Microsoft Downplays Nightmare Flaw

John_Keck

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 3, 2010
Messages
379
A new exploit allows attackers to bypass UAC and execute code with administrative privileges. The good news, Microsoft says, is that it does not allow remote code execution on its own. So when patch day comes around don’t be lazy and keep ignoring it for 4 hours at a time for a week straight. ;)

Attackers would have to combine the exploit with other malicious code that takes advantage of another vulnerability on the machine -- not necessarily one in Windows, but in any commonly-installed application, such as Adobe Reader, for example -- to hijack a PC and bypass UAC.
 
It took 3 years to find a UAC flaw, and only in combination with another attack... yet people are using this as an example of how "bad" they think Microsoft's security is. :rolleyes:
 
Thankfully, hackers are going to have a hard time finding a vulnerability in Adobe Reader to piggyback this local exploit on.

Windows is pretty secure until you install an Adobe or Sun product. Then you're completely boned.
 
It is not a nightmare flaw. Seriously, let's stop with the sensationalistic journalism. It is what's called a "local privilege exploit." A situation where you cause a program to run at a privilege level higher than it is supposed to without proper credentials. These sorts of bugs are not that rare. They also aren't anything to panic over because, as noted, they are local. The code has to get on the system and be executed with a regular user account before it is a problem.

Not saying they aren't something to be dealt with, and I expect MS will issue a patch, but it is no nightmare.

Hell, a lot of the Malware we encounter these days doesn't bother to try and get admin, it just installs for the user. After all most systems are single user so who cares? At work we don't give people admin accounts without reason so most people are running as normal users. None the less, the dumb ones Malware up their systems, it just installs in their user directory and runs as them. Also makes it a little sneaky because when a support guy logs in, you see nothing because it is all in their account, the system looks clean to other people.
 
UAC > Antivirus

Antivirus software has more flaws and will more frequently KO your system without any help from malware lol
 
UAC is awful. I wasn't aware people used it. Even my parents can't stand it.
 
People forget that intelligent PC use trumps any "anti" program. Granted, I use NoScript + Sandboxie, but the resource footprint is no where near what an Antivirus uses.
 
It is not a nightmare flaw. Seriously, let's stop with the sensationalistic journalism. It is what's called a "local privilege exploit." A situation where you cause a program to run at a privilege level higher than it is supposed to without proper credentials. These sorts of bugs are not that rare. They also aren't anything to panic over because, as noted, they are local. The code has to get on the system and be executed with a regular user account before it is a problem.

Not saying they aren't something to be dealt with, and I expect MS will issue a patch, but it is no nightmare.

This I agree with. I'm about as much of a Microsoft fanboy as I am an Apple fanboy and that is to say I'm almost the opposite, but if it's a local privilege escalation exploit that isn't all that extraordinary.

Hell, a lot of the Malware we encounter these days doesn't bother to try and get admin, it just installs for the user. After all most systems are single user so who cares? At work we don't give people admin accounts without reason so most people are running as normal users. None the less, the dumb ones Malware up their systems, it just installs in their user directory and runs as them. Also makes it a little sneaky because when a support guy logs in, you see nothing because it is all in their account, the system looks clean to other people.

This I don't agree with. Privilege escalation is always a bad thing as it allows for the attacker to completely control the system as they wish. While an exploit able to take over an unprivileged user account is bad, having admin or system user access is worse.

Oh and if you need to see the process running to locate anything you're in the wrong field. But if it IS a single user system as you're saying then you can just d/c it from the network and examine the user's account directly.
 
The only flaw in UAC is its existence.

Only in so much as it tricks people into thinking they can run as admin all the damn time.

UAC is MS's attempt to protect the people that believe they have to run as admin all the damn time, and as a way to nag devs into writing their software so that it does not need admin privileges. Because fewer and fewer programs need escalation theses days, MS can default users to limited accounts in a future version of Win. Prolly not Win 8, but by Win 9, they could prolly do that with only a few whiners, and the typical nix zealots and win haters bashing them for it.
 
Because fewer and fewer programs need escalation theses days, MS can default users to limited accounts in a future version of Win.
All accounts in Windows Vista/7 are limited user accounts if you want to get technical.
 
The only flaw in UAC is its existence.

Facepalm

UAC is one of the most important and unappreciated security features in Windows. The ignorant masses complained for years about how insecure Windows was, and when Microsoft finally brought security up to the same level of popular Unix-like operating systems they bitch and moan about how annoying it is. Have you ever used Linux?

