Reading Your Cheating Wife's E-mail a Crime?

If he was white and female, nobody would ever have heard this.

Why the fuck do we tolerate women in our society? They get our children (even despite major confounds like drug abuse), half our shit etc. They're more likely to fall out of love, use a weapon in a dispute etc. Giving them the right to vote was the worst thing our nation has ever done.

Sometimes I wish cock didn't disgust me. It'd be so much easier than dealing with stupid whores.

Calm down my friend. Not all of them are bad but I agree laws needs to be changed or just don't marry the "wrong one".
 
He didn't even keylog anything. She had her password written down in a little book next to the computer.

And thats what the prosecution called "Hacking"?

He should have just used some low end free keylogger like Polymorph Keylogger and he wouldn't have gotten caught and charged.
 
A friend of mine was suspecious of this wife being unfaithful so he decided to check into her email. He did and found very incriminating evidence. He confronted her about the cheating and she was more upset that he read her email than the cheating itself and she had been caught.

The moral of the story folks, cheaters will always screw up and some point and you will find out one way or other. If you HAVE to check on your spouses email then he/she is not worth having a relantionship/marriage with. If you have trust issues that thats another story entirely.

I don't have time or the inclination to check anybody's email. As far as im concerned, people's email(including spouse) is none of my business unless its a shared account of some sort.

Similar thing happened to me. I got suspicious of my wife so I keylogged her laptop (MY laptop with one account and I know the password) and mine. Got passwords to Facebook and saw things I wish I didn't see. She was more mad at me for the snooping than the cheating itself and that she had been caught.
We are working things out as I blame myself for her cheating as much as I blame her.
Moral of the story is: I am the Admin in my home network, I know all and I see all.
 
To the topic question, no unless it isn't YOUR network you're spying on.

If it's his network he should by law, like a company, have right to anaylze data being sent out as he is the one paying the ISP for this connection.

No doubts that you can legally watch your network (and even decrypt its traffic for the most part) if you have the skills and the tools.
 
Depending on the state they may both be considered the same legal entity (what's his is her's and what's her's is his) and this whole thing may get thrown out since they were still married at the time in question.

Similar thing happened to me. I got suspicious of my wife so I keylogged her laptop (MY laptop with one account and I know the password) and mine. Got passwords to Facebook and saw things I wish I didn't see. She was more mad at me for the snooping than the cheating itself and that she had been caught.
We are working things out as I blame myself for her cheating as much as I blame her.
Moral of the story is: I am the Admin in my home network, I know all and I see all.

No, no you're not to blame for her cheating with some other guy. Doesn't matter how you or her tries to rationalize it. Her actions are solely her responsibility. Once you accept this and the realization that goes along with it only then can you move forward properly. Right now that isn't the case as evidenced by the fact you're still making excuses for her, so my advice is to really treat carefully and that it's time for a gut check.
 
Depending on the state they may both be considered the same legal entity (what's his is her's and what's her's is his) and this whole thing may get thrown out since they were still married at the time in question.



No, no you're not to blame for her cheating with some other guy. Doesn't matter how you or her tries to rationalize it. Her actions are solely her responsibility. Once you accept this and the realization that goes along with it only then can you move forward properly. Right now that isn't the case as evidenced by the fact you're still making excuses for her, so my advice is to really treat carefully and that it's time for a gut check.

I honestly dont understand how any man could be so pussy whipped he blames himself for his wife;s affair.
 
Did she log out of her account? Either way, this seems like a dumb case to try. Ultimately, this is roughly the same has him opening a letter addressed to her from her Ex.

Based on the limited information in this article, I seriously doubt they'll get a conviction.
 
shouldnt take much for the defense to prove he did not violate the intent or even the word of the law he is being charged with.. also good chance the sheer lack of common sense beign used by the prosecutor could result in a good counter suit case.
 
I am honestly surprised at the number of people who are saying that digital property being accessed through a network or device with third party ownership means that third party can now legally access and use what was accessed. And also at how knowing the password to someones digital property also means one can legally access and use it. Do people not see the far reaching implications of this?
 
I am honestly surprised at the number of people who are saying that digital property being accessed through a network or device with third party ownership means that third party can now legally access and use what was accessed. And also at how knowing the password to someones digital property also means one can legally access and use it. Do people not see the far reaching implications of this?

joint property marriage states I would argue he had as much right to the email account as she did...

a person can break into their significant others car if they are married and its not criminal damage... same with other property etc etc. dont see how a email account is any different. no different then going through her pockets and finding a note etc. no crime on his part.. though if he lives in a state where adultery is still a crime he should demand prosecution for it.
 
Society and world is falling apart. I give the United States until 2015.

