Busting 10 Top Myths About Technology

Too bad the CNET author didn't address the myth about putting a bad hard drive in the freezer before trying to recover its data.

Oh, I guess I didn't get the 700gb off data off my wd caviar green 1tb drive when it went caput with the help of my freezer then. ...Oh wait, I did. It's hard to forget those little 30 minute bursts before it crapped out again and I had to put it back. Took a while, but yeah, certainly not a myth.
 
For everyone complaining about Geeksquad, I want to hear your suggestions for authorities? How about some forum nerd who has zero credentials? Would they be better people to ask? Yeah, I thought so.

Because apparently no one on Geeksquad can't be knowledgeable can they? The bias in this forum is absolutely astounding.

Geeksquad's reputation is deserved. It's well known that they snoop on PC's, re-image the drive and claim "virus" when they can't fix a software problem, which is often, and generally don't know what the spork they're doing. Does that mean all Geeksquad employees are incompetent? Of course not, but why would I recommend their services to anyone when I know I from experience that I can do a better job? Why would anyone here do that? If that's bias, then we have every right to be biased.

Regarding credentials... credentials don't mean jack. It's a piece of paper that says you can pass a test. I would wager that pretty much anyone on this forum has enough knowledge to pass an A+ certification test without even taking the course. There are people with MCSE certifications that don't know how to fix an IP conflict on a network printer. Book smarts != problem solving skills, and problem solving skills are what matter most when it comes to troubleshooting.
 
C| The myth that "all computer geeks are nerds that can't get chicks" is curiously absent from the list. :D

Thats because that one has been busted a long time ago :p geeks have money so they get the chicks:p,
 
Oh, I guess I didn't get the 700gb off data off my wd caviar green 1tb drive when it went caput with the help of my freezer then. ...Oh wait, I did. It's hard to forget those little 30 minute bursts before it crapped out again and I had to put it back. Took a while, but yeah, certainly not a myth.

How do you know it was the freezer and not just the fact that you gave it a nap. :p
 
It had nothing to do with s spinning down of disks.

It had to do with positioning of the read/write arm. Back in the days of 10 MB MFM hard drives, you actually had to manually park your HD heads. Later on the OS did it for you, with a shutdown command. Today, the hard drives do it themselves, even in the event of losing power.

The hard drive head "floats" above the platters on a cushion of air formed by the disk spinning. If the read arm isn't parked, when the drive slows down enough the read head touches and scratches the platter.

This is where the term "Hard Drive Crash" came from - the read/write head literally crashing onto the drive platters and damaging them.

You obviously didn't read what I said then, since that was not even the reason for the "15" second myth. That is why I didn't go into more detail about it. Please read more fully before posting someone else is incorrect.
 
You obviously didn't read what I said then, since that was not even the reason for the "15" second myth. That is why I didn't go into more detail about it. Please read more fully before posting someone else is incorrect.


My response was more towards the GS person than you. You just brought up the spinning down part, I elaborated on it a little bit further (why the GS person was wrong, not you). Sorry if you took it the wrong way.
 
I was going to tell you guys to not jump to conclusions and give the Geek Squad guy the benefit of the doubt. But after reading how he's blatantly wrong about having to drain batteries all the way to 0 before recharging to get max perf, I lost hope in him as well. That was true with older battery tech, but not today's Li-Ion. :rolleyes:

I never heard of the keyboard/dishwasher thing.

Too bad the CNET author didn't address the myth about putting a bad hard drive in the freezer before trying to recover its data.

The HDD 'freezer trick' was effective for the old Hitachi Deskstar (Deathstar). It would allow some users to recover small amounts of data. Wasnt without its fair share of failures though. Wasnt fool-proof by any measure, either.
 
The HDD 'freezer trick' was effective for the old Hitachi Deskstar (Deathstar). It would allow some users to recover small amounts of data. Wasnt without its fair share of failures though. Wasnt fool-proof by any measure, either.

Grr, what is this was? I used it for a tb drive just a year ago so it can clearly still work. I'm not saying it's needed or works in every case, just that it isn't a myth.
 
I didn't notice the comment about the freezer trick but I can say that it did work for me when my hard drive was dying and I had to grab everything off of it. It's hardly a "myth". It works for certain drives but not others is more like it. SSD hard drives? No shit, it won't work. People at this forum unlike Geek Squad are not dumb.
 
My response was more towards the GS person than you. You just brought up the spinning down part, I elaborated on it a little bit further (why the GS person was wrong, not you). Sorry if you took it the wrong way.

I understand, but if you quote me, than that means you are responding to what I said. If you were going to respond to the what the GS person said in the article, then grab the quote from there. It makes it far less confusing.
 
You must wait 15 seconds before rebooting your computer

...I decided that since this was a hardware question, the best place to turn was to the Geek Squad...


Yeah I stopped reading right there.

I stopped caring right there, but I read the rest of it.. The only part of interest was the femaile gamers part..
 
Ha. This is one of those times I'm glad I visited the [H] comments before RTFA. I will now just GTFO with a few minutes of my time spared.

I just wished the Editors here would spare us all the grief and not post links to such drivel in the first place.
 
