Windows 8 ARMED!

This may seem like a big deal, but ARM windows will pretty much be on Phones. This is more about getting NT kernel in phones, than ARM Windows desktops.

Phones AND tablets. Remeber Microsoft has been taking a of heat for not having a tablet strategy, I think Windows on ARM is a good one. The next part of the sauce will be how they pull of the UI.

As for desktops, yeah, I don't see nVidia coming in with ARM and posing much of a threat to Intel dominance and I don't even think Microsoft cares about ARM on desktops, what would be in it for them?
 
Phones AND tablets. Remeber Microsoft has been taking a of heat for not having a tablet strategy, I think Windows on ARM is a good one. The next part of the sauce will be how they pull of the UI.

For tablets, it depends on info we don't have. If they are just going to create an identical parallel Win8 on ARM and x86 then I don't see it making any difference, and from the sound of things they are parallel.

But if they actually differentiate the builds then lots of interesting things could happen.

Something like this:

On Intel:
Streamlined Win8 Kernel, new modern APIs.
Slick new Touch interface.
Legacy Services (components necessary to run legacy apps)


On ARM:
Streamlined Win8 Kernel, new modern APIs.
Slick new Touch interface.

Basically the kernel becomes more modular, and you split off every legacy element you can from the ARM build, since it won't run legacy anyway. You provide only the newest modern APIs for programming.

That way the ARM build is lighter weight for tablets. Something I think it needs to be.

Then start a tablet App store for Win8 tablets, to spawn touch specific apps.

But just a parallel build exactly the same as on Intel. They why wouldn't everyone get an Intel tablet for the legacy software?? There has to be corresponding benefit for the ARM build to offset the loss of legacy software.

A small edge in Battery life won't be enough.
 
For tablets, it depends on info we don't have. If they are just going to create an identical parallel Win8 on ARM and x86 then I don't see it making any difference, and from the sound of things they are parallel.

Microsoft is working on a touch UI and the rumor is from Paul Thurott who usually has pretty good Microsoft insider info is that it's a variant of WP7 tiles and I think that it's being developed in Silverlight so that means it should work on both x86 and ARM.
 
Microsoft is working on a touch UI and the rumor is from Paul Thurott who usually has pretty good Microsoft insider info is that it's a variant of WP7 tiles and I think that it's being developed in Silverlight so that means it should work on both x86 and ARM.

That still doesn't explain why you would choose ARM over Intel.

It certainly doesn't sound they are going lightweight in either version, in fact it sounds like bloat city:

http://www.winsupersite.com/article...-Confirms-Windows-8-Port-to-ARM-Chipsets.aspx
"According to Sinofksy, the system requirements for Windows 8 will actually double since Windows 7, but he downplayed the potential problem ... "
 
There's NO WAY that the system requirements for Windows 8 ARM will be double that of Windows 7 x86. What would be the point in developing an ARM version of Windows if that were the case? Hardware isn't going to advance that much in 18 months. Sinofksy lead the effort for Windows 7, one of the great product comebacks ever for Microsoft after the PR disaster of Vista. Sinofksy seems to know what he's doing and so I'll give him the benefit of the doubt for now.

Not directly related but here's something that makes me think that it's not business as usual at Microsoft. Do you know the contribution that Microsoft made to the Asus EP121? It wasn't software, they actually created a process to fuse the digitizer layers and screen together of all things. This was mentioned in Ballmer's keynote Wednesday evening. Screens have ALWAYS been an issue with lower end Tablet PCs and I've talked to people at CES 2011 that have seen the 121 and they say the screen is remarkable rivaling the iPad. NEVER before has there been a Tablet PC at this price point with a fantastic screen. This is attention to detail that in all the years I've had Tablet PCs that Microsoft simply hasn't bothered with before in tablets.

In any case the answers to all of this will come sooner rather than later. The Windows 8 beat pretty much has to be out by this summer to meet a mid 2012 especially in order to get the ARM version prepped and some good apps for it.

Windows ARM isn't a bold move but its the riskiest thing Microsoft has ever done with Windows as this is clearly tied to slates and tablets and so far Windows hasn't ignited the world on far with it's previous Windows slate efforts.

Windows ARM is either going to be a big sucess or a huge flop and at this point it's 50/50 either way as I see it.
 
Welcome to 15 years ago!

It took my group at a fortune 500 tech company less than a year to port our operating system to ARM9. I have to believe them holding off for so long was either due to politics, or the Windows codebase was even worse than we thought.
 
I doubt your code base is ANYWHERE near the size of Windows or has to support a bazillion different devices. And afterall Windows is bloated right?;) Plus Windows has been multi-platform for, oh snap around 15 years, x86, Alpha, Itanium now ARM.
 
Windows ARM isn't a bold move but its the riskiest thing Microsoft has ever done with Windows as this is clearly tied to slates and tablets and so far Windows hasn't ignited the world on far with it's previous Windows slate efforts.


