FCC Poised to Adopt Network Neutrality Rules

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The good news is that the FCC is set to pass net neutrality rules. That bad news is that the rules aren't as strong as they should be, possible just making matters worse than they already are. Thanks to [H] reader Maximuss for the link.

The rules would prohibit phone and cable companies from abusing their control over broadband connections to discriminate against rival content or services, such as Internet phone calls or online video, or play favorites with Web traffic.
 
I want to go back to 1997 or 98 when this site and Anandtech were all new, and the MaximumPC forums were a hot spot for information. There wasn't a pop up or an advertisement blasted in your face every which way you turned. You would have never thought that one day there would be a reason to fear what amounts to restricting your internet access in the name of greed.

sigh
 
Yay -- now let's wait for congress to get involved and argue about something they know little to nothing about!
 
"Republicans, meanwhile, warn that the new rules would impose unnecessary regulations on an industry that is one of the few bright spots in the current economy, with phone and cable companies spending billions to upgrade their networks for broadband."

^ Prove it! We the tax payers spend billions on upgrades! Anyone remember the broadband stimulus plan?

As long as these company's still use the "Up To" in their billing I wont accept that B.S. that you see above.
 
This isn't good. Once the government gets their hands on anything it's not good. It is a form of communication and therefore they'll probably do it, but it will take away part of the freedom of the net.:mad:
 
This isn't good. Once the government gets their hands on anything it's not good. It is a form of communication and therefore they'll probably do it, but it will take away part of the freedom of the net.:mad:

Yeah because Comcast is so much more trustworthy...
 
There is a big difference between Crapcast managing content and delivery and the government doing it. As another poster said, the government doesn't understand the highly technical aspects of traffic management (on the interwebs or otherwise) and certainly lacks the expertise to properly manage net traffic. Once they get the hooks in, you never know what can happen. This already affects content because everyone knows the issue is video distribution.

Stupid is as stupid does.
 
As far as I'm concerned, Comcast and the government are both in it for themselves.
 
I'm not getting excited over this... when net neutrality rules are passed, made permanent, then I'll breath a sigh of relief. But until that happens all those billions of dollars those companies made can send lawyers and lobbyists and all sorts of other things to change laws, buy votes, and kill baby seals.
 
I read in one of the articles about net neutrality that they would encourage isp's to try different pricing schemes. Does this mean that that the isp couldn't block you from say Netflix...but if you want to view it with speeds supporting HD you'll have to ante up $10 extra on top of your normal isp bill? With this being a way to control traffic congestion on their network as they see fit. Still trying to get my head around what all of this means.
 
This is a load of shit. When has the government fixed anything? Get ready for the royal ram job.....
 
This is a load of shit. When has the government fixed anything? Get ready for the royal ram job.....

WWI, WWII, The Constitution, the highway system, ending slavery, women's right to vote, desegregation, social security, the military, monitoring and controlling air traffic, GPS, the internet, removal of "preexisting conditions" from insurance denials, the park system, the EPA, etc. etc. etc.

The rules are weak, yes, but they need to be put forth so that greedy corporations like Comcast know that they do have something to stop them. Maybe.. possibly. Again, the rules are weak. Having no rules is great as long as there's no bigger fish out there controlling everything. Which is the growing problem.
 
There is a big difference between Crapcast managing content and delivery and the government doing it. As another poster said, the government doesn't understand the highly technical aspects of traffic management (on the interwebs or otherwise) and certainly lacks the expertise to properly manage net traffic. Once they get the hooks in, you never know what can happen. This already affects content because everyone knows the issue is video distribution.

Ever heard of the NSA? :p
 
rofl social security rofl

Well. it'd work great if the government hadn't stolen TRILLIONS from it to buy new cars and yachts. It's only failing because Congress took no-interest loans from it once they realized it was a cash cow. A healthy portion of our national debt is owed to Social Security loans.

If that money had stayed there, remained interest bearing and usable, things would be fine. Then again, a massive population surge after WWII coupled with longer lifespans and more people cheating the system aren't helping either. Despite the bad press, it's still the only program that pulls in a profit.
 