UAC is fantastic. Microsoft managed to maintain backwards compatibility with older Windows software while dramatically improving security. They also did it in a way that is less annoying than other user privilege authorization systems, IMO.
 
Prolly not Win 8, but by Win 9, they could prolly do that with only a few whiners, and the typical nix zealots and win haters bashing them for it.

You really don't get it do you? UAC was criticized by those of us who had a fricking clue for being the computing equivalent of the Maginot Line. It had flaws a mile wide and it's still hardly perfect (too easy to just click through), but improved? Yep.

Microsoft's reluctance to quickly fix issues with it is hardly encouraging, but then that is par for the course for them.
 
It took 3 years to find a UAC flaw, and only in combination with another attack... yet people are using this as an example of how "bad" they think Microsoft's security is. :rolleyes:

I did think that when I read the first bash MS security post. I remember the old days of XP pre sp1 and every os before that. People actually had a right to bitch then, now not so much.
 
Facepalm

UAC is one of the most important and unappreciated security features in Windows. The ignorant masses complained for years about how insecure Windows was, and when Microsoft finally brought security up to the same level of popular Unix-like operating systems they bitch and moan about how annoying it is. Have you ever used Linux?

UAC is fantastic. Microsoft managed to maintain backwards compatibility with older Windows software while dramatically improving security. They also did it in a way that is less annoying than other user privilege authorization systems, IMO.

JHFC...UAC is trash.

If you're too stupid to control the content that goes on your computer, you deserve what you get. UAC is a useless arse crap program better suited for distribution with AOL discs. Let it go, Man. For God's freakin' sake...
 
You can't exploit something i have disabled. not worried about exploits i exercise safe internet browsing habits. i never click on an advert or popup unless i've won something, something is for free or infected files have been found on my pc by a web animation that doesn't have the capacity to scan my files. oh that reminds me i must email back the king of beijing with my banking details.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
All accounts in Windows Vista/7 are limited user accounts if you want to get technical.

Until you click through the UAC prompt. Can't fault UAC or the OS for stupid users I guess.


You really don't get it do you? UAC was criticized by those of us who had a fricking clue for being the computing equivalent of the Maginot Line. It had flaws a mile wide and it's still hardly perfect (too easy to just click through), but improved? Yep.

Microsoft's reluctance to quickly fix issues with it is hardly encouraging, but then that is par for the course for them.


I get it just fine. Yes it had problems, the users primarily, but it was far better than nothing. Most complaining I heard regarding UAC when Vista launched was "it's annoying", or "nix already does this M$ Winblow$ suxors" or "I know what I am doing". The people really "in the know" were not the ones I heard doing all of the complaining. Or if they were complaining, they were complaining that UAC was not enough.

Until recently the only way around it was users being stupid and intervening on behalf of the ass holes that wanted to infect their PC. "The click through" is indeed it's biggest draw back. Then again stupid users have always been the biggest draw back to any computer system. UAC was still definitely a step in the correct direction, and it has had some benefits. Programs written in the Xp era and prior, almost all asked for admin privileges whether they really needed them or not. Now, very few new programs ask for privilege escalation aside install. Which actually makes a limited or standard account far less a pain in the ass than in the past. Which in turn, allows for limited accounts to eventually become the standard default option and not the exception. Additionally, because UAC prompts are now less common, when a UAC prompt comes up, people might be tempted to look at it a little harder. And maybe, just maybe, even click NO for once in their lives.
 
UAC is awful. I wasn't aware people used it. Even my parents can't stand it.

why so? I put it up all the way in windows 7 and it doesn't bother me at all. imo how the UAC works is exactly how it should have been since windows 95. it's one of the best features microsoft has added recently, though, linux fans will argue that the separation of users and admin rights has been part of that OS for forever.

I guess you don't do backups either, huh? that's even more inconvenient than the UAC.
 
JHFC...UAC is trash.

If you're too stupid to control the content that goes on your computer, you deserve what you get. UAC is a useless arse crap program better suited for distribution with AOL discs. Let it go, Man. For God's freakin' sake...

You really don't get it do you? UAC was criticized by those of us who had a fricking clue for being the computing equivalent of the Maginot Line. It had flaws a mile wide and it's still hardly perfect (too easy to just click through), but improved? Yep

Please, please, please educate yourselves before you go around telling people how stupid you think UAC is.