So far, WinNT on ARM is no more bold than WinNT on Alpha/PPC/MIPS etc....

Unless MS segments and actively differentiates and offers compensating advantages for the ARM version it is meaningless.

If in Win8 ARM/Intel versions are the same, it won't go anywhere, because everyone will choose Intel for backward compatibility, just like they did for all previous WinNT CPU ports.
 
So far, WinNT on ARM is no more bold than WinNT on Alpha/PPC/MIPS etc....

Unless MS segments and actively differentiates and offers compensating advantages for the ARM version it is meaningless.

If in Win8 ARM/Intel versions are the same, it won't go anywhere, because everyone will choose Intel for backward compatibility, just like they did for all previous WinNT CPU ports.

I said it was risky, not bold. Porting a code base the size of Windows and then getting 3rd parties to support it is as risky a software effort that's ever been attempted. Can you name a software project that's riskier? You more than once pointed out how this could be a disaster and I agree. This is FULL of risk, from techical issues, lack of 3rd party support which is CRITICAL for this to work, the enourmous cost of this and so forth. The 3rd party support in and of itself is a super risk. Who relies on 3rd parties more than Microsoft? Without 3rd party support this will be a failure of Titantic proportions, that's not even up for debate.

What would be the point of just porting Windows to ARM and not optimizing it for power and touch, that simply makes ZERO sense as this move is clearly Microsoft's tablet strategey, one where Microsoft CLEARLY knows they are much maligned for power and UI issues on tablets currently. This forum and the Internet is FULL of that conversation. Microsoft isn't that dumb.
 
Last edited:
I said it was risky, not bold. Porting a code base the size of Windows and then getting 3rd parties to support it is as risky a software effort that's ever been attempted. Can you name a software project that's riskier? You more than once pointed out how this could be a disaster and I agree. This is FULL of risk, from techical issues, lack of 3rd party support which is CRITICAL for this to work, the enourmous cost of this and so forth. The 3rd party support in and of itself is a super risk. Who relies on 3rd parties more than Microsoft? Without 3rd party support this will be a failure of Titantic proportions, that's not even up for debate.

Sorry was skimming. Still same argument though, no more risky that WinNT on MIPS/Alpha/PPC. You could make all the same claims.


What would be the point of just porting Windows to ARM and not optimizing it for power and touch, that simply makes ZERO sense as this move is clearly Microsoft's tablet strategey, one where Microsoft CLEARLY knows they are much maligned for power and UI issues on tablets currently. This forum and the Internet is FULL of that conversation. Microsoft isn't that dumb.

I know you are a huge MS fan so we will disagree here, but lately under Ballmer, it is my opinion that they are indeed that dumb.
 
I said it was risky, not bold. Porting a code base the size of Windows and then getting 3rd parties to support it is as risky a software effort that's ever been attempted. Can you name a software project that's riskier? You more than once pointed out how this could be a disaster and I agree. This is FULL of risk, from techical issues, lack of 3rd party support which is CRITICAL for this to work, the enourmous cost of this and so forth. The 3rd party support in and of itself is a super risk. Who relies on 3rd parties more than Microsoft? Without 3rd party support this will be a failure of Titantic proportions, that's not even up for debate.

Spend a modest amount of time on money (on microsoft's scale) on porting windows and office. Promote it a bit. See if it sticks.

Yeah, very risky ... in the worst case they're out the cost of porting&promoting, and perhaps some goodwill from intel. They can easily afford that - so on the "risk to the company"-scale, it's well behind e.g. IBM's move to being a service company, any number of attempted migrations to SAP, or for that matter the American Airlines - funded development of SABRE.
 
Sorry was skimming. Still same argument though, no more risky that WinNT on MIPS/Alpha/PPC. You could make all the same claims.

I know you are a huge MS fan so we will disagree here, but lately under Ballmer, it is my opinion that they are indeed that dumb.

Spend a modest amount of time on money (on microsoft's scale) on porting windows and office. Promote it a bit. See if it sticks.

Yeah, very risky ... in the worst case they're out the cost of porting&promoting, and perhaps some goodwill from intel. They can easily afford that - so on the "risk to the company"-scale, it's well behind e.g. IBM's move to being a service company, any number of attempted migrations to SAP, or for that matter the American Airlines - funded development of SABRE.

The BIG difference in those migrations is that they weren't meant for a different form factor. I see slates and tablets as the future, have for a long time and in the era of the iPad I now have a LOT of company. If Microsoft fails in this space they are in big trouble. I might be a huge Microsoft fan but I'm not saying anything that any number of far less Microsoft friendly types haven't said since the iPad came out.