Good to see there's still some optimistic people out there!

Shit, its a crime to read your missus' email these days? i mean sure its definitely a moral/trust issue and i wouldn't do it to my missus but that's because I TRUST HER! Obviously this guy had a reason to be suspicious of the skank and she was keeping secrets about someone who was putting her and the child in danger and seems to me he suspected that. every man has the right to go to whatever lengths necessary to protect the safety of his family!
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
I hate to say so, but what the guy did was wrong. you do have to draw a line at some point. Is it ok for somebody at your work to log into your work computer and stole your info? Lets even look at it from that stand point. What if it wasn't her gmail account. What if he had logged into her work email account and stole confidential information that was sent to her? what if she had remote access into her work and he had logged into that?

The ends doesn't always justify the means. Are you fine with the government reading every single one of your emails and listening in on every one of your calls, just so that they can catch that 1 person planning to bomb some buidling? What is this was the way around and this was the abusive man? What if she was planning on leaving him and was trying to get help and he found the info and then beat her till she was nearly dead. whould you be saying that he had every right to read her emails and know she was going to get away from him?

It would be one thing if the emails where stored on computer and not password protected, but she did go through some messures, while not very good since she had the passwords wrote down, to protect her account as it was stored on a server and required a password.
 
HERE'S THE WAY IT IS:

1. Courts have recently upheld the rights for expectation of privacy to include email.

Got it? Are YOUR rights important to you? Do you want YOUR rights compromised for some non-existant "greater good"? Do you think your Constitutional Bill of Rights should be waivable at someone else's discretion without due process?

Are YOU the type of person that thinks laws are good as long as they get you what you want, and are they an obstacle to overcome, ignore, skirt, when they get in the way of what YOU want?

Finally...when you're married to someone, you have an even GREATER responsibility to look out for that person's constitutional rights. One of the biggest reasons for divorce is the old "familiarity breeds contempt" thing. Opportunity does NOT create a right. When people say, "Love, Honor, and Respect" they should MEAN it and ACT it! If they did, the divorce rate would plummet because this shit wouldn't happen in the first place!

Learn to live under the law that protects your right to air your stupid, selfish, faux-moral opinions. If you don't like the law, then work to change it, but in the meantime...respect it and others it protects.

I've been cheated on, but never cheated...but in NO way does that allow me to abrogate the rights of others...unless, of course, I want it done to me. One of the major reasons we're in the mess we're in in this country is because we have allowed others to undermine our rights...a little at a time...by preying on people with "morals" they profess to believe...

The Constitution belongs to all of us: the workers, the unemployed, the priests, the hookers, the drug addicts, our lawmakers, our police...every citizen.

Do you know how many people sacrificed, suffered, and died for YOU?

Now...for this particular case...I seriously doubt that this is going to go anywhere, because our laws also allow for "civil disobedience," and estoppel. However, the news isn't complete...there may be other extenuating circumstances of which we're unaware. BUT, if this is all there is to it, the guy's a hero, and I seriously think he'll get anything more than a slap on the wrist, if that.

Were I the judge...I'd have to hand out some really minor sentence under a lesser charge, just to discourage others from misinterpreting it as if I was giving them license to act..."just because they want to know."

...but you have to do the right thing for the right reason.
 
FACTS of the case:

1.) They were married.

2.) He bought the laptop.

3.) He paid for the internet connection.

4.) No hacking took place. I repeat...NO hacking took place.

5.) He is not being charged with being a dick, thief or privacy invasion....he is being charged with HACKING under a statute intended for HACKERS.


Whether what he did was right, wrong, etc. etc. etc. he is NOT a hacker and the prosecutor in this case is an idiot. What's next...you listened to your girlfriends iTunes? That's not your ACCOUNT!! YOU DIDN'T PAY FOR THOSE MUSICS!! HACKER!!!! :rolleyes:

oh yeah, one more....

6.) The wife is a cheating ass ho, here rights are forfeit. :D
 
FACTS of the case:

1.) They were married.

2.) He bought the laptop.

3.) He paid for the internet connection.
These points are not relevant. It was not his email. Opening someone else's paper mail is a a federal offence; the law may well treat electronic mail with a similar degree of seriousness.

4.) No hacking took place. I repeat...NO hacking took place.

5.) He is not being charged with being a dick, thief or privacy invasion....he is being charged with HACKING under a statute intended for HACKERS.
Are you familiar with the legal definition of hacking? It was unauthorized access of a computer system; it seems like this could reasonably fall under the umbrella of hacking.
http://definitions.uslegal.com/c/computer-hacking/



Whether what he did was right, wrong, etc. etc. etc. he is NOT a hacker and the prosecutor in this case is an idiot. What's next...you listened to your girlfriends iTunes? That's not your ACCOUNT!! YOU DIDN'T PAY FOR THOSE MUSICS!! HACKER!!!! :rolleyes:
Accessing someone else's music and accessing someone else's email are very different things.


