Seagate Barracuda Green 2TB HDD

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The gang at Overclockers Club just put the finishing touches on their review of the Seagate Barracuda Green 2TB HDD today. Here's a quote from the review to get you started:

This drive is all about a balance of strong performance with low overhead. For just a bit more than $100 you get a massive 2TB of space (before formatting) that is quiet and consumes a low amount of power. Seagate has put a lot of time and research into this drive and it shows.
 
I wonder if this will improve Seagate's image and restore consumer confidence...


I for one really wont trust anything from them until I hear reports of these drives going strong after 4 - 6 months. It's a shame since they really used to be my goto HDD vendor.
 
2TB of space (before formatting)
What does this mean, is this some magical drive that loses space when you format it :confused: or is the hard drive reviewer just clueless about hard drive technology.
 
What does this mean, is this some magical drive that loses space when you format it :confused: or is the hard drive reviewer just clueless about hard drive technology.

All hard drives are magic and lose space when you format them....



It is due to the fact that they are only required to call 1000MB 1 GB and not the 1024 (or some multiple of that) 1GB.... i.e.. 1MB = 1024k not 1000k.

It is more of a marketing ploy than anything else and this is nothing new; it has been this way for a long time.
 
All hard drives are magic and lose space when you format them....



It is due to the fact that they are only required to call 1000MB 1 GB and not the 1024 (or some multiple of that) 1GB.... i.e.. 1MB = 1024k not 1000k.

It is more of a marketing ploy than anything else.
1. It has nothing to do with formatting.
2. It has nothing to do with marketing.

You touched on it, but missed.

It's simply hard drive manufacturer's using the 200+ yr old metric system standard prefixes. This is used for anything that isn't constricted by the binary system, storage size, data transfer rate (your 5 mbps internet connection is 5000 bps), clock speed (your 2 GHz computer is 2000 Mhz, not 2048 Mhz).

Software, like your OS, follows a binary system, powers of 2 due for ease of memory addressing and allocation. Thus RAM, ROM, etc are counted in the binary sense of powers of 2.

1. OS developers shouldn't be using binary system to refer to storage space.
2. Metric system nomenclature should never have been used for binary number systems 1024 != 1000.
 
I wonder if this will improve Seagate's image and restore consumer confidence...

I for one really wont trust anything from them until I hear reports of these drives going strong after 4 - 6 months. It's a shame since they really used to be my goto HDD vendor.
I thought early failure was a problem with the WD Green drives.
 
1. It has nothing to do with formatting.
2. It has nothing to do with marketing.

You touched on it, but missed.

It's simply hard drive manufacturer's using the 200+ yr old metric system standard prefixes. This is used for anything that isn't constricted by the binary system, storage size, data transfer rate (your 5 mbps internet connection is 5000 bps), clock speed (your 2 GHz computer is 2000 Mhz, not 2048 Mhz).

Software, like your OS, follows a binary system, powers of 2 due for ease of memory addressing and allocation. Thus RAM, ROM, etc are counted in the binary sense of powers of 2.

1. OS developers shouldn't be using binary system to refer to storage space.
2. Metric system nomenclature should never have been used for binary number systems 1024 != 1000.

1. It has nothing to do with formatting.

Yeah it does, thats why I said "every drive is magic".... I know, formatting doesn't actually change the usable storage amount but every OS is going to format it at a lower capacity than it is advertised at. Therefore the usable size has everything to do with formatting.... for the reasons you actually explained..

1. OS developers shouldn't be using binary system to refer to storage space.

But they do.... hence the magic shrinking drives.

2. It has nothing to do with marketing.

It really does... no HDD manufacturer is going to advertise what the actual formatted size is going to be. If they did we would be reading about a 1.863 TB drive. Because we are talking about 8 bits to a byte and so forth... what they are calling a gigabyte on the hard drive is not really a gigabyte but simply 1000mb.. Hell, you said it here
"It's simply hard drive manufacturer's using the 200+ yr old metric system standard prefixes."
right, because they can use that and make it sound like they have more storage space than it will really be able to use.

It would be like if I went to the UK and advertised something like milk as a gallon but I was using US gallons and not imperial gallons... People would eventually catch on. They just used their own method of a GB, you think they used a 200 year old metric system standard on accident????

(actually, look at a data usage bill from AT&T, if they started billing GB as 1000 MB I think there would be a shit fit like we have never seen from their customers)

your 5 mbps internet connection is 5000 bps

we are talking about bytes... not bits. if I had a 5 Mega BYTE per second connection I would be running speed tests all day and wearing the shit out of my ISP. (again with bandwidth and data being measured in true GB)

your 2 GHz computer is 2000 Mhz, not 2048 Mhz

No but this is more a measure of speed


anyways.... I would still have to see one of these drives hold up in time. I am not as worried about speed of transfer as I am about reliable data storage.
 
2TB for $100.00 seems like a very nice price point to be honest. I'm looking forward to maybe 2 more years down the road when we can get 4TBish for $100.00. At that rate, buy a single 4-TB hard drive for $100.00 and you could store literately 1000 720p movie(4.37GB roughly) backups in h264 in an hd profile or 500 1080p(7GB).

At that rate, spend $400.00 or so and you can get every decent movie made within the last 20-years in high definition(assuming 200 worthwhile movies are made per year *probably an overestimation*) and local piracy via hard drives becomes a real concern. Have a friend copy his 4,000 hd movie collection onto $400.00 worth of hard drives, ship it for 20 bucks to you and who needs the Internet? You just got 4000 HD movies that you can playback at anytime you want for $420.00. A lot of people claim great prices from buying hd-dvds when they were going out of style or blu-rays from Amazon.com but have heard of few ppl claiming $0.10 per movie.
 
There is nothing green about this drive at all. I don't understand why these companies continue to propagate such lies and nonsense to people who should know better. I assure you all that manufacturing this drive is one of the least green things you will ever see and deriving the constituent components even less so.
 
Back
Top