And perhaps you're right about Microsoft being dumb under Ballmer, I'm not his biggest fan either. But I think the people at Microsoft can read, including Ballmer, he did go to Harvard after all, and clearly they and he know that they have a BIG problem with tablets and slates. People that I've talked at CES to have told me that there's just row after row after row of Android slates but VERY FEW Windows devices. What I'm saying really isn't pro or anti Microsoft. I'm simply looking at the landscape and if what looks to be the case today with tablets, slates and phones taking over desktops and laptops as the preeminent computing platforms, again nothing that a bazillion industry analysts aren't already saying, how can Microsoft's failure to execute on the platforms not present enormous risk?:confused:

If Microsoft is thinking like you guys they are in a for a SERIOUS world of pain. If Microsoft cannot execute in the mobile market they are in for a deep decline. Of that I have no doubt and once again something that plenty of anti-Microft people say and they are completely correct. If we disagree it has nothing to do with me being a Microsoft fan, the difference is our perception of the importance of mobile computing. I believe it's even MORE important than is generally percieved today. And when do fanboys say things this chilling about their favorite?
 
Last edited:
The problem is, nothing here indicates Microsoft is doing the right thing and building a different OS for each segment. We need somethling like this:

Windows 8 Desktop (the bloated OS we all know).
Windows 8 Tablet ( a completely different version that is stripped and lean).

Instead everything points to a stubborn continuation (and even extension) of the "Windows (NT) Everywhere" strategy.

From everything telegraphed this looks like Bloated Window 8 will run everywhere from Workstations to Tablets and everywhere in between. We will get a new touch interface, but same old bloated windows and they are counting on SoCs to save them from the consequence of their software bloat.

Remember a few months ago when Tablets were coming with Windows Embedded Compact 7 ???
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yxkb-mnwBxs&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMpzq57VV40&feature=related

It looked like they were going to build a CE tablet OS that would be resource competitve with iOS/Android and already is on ARM and could easily leverage WP7 work (same Kernel). Instead it is obvious MS killed this and these tablets all went Android instead.

So they killed a resource competitive WinCE/WP7 derived Tablet OS that was due this year and already on ARM, let all the designs go Android and have gone back to the Window NT design sometime in late 2012.

That is dumb on an Epic scale in my book. To me it is the corporate illness that can't get beyond wanting to run the same OS on everything from tablets to workstations and it will continue to be their undoing in tablets.
 
Aren't reusability, platform independence, scalability and separation of concerns via concepts such as model-viewer-controller core principles of modern software design? What you're calling corporate illness is what others call Software Engineering 101.

And this is the beauty of competition. Microsoft is going to attempt to do something other than throw and phone OS on something and leverage their core asset. There's absolutely no technical reason why this can't work and it has a lot of potential upside. For instance interoperability between different devices is enhanced. 3rd party developers could develop applications that come bundled with desktop and mobile versions and share both data and functionality more readily.

Calling this dumb is a denial of modern software engineering principles. Not saying that Microsoft will succeed but the theory behind it is very sound.
 
It is clearly Dumb to have completely indecisive management that lets things like Kin get all the way to market and then kills it days later, or goes down the path of making WinEC tablet OS, and then kill it letting the designs all go to a competing OS. These are world class screwups.

So far they have demonstrated a lack of scalability. It is a Dog on low end hardware and this is the problem. They aren't scaling, they are just hoping HW catches up with their bloat.

But yes choice makes competition great.

We have Apples lightweight iOS, with a curated walled garden, which is exactly what I would recommend for my Mom and most regular folks.

We have Googles lightweight Android, with a more wild west approach, which is good for tech nerds and likely what I will get.

We have bloated windows with much heftier HW requirements coming out in the 2012, seemingly for the same group that insist on windows slates today.

IMO it is shaping up the same way as smartphones.

MS is squeezed on one side by a more open/cheaper/faster iterating Google. Essentially Google is the new MS in mobile. The will be on everything from top to bottom in smart-phones. The same will happen in tablets, Android will be on everything from Sharp Asus tablets to $99 craptablets.

On the other side MS is squeezed by Apples elegant, controlled model.

Basicially Google does Open better and Apple does closed better, and the MS niche is shriking while they will be late to the party again.

This definitely bears watching but I see no signs of sanity yet and it will soon be too late to matter.
 
Sure Microsoft has made plenty of mistakes and in spite of that they still make more money than Google or Apple. It's kind of scary to think where they could be if they had executed better.

And you know that Windows 8 ARM doesn't scale how? Praising or dogging on something neither of us has seen is illogical but the beta should be out sometime in the summer so we should know soon enough.

As for Windows slates they still do a lot that can't be done on iOS or Android on the content creation side yet, the big task for me being note taking. Windows handwriting recognition might be bloat to you. To me it's been a natural and productive way to interact with my devices. And yes I know it's niche but that has no impact to me and others who pay a premium over typical mobile OS for the power.
 
Yes Monopolies are sweet for pulling in money. You have to do more damage than the typical Ballmer, shoot yourself in the foot, to screw up a monopoly.

