Poor Mushkin Callisto DX SSD Performance

techobrien

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 27, 2010
Messages
132
So I know these benchmarks aren't perfect, but I have been noticing some slow-down on my Mushkin Callisto DX drive which is less than 2 months old, and decided to see what kind of results I get. To say the least, this is pretty disappointing.
Any thoughts as to what's going on here?

CDI.png


as-ssd-bench%20Mushkin%20MKNSSDCL%2011.30.2010%2012-52-31%20PM.png



EDIT:

I received a firmware update from Mushkin and applied it. Results actually got WORSE?! See below

ssd%20info%202.png


as%20ssd%202.png


System is a Lenovo T400, 4 GB DDR3 Ram, Intel T9400 2.53 GHZ. Intel RST 9.6.1014, running in AHCI mode. 12.3 GB / 37.1 GB Free Space, Disk Data Cache Enabled

Any feedback is appreciated.
 
Last edited:
Contacting Mushkin Support, anything anyone recommends trying before I RMA this puppy? :confused:
 
Coupla thoughts.....I don't know what speeds the drive is supposed to have....that SMART data from Crystal Disk doesn't mean anything.

The mobile chipsets in laptops usually aren't as speedy as the desktop versions.

Is that chipset SATA2?
 
Coupla thoughts.....I don't know what speeds the drive is supposed to have....that SMART data from Crystal Disk doesn't mean anything.

The mobile chipsets in laptops usually aren't as speedy as the desktop versions.

Is that chipset SATA2?

It's a SF-1222 controller (I believe) and it's got an advertised 285 MB/s read, 275 MB/s write. I don't actually expect to get those speeds, but remotely close would definitely be nice.

It's definitely SATA II and a decent chipset so I'm not sure this is the laptops fault, but to be safe I'll go ahead and test it in a desktop later today (after I sleep :p)

I'm also now getting BSOD on wakeup from sleep and a whole slew of other issue after flashing, so something weird is definitely going on here
 
It's definitely SATA II
I've read numerous reports about some of those laptop SATA2 configurations and it turns out some are actually SATA1.

If you look at your max seq. read in both cases it looks capped at SATA1 speeds.

Not only that...it's got the infamous SF "overly optomistic" "not real world" specs.

This inflation issue has been discussed before but here's a current thread.

Basically the SF drives can only achieve those rated speeds under certain conditions but in real world use they aren't what the specs would indicate.

Go ahead and send it back but I think it's doing the best it can in this situation.
 
I've read numerous reports about some of those laptop SATA2 configurations and it turns out some are actually SATA1.

If you look at your max seq. read in both cases it looks capped at SATA1 speeds.

Not only that...it's got the infamous SF "overly optomistic" "not real world" specs.

This inflation issue has been discussed before but here's a current thread.

Basically the SF drives can only achieve those rated speeds under certain conditions but in real world use they aren't what the specs would indicate.

Go ahead and send it back but I think it's doing the best it can in this situation.

Hmm well I know my side UltraBay port is definitely Sata1, as reported by RST Utility, however that same utility reports Sata2 for the main HDD. I'll do some research, but is there any way to definitively tell if it's capped or not on any system?

Thanks for the link, quite an entertaining heated debate over there :D I do understand the 285/275 rates are highly inflated and overly optimistic, and I do realize the compressed / unconpressed data issue, but even according to that thread Sandforce SSD's with the same chipset are getting roughly 200 MB/s write and 100 MB/s read with the same testing utility I used, so something is not quite right either way.

Just wanted to say thanks for all your help Old Hippie I appreciate it.
 
I'll do some research, but is there any way to definitively tell if it's capped or not on any system?
Just install the drive in a desktop machine and run a test.

Your laptop sure looks like SATA1 to me.

Sandforce SSD's with the same chipset are getting roughly 200 MB/s write and 100 MB/s read with the same testing utility I used,
That sounds about right but.......
The SF drives read/write real world speeds seem to depend upon the size of the drive....many drives are like this and the best scores always go to the larger drives. That's what makes RAID0 so compelling with these SSDs.

AAR, when you're comparing real world speeds, make sure it's the same size drive.
 
Last edited:
Just install the drive in a desktop machine and run a test.

Your laptop sure looks like SATA1 to me.


That sounds about right but.......
The SF drives read/write real world speeds seem to depend upon the size of the drive....many drives are like this and the best scores always go to the larger drives. That's what makes RAID0 so compelling with these SSDs.

AAR, when you're comparing real world speeds, make sure it's the same size drive.