Yes when fighting for freedom, . We are talking about regulations, restrictions. The EPA? Please! Social Security? Even a bigger joke.... This is just a power grab....
 
Here comes the Lawyers.....The FCC did its thing today. ISP's you can lick Jelly off my @$$, because your b.s. lies are over. Upgrade your infrastructure and dont even think about passing the buck off on us. Cause we already pay Tax's to subsidize your already poor infrastructure that you pass the back right back on us.
 
The Correct Answer is: This is bad.

If Comcast shafts you, just go to DSL or a half-dozen cell providers (five years from now, landline internet might be quaint). If the government shafts you, there's nothing you can do about it (unless you want to go out in a blaze of glory). Both Comcast and the government know this.

There's a lot more chance of the government dictating discriminatory traffic rules than for Comcast to choose to do it on their own. Comcast doesn't even have to care, because their competition will be saddled by the same thing. Unless your make you living on the backs of taxpayers, with the government, you always lose.
 
The Correct Answer is: This is bad.

If Comcast shafts you, just go to DSL or a half-dozen cell providers (five years from now, landline internet might be quaint). If the government shafts you, there's nothing you can do about it (unless you want to go out in a blaze of glory). Both Comcast and the government know this.

There's a lot more chance of the government dictating discriminatory traffic rules than for Comcast to choose to do it on their own. Comcast doesn't even have to care, because their competition will be saddled by the same thing. Unless your make you living on the backs of taxpayers, with the government, you always lose.


qft
 
What isn't realized by some is the free internet already exists (except for the DNS centralization issues). Corporations are already employing competition, and getting your government to regulate it is just going to chew up more useless tax dollars and further bloat your government when there is no real threat.

If anything this will offer certain competitive advantages to only some businesses. I for one like what Milton Friedman says and support a free market.
 
WWI, WWII, The Constitution, the highway system, ending slavery, women's right to vote, desegregation, social security, the military, monitoring and controlling air traffic, GPS, the internet, removal of "preexisting conditions" from insurance denials, the park system, the EPA, etc. etc. etc.

Wow, what a list of total failures.

WWII - Government purposefully provoked Japan to attack the US, then allowed the attack to proceed to ensure our entry into the war. Government cost thousands of soldiers their lives.

Highway System - Federal highway funds are routinely used to enforce Federal authority over the states in areas which the federal government has no authority. Why is the drinking age 21 in all states? Because if you don't raise your age to 21, the government withholds the federal highway funds. This is a perfect example of how the government, once it has its claws in place, will abuse the position. It is not something that might happen, it is something that WILL happen.

Ending Slavery - Our government killed almost 700,000 people to do that. No other western country in the world ended slavery with a war. Civil war wasn't about slavery anyway, that was a sideshow. It was about economic power and wealth.

The military - Which is responsible for the deaths of over 100,000 innocent civilians in the last decade alone. Who could as for more than that?

Air traffic system (FAA) - See this weeks clown new title...."FAA loses track of 119,000 aircraft" http://dailyherald.com/article/20101209/business/101209490/

Pre-existing condition removal - You realize that the actual penmanship of the health bill was done by the insurance companies? And yes, it had anti preexisting condition removal language in it, so what is the result of that? wait for it......."Insurers drop child-only coverage on eve of health reform mandates" - As preexisting condition rules kick in for children, health plans stop selling such policies in most markets, casting doubt on their reform pledges. http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2010/10/04/bil11004.htm

As the small sampling above shows, you can surely see that anything and everything the government gets its hands on is destroyed, manipulated, brokered for power, lied about, leveraged, abused, and is managed with a general sense of a drunk clown.

In 20 or 30 years, these net neutrality rules WILL be the basis for a bunch of new unenumerated powers. Once it's "accepted" that the government can regulate all these new things about the internet, that power will be exploited by someone. Ie, as soon as a corporate friendly person runs the FCC, the rules will be modified and leveraged by the corporations for their own benefit.
 