But the screwups under Ballmer are still comically bad, he needs replacement. This trails back to my comment, that under Ballmer they are indeed dumb enough to not optimize for tablets. All evidence is that Ballmer is fairly dismal leader and all evidence so far shows the ARM version is nothing other than full Ported version of the Intel Desktop version. Full legacy of bloat where they will bolt on yet another touch layer and pronounce windows everywhere again.

As far as Win8 not scaling, I refer you back up Sinofksy statement that system requirements will double for Win8. So straight from the mouths of Microsoft, they are not going more lightweight, they are going more heavyweight. They are counting on HW advancement to dig them out of the bloat hole.

The direction revealed so far is that the MS tablet solution in 2012 will essentially run the Desktop OS of 2012 (with a new touch interface tacked on top) which will be even more of resource hog than the current one. They will count on HW improvement counter the bloat and maybe ARM to help tame the beasts battery life.

That isn't to say that they don't have a massive internal fight in the interim and jettison Ballmer, and produce a stripped and lean ARM tablet OS with no legacy baggage, and no legacy interface, It will be only a touch OS, with only touch apps. But they longer they stick with the current plan they more effort it would be to change direction yet again.
 
It's definitely going to depend on the price and performance of whatever nvidia launches - there's no theoretical reason they can't launch something a bit faster than atom with comparable power draw, or for that matter something much faster with a power draw on the i5/i7 scale - and that would be downright fun.

As for competing in speed - ARM isn't x86/amd64, and it has had a lot of optimization pumped into it to make it run fast on very little energy. No one has really tried scaling ARM to mainstream performance since Acorn in the mid 90s, so it's in the blue how it'll perform if you really throw silicon and power at it. Maybe it'll be easier to scale up than amd64? Maybe it'll be nigh-impossible? I'm actually excited; it would be hilarious if the end of the x86-kills-everything period was ARM of all possible things. (It's the last legacy of the British computer industry, too - for added weirdness. :D )

Before we start comparing NT and Android I'd really love to see them tested on the same hardware; from the looks of things that'll have to wait until someone gets hold of both an NT-supported ARM device and an android port to the same ...
(NT itself is probably fine, but it drags along more subsystems and a larger feature set than what you can use in an android app - as for exactly how much it matters, well.)


given the performance of the i series CPUs in general Nvidia is going to have an extremely hard time on the price performance front.......especially with the sandy bridge stuff
 
given the performance of the i series CPUs in general Nvidia is going to have an extremely hard time on the price performance front.......especially with the sandy bridge stuff

Oh, absolutely - but it's essentially unknown at the moment how ARM performance will scale into that power/cost niche, or for that matter how good nvidia are at making CPUs. As I said, I look forward to seeing what they come up with. :)

heatlessun said:
The BIG difference in those migrations is that they weren't meant for a different form factor. I see slates and tablets as the future, have for a long time and in the era of the iPad I now have a LOT of company. If Microsoft fails in this space they are in big trouble. I might be a huge Microsoft fan but I'm not saying anything that any number of far less Microsoft friendly types haven't said since the iPad came out.

I think we basically agree here. I don't think "making a windows/arm and a windows/intel-soc port" is especially risky in itself; it's a fairly low-cost indecisive move, and it won't harm their currently largest income sources. What is more risky is "making those ports their mobile/tablet strategy". I don't think they've explicitly said that WinCE and WP7 are dead yet, but it does seem likely.

Oh, and even if they fail completely at it? Windows and office for PCs are likely to remain profitable enough to sustain them for a very long time - though it'll be confusing for them if they have to survive as a niche company. I mean, it's not like the business sector will suddenly stop using office apps on PCs.
 
What is more risky is "making those ports their mobile/tablet strategy". I don't think they've explicitly said that WinCE and WP7 are dead yet, but it does seem likely.

WinCE will continue in real embedded work as it is a real time kernel and NT could not replace it there.

WinCE as the basis of WP7 will continue for sometime and it's replacement will be trivial as applications are entirely managed code. Which is why they should have brought out the tablet equivalent this year. Because they would have something and migration would be easy. But this highlights a second issue; They don't want a unique Tablet OS.

Stated or not, WinCE for tablets is DEAD. That was started and aborted this year, it will not return.

I think the biggest risk, is that MS will not have a distinct OS for tablets. This is exactly why MS failed to gain traction with its tablets for a decade, and why Apple sold more in one year than MS did the previous 10.

MS insists on selling you the same Leatherman Multi-tool for every task, while Apple is selling you Vice Grips, Wrenches or Precision Screwdrivers, depending on your task.

Every indication is, that this riskiest strategy, which is essentially just doing the same thing they have always done, is exactly what MS intends to do. Some times the greatest risk is simply not changing.

It really doesn't matter if they port that failed strategy to ARM.
 