Well unfortunately for me you hit the nail right on the head with the SATA1 prediction :(

Just found this from lenovo:

For Santa Rosa-based systems, the Intel ICH8 supports a SATA bus speed of up to 3.0 Gb/s. Lenovo made a design decision to prioritize maintaining compatibility with Ultrabay disk drives, which are connected via a SATA-to-PATA conversion chip which could not handle a 3.0 Gb/s SATA bus speed reliably. Therefore the system was standardized to 1.5 Gb/s.
In testing rotating media drives, our measurements show data throughput difference between 1.5 Gb/s and 3.0 Gb/s bus speed is less than 5% since the drive mechanics are the limiting throughput factor, rather than the SATA bus itself.
For those customers who choose to purchase an after-market SSD drive capable of SATA bus speeds up to 3.0 Gb/s, the system will interface with them at 1.5 Gb/s. Lenovo's official position is that the Santa Rosa systems are working as designed.
The Montevina based systems which began shipping last year have direct SATA interfaces for both drive bays and are enabled at a system level for SATA bus speeds of 3.0 Gb/s performance. Current Lenovo drives have firmware set to 1.5 Gb/s data rates.
Exchanging these drives for after-market drives which support SATA bus of 3.0 Gb/s should provide for the higher data rate at the overall system level. Again, it should be noted that our performance measurements show less than 5% performance improvement between 1.5 Gb/s and 3.0 Gb/s SATA bus speeds for rotating drives, since the drive mechanics are the limiting throughput factor, rather than the SATA bus itself.
After-market SSDs which support SATA bus speed of 3.0 Gb/s will operate at that bus speed. Depending on the data transfer test method used, your actual data throughput from a 3.0 Gb/s SATA bus speed should be 220-250 MB/s and about 90-120MB/s throughput when running on SATA bus of 1.5 Gb/s. This is due to the bus signaling used for the SATA bus, as well as overhead for error checking

That being said, shouldn't performance be limited only to approx. 140-150 MB/s each way? This cap is definitely reflected in the read speed, but what about write speed? EDIT: Checked out some benches are 70-80 MB/s is normal for this size drive and controller combo.
My next question would be why did the drive get worse after the firmware update, and how do I get that original speed back?

Thank you for pointing out the size difference. I'll go ahead and test the drive in another computer and post the results
 
Last edited:
My next question would be why did the drive get worse after the firmware update
I see a drop of 11 points in your final score which isn't much.

I can't tell the date spread between tests but you're going to have a little difference as SSDs age or maybe it was just before TRIM had taken place or the firmware update or........it could be anything but it's nothing drastic. ;)

Like I said, the drive's doing all it can under the circumstances.

Good Luck!
 
I see a drop of 11 points in your final score which isn't much.

I can't tell the date spread between tests but you're going to have a little difference as SSDs age or maybe it was just before TRIM had taken place or the firmware update or........it could be anything but it's nothing drastic. ;)

Like I said, the drive's doing all it can under the circumstances.

Good Luck!

The second test was about 10 minutes after the first test, and a third test about 10 minutes later only was doing about 40 MB/s write. Just kind of weird behavior IMO but I understand SSD's can be fickle things. I'll keep poking around the drive, unfortunately I haven't heard back from Mushkin so I'm not feeling too good about the RMA.

:) Thanks for all your help Old Hippie, I appreciate it
 
The second test was about 10 minutes after the first test, and a third test about 10 minutes later only was doing about 40 MB/s write
Sounds about right. Sometimes the "cleaning" tools (TRIM/GC) take awhile to do their job.

I'm not sure about Mushkin's RMA policies but I'm sure your drive is OK and an RMA would be a waste of time and money.;)
 
Sounds about right. Sometimes the "cleaning" tools (TRIM/GC) take awhile to do their job.

I'm not sure about Mushkin's RMA policies but I'm sure your drive is OK and an RMA would be a waste of time and money.;)

Ohh hrm I didn't take GC into consideration :p

Well I'll see if I can fix the yummy random bsod errors, but with the drive being so new I'm inclined just to have them swap it.
 
I was gonna add this to my post.......

I'm also now getting BSOD on wakeup from sleep and a whole slew of other issue after flashing, so something weird is definitely going on here

I guess I should have said that the drive's speed specs looked OK but if you're stiil having other issues, I'd send it back.

I forgot about the "Random Issues" after the update.

I've seen many problems with "sleep" and SSDs.

The only thing I can suggest is to make sure your laptop's BIOS is the latest. Many MB mfgs have updated the BIOS files to accept SSDs' quirks.
 
I was gonna add this to my post.......



I guess I should have said that the drive's speed specs looked OK but if you're stiil having other issues, I'd send it back.

I forgot about the "Random Issues" after the update.

I've seen many problems with "sleep" and SSDs.

The only thing I can suggest is to make sure your laptop's BIOS is the latest. Many MB mfgs have updated the BIOS files to accept SSDs' quirks.

Oh haha got it. Yeah I can live with the speed specs but the other issues are definitely frustrating. I have the latest firmware on both my laptop and SSD. I also just tested the drive in my desktop and am having the same issues there. Do you have any experience with Mushkin's support?
 
Do you have any experience with Mushkin's support?
Sorry, you're on your own.

Maybe you can start another thread with the drive's symptoms and get more help?

Can you flash to the old firmware?
 
One other question I didn't see asked here - does performance seem to be suffering on your laptop? A 297 to a 286 is hardly noticable, but does the baseline performance satisfy you?
 
Did you try to secure erase the drive first? I had 2 x 64GB Mushkin Callisto Deluxes and one drive needed to be secure erased before it would perform as advertised.
 
Back
Top