6.) The wife is a cheating ass ho, here rights are forfeit. :D
This does not forfeit her rights.
 
Keyword in that law is "Before" they receive the mail. What about opened mail that is left in the inbox?
 
Keyword in that law is "Before" they receive the mail. What about opened mail that is left in the inbox?

There would be a difference between it being left in an inbox on the computer in something like outlook / thunderbird where anyone on the computer just has to open the program when using it and they can see the emails, and you having to know / find the password to gain access to the account.
 
i think the crime here is that he handed the email's off too someone else... right?
 
I think the rule of thumb would have fixed this situation long time ago.
 
lmao.. That article made me giggle.. I Go through my wifes email on occasion as I am sure she does mine.. To me its a given that its going to be the case.. This being said we have the same password and have no reason to change it as we have nothing to hide from each other..

The couple in the article on the other hand.. What a crock of shit. That bitch should be strung up for wasting the legal systems time.
 
"This does not forfeit her rights."

Thank you. God...just think...if you used some people's rationale, who post here, think of the bandwidth we could save by just accusing people of something WE consider poor behavior, like IDIOCY, bypassing our legal system...then taking them out and shooting them.

No doubt this would raise the average quality of the living human being in general, but it would be wrong...right?

So what do you think the Nazis and Communists did?

Sure...cheating is wrong...but it's only a crime depending on the laws of the state in which you're living...and, then, awfully hard to prove. BUT...with a good PI, you CAN prove it, and I believe that it should be prosecuted.

However...ANYWHERE in US, accessing someone's email is wrong...regardless...but the law also allows for leniency in cases where people are in danger.

If the law was "cut and dried" (like many people here and elsewhere seem to think), there would be no need for judge, juries, and attorneys. All authorities would have to do is look up the crime in a database, and hand out the sentence. Of course...this would require INCONTROVERTABLE evidence...so fewer guilty people would actually be caught and go to jail.

We have deliberately retained the "human element" in order to temper justice with mercy and common sense. I have no doubt that this guy's not going to suffer much, if at all, since it was in defense of a child, and in a situation where it would otherwise be likely to never be detected.

Let's just hope the pendulum swings the other way for the abusers. I personally think that child abusers should be prosecuted to the maximum allowed by law, to the degree of the infraction. (I just somewhat disagree with what constitutes "child abuse" these days...nobody should do time for swatting their kid in the ass for unacceptble behavior. These days, they should get a medal for it.)
 
joint property marriage states I would argue he had as much right to the email account as she did...

a person can break into their significant others car if they are married and its not criminal damage... same with other property etc etc. dont see how a email account is any different. no different then going through her pockets and finding a note etc. no crime on his part.. though if he lives in a state where adultery is still a crime he should demand prosecution for it.

I was more referring to a broader sense and not in this specific case, as several posters have said they should be able to claim access/usage/ownership of all data that passes through their network or a device they own. Likewise if any digital property is accessed without "hacking" in the technical sense is also fair game. If there are no protections legally against these, can you not see how problematic issues will be as more and more of society becomes "digitized"?

Though there are actually specific laws related to marriage regarding privileged communication and exclusions to joint property I believe. As some people have mentioned it is illegal to open letters addressed to your spouse in some states without permission for instance.

Though would people still be for this line of thinking if e-mail providers gave the government access to e-mails without warrants in the name of homeland security? What if ISPs gave free access as well to the government or maybe the RIAA? The same concepts apply, they do not need to "hack" to get access. They also own the network and devices where the content is stored/transmitted. And it is also for the "greater good." Should this then be legal or should there be legal protections?
 
Joint property would refer to the computer, not the email account. The two are completely separate properties.
 
The real shitty part is that he got cheated on, now the bitch wants to put him in jail.
 
Though there are actually specific laws related to marriage regarding privileged communication and exclusions to joint property I believe. As some people have mentioned it is illegal to open letters addressed to your spouse in some states without permission for instance.

This is the only deciding factor here.
 
i guess.... if you find out some one's a terrorist through their mail, don't tell the giv't that's where you got it from.
 
I am honestly surprised at the number of people who are saying that digital property being accessed through a network or device with third party ownership means that third party can now legally access and use what was accessed. And also at how knowing the password to someones digital property also means one can legally access and use it. Do people not see the far reaching implications of this?

