Amazon, Google Sued Over Instant Search

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
I think this would definitely be classified as a David and Goliath moment. A small search software company called MasterObjects, is suing both Google and Amazon in a patent infringement lawsuit. The company has a legitimate claim on the Instant Search software, but battling two internet giants is definitely an uphill battle.

Neither Google nor Amazon has responded to the actions. Google rolled out its instant search technology back in September 2010; rival search engine Bing just introduced a similar feature this month.
 
Good , hope they pull it. The "feature" will not stay turned the hell off, and I really dislike it.
 
I disable it with a few "hacks" in Firefox so it's never there, ever. Not a problem for me anymore... ;)

One change in about:config and it's gone, completely, and so is the new image search as well which I really can't stand, all gone with one edit.
 
such bullshit. wouldn't this mean that AJAX in general is infringing then....

The patent describes a way of using asynchronous calls between a client and server to produce query results as a user types, rather than waiting for a user to finish formulating a query and submit it as a separate action.
 
Since when can anything "instant" be copyrighted or patented?

I hereby patent the universe of all computers to an operating CPU clock speed of no greater than 266 MHz with fixed 0.01ms delays between instructions
 
Just so you guys above know, there is a link from google that has no automatic search (I REALLY hated it too, along with almost all tech people I know)

It's NOT FASTER fro me, it wastes my damn time constantly when I use someone elses computer, and I hope google loses this one case for once.... instant search is seriously garbage, no matter how many people attempt to make it better, it will always SUCK to me.

It should be optional on the main google page, not permanent!!!!!!

I type more than 40WPM, maybe that's our problem and why most people like me hate instant google?

By the way, here is the google page that DOES NOT use instant search:

http://www.google.com/webhp?complete=0&hl=en

If it wasn't for me finding the link above, I would have 100% quit using google.
 
I thought I was the only one that hated it. But when I turn it off, it's off unless I go into incognito mode or something.
 
doesn't this "instant" feature create unnecessary traffic and cpu load?

it's like hitting enter after every word.

i turned this shit off from day 1.

when google reported that their advertising got 25% more traffic....... well, no shit. The instant gimmick displays search results before i'm even done typing. lots of unnecessary traffic.
 
I love the instant search feature in Google and the instant complete Chrome address bar. It doesn't slow anything down so I don't see what the problem is.
 
I disable it with a few "hacks" in Firefox so it's never there, ever. Not a problem for me anymore... ;)

One change in about:config and it's gone, completely, and so is the new image search as well which I really can't stand, all gone with one edit.

Post up those hacks so the rest of us can disable the bs instant search.
 
Post up those hacks so the rest of us can disable the bs instant search.

It's pretty simple, just a single edit in the about:config settings.

For Firefox 3.x.x:

Open the about:config options. Search for firefox (just the word) and you should find this string variable:

general.useragent.extra.firefox

Change the actual string variable to:

www.firefox.com

Just that, nothing more. If there's a value there already (usually the default user agent string for the build of Firefox you're using), delete it all and just put www.firefox.com in there as the value, save it, restart the browser and you're done.

For Firefox 4.x it's a bit different:

They removed the specific string from about:config and adding it doesn't help, so you have to find the one they now use, but you still search for firefox and you should find this as one of the entries:

general.useragent.override

That one should be the default user agent string for the browser by default and it should look something like this:

Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:2.0b12) Gecko/20100101

Now, the trick is to keep that but add www.firefox.com to the end of it so the actual value becomes:

Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:2.0b12) Gecko/20100101 www.firefox.com

Save, restart the browser, done. There is one side effect of these changes, and that's that some websites can't ID the browser with 100% accuracy and will complain at times. Google has no issues, it simply doesn't do the instant search or the new image search - in fact, anything related to those search changes they've been implementing will not work, they won't show up at all, even the instant preview no longer works.

If you go to Mozilla.com and try to get addons for Firefox with these changes in place, it will complain that it can't "see" Firefox to add the addons, but they'll install just fine.

The changes have effects on the user agent string ID that some websites use, that's about it. One cool side effect is that anything that targets specific browsers based on that same user agent string now get disabled by default, all of 'em.

Hope this helps...
 
Ack, my mistake:

You need to create the string general.useragent.override in Firefox 4.x - it doesn't exist by default.

Then use that user agent string above (or whatever you want, as long as it has www.firefox.com at the end - that's the trick that "misidentifies" the browser so that the search crap gets disabled and not used at all.
 
Dammit I'm just not having a good day... :p

In the Firefox 4 RC, the user agent string is:

Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:2.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/4.0

What websites are looking for is the last part there, the "Firefox/4.0" part. That's what you need to replace with www.firefox.com so it looks like:

Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.1; rv:2.0) Gecko/20100101 www.firefox.com

As long as the "Firefox/4.0" or "Firefox/3.6" part(s) are changed, that gets the results people want: no search crap.

Ok, I'm done, really.
 
Odd, I love the instant search. It speeds up everything I do. Maybe I type too fast for it to display irrelevant results?
 
I like the feature but I turned it off because of the small 10 results limit.
 
They better not win this case. Anything AJAX is liable for being sued doesn't it?
 
I don't like this. I hope they don't win. Anyone that knows AJAX can write something that works just like an instant search.
 
I don't like this. I hope they don't win. Anyone that knows AJAX can write something that works just like an instant search.

And so can anyone who knows any number of other languages. Someone who;s a good machinist could also build an awesome rocket motor.

Software patents as currently implemented are pretty effed up. But until it's fixed, after reading the actual article (they started this patent in 2001), it looks like these guys have a legit gripe.
 
Are you on a Commodore64 on dial up or something?

1. I think he meant server-side load.
2. When you think about it, it's not a big deal with "small" (relative term...) number of search requests, but Google is used by millions of people, so it does add a significant amount of additional workload.

Software patents as currently implemented are pretty effed up. But until it's fixed, after reading the actual article (they started this patent in 2001), it looks like these guys have a legit gripe.

Umm, no they don't. Or they shouldn't in any case. If you can patent this, who's stopping anyone from patenting asynchronous loading of anything. Be it images, text, or w/e.
 
i hate instant search anyway it's ridiculous why it's not simple to disable. haven't enough people complained?

Took me all of 10 seconds to find the setting to turn it off. Go to google.com, click the gear icon in the top right->search settings, scroll down to "Google Instant", select "do not use Google Instant". Done and done. Oh, and if you want the setting to "stick" better, log in first and then disable it.

I'd assume there isn't an quicker setting to disable it as most people find it faster. Especially since "most people" don't realize you can click enter to search, and would instead type in their search and then use the mouse to click "search" - for those people (aka, 99% of the people on the internet) instant must be a massive speedup.
 
Why do so many hate this feature? My "Google Fu" (search ability) sucks anyway, but it doesn't change the amount of work except removing a keystroke from the equation.
 
Back
Top