Internet 'Kill Switch' Bill Will Return

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Ugh, please let this damn thing die already.

A controversial bill handing President Obama power over privately owned computer systems during a "national cyberemergency," and prohibiting any review by the court system, will return this year.

The revised version includes new language saying that the federal government's designation of vital Internet or other computer systems "shall not be subject to judicial review." Another addition expanded the definition of critical infrastructure to include "provider of information technology," and a third authorized the submission of "classified" reports on security vulnerabilities.
 
Completely horrible idea. You know whoever wrote it (not the sponsor, the person/group pulling the puppet strings behind them) is up to no good when they specifically state it can't be subject to judicial review.
 
Trying to defeat the checks and balances of the Constitution. Quite sad.
 
They wants it! Its their PREEEEECIOUSSSSSS! They'll keep trying to slip it in the back door until they finally get it....
 
The first step in gaining victory over an enemy is to cut off and/or take control of the enemy's communication. Information control is everything. History proves it.
 
down with BIG govt, Legalize FREEDOM i say..........he not an american why should he follow the laws he never swore to protect anything he cant he not a us citizen...
 
And they will continue to present the bill, re-word it, sneak it into other bills, or vote on it during a Christmas Eve vote until it's passed.

So much for freedom and checks and balances.
 
Not even if Gandhi was president, would I trust such power in the hands of the US president.
 
Completely horrible idea. You know whoever wrote it (not the sponsor, the person/group pulling the puppet strings behind them) is up to no good when they specifically state it can't be subject to judicial review.

Which, of course, would make the bill an unconstitutional expansion of the powers of both the executive and legislative branches over the judicial. The very first thing SCOTUS would do is strike that part. Even if they aren't allowed to by the bills wording.
 
Trying to defeat the checks and balances of the Constitution. Quite sad.

See: PATRIOT Act.

It's nothing new. Fourth Amendment? What's that?

Just hope your neighbor doesn't rat you out to the feds and you get shipped off to some 3rd world shithole for special treatment.
 
And this is how you get voted out of office!

Really? It didn't get W voted out of office. The sheeple like to feel safe.

I was reading articles on credit card security (lack thereof in the magnetic strip variety) and the comment sections on various news sites were hilarious. The pearl clutching housewives didn't want "chips" in their credit cards because the "chips" in their PCs got hacked by some guy once and you "can't hack a magnet."

That's the level of user tards out there. You tell those folks that to protect them from the scary brown terror cyber molesters that you need to have control of their inter-tubes and they'll pre-order the service for a fee.
 
Wow, by seeing the comments here I have to say. All is fun and dandy love and hope until someone messes with what you love he?
Why the freaking hell people don't realize that changing the president doesn't change the government?
 
Really? It didn't get W voted out of office. The sheeple like to feel safe.

I was reading articles on credit card security (lack thereof in the magnetic strip variety) and the comment sections on various news sites were hilarious. The pearl clutching housewives didn't want "chips" in their credit cards because the "chips" in their PCs got hacked by some guy once and you "can't hack a magnet."

That's the level of user tards out there. You tell those folks that to protect them from the scary brown terror cyber molesters that you need to have control of their inter-tubes and they'll pre-order the service for a fee.
But it's also not like the internet is a furry pink happy land (well, okay, some of it, but those are the most dangerous parts). As long as an insecure computer can be zombified, there's a fair case in protecting those people, because that means they're all potential threats. And a truly massive botnet might be the sort of thing to at least put people off their internets, if not warrant further action.

The problem is in how it works in reverse for convenience. It doesn't matter how stupid people are if you can flip a switch and undo it. And they don't just have to be stupid in one sense. If you're thinking of how they might try to apply it to things like Wikileaks; in the case of those cables, it's the same situation. A really stupid lack of security at the low level. Chances are that the kill switch's first use would be used to try and cover up some massive explosion of stupid from the US government.

