Apple Criticized by Chinese Environmental Groups

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Apple has come under increased criticism from Chinese ‘green’ groups for exposing the Chinese workers to unsafe working conditions and using environmentally unsafe practices in manufacturing procedures. Apple has denied any wrongdoing.

"We've found that Apple isn't honoring its commitment in ensuring its supply chain's work safety and environmental responsibility and giving dignity and respect to the workers," said Ma Jun, of the Institute of Public & Environmental Affairs (IPE)
 
Game over apple china wont make your widgets for penny's on the dollar. you are making a lot of money off of them, using cheep labor and relaxed workers rights in a place that has zero environmental responsibility. hell all tech companies do this and its time to pay the piper.
 
Well, you have to crack a few eggs to bring in $26 billion in revenue per quarter.
 
To be fair I imagine HP, Dell, Microsoft, etc. probably aren't much better if not worse. When it comes to green the environment isn't what's on these companies minds.
 
Caring about safe working and environmental conditions seems like it would be a criminal offense in China.
 
To be fair I imagine HP, Dell, Microsoft, etc. probably aren't much better if not worse. When it comes to green the environment isn't what's on these companies minds.

Yeah pretty much. You can't single out a company for something like this. Everybody's at fault. HP, Dell, Apple and everyone who buy things from Chinese vendors are enabling them, making them get away with their lack of workplace quality standards, and the Chinese government shares blame for not enforcing their workplace safety laws (believe it or not, they DO have a version of OHSA, but they're turning a blind eye in the name of greed). And the vendors also get blame for this because, well it's their shop.

Focusing only on Apple isn't going to get them anywhere. Apple can try to pressure their vendors and say "we'll cut our purchases in half if you don't do something about workplace safety" but the vendors will just increase sales with other OEM manufacturers and ignore Apple's ultimatum.
 
You know its bad when CHINA is calling you out.

Apple needs to fix their approach. Talk is not enough.

Sure, many (all?) brands are at fault. But 1 can be fixed. Many are just statistics.

Dell from what I remember has always tried to be as green as possible. I dont know how successful they are at it, but they put it out there.

Apple, stop being secretive about this stuff. The environment belongs to everyone. Stop messing with it.
 
To be fair I imagine HP, Dell, Microsoft, etc. probably aren't much better if not worse. When it comes to green the environment isn't what's on these companies minds.

However, those companies don't put out adverts about how eco friendly their crap is. Apple does.
 
Seems funny they're criticizing an American company while Foxconn is running factories that workers are literally dying to get out of. Not that I think Apple or any other big company really gives a damn about any workers welfare as long as they make big profits.
 
However, those companies don't put out adverts about how eco friendly their crap is. Apple does.

I want whatever you're smoking.

http://content.dell.com/us/en/corp/d/corp-comm/earth-green-infoworld-green15.aspx

http://www.hp.com/hpinfo/environment/commitment.html

http://www.ibm.com/ibm/green/index.shtml?cm_re=masthead-_-business-_-green

http://www.lenovo.com/social_responsibility/us/en/index.html

Every links were accessible easily from their website's front page.
 
You know its bad when CHINA is calling you out.

It's not the Chinese government. It's just some Chinese citizens that have formed a group to protest this kind of thing. You know, like Greenpeace here.

Being able to get away with less oversight for worker safety and fairness is the whole reason manufacturing went to China though, so if that changes companies would probably just decide to move production to an African country.

Nobody doubts that Chinese factories are unsafe (just walking through one on a tour probably increases your chances of who knows how many forms of cancer), but that lax oversight and using the cheapest methods instead of the safest methods is what got them the manufacturing jobs and it probably won't change anytime soon.
 
but they are human resources. human resources are there to be used up, and china has lots of them!

/apple
 
Wait, let me stop laughing at the fact that their are chinese environmental groups. Nope, not done laughing yet.
 
Wait, let me stop laughing at the fact that their are chinese environmental groups. Nope, not done laughing yet.

I see what you're saying, but I like to see China as the leader at how society will work here when it gets to be more populated. China is not as advanced as America in tech obviously, but they have more people so you can't really laugh here. Most people don't give a damn abot the future, they only care about NOW and what they see.. it's good this chinese group is being the "one in a billion" group whom cares about the planet they live off of. The rest would rather say "wow what a bunch of hippies" in keep on working in shittier, and shittier planets doing half-ass, brainless manufacturing jobs.
 
I see what you're saying, but I like to see China as the leader at how society will work here when it gets to be more populated. China is not as advanced as America in tech obviously, but they have more people so you can't really laugh here. Most people don't give a damn abot the future, they only care about NOW and what they see.. it's good this chinese group is being the "one in a billion" group whom cares about the planet they live off of. The rest would rather say "wow what a bunch of hippies" in keep on working in shittier, and shittier planets doing half-ass, brainless manufacturing jobs.

They have a long road to hoe. A nation of 1.2 billion people spread over a large and diverse land mass is going to be a big problem when you have a centralized government that doesn't give to shits about the environment when it means that they can achieve technological progress at the price of their human capital, which by the way is largely poor and illiterate and has no say in how they are treated or in their futures. Chinese environmentalism at this point is an oxymoron in lieu of their larger issues.
 
Game over apple china wont make your widgets for penny's on the dollar. you are making a lot of money off of them, using cheep labor and relaxed workers rights in a place that has zero environmental responsibility. hell all tech companies do this and its time to pay the piper.

I gather from your glee that you fail to realize that it will be consumers paying the piper not the companies. Any new costs inferred will not be taken from the bottom line, simply added to the cost of the products on the shelves.
 
LOL, if Apple is getting criticized for outsourcing to "inhumane" companies like Foxxcon/Inventec, then I don't even want to think about how much fire Dell/HP are coming under.

Oh wait, no one even notices that HP outsources every single one of their products to those same exact companies. Must be because they aren't the guys it's cool to criticize this month.
 
Accessible, but Apples the only one that markets it as a selling point.

Um, what? It's marketed as Eco-friendly and workplace-safe no matter how you paint it. I'm looking at the Apple site and I fail to see how it's more eco-focused than any other manufacturers.
 
Back
Top