I'm confused. Just how can the FCC make up rules as it goes? Isn't Congresss supposed to make the laws???
 
actually, the FCC is just being a bunch of pussies, they need to go back to the old days and make comcrap and the rest rent out the lines at cost like they did ATT before the repubs took over
 
There's a (surprising, I know) fairly well researched article on the FCC and net neutrality in the Wall Street Journal. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB100...031512110086694.html?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTop=

This is so bad, the internet was fairly free. Decent competing services in many areas (I know....really bad choices in others...don't like it? move.)

After reading some of the rules, it seems they are in large part anti-neutrality. Hilarious.

"The new rules will also allow phone and cable companies to sell to Internet companies like Amazon.com Inc. faster data delivery for extra money, particularly on wireless networks. That would let a company that offers streaming video, like Google Inc.'s YouTube, pay a wireless company like Verizon Communications Inc. a bonus for guaranteed delivery of its videos to consumers' smart phones."

What's funny is that they could already do this, there is no law that says they can't, but nobody would actually have done it due to the outcry if such a deal was made public. Now, this tactic is enshrined in "law", so they're free to offer it up.

And the wireless stuff is just terrible. While currently the wireless networks are fairly open...yes handsets are locked down, but anyone who wants to can root/jailbreak/reflash their phone and run any app they want. Now, the carriers have the green light to do packet based discrimination.

"Wireless companies are less restricted by the new rules—a win for the industry because consumers are increasingly accessing the web using hand-held devices such as iPhones or Blackberries. Mr. Genachowski said mobile carriers faced more congestion issues than other companies and need more leeway to manage their networks.

"Wireless companies would be prohibited from blocking Internet voice services but they could block access to many other applications, citing congestion issues."

Wireless was the internet that was eventually going to free us from the local physical last mile monopoly. That will never happen. Wireless networks will never need to grow to accept all traffic consumers want, they'll just block whatever type of traffic they need to in order to do the minimal build out required.

In other words, the growth of wireless infrastructure is now on the carriers' terms instead of the consumers by legal fiat. This is good for the comcasts of the world, too, because now the market cannot force the wireless carriers to directly compete against the last mile providers. What a shitbag for consumers this whole thing is.
 
I'm confused. Just how can the FCC make up rules as it goes? Isn't Congresss supposed to make the laws???

This is how most regulations and "laws" are made in the US. By unelected bureaucrats. A strict (and common sense) reading of the constitution and the separation of powers doctrine would obviously mean that only congress can make laws. Ie, they cannot make a law that says "Agency X can make up regulations about Area Y as needed".

See the non delegation doctrine - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nondelegation_doctrine

Of course, violating the non delegation doctrine is what Congress does day in and day out. The IRS, SEC, FBI, FCC, ICC, EPA, ATF - they all exercise powers of law that were supposed to be delegated only to Congress.

That's how you get so many pages of tax law that all the pages cannot be read in a normal human lifespan.

So no, the FCC isn't and shouldn't be able to do such things as make up laws. But when do we ever pay attention to the constitution anyway?
 
Wow, what a list of total failures.

WWII - Government purposefully provoked Japan to attack the US, then allowed the attack to proceed to ensure our entry into the war. Government cost thousands of soldiers their lives.

Highway System - Federal highway funds are routinely used to enforce Federal authority over the states in areas which the federal government has no authority. Why is the drinking age 21 in all states? Because if you don't raise your age to 21, the government withholds the federal highway funds. This is a perfect example of how the government, once it has its claws in place, will abuse the position. It is not something that might happen, it is something that WILL happen.

Ending Slavery - Our government killed almost 700,000 people to do that. No other western country in the world ended slavery with a war. Civil war wasn't about slavery anyway, that was a sideshow. It was about economic power and wealth.

The military - Which is responsible for the deaths of over 100,000 innocent civilians in the last decade alone. Who could as for more than that?

I'm impressed whenever I see someone who sees through the BS. Anyway, now the FCC is allowed to make "laws" and do with the internet as they wish. They're not going to sin on that power and do nothing.

From the bill, "The Commission [FCC] may, by rule [FCC made-law], define with specificity, the acts or practices that shall constitute unfair methods of competition." Notice, the language is about fairness (as decide by the FCC) not net neutrality. The FCC can do anything they want in the name of fairness to the consumer. When has the government not used "fairness" as an excuse for discriminatory behavior?
 
Back
Top