Of course, prevention is better than cure. Tackling stupidity might be a tougher job, but everyone can start today!
 
Would the US govt be happy if Australia, NZ, Canada, the UK, or lets say, Spain, China, had a kill switch on the net? i dont think so... :rolleyes:

The US govt needs to realise that its not just about them
 
Anything that would be effected by a "national cyberemergency" shouldn't be on the public internet.
 
Anything that would be effected by a "national cyberemergency" shouldn't be on the public internet.

WINNER!

Much like the statement that all the electronic voting machines had McAfee security (or Norton or something) on them.

Why in God's name were they connected to the Internet in the first place?!?!

Priorities out of order.

However, I agree that the Supreme Court would strike at LEAST the provision that restricts judicial review.

Congress: "You guys can't touch this!"

SCOTUS: "Watch us."
 
Isnt the internet designed in such a way that prevents this from being possible?

I guess you could kill parts of it. But the whole internet? I doubt it.

Well I take it back. I guess if you nuked the whole earth to oblivion, it would also kill the internet.

Well, I take it back. Maybe someone in space has a few ip networks.
 
this bill is retarded.

They want to be able to cut off the internet? The internet connects every x86 based processing computer in the world. Even if they flip the kill switch what is to stop people from communicating via tcp/ip with dial in modems. Truth is you cannot stop the internet, with out completely destroying ALL wired/wireless communications around the globe.

the infrastructure is so developed now even if they tried to kill the internet it would just adapt and move to another.

Our governments need infrastructure to communicate with each another. Shut it down, might as well be no government acting under martial law.
 
The first step in gaining victory over an enemy is to cut off and/or take control of the enemy's communication. Information control is everything. History proves it.

And who's the government's enemy? Yes, people who believe in liberty and free speech.

This kind abuse of power is why the rest of the world is starting to not trust US based technology.
 
the infrastructure is so developed now even if they tried to kill the internet it would just adapt and move to another.

OMG THE MACHINES ARE LEARNING :D

You only have to browse Soapbox for 5 seconds to know my views on anything the government pushes forward anymore. Its a shame, its upsetting, and this one, its not as impossible as you believe.

If you require all the Tier 1 providers to idle their systems, you in essence shut down access. You don't have to worry about the Tier 2-3 providers, they have no way to communicate to other T2/3 providers without the T1's uplinking them.

The funny part is, wasn't it the Obama administration that demanded Twitter stay active during a foreign scuffle, where some Iranian girl got killed, and it was videotaped and everyone and their brother watched the video. Hrrrm I think it was. So, its ok to push the Internet to do things you want, when it provides you political brownie points, but if it doesn't we can throw the switch too. Hooray, a perfect world! Why not just admit it America, we're China 0.5 Beta version.
 
Alright that is it i am moving out of here. Someone please point me in a country that i can have internet in peace. Much less get internet here 11 miles out of a town.
 
Right of revolution, it is the duty of the citizens of a nation to overthrow a government that acts against their common interests.

Although, I wouldnt put it past this government that, if the citizens of the US revolted, wouldnt hesitate to just declare martial law and kill their own people. What kind of country do we live in when the government has become its own entity, seperate and in conflict with the majority of the people? When broad sweeping laws get passed without any oversite of the people? What can we do? Write our freaking senator? Right! Our state sentators dont represent us, they represent their own self interest and ambition. We are in a downword spiral here people, and unless we got off our collective fat lazy asses its not going to stop!
 
Right of revolution, it is the duty of the citizens of a nation to overthrow a government that acts against their common interests.

Although, I wouldnt put it past this government that, if the citizens of the US revolted, wouldnt hesitate to just declare martial law and kill their own people. What kind of country do we live in when the government has become its own entity, seperate and in conflict with the majority of the people? When broad sweeping laws get passed without any oversite of the people? What can we do? Write our freaking senator? Right! Our state sentators dont represent us, they represent their own self interest and ambition. We are in a downword spiral here people, and unless we got off our collective fat lazy asses its not going to stop!