I think you're spending a fair bit of energy and text on agreeing with me. :)
 
As far as Win8 not scaling, I refer you back up Sinofksy statement that system requirements will double for Win8. So straight from the mouths of Microsoft, they are not going more lightweight, they are going more heavyweight. They are counting on HW advancement to dig them out of the bloat hole.

Was this a reference to only x86 or both x86 and ARM? Why do you keep assuming that x86 and ARM will have the same level of hardware requirements?
 
I think you're spending a fair bit of energy and text on agreeing with me. :)

Well would you rather have a flame war? :D I just find this about the only interesting announcement of a rather bland CES.

Though I don't think we are really in agreement. You said making this port their mobile strategy, was the risky move.

I don't think there is anything wrong with the NT kernel if they freed it of all baggage and made a targeted and unique mobile platform with it. IMO that wouldn't be the risky solution, that would be the sane one.

But, continuing the status quo on mobile is the risky move. Continuing to make a full workstation OS run everywhere, including mobile, without stripping it down and making a unique version. IMO that is still status quo, whether it runs on ARM or on Windows. That is taking the biggest risk of all, but being too timid to change a failing strategy.
 
But, continuing the status quo on mobile is the risky move. Continuing to make a full workstation OS run everywhere, including mobile, without stripping it down and making a unique version. IMO that is still status quo, whether it runs on ARM or on Windows. That is taking the biggest risk of all, but being too timid to change a failing strategy.

Why do you think that this is what they are trying to do? Here's an example of what I think they're trying to do that makes a lot more sense.

Just got Angry Bird for Windows on IntelAppUp yesterday. That one application works on EVERY Windows device I have (except the HP Slate, getting a crash at launch unfortunately). But not only that, on my touchscreen devices other the Slate it works just like an iPad. And get this, the damn thing even works in with Surround. The same app from 7" screens to 70", works with a mouse, works with touch, scales to the screen(s). Those birds look REALLY angry in Surround!

This is what Windows ARM is about I believe. Applications with consistent functionality that scales to the client hardware and that expose different UIs based on that client hardware. While Angry Bird Windows is a simple example of idea its also PERFECT example of this idea. This is also why people who like Windows on slates like. The SAME applications work on my desktop, my laptop and my tablets. No screwing with a bunch of disjointed stuff that works here but not there or file conversions or media transcoding. Now get those apps to scale to the hardware and expose the proper UI. Yes, this is a powerful tablet strategy.

So I understand that you think all Microsoft is going to do is slap Windows ARM on a device and it'll be just like a desktop, they do that already (ExoPC, HP Slate, EP121 for example) and don't need to port Windows to ARM for that so I respectfully disagree and we should know who is right by summer.
 
Last edited:
Why wouldn't AngryBirds run on every windows device? You run workstation (NT kernel) windows on every device and they are all running x86 processors.

But this is exactly Microsoft Think. One OS everywhere. Exactly why IMO their slates sell only to a few diehards(such as yourself).

As far as just slapping windows on ARM. That is exactly what they have done. There has been no hint that Win8ARM and Win8Intel will have any differences (other than inability to run legacy apps on ARM). These are parallel builds just like MIP/PPC/Alpha.

You are also missing the point of the Port. The point was SoCs,not ARM, that work had to be done.

Current Windows doesn't run on Intel SoCs, it runs on desktop HW which is not the same as Intels SoC HW. ARM is more a hedge than anything. If you watch the keynote, you will note that the make big deal about the Intel SoC being backward compatible. The ARM SoC doesn't do anything different except lacking backward compatibility, but the clear indication is that it is interface compatible so any old code can be ported, that implies that it is identical libraries and services. IOW exactly the same as Win8Intel.

Unless MS actually defines a new separate ARM platform, it is dead, just like PPC/Alpha/MIPS which is essentially the same story as this one. Left to the market to decide, Intel SoCs will win over ARM SoCs.
 
Why wouldn't AngryBirds run on every windows device? You run workstation (NT kernel) windows on every device and they are all running x86 processors.

But this is exactly Microsoft Think. One OS everywhere. Exactly why IMO their slates sell only to a few diehards(such as yourself).

You totally ignored the point. It was about one OS and applications that FIT the client. The Angry Birds example was about scaling and UI appropriateness, the CPU platform is irrelavent in this example. On a touch device there's a touch interface. On my sig rig there's a mouse interface and support for multi-monitor resolutions.

And you might be underestimating the appeal of current Windows slates a little bit, it's a niche space but well beyond die hard unless you're saying that the best content creation, note taking and artistic tools are die hard. Niche, sure in the slew of entertainment slates, die hard, absolutely not. Unless you're saying that going to school or working for a living die hard.;)
 
Last edited:
Doubtful. ARM was built specifically for low-power use, x86 was not. x86 has been moving towards low-power in the last few years, but it is still nowhere near ARM.