Oh, I guess I didn't get the 700gb off data off my wd caviar green 1tb drive when it went caput with the help of my freezer then. ...Oh wait, I did. It's hard to forget those little 30 minute bursts before it crapped out again and I had to put it back. Took a while, but yeah, certainly not a myth.
That's cool (no pun intended :p) that the freezer trick worked for you. How long did you freeze your HDD for in both instances?

The HDD 'freezer trick' was effective for the old Hitachi Deskstar (Deathstar). It would allow some users to recover small amounts of data. Wasnt without its fair share of failures though. Wasnt fool-proof by any measure, either.
I guess when desperate, it can't hurt to try out the freezer trick. In general, do you put the hard drive in the freezer by itself or inside a Ziploc bag?

I just wished the Editors here would spare us all the grief and not post links to such drivel in the first place.
You don't enjoy comic relief? :p
 
Interesting.

I never heard the myth that you needed to leave a computer off for 15 seconds before powering it up again in order to avoid damage. That's a new one for me.

That being said, with all electronics, if I am having issues and restart it to see if that will work, I'll let it sit unplugged for ~30 seconds in order to make sure all of the capacitors are completely discharged so that I can be sure all memory has been cleared...
 
While the GS guy falsely said that (Li-Ion) batteries should be fully drained before recharged, many here have said that actually damages the battery. Does it really make a difference? Or is it true that fully discharging and recharging these batteries is worse than partially discharging and recharging? :confused:
 
That's cool (no pun intended :p) that the freezer trick worked for you. How long did you freeze your HDD for in both instances?


I guess when desperate, it can't hurt to try out the freezer trick. In general, do you put the hard drive in the freezer by itself or inside a Ziploc bag?

You're right no pun intended. Because it wasn't cool, it was freezing. Also, if memory serves I stuck it in for 30 min bursts before attacking again each time. Also, I obviously can't speak for if it made a difference, but I stuck it in an antistatic bag which I put in a ziplock bag each time.
 
You're right no pun intended. Because it wasn't cool, it was freezing. Also, if memory serves I stuck it in for 30 min bursts before attacking again each time. Also, I obviously can't speak for if it made a difference, but I stuck it in an antistatic bag which I put in a ziplock bag each time.
Sounds logical enough, other than knowing why freezing a HDD can help recover its data. Good to know in the unfortunate circumstance that I have to recover data from a seemingly dead HDD.
 
While the GS guy falsely said that (Li-Ion) batteries should be fully drained before recharged, many here have said that actually damages the battery. Does it really make a difference? Or is it true that fully discharging and recharging these batteries is worse than partially discharging and recharging? :confused:

Yes, for most modern rechargeable battery tech. Draining the battery 100% out is bad. So is leaving something laying around without a charge for months at a time so that it drains out.
 
I was going to tell you guys to not jump to conclusions and give the Geek Squad guy the benefit of the doubt. But after reading how he's blatantly wrong about having to drain batteries all the way to 0 before recharging to get max perf, I lost hope in him as well. That was true with older battery tech, but not today's Li-Ion. :rolleyes:

I never heard of the keyboard/dishwasher thing.

Too bad the CNET author didn't address the myth about putting a bad hard drive in the freezer before trying to recover its data.

So if you read the article you would of seen they state nickel batteries specifically :rolleyes:
 
So if you read the article you would of seen they state nickel batteries specifically :rolleyes:

What? The article most certainly DOES NOT state nickel batteries specifically. :rolleyes:

They added some footnote to the bottom afterwards. Either way the GS moron cant have meant nickel specific hes just an idiot. Nothing is coming with nickel batteries these days so even if he did mean nickel specifically why the fuck would he give that answer?
 
Yes, for most modern rechargeable battery tech. Draining the battery 100% out is bad. So is leaving something laying around without a charge for months at a time so that it drains out.
I guess I'm having trouble reasoning why that would be the case. :confused: That pretty much means the recharging behavior of nickel nickel batteries and today's lithium batteries are direct opposites. :eek:
 
Stopped reading after I read this..
I decided that since this was a hardware question, the best place to turn was to the Geek Squad...

Seriously?
 
The CNET author is also getting raped (although not as badly as here) by CNET posters. :D Such as:

Don't know if any one caught this yet but Terdiman edited this article from the original that I read the day it came out, though he did not mark it as edited. No he just changed it so he doesn't appear so miss informed. A real journalist heck anybody with integrity would have marked it as edited and given reasons why. What a low life, CNET why are you allowing this wanna be to tarnish your reputation?
 
I guess I'm having trouble reasoning why that would be the case. :confused: That pretty much means the recharging behavior of nickel nickel batteries and today's lithium batteries are direct opposites. :eek:

They are. For nickel you wanted a full charge and full discharge for optimal conditions for lithium Ion the best thing you can do for it is never fully charge it and never fully discharge it.
 
They are. For nickel you wanted a full charge and full discharge for optimal conditions for lithium Ion the best thing you can do for it is never fully charge it and never fully discharge it.

That's pretty scary b/c people were correctly told during the old rechargeable battery days to fully discharge then recharge. How many of them will unlearn those habits? For example, my father keeps insisting on draining his cell phone battery before recharging. :(
 
Back
Top