They're MARRIED. I fail to see how this is different than going through her underwear drawer or jewelry box and finding letters from the guy. If it was a stranger, I'd be inclined to agree with you, but in this case, it'd take something out of the ordinary to get me to vote for a conviction.
 
lmao.. That article made me giggle.. I Go through my wifes email on occasion as I am sure she does mine.. To me its a given that its going to be the case.. This being said we have the same password and have no reason to change it as we have nothing to hide from each other..

The couple in the article on the other hand.. What a crock of shit. That bitch should be strung up for wasting the legal systems time.



They're MARRIED. I fail to see how this is different than going through her underwear drawer or jewelry box and finding letters from the guy. If it was a stranger, I'd be inclined to agree with you, but in this case, it'd take something out of the ordinary to get me to vote for a conviction.

This is completely different, this is like her having a safty deposit box, you make a copy of her key for it when she is sleeping, you then make a fake ID for a female that you know giving her and have her go to the bank and pretent to be your wife. Then see what she has in there. Remember the email account had a password, there was security in place, it wasn't just sitting there waiting to be read. Regardless of how he got the password, the moment it was secured it was expected to be private. Some states have laws that will keep you from setting up wiretaps on your spouse or setting up hidden cameras without them knowing about it. when you get married you don't give up your rights. If you think you can tie your wife up in the basement and keep her from leaving just because you are married to her or that she can't leave without you being able to put a GPS locator on her and know every single person she will interact with then you are misinformed. I think it sucks that he was cheated on, especially with the person that she was cheating on him with. I think the bitch needs to have her kid taken away and hope that her ex beats the hell out of her now that she is back with him. I guess she must just like it like that. However as i said above, you have to draw a line at some point about what is and isn't ok when it comes to who can and can't access your secure information without being punished for it. he gained access to an account that wasn't his, regardless of what his motives where and that outcome he should have been more careful in what he was doing as that is a slippery slope.
 
To the people saying this is some huge rights violation by this guy... what about the case where the guy that downloaded kiddie porn was turned in by Geek Squad employees and was prosecuted for it? Using the same logic would you defend that pond scum or would you drudge up numerous technicalities to rationalize some difference between the two situations? The situation is no different - someone looked where the law says they shouldn't, but in the Geek Squad situation the law said "Hey, he's a perv so bust him!" and patted Geek Squad on the head for being good little informants, and in this case they said "Dude broke the law by snooping on his wife" and wants to throw him under the bus. That's not what I would consider justice by any means.
 
Joint property would refer to the computer, not the email account. The two are completely separate properties.
While that's true, if they're jointly paying the ISP fees, and the e-mail account is a feature from the ISP, it could be argued that that is jointly owned.

Now, if it's a GMail or other free e-mail account, that's a murkier issue.

I'm a big privacy advocate, and yet I'm torn. The cheating is bad. But my real question is this: What if he had done nothing, and the child in this situation suffered because of it? The real reason he forwarded the information on is because the man his wife had the affair with was violent with her in front of a child. Child endangerment is a serious thing, and while an affair is damaging to every party involved, physical and/or emotional damage to the child is beyond the pale.
 
This is completely different, this is like her having a safty deposit box, you make a copy of her key for it when she is sleeping, you then make a fake ID for a female that you know giving her and have her go to the bank and pretent to be your wife. Then see what she has in there. Remember the email account had a password, there was security in place, it wasn't just sitting there waiting to be read. Regardless of how he got the password, the moment it was secured it was expected to be private. Some states have laws that will keep you from setting up wiretaps on your spouse or setting up hidden cameras without them knowing about it. when you get married you don't give up your rights. If you think you can tie your wife up in the basement and keep her from leaving just because you are married to her or that she can't leave without you being able to put a GPS locator on her and know every single person she will interact with then you are misinformed. I think it sucks that he was cheated on, especially with the person that she was cheating on him with. I think the bitch needs to have her kid taken away and hope that her ex beats the hell out of her now that she is back with him. I guess she must just like it like that. However as i said above, you have to draw a line at some point about what is and isn't ok when it comes to who can and can't access your secure information without being punished for it. he gained access to an account that wasn't his, regardless of what his motives where and that outcome he should have been more careful in what he was doing as that is a slippery slope.

As others have said, he bought the computer and he had access to that computer. If you read email on a work computer, you have zero, ZIP ZILCH expectation of privacy. She used a computer that her husband bought and had regular access too. More than likely, she stayed logged into her email, which, if I'm correct, means she effectively left the letters in an unlocked box on her dresser, and when her husband looked for his cuff links, he found the letters from her lover.

I'm a strong privacy advocate and yes, we have to draw the line somewhere. This isn't that place.
 
Back
Top