A lot of talk. I agree with you and the others bitching about Nanny States and such but people that talk like this need to stop and think it through.

Unfortunately we all love our technology and that's fine but it's almost made us super vulnerable sheep.

All the government has to do is shut down the utilties, water, and power to any "troublesome area" and so much for any "revolution."

No shots would even have to be fired. Starve 'em out, lock 'em down.

Piece of cake.
 
A lot of talk. I agree with you and the others bitching about Nanny States and such but people that talk like this need to stop and think it through.

Unfortunately we all love our technology and that's fine but it's almost made us super vulnerable sheep.

All the government has to do is shut down the utilties, water, and power to any "troublesome area" and so much for any "revolution."

No shots would even have to be fired. Starve 'em out, lock 'em down.

Piece of cake.

It has nothing to do with whether one as thought through the semantics of an actual revolution. Obviously we cant, and shouldnt, just revolt and start killing people as our predecessors may have. A revolution can come in many ways, what we need is a revolution in our way of thinking. We need to reform government, not abolish it and revolting would solve nothing. There are what like 6+ billion people in this country? If even 5% of those people banded together to force change, it would make a difference. Im no politician, but I do see a problem here and I would join any coalition for reform.

Unfortuantely our government has succesfully convinced its people that there is nothing we can do. And our people are too lazy, selfish, arrogant, stupid, and passive to follow through with anything. Then laws like this and the patriot act get passed that complete subvert any and all ability we might have had to do anything at all. It is obvious here that the government has turned against its people, and is seeking to protect itself from the people when it was created to protect the people. I simply cannot comprehend why anybody; democrat, republican, or otherwise can't see that and agree that there is problem here.
 
It has nothing to do with whether one as thought through the semantics of an actual revolution. Obviously we cant, and shouldnt, just revolt and start killing people as our predecessors may have. A revolution can come in many ways, what we need is a revolution in our way of thinking. We need to reform government, not abolish it and revolting would solve nothing. There are what like 6+ billion people in this country? If even 5% of those people banded together to force change, it would make a difference. Im no politician, but I do see a problem here and I would join any coalition for reform.

Unfortuantely our government has succesfully convinced its people that there is nothing we can do. And our people are too lazy, selfish, arrogant, stupid, and passive to follow through with anything. Then laws like this and the patriot act get passed that complete subvert any and all ability we might have had to do anything at all. It is obvious here that the government has turned against its people, and is seeking to protect itself from the people when it was created to protect the people. I simply cannot comprehend why anybody; democrat, republican, or otherwise can't see that and agree that there is problem here.

Great post.

I'm going to say this: There's only one person that I've seen in the public sphere that has the guts to talk or even address any of this. I don't agree with him on absolutely everything but I tell you what: It's going to be hard for me to NOT support Ron Paul in a big way if I see him up at bat again.
 
Great post.

I'm going to say this: There's only one person that I've seen in the public sphere that has the guts to talk or even address any of this. I don't agree with him on absolutely everything but I tell you what: It's going to be hard for me to NOT support Ron Paul in a big way if I see him up at bat again.

I like the few things that I have heard about Ron Paul, and supported him over any of the other candidates during the last election. Although I think we need to take it further than that. The problem is not just the people who are elected into government, but also those that are appointed; judges, cabinet members, etc. We need to reform the system entirely away from this electoral college BS. It made sense when it was created, there was no way for the people to effectivly communicate with the government so we had to send representatives instead. But we dont have the means now, to count and commuicate the vote of the people! I am sick and tired of some slime bag politicians presumeing to speak for the people, when the reality is that their only concern is their own self interest. Not to mention, this bi-partisan system is bogus to stay the least. Give the independents, greens, and other parties a chance as well. The wack job republicans and democrates in office today have had their chance, and they failed miserably.
 
Back
Top