Here's a good simple description for you:
http://maximumpcguides.com/windows-vista/windows-vista-user-account-control-uac-explained/

User account control isn't for "stupid users." It's an effective defense against unknown zero-day exploits and malware. UAC prevents applications from running with elevated privileges without your permission, otherwise running as an admin on Windows is like running as root on Linux, things can happen without your knowledge or permission. Something similar to UAC is included in most modern operating systems, try loading up Ubuntu Linux and see what happens when you go to install software/updates or make administrative changes.

I run Windows 7 with UAC all the way up. The only time I ever see a UAC prompt is when I go to install something.
 
JHFC...UAC is trash.

If you're too stupid to control the content that goes on your computer, you deserve what you get. UAC is a useless arse crap program better suited for distribution with AOL discs. Let it go, Man. For God's freakin' sake...

So I assume you run a *nix box with everything as root? After all, "if you're too stupid to control the content that..."

...actually, I can't even finish typing that, it's too ridiculous.

Gods, I hope you don't have a job in IT.
 
imo UAC is fine. if you are a hardcore PC user then disable it, but for the masses leave it be, as mentioned atleast it forces developers to streamline their software to NOT require escalated privileges which is the best way to go.
 
Please, please, please educate yourselves before you go around telling people how stupid you think UAC is.

User account control isn't for "stupid users." It's an effective defense against unknown zero-day exploits and malware. UAC prevents applications from running with elevated privileges without your permission, otherwise running as an admin on Windows is like running as root on Linux, things can happen without your knowledge or permission. Something similar to UAC is included in most modern operating systems, try loading up Ubuntu Linux and see what happens when you go to install software/updates or make administrative changes.

I run Windows 7 with UAC all the way up. The only time I ever see a UAC prompt is when I go to install something.

Not necessary, as I read it about it when it was first announced and have kept a bit of an eye on how things are going there. Windows systems becoming less prone to winding up as zombies can only be a good thing IMO. That being said, why don't YOU educate yourself about what I was talking about when I described it as a Maginot Line?

There was an earlier vulnerability in Vista which made UAC useless and which may or may not have been (but I believe was NOT) patched. There was an incredibly simple to exploit vulnerability in Windows 7 Beta which Microsoft denied and then patched after being run through the wringer for a bit. There is also a code injection vulnerability in UAC on Windows Vista 7 that shipped in the RTM and last I heard wasn't patched, despite exploit code being available (I may be wrong).

Does UAC represent an improvement? Sure. The question is how much of an improvement and whether it makes people all that much safer. My answers to those questions right now are appreciable, but not huge and not especially.

They can improve to make it better, but the question is will they? To correct that when it requires escalation UAC should always prompt, it should always require a password, and (heres a big one) the first user should not have admin rights. It should be a separate account entirely.

That solves a whole lot of issues right there.
 
Ooh you mean that MS actually is going to use something nix based. That is a very dangerous suggestion i mean all these years now MS been claiming they know it all. For you to suggest that they move their user/admin policies towards nix would mean defeat.
On that note can't MS kill all those stupid applications with kernel acces that would safe some headache's too :) .
 
The only flaw in UAC is its existence.

Similar features exist in both Linux and OSX. Also, similar exploits and vulnerabilities have been discovered in those OS's. You usually even have to type an administrator's password every time rather than just clicking a button. But it's a very good security feature most of the time.

The problem with UAC when it debuted with Vista was that many third party programs were incorrectly designed to keep their configuration files and other data in the Program Files folder (which requires administrator permissions to write to) instead of the current user's folder. Also, many control panel applets required UAC prompts even for trivial changes to the system.
 
I feel so safe and secure with windows ya right LOL !!! Lies MS is all Lies about every OS they release. Best ever, most secure...whatever :rolleyes:
 
I find it hilarious that UAC is blasted for being stupid and useless, but when *nix does the same thing (or even, gasp, Mac OS X) no one complains. And let's not forget: MS was the last one to this party.

UAC already has an option to "always require a password" and trip on virtually anything. It's called Vista or 7-in-maxed-UAC-mode running on a Limited Account.

MS can't catch a break from anyone--XP was "Swiss Cheese" (which was a legitimate gripe). Then they emulated the more secure OSes on the market (*nix, OS X) and everyