing to pay money for it. No matter how strongly anyone feels in either direction about piracy, they can't magically make anyone crave their art enough to pay for it

Especially when consumers have literally hundreds of years' worth of music to choose from already. With every passing year, with every song released, music has less and less intrinsic value. There's no scarcity of art outside of the artificial scarcity that publishers and laws create, and there's nothing that hasn't been done before.

Agreed. I'm sorry it has to be this way, but art isn't profitable until you're dead.
 
No matter how much money, thought, effort, or time that musicians put into their craft, they should find a new craft if nobody is willing to pay money for it. No matter how strongly anyone feels in either direction about piracy, they can't magically make anyone crave their art enough to pay for it

Especially when consumers have literally hundreds of years' worth of music to choose from already. With every passing year, with every song released, music has less and less intrinsic value. There's no scarcity of art outside of the artificial scarcity that publishers and laws create, and there's nothing that hasn't been done before.

Thing that you completely miss is that there's always someone willing to pay. Are you really trying to tell me that putting a CD into your stereo (no matter HOW good) is the same as going to a concert? If all musicians are to put down their instruments and find "a new craft", who will perform?
Given the drivel that the masses pay for (see: Justin Bieber), and of course with easy online distribution, finding an audience is not difficult & getting them to pay is not difficult in a lot of circumstances either (if you're good enough, good looking enough, or just some how popular enough).
Yes, there is constantly new music being made. You seriously think every arrangement of music possible has been produced? I laugh at you! Maybe you should turn off the pop radio and listen to other sources of music... and I strongly disagree with the "less intrinsic value" part as well, at least, as you assume that it's the musicians' fault for not being "creative"/"original". You can apply that logic to anything - computer games, painting, poetry etc. Every arrangement of colors/0s and 1s/words has probably been spoken, you know. :rolleyes:

Eh, ignore that phrase then. But keep in mind that people can and do write programs that can generate a thousand moving symphonies every minute. And the programs will only get better.

Yup, cos listening to music on speakers is the exact same as going and listening to a 100+ piece symphony with a large chorus. Yup, I can't tell the difference.
:rolleyes:
 
Thing that you completely miss is that there's always someone willing to pay. Are you really trying to tell me that putting a CD into your stereo (no matter HOW good) is the same as going to a concert? If all musicians are to put down their instruments and find "a new craft", who will perform?
I'm not referring to live music. Billions of people have enjoyed concerts since the dawn of performing arts. It's a form of music you can't pirate, and people will pay for it if they are willing.

Live performances are very much different from the digital music which is the subject of this news story and the post you quoted.


Yup, cos listening to music on speakers is the exact same as going and listening to a 100+ piece symphony with a large chorus. Yup, I can't tell the difference.
:rolleyes:
See above. Also, these computer generated pieces can be performed by live musicians.
 
Back
Top