Cyber-War Risk is Exaggerated

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Raise your hand if you are shocked by this revelation. Nobody? That's what I thought. Besides, everyone knows the real attacks are going to come after the robot invasion, not before. Duh.

In a cyber-warfare report released on Monday, the OECD said that the risk of a catastrophic attack on critical national systems has been exaggerated. The majority of cyberattacks are low level and cause inconvenience rather than serious or long-term disruption, according to report co-author professor Peter Sommer of the London School of Economics.
 
Absolutely irrelevant to the security-industrial complex.

TSA, Homeland Security, government in general will continue to fearmonger and increase surveillance, push internet ID registration, etc.
 
OMG I heard if we protect our computers from radiation with lead shielding it will make the Earth be too heavy and fall into the sun!
 
Tell that to the scientists running the Iranian nuclear program.

That was my first thought. The way it currently stands the majority of the cyber attacks are minor just like the majority of the attacks over in the middle east are (relatively) minor (IED here or there). The issue isn't with the minor attacks it is with the grand scale attacks like the one supposedly started by russia and the attack on the Iranian nuclear program.
 
Absolutely irrelevant to the security-industrial complex.

TSA, Homeland Security, government in general will continue to fearmonger and increase surveillance, push internet ID registration, etc.


Completely agree. This finding has no reference to the military industrial complex (as President Eisenhower said) of the United States of America. Why you guys are posting what some British hackjob academic says is beyond me...

I live in the UK (not for long) and I have noticed that British people are jealous of Americans and always look down on you guys.
They always say ..."ugh Americans, they are so thick"

I always defend my American friends/brothers!


Personally I love America( have lots of family and my cousin is a serving Sgt in the USMC) and could dump the junk UK passport right now if someone wants it. It isn't worth shit in this day and age.
 
Hmm, well, he really missed the intent of that vast majority of the network security that goes on in the military. He's essentially right, but that also doesn't matter. Mall security likely won't stop a coordinated terrorist attack on malls, but that'a also not why it's there.
 
Wasn't this pretty much explained in the movie "Live Free or Die Hard"?

I swear I recall Justin Long's character explaining quite clearly that the attack that is taking place in that movie is basically impossible, or was believe to be until it happened, and for the same basic reason. Anything large enough to be truly damaging is just too hard to do.
 
This is just what Skynet wants us to think.

*** Obligatory Skynet reference fulfilled ***
 
Tell that to the scientists running the Iranian nuclear program.


Well now come on, the London School of Economics always has been a leader in the field of global network security risks and damage assessment patterns. :rolleyes:
 
Tell that to the scientists running the Iranian nuclear program.

People seem to think that whomever did the stuxnet attack were just some kids in a basement slinging code. The amount of effort put into the development of that malware is incredible, including buying identical copies of the equipment they were trying to destroy and testing the code on them, wrecking the equipment. Only a MAJOR government could afford the time and effort to do something like that, and even then, the target would be VERY specific, as in NOT the entire power grid for example.
 
People seem to think that whomever did the stuxnet attack were just some kids in a basement slinging code. The amount of effort put into the development of that malware is incredible, including buying identical copies of the equipment they were trying to destroy and testing the code on them, wrecking the equipment. Only a MAJOR government could afford the time and effort to do something like that, and even then, the target would be VERY specific, as in NOT the entire power grid for example.

I wonder who it could have been?
 
not necessarily. someone could have hacked into their systems and created their own developers account. from there it would be simple to create code to cause all types of problems, not to mention opening back doors.
 
I heard this story where chinese-manufactured USB ic's had specific vulnerabilities in them and used widely in manufacturing. They then planted "discarded" tampered USB sticks in coffee shops that intelligence "employees" (maybe cia/nsa) were known to frequent. I'm not sure what happened then, but you can imagine that this would have allowed all sorts of things through the system bus and usb driver.
 
Somebody is really missing the boat here if you think it's exaggerated. If anything it's been underestimated. People are so used to dealing with kids copying malware around and pirating music, or organized criminals trying to empty bank accounts, that they tend not to think about what is possible, but instead focus on what they see 90% of the attacks doing. Stuxnet should have been a lesson to everyone, and we only know about it because the malware failed to adequately hide itself. (That part didn't work.) Of course it is possible that all governments will behave honorably and not attack each other, but...
 
I heard this story where chinese-manufactured USB ic's had specific vulnerabilities in them and used widely in manufacturing. They then planted "discarded" tampered USB sticks in coffee shops that intelligence "employees" (maybe cia/nsa) were known to frequent. I'm not sure what happened then, but you can imagine that this would have allowed all sorts of things through the system bus and usb driver.

This is hardly some highly original method, nor is it that difficult to mitigate. If you're supposed to be in a high security environment you should not be permitted to use removable media. Period.

If you are it should not be configured to auto-run and if for some idiotic reason people allow even that, you should not be permitted the ability to write to anything of importance on the system. No new powers or technology are needed to fix that sort of vulnerability.

Shit security policy is shit. News at 11.

Somebody is really missing the boat here if you think it's exaggerated. If anything it's been underestimated. People are so used to dealing with kids copying malware around and pirating music, or organized criminals trying to empty bank accounts, that they tend not to think about what is possible, but instead focus on what they see 90% of the attacks doing. Stuxnet should have been a lesson to everyone, and we only know about it because the malware failed to adequately hide itself. (That part didn't work.) Of course it is possible that all governments will behave honorably and not attack each other, but...

What you're describing is called cyber espionage and takes a hell of a lot of effort to hit even a particular system. To do something that would really disable things or cause an appreciable amount of havoc would take orders of magnitude more effort, if it even worked at all. Go read some Schneier before you start spouting off about things you know nothing about.
 
Wasn't this pretty much explained in the movie "Live Free or Die Hard"?

I swear I recall Justin Long's character explaining quite clearly that the attack that is taking place in that movie is basically impossible, or was believe to be until it happened, and for the same basic reason. Anything large enough to be truly damaging is just too hard to do.

Would that be the same movie where when people press the delete key (because as you know that is something used all the time on *nix systems :rolleyes:) their computers explode along with their entire house?

You'll understand why I don't think we should take much from that movie.
 
This is hardly some highly original method, nor is it that difficult to mitigate. If you're supposed to be in a high security environment you should not be permitted to use removable media. Period.

If you are it should not be configured to auto-run and if for some idiotic reason people allow even that, you should not be permitted the ability to write to anything of importance on the system. No new powers or technology are needed to fix that sort of vulnerability.

I'm not talking about auto-run, or usb-plugging idiots, or lax policy. Autorun is extremely basic; If the USB microcontroller in the stick being tampered with to access a system bus via a vulnerability in the PC's usb IC, that's fairly novel. But that's not the point I'm making (and I'm speculating because I can't remember the exact details).

The point I'm making is about the scope and implications of a move like this. If the Chinese government influenced a manufacturers to build vulnerabilities into ICs, that has intelligence implications on a massive international scale. It's an abuse of international trade (again, if that's what specifically happened) that we'd have to expect more of. And it suggests that the millions of other things we take for granted are potential "vectors".

What you're describing is called cyber espionage and takes a hell of a lot of effort to hit even a particular system. To do something that would really disable things or cause an appreciable amount of havoc would take orders of magnitude more effort, if it even worked at all. Go read some Schneier before you start spouting off about things you know nothing about.

"Spouting off" ?? What, are you personally offended by my point?
 
Disregard my last response; apparently you were responding to two people in one post? They just get lumped together in quoted text...
 
Back
Top