Reading Your Cheating Wife's E-mail a Crime?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Seriously? We have criminals running loose everywhere and they charge this guy with a crime? Let's just hope the EFF or one of those other organizations come to his defense.

Leon Walker of Rochester Hills is charged with unlawfully reading his then-wife's e-mail, which showed she was having an affair with her second husband, who once had been arrested for beating her in front of her son. Walker says he gave the e-mails to her first husband, the child's father, to protect the boy. "I was doing what I had to do," he said.
 
Society and world is falling apart. I give the United States until 2015.
 
I am sure the EFF would say that what he did was illegal and refuse to defend him. He should have got a subpoena to access the emails after he discovered evidence located in her email. It would still have been illegal but he would have got away with it if he kept his mouth shut and got what he wanted.
 
Much much much less of a crime than anything Julian Assange and Wikileaks did. Also much more noble too IMO. He deserves to know if his wife is cheating on him and the child deserves protection from the abusive second husband from the affair.

Some people try to claim Assange is a hero, I say make this guy a hero.
 
Much much much less of a crime than anything Julian Assange and Wikileaks did. Also much more noble too IMO. He deserves to know if his wife is cheating on him and the child deserves protection from the abusive second husband from the affair.

Some people try to claim Assange is a hero, I say make this guy a hero.

agreed
 
Niconx,

I don't know what ax you have to grind, but this guy not only did nothing wrong, he did nothing illegal. A female prosecutor with something to prove is trying to make an example out of this guy. She picked the wrong case. Throw out the fact the wife is a piece of lowlife trash, and he did the right thing in protecting that poor boy. The fact he bought the laptop and had routine access to it AND the fact her passwords were next to the computer in a booklet means there was NO hacking going on. He may indeed have "skills" as the prosecutor alleges, but he didn't have to use any of them here.
 
yep. shit is fucked up.

and 1/3 of the people on death row don't belong there.
 
Much much much less of a crime than anything Julian Assange and Wikileaks did. Also much more noble too IMO. He deserves to know if his wife is cheating on him and the child deserves protection from the abusive second husband from the affair.

Some people try to claim Assange is a hero, I say make this guy a hero.

I think you're trying to Troll the wrong thread...
 
Much much much less of a crime than anything Julian Assange and Wikileaks did. Also much more noble too IMO. He deserves to know if his wife is cheating on him and the child deserves protection from the abusive second husband from the affair.

Some people try to claim Assange is a hero, I say make this guy a hero.

Don't forget that newspapers reported some of the same things that Wikileaks did. If Assange is a criminal then so are the editors of the NYT and Washington Post.
 
Niconx,

I don't know what ax you have to grind, but this guy not only did nothing wrong, he did nothing illegal. A female prosecutor with something to prove is trying to make an example out of this guy. She picked the wrong case. Throw out the fact the wife is a piece of lowlife trash, and he did the right thing in protecting that poor boy. The fact he bought the laptop and had routine access to it AND the fact her passwords were next to the computer in a booklet means there was NO hacking going on. He may indeed have "skills" as the prosecutor alleges, but he didn't have to use any of them here.

No axe to grind, technically what he did was illegal, hacking or not. I am speaking from a totally unbiased point of view. I was more upset with the guy for not using the information against her more intelligently and this getting himself into this situation in the first place. He got a little info, got jumpy, and thus threw away his chance to do some good.

You are saying since she failed to protect her password sufficiently it suddenly means anyone in the house can legally access the account even if the rightful account owner disputes such access. That seems a little odd, and how far would you take that premise? Legally speaking it is too vague, so that's how I call it.

Don't forget Firefox allows anyone to view the password it saves in a profile. Suddenly everyone who uses that profile of Firefox is legally allowed to access all of those accounts because the owner didn't secure them better. It sets a terrible precedent to say it was legally accessed.
 
Technically isn't the email his property and his email her property since they are married?
 
Technically isn't the email his property and his email her property since they are married?

Would this not fall under "privileged communication" then?

I know people are going to latch onto the fact that in this case it does not seem to be for nefarious or malicious purposes, but laws (for better or worse) are not supposed to discriminate in this manner.

If you are legally allowed to access someones virtual property as long as you know the password, then this would be open to every circumstance, not just this particular one.

One of the issues today is that technology is moving much faster then the law and society can address its implications.
 
I feel bad for the guy but he acted rashly and now he is an unfortunate jam. The best thing to do in these volatile situations is to step back, think and consider all the options. Whenever you deal with ex-husbands or wife's I always recommend talking to a lawyer first before you run off half-cocked and do something stupid.

And yes, technically he did break the law if his wife did not give him permission to access her email even if it is a computer he bought and has access to daily. Just like technically speeding 5mph over the limit, jaywalking and spitting on the ground is against the law. The DA's office is in charge of deciding what cases are worthwhile to prosecute... looks like someone's running for re-election.
 
The law states:
"A person shall not intentionally and without authorization or by exceeding valid authorization do any of the following:
"Access or cause access to be made to a computer program, computer, computer system or computer network to acquire, alter, damage delete or destroy property or otherwise use the service of a computer program, computer, computer system or computer network.

I think in this case, where they are married, living together, and sharing use of a co-owned computer, he did not exceed valid authorization to access information contained on it. Especially if he had an administrator account. My only concession may be in the difference between info locally stored on the drive, and info external to the computer - stored on web servers for example. Was she using the browser to get into the mail, or a mail client to download the mail?
Damn - alright - grey area.........a locally stored password. Hmm. May still be outside valid authorization to log-in even with access to the password considering the mail would be outside the local computer.
 
