No Copied Java Code in Android

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Woo hoo! Nerd fight! Big bad bully Google stands accused of copying source code from poor defensele....bah, screw the details...NERD FIGHT!!!! :D

Sometimes the sheer wrongness of what is posted on the web leaves us speechless. Especially when it’s picked up and repeated as gospel by otherwise reputable sites like Engadget. “Google copied Oracle’s Java code, pasted in a new license, and shipped it,” they reported this morning. Sorry, but that just isn’t true.
 
Engadget is a reputable apple fanboy site and bashes android as much as they can. Just compare all the iPhone reviews to all the Android reviews.

I think their editor has even admitted to being a Steve Jobs hack and downgrades android reviews for this very reason.
 
Correct me if I am wrong, but hasn't JAVA always been a solution in search of a problem?
 
If I was Google I would bring the company that actually uploaded the relevant code to the project in on this. Because of the nature of this open source project they are probably the ones that actually should bear most of the burden for any damages incurred. This kind of thing happens all the time to simplify cases like this and avoid a string of suits....

Company A sues Company B. Company B blames Supplier C for the core problem. Supplier C blames Contractor D for the problem. Rather than having three trial, A suing B, B suing C, C suing D, the court just throws them all in together and apportions damages, if any, in accordance with each companies fault, which might turn out like this:

D shows they actually met the specs provided by C. No blame. B shows that C failed to provide a product with the actual specs they ordered, 20% blame. Court places other 80% on B because they should have actually checked to make sure C's product was up to their specs and refused any products received that didn't meet spec.
 
If I was Google I would bring the company that actually uploaded the relevant code to the project in on this. Because of the nature of this open source project they are probably the ones that actually should bear most of the burden for any damages incurred. This kind of thing happens all the time to simplify cases like this and avoid a string of suits....

Company A sues Company B. Company B blames Supplier C for the core problem. Supplier C blames Contractor D for the problem. Rather than having three trial, A suing B, B suing C, C suing D, the court just throws them all in together and apportions damages, if any, in accordance with each companies fault, which might turn out like this:

D shows they actually met the specs provided by C. No blame. B shows that C failed to provide a product with the actual specs they ordered, 20% blame. Court places other 80% on B because they should have actually checked to make sure C's product was up to their specs and refused any products received that didn't meet spec.
 
"The speed of communications is wondrous to behold. It is also true that speed can multiply the distribution of information that we know to be untrue. " -Edward R Murrow
 
Oh come on Steve, this is hardly news and you didnt even cover the new iphone bumper that is universal for the ATT and Verizon iphones! :rolleyes:
 
With Oracle screwing up all of Sun's old software I am not sure Java will be around much longer.
 
It's a copyright issue, not a code issue anyways. You can't take code, used or not and copy it elsewhere under a different license. This wasn't what Oracle sued for anyways.
 
Well, unit tests aside: if GOOG distributed unlicensed copyrighted source then the nature of the source is irrelevant.
 
And my question is....if both are open source (Java and Android)....then exactly what is the problem with doing that?

Please educate me, this is obviously confusing.

Open source does not mean free to copy and paste. There are licenses involved. And lawyers.

Come on, this is Sun we're talking about.
 
Back
Top