No More Cell Towers?

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Next week in Barcelona, Spain, some heavy hitters in the wireless world will be demonstrating small cell technology at the Mobile World Congress. The development and implementation of diminutive cell antenna technology may spell the demise of the familiar large steel cell towers that dot the landscape.


For cell phone companies, the benefits of dividing their networks into smaller "cells," each one served by something like the cube antenna, go far beyond esthetics. Smaller cells mean vastly higher capacity for calls and data traffic.
 
Cell companies won't ever implement this. They would have to spend a massive amount of money to have fewer excuses to charge through the nose for the capacity they already have.
 
Cell companies won't ever implement this. They would have to spend a massive amount of money to have fewer excuses to charge through the nose for the capacity they already have.

Wrong. They're gonna go crazy getting those out if they become viable. You know how much money they'll save in construction and permits alone? They can charge the same rate and make more money with the reduced operating costs after deployment. It would suck for the cellular equipment vendors since they can't charge thousands of dollars for a single tower, not the carriers.
 
Not to mention shutting up the thousands of farmers bitching about their cows getting sick from towers that haven't even been powered yet.
 
I'm going to paraphrase this badly but I've read and heard about a potential concept for at least the Internet and possibly even cellphones where you could use the now abandoned bandwidth and spectrum TV left behind when it went "all digital."

Possible? I seriously doubt any number of cable, ISP, phone, etc. outlets would ever allow this to come to pass because if it were possible it would mean the end of getting price gouged and you could theoretically have all of that everywhere.

^^
Am I even remotely getting any of that right?
 
"Small cellular base stations have already penetrated hundreds of thousands of U.S. homes. Phone companies like AT&T, Verizon Wireless and Sprint Nextel Corp. have for several years been selling "femtocells," which are about the size of a Wi-Fi router and connect to the phone company's network through a home broadband connection."

Hundreds of thousands of homes have femtocells? Isn't it more like a few thousand or tens of thousands? The don't work extremely well...

This lightRadio tech would be used in a similar way to the microcell transmitter placed on some buildings in high-density downtown areas, but wouldn't this just increase the need for more fiber to connect them to the network?
 
Wrong. They're gonna go crazy getting those out if they become viable. You know how much money they'll save in construction and permits alone? They can charge the same rate and make more money with the reduced operating costs after deployment. It would suck for the cellular equipment vendors since they can't charge thousands of dollars for a single tower, not the carriers.

You're talking about companies that have historically refused to expand their infrastructure to reach areas that aren't currently served because there's not enough money to be had. They also as little as possible to improve their service unless a competitor forces them too.

What benefit do you see from spending money to remove existing equipment, spending money to expand the network to reach each new small cell site, and getting no money in return for their effort? Expanded capacity? They don't want that. Better coverege? They were already covered.

Maybe will be implemented in areas that aren't currently covered.. but new coverage areas generally don't have the problems this technology is supposed to solve.
 
a potential concept for at least the Internet and possibly even cellphones where you could use the now abandoned bandwidth and spectrum TV left behind when it went "all digital."

you are right except that the government has already sold the rights to that bandwidth to tcom and other firms. there was potential for a nationally supported high speed network with all of the infrastucture already built up. However that idea died as soon as tcom lobbying started. It's sad really that with all the talk of how far the US is slipping in internet access and overall technology per capita that what really matters is how much money each of our elected officials pocketed to prevent this from happening.
 
Wrong. They're gonna go crazy getting those out if they become viable. You know how much money they'll save in construction and permits alone? They can charge the same rate and make more money with the reduced operating costs after deployment. It would suck for the cellular equipment vendors since they can't charge thousands of dollars for a single tower, not the carriers.

Anything that reduces THEIR costs is money in their pocket. And of course any savings would NOT be passed to the customer. :rolleyes:
 
I admit, at least AT&T will be able to claim they have the best service once they get it set up. Sure the prices remain the same but at least they'll be able to keep their subscriber base from going to Verizon. (after all, they are the best network for the iPhone according to a commercial I've seen on TV.)
 
Some really startling things happened technologically during the Egypt revolution:

Meredith’s group has developed a software program that can turn regular laptops into nodes on a “mesh network,” all able to communicate with each other. The software can also run on the little Wi-Fi routers that you use to make a home network. Last week Meredith was trading email with people who run five small radio stations in Amman, Jordan, and explaining how they can use relatively inexpensive gear to set up a mesh network to carry on communicating with each other if the Internet gets shut down. There’s even a MacGyver-style do-it-yourself version that relies on copper cable and—no lie—coffee cans. Best of all, if any single node on a mesh network can make a connection to the wider Internet, that node can share the connection with everyone. In Egypt, even when ISPs shut down service, connections based on satellite dishes were still working.

Dictator-Proofing The Internet

Think about that. With everybody carrying around something wireless (be it laptop, slate or phone), why go with cells at all in populated areas, and just have everything communicating with each other in that "mesh network"?
 
you are right except that the government has already sold the rights to that bandwidth to tcom and other firms. there was potential for a nationally supported high speed network with all of the infrastucture already built up. However that idea died as soon as tcom lobbying started. It's sad really that with all the talk of how far the US is slipping in internet access and overall technology per capita that what really matters is how much money each of our elected officials pocketed to prevent this from happening.

^^ That's what I figured.
 
you are right except that the government has already sold the rights to that bandwidth to tcom and other firms. there was potential for a nationally supported high speed network with all of the infrastucture already built up. However that idea died as soon as tcom lobbying started. It's sad really that with all the talk of how far the US is slipping in internet access and overall technology per capita that what really matters is how much money each of our elected officials pocketed to prevent this from happening.

...ah, yeah. That government thing again. :rolleyes:

What's really sad is that it's more likely a matter of corporate greed holding the US market back.
 
Back
Top