Anybody wonder how this would be if the genders were reversed?
 
What a monumental waste of time, taxpayers dollars, and in her case, a waste of flesh and breathing air.

But, since she was his ex wife at the time he accessed those emails, (according to the article), he is prolly up shit creek. He should have just warned the first husband about what was going on quietly, on the down low. Let the first husband work out how to get custody from the ho. Yes, ho, any woman that goes through three husbands, cheats on the third husband with the second, and is stupid enough to have willingly sex with a guy that has beaten her ass, is a stupid ho.
 
What a monumental waste of time, taxpayers dollars, and in her case, a waste of flesh and breathing air.

But, since she was his ex wife at the time he accessed those emails, (according to the article), he is prolly up shit creek. He should have just warned the first husband about what was going on quietly, on the down low. Let the first husband work out how to get custody from the ho. Yes, ho, any woman that goes through three husbands, cheats on the third husband with the second, and is stupid enough to have sex willingly with a guy that has beaten her ass, is a stupid ho.

typing too fast words got flipped.
 
@GORANKAR
The article seems to reference her as his wife at the time, and the divorce wasn't until afterwards.


Two things come to mind reading this article.

"Letter of the law vs the spirit of the law"

"Does the punishment fit the crime?"
 
Whenever you deal with ex-husbands or wife's I always recommend talking to a lawyer first before you run off half-cocked and do something stupid.

Amen to this. Don't think you know you're doing something right in the eyes of the law. Find out from a lawyer, you will save yourself a lot of headaches. The reason this prosecutor is doing this has more to do with "battered women" and abusive boyfriends/husbands. It's misguided IMO but nonetheless there to protect innocent women who are in this abusive relationships where their abusive "other" is in control of all, and they would have no way to be protected.
 
As the admin of my home network, I frequently need to capture and review network traffic so I can address network and security issues. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. :)
 
so, does this mean I am not allowed to read the snail mail addressed to my wife? wife has a credit card in her name, I open the bill to pay it, (or access the account online) and notice a charge that indicates to me she is cheating, do I get arrested for acting on this info?

This sort of thing wanders into all sorts of strange territory, does it mean that the television show cheaters is violating the right to privacy of a spouse, when it films the spouse kissing the baby sitter?

wow.
 
This is utter and complete crap. The prosecutor in this case needs to be prosecuted for unlawful prosecution. This is an abuse of law if I've ever seen one.
 
Wonder who was the owner of the internet connection? If it was him, he should be able to access anything, since he would be held accountable for his (ex)wifes porn collection, if it was illegal type porn. Not to mention all her torrented stuff.
 
As the admin of my home network, I frequently need to capture and review network traffic so I can address network and security issues. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. :)

You sound paranoid, maybe you should see someone for that...
 
so, does this mean I am not allowed to read the snail mail addressed to my wife?
You can read it with her permission. Otherwise it is a federal offence to open another person's mail.

§ 1702. Obstruction of correspondence said:
Whoever takes any letter, postal card, or package out of any post office or any authorized depository for mail matter, or from any letter or mail carrier, or which has been in any post office or authorized depository, or in the custody of any letter or mail carrier, before it has been delivered to the person to whom it was directed, with design to obstruct the correspondence, or to pry into the business or secrets of another, or opens, secretes, embezzles, or destroys the same, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than five years, or both.
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode18/usc_sec_18_00001702----000-.html
 
As the admin of my home network, I frequently need to capture and review network traffic so I can address network and security issues. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. :)

No need to worry about justification here - I totally agree with the basis of your argument.
 
Highly skilled hacker? Alrighty then.
You'd think the court system would have more important things to do? Guess not.
 
How is it illegal when it's his device and his network connection... and the password was knowingly written down in a notebook nearby. There was no "hacking", nor illegal access. It was all in the clear what the information was there and available. He even had consent to access it from what I read, but when he found the info and all hell broke loose she rescinded it and that claimed impropriety is what got him in trouble. I seriously hope this gets thrown out of court post haste.
 
Considering that when you are married, in terms of property rights, you are considered a single legal entity, I honestly don't see how this would stand up in court.
 
A friend of mine was suspecious of this wife being unfaithful so he decided to check into her email. He did and found very incriminating evidence. He confronted her about the cheating and she was more upset that he read her email than the cheating itself and she had been caught.

The moral of the story folks, cheaters will always screw up and some point and you will find out one way or other. If you HAVE to check on your spouses email then he/she is not worth having a relantionship/marriage with. If you have trust issues that thats another story entirely.

I don't have time or the inclination to check anybody's email. As far as im concerned, people's email(including spouse) is none of my business unless its a shared account of some sort.
 
When married, you are can be treated as a single entity. Let us use Credit cards as an example..

Couple has 2 separate bank accounts before they got married, they keep them separated, and split the bills each month and never merge their accounts. Husband gets a credit card, and runs up a 50,000 bill. He then dies in a car accident from a drunk driver..

Wife is legally allowed to file suit against drunk driver / insurance on behalf of her dead husband.

Wife now is legally responsible for $50,000 credit card bill.

Even though their property was separated, the law sees it all as the same, no matter what safeguards private entities (i.e. banks & bank accounts) were put in place. The only way to avert something like this would be with a PreNup / Will.
 
If he was white and female, nobody would ever have heard this.

Why the fuck do we tolerate women in our society? They get our children (even despite major confounds like drug abuse), half our shit etc. They're more likely to fall out of love, use a weapon in a dispute etc. Giving them the right to vote was the worst thing our nation has ever done.

Sometimes I wish cock didn't disgust me. It'd be so much easier than dealing with stupid whores.
 
Back
Top