Example: ARM's (currently available) dual-core power-optimized Cortex-A9 SoC consumes ~0.6mW per MHz, or about 8 DMIPS / mW.

Intel's (recently announced) single-core, dual-threaded E660T SoC uses ~2.5mW per MHz, and is the neighborhood of 0.9 DMIPS / mW.

Yes, you can't directly compare MHz to MHz and IPS to IPS between ARM and x86, but this should illustrate the distance Intel has yet to go to catch up with ARM when it comes to power efficiency. (If anyone has a more appropriate method of cross-platform power-efficiency comparison, please let me know.)

I should also mention that ARM SoCs are a fraction of the size of the Intel's... try under 5mm^2 for the whole Cortex-A9 SoC, while Intel's E6xx are 22mm^2, and that's not counting the 23mm^2 PHC.

ARM isn't slowing down either; Cortex-A15 isn't too far away and boasts further reductions in feature size and energy consumption.

EDIT - Also worth noting, Cortex-A15 will provide full hardware virtualization support. x86 VM anyone?

and on the same note arm is nowhere near the performance of x86 either so it's a trade off low power lower performance or higher power and more performance.......
 
And you might be underestimating the appeal of current Windows slates a little bit, it's a niche space but well beyond die hard unless you're saying that the best content creation, note taking and artistic tools are die hard. Niche, sure in the slew of entertainment slates, die hard, absolutely not. Unless you're saying that going to school or working for a living die hard.;)

Well then I guess you think like Ballmer and there is nothing to fix. :D
 
Well would you rather have a flame war? :D I just find this about the only interesting announcement of a rather bland CES.
I'll admit I haven't been in a good one for a long while. :D

Though I don't think we are really in agreement. You said making this port their mobile strategy, was the risky move.

I don't think there is anything wrong with the NT kernel if they freed it of all baggage and made a targeted and unique mobile platform with it. IMO that wouldn't be the risky solution, that would be the sane one.

But, continuing the status quo on mobile is the risky move. Continuing to make a full workstation OS run everywhere, including mobile, without stripping it down and making a unique version. IMO that is still status quo, whether it runs on ARM or on Windows. That is taking the biggest risk of all, but being too timid to change a failing strategy.

Well, yes - when I said "this port", I meant the full desktop OS they demoed, not a theoretical lighter OS built on the ARM port of the kernel.
 
And on the same note, arm is nowhere near the performance of x86 either, so it's a trade off: low power lower performance or higher power and more performance...

As of right now, a cortex A8 or A9 uses, ooh, perhaps a tenth of the power of a current gen dualcore atom. They're not ten times slower, by far. The interesting question is - if you scale them to be slightly faster than the current Atoms, how much less power will they use?

The other interesting question is "how fast will an ARM CPU with the power draw of an i7 be".
 
Well then I guess you think like Ballmer and there is nothing to fix. :D

Not at all! I consider myself pretty objective though like anyone else I have to check my biases. I've been dealing with Windows Tablet PCs for a long time, many years ahead of the iPad and Android on this form factor and the platform does a lot of things that I use daily that simply have no solid analog on iOS or Android or any other mobile device I’ve seen. There’s just a LOT of powerful productivity capability there if one actually bothers to look at it objectively.

That said I agree 200% that touch needs work and that Microsoft needs a learner mobile OS! This generation of slates is about CONSUMPTION NOT PRODUCTION! Desktop Windows is geared for productive tasks and it not a good fit for lower power, low cost, touch based entertainment devices. If Windows ARM is nothing but Windows x86 desktop then yes, that’s TOTALLY dumb as that can be done today on dozens of devices and it's BEYOND CLEAR that that has NOT been well received. And if you think that Ballmer, as dumb as his is by your assesment HASN'T gotten the message that he's not done weill in this space I really don't no what planet you've been on sense the iPad came out.

But they DON’T have to take the same approach as Apple and Google. Just slapping Windows CE on a tablet and saying “Hey look me too” isn’t enough for Microsoft. Clearly Microsoft thought about that idea, they obviously had it ready to roll and then decided on this approach. From a software engineering standpoint I think that it’s a better way. It’s also more complicated and risky and it still may not be enough.

The iPad is a wonderful entertainment device with a great touch UI. Windows in its current form simply has much better overall productivity capability with coupled with a dual mode touch AND pen digitizer. Your bias is preventing you from decomposing the problem and you look at Windows and discount the things Windows actually does well on slates. That doesn’t seem to be any better than your assessment of Ballmer.

But maybe you’re right. Microsoft is going to take all this effort to do what they already can do to a large extent on x86. I 100% agree with you that that would be DUMB! I’m simply saying that it would be nice to take the great pen interface, leverage .NET to allow for easy develop of cross platform, multi-UI applications where it makes sense with high reusability and scalability and create an ARM platform version of Windows that supports a decent subset of Windows x86 to allow for powerful cross platform interoperability. I seriously doubt that this dumb idea considering how elegant and complex it is. Maybe Microsoft ISN’T doing this but if they are, then no not dumb at.
 
Last edited:
Good to see they are doing this. They need to make a Tablet OS though, or have a tablet mode or something in Windows 8. Using my T101MT and Windows 7 is OK, but I only use the touch portion of it so that customers can sign their invoices.
 
They need to make a Tablet OS though, or have a tablet mode or something in Windows 8.

I believe that the "tablet mode" idea is EXACTLY what they are trying to do. There's just no point to slap Windows 8 desktop on a slate. They've been doing this LONG before the iPad and while it has it purposes for productive tasks it's ill suited for for low power touch based consumptive tasks.

That said there are some consumptive tasks that work quite well in function. Web surfing on HP Slate is not bad though not a fast as I would like on heavier sites. Surprisingly some heavy Flash sites work quite well. But the FULL web is there via touch.

The tm2, though not a pure slate is even better. Everything loads as fast as a mid-range laptop and I can surf with touch, input text with a pen and stream music via Pandora like I'm doing now while laying in bed on my side. It's MUCH faster to input text with a pen with only one hand. And as the screen get's larger the touch experience in Windows becomes reasonably useful and powerful.

I can pull up Kindle, Nook, Outlook, have dozens of browser windows and scrape articles and info out of all those apps into OneNote, add comments, write code in Visual Studio or Eclipse and now play Angry Birds!

And this is why I totally understand Windows deficiencies on touch devices. I mean honestly, who the hell using an iPad would even want to have all this power or even know HOW to use it? It's not all that intuitive, attractive or smooth and it's fairly complex. I've been using for 8 years so it's second nature to me and I completely understand that the masses just want to plop their fingers on a screen and be delighted. They aren't looking to do calculus homework on their iPads and even Android slates. They want INSTANT gratification with EASE. And they don't want to spend $1000 for it.

Unlike others I simply REFUSE to let my biases prevent me from looking at only part of the story and I force myself look at different points of view. I know the weeknesses of Windows and I know its strengths very well on slates and its strengths simply DO NOT align well with low power touch screen primarily entertainment focused devices. It's capable to do those tasks but it's just isn't appealing to Joe Sixpack and the battery life simply is not good enough.

Yep, I think just like Ballmer.:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Unlike others I simply REFUSE to let my biases prevent me from looking at only part of the story and I force myself look at different points of view.

Is that meant to be a joke? You can't even stop the condescension from pouring out of you, when you claim you are being "unbiased", you say MS needs a learner version, iPad users wouldn't even know how to use windows touch. Too powerful and complex for them. This is you being unbiased? Really more complex and powerful than their windows desktops?? A lot of people actually realize that not every device needs to do everything and they are significant advantages to specialization.

I had to put you on ignore when they iPad came out because nowhere here could anyone talk about the iPad without you jumping in and answering every post with a diatribe about how limited it was and how it would face difficulty in the market vs more capable devices like the HP Slate.

It was so bad that you were the top poster in every single thread about iPad. Only much later did I stumble on your posts pushing Windows slates in other forums as well.

Do you have another job or is marketing windows slates full time?
 
Last edited:
Is that meant to be a joke? You can't even stop the condescension from pouring out of you, when you claim you are being "unbiased", you say MS needs a learner version, iPad users wouldn't even know how to use windows touch. Too powerful and complex for them. This is you being unbiased? Really more complex and powerful than their windows desktops?? A lot of people actually realize that not every device needs to do everything and they are significant advantages to specialization.

Not at all! I consider myself pretty objective though like anyone else I have to check my biases.

Where in that did I say say I was unbiased? I FLAT OUT said that I was. Everyone is honestly and its something that ones has to fight against. It's called HUMAN NATURE! Yes Tablet PCs are powerful and complex; they have twice as many input methods as a conventional desktop or laptop. I hear this complaint from iPad users all the time, that Tablet PCs are too complex. No you don’t need to PhD but the tools that run well on them like OneNote, Photoshop, etc. are inherently more complex than most apps that people use on iPads. That’s just the reality. I had my criticisms of the iPad but I said PLENTY of times that it would do well because its attractive and simple to use.
This is nothing once again that bazillion industry analysts haven’t said.

Do you have another job or is marketing windows slates full time?

Beer taster.:D

Let's see I just said that Tablet PCs are complex, not particular fun to use, have poor battery life. I could have done a better job promoting a TPC than what BTW.;) I'm agreeing with a lot of what you're saying and you're are for whatever reasoning arguing about it. Strange.

I have a lot of passion about Tablet PCs and I admit, I had fun getting into a little bit a food fight. To me this is just all talk and until the iPad and now Android no one much cared about tablets in general so it was kind of neat to see people get passionate about my favorite form factor. Before 2010 would you have cared much about tablets? Just wondering.
 
Last edited:
Before 2010 would you have cared much about tablets? Just wondering.

I had been thinking about getting an e-book reader for a while before that. I have owned a couple of pen based PDAs (which I did read on), but I really don't care for pen input at all. I can type at double the speed that I can write. I think that when checking your Biases, you need to recognize that stylus input is not that big a deal to most people. Handwriting is fast becoming an anachronism, which I use mainly for signing documents/cheques these days. I don't want to use handwriting on paper or screen.

I was also well aware of windows tablets for quite some time, but once you get beyond Pen input(covered above) I don't see any advantage a tablet windows PC has over a laptop. Pretty much all the software is designed for KB/mouse and works better that way. They were also way too big/heavy for ebook reading. So zero interest.

I was interested in MS potential this past summer when it looked like MS was going to create a Windows Embedded Compact Tablet OS, which would be essentially a direct competitor to iOS/Android and natural outgrowth of WP7, but that was obviously canceled in favor of what looks like (to me) back to business as usual. Desktop OS on tablets.

All I get from this now is that MS will count on Moores law/SoCs to reduce the weight/power aspect of their future tablets. But other than that it will be same old legacy bloat dressed up in a new interface. That won't change the fact that nearly all applications are still designed for KB/Mouse, giving users a very mixed experience.
 
Snowdog, do you have any facts or just rumors and bashing "bloat"?
 
Snowdog, do you have any facts or just rumors and bashing "bloat"?

I never said Windows was bloated for a Desktop OS. I don't consider it any more bloated than OSX.

But it should be obvious that it is fairly bloated compared to the smartphone OS used for Android/Apple tablets. I thought most people here understood that. If you doubt it you can look up system requirements for each. You can also read about how Windows performs on systems meeting those minimal requirements like an Atom with 1G of ram.

Do you really need me to Google it for you?
 
I had been thinking about getting an e-book reader for a while before that. I have owned a couple of pen based PDAs (which I did read on), but I really don't care for pen input at all. I can type at double the speed that I can write. I think that when checking your Biases, you need to recognize that stylus input is not that big a deal to most people. Handwriting is fast becoming an anachronism, which I use mainly for signing documents/cheques these days. I don't want to use handwriting on paper or screen.

Yes pens are niche. You don't like them and that's fine, I'm not trying convince you otherwise. But can you honestly say that given current technology that pens are easily replaced by mice, keyboards or touch for ALL the tasks that pens (and by pen I mean any writing implement) are used for today? Millions of people each and every day use whiteboards, chalkboards, yellow pads, white pads, canvases, etc. with a pen. Just do some YouTube and web searches, you’ll see example after example after example of people using styli on an iPad. I've seen a number of note taking iPad setups that use styli and keyboards, essentially trying to be Tablet PCs. I've found it odd when people say that the iPad is a great note taking device and have BT keyboards attached to them. Not saying that there's anything wrong with that but for free form note taking keyboards are extremely awkward for plenty of folks. Of course no palm rejection is part of the reason.

Are pens niche? Yes. Can what pens do well be easily replaced across the board with some other input method? Not yet I believe. A device sold by a company openly hostile to the concept of pen computing (well at least now, I did own a Newton) with a lot of people going out of their to make it do something that Tablet PCs do with ease actually surprised even me. Sure people will try anything but when Jobs himself self says that a stylus equals failure I was just surprised that anyone would want to waste the effort on a community that’s always reminding the world that pens are indeed niche.

And now Android is in the game with digital pens as N-trig is now developing for that platform, though I’ve not heard Wacom yet announce anything yet. So are pens niche, once again yes. But it is a niche looking to do VERY productive tasks on slates which by its very nature is niche anyway. I know I’m not the most objective observer on this topic, and let’s be honest, I don’t think you are either, but I’ve seen more interest in pen computing since the iPad came out, not less. Maybe it’s my bias but clearly it’s coming to Android and we’ll see how that plays out.

All I get from this now is that MS will count on Moores law/SoCs to reduce the weight/power aspect of their future tablets. But other than that it will be same old legacy bloat dressed up in a new interface. That won't change the fact that nearly all applications are still designed for KB/Mouse, giving users a very mixed experience.
Going around in circles on this one but you seem to keep ignoring that this is what Microsoft has RIGHT NOW without the cost and risk developing for ARM, just let Intel do the work for them. EVERYONE says that that will not work in the entertainment slate space including yours truly. What you’re saying is that Microsoft is going to spend a metric ton of hundred dollar bills to do NOTHING. Maybe, but there’s ZERO logic to it after Microsoft has been reminded countless times that they need an iPad and now Android competitor. And yes they could have used Windows CE but all I’m saying they are trying to do is to LEVERAGE Windows on tablet platforms, not replicate it. Once again, they have that TODAY and it’s clearly not working. Eventually even Microsoft and Ballmer get the memo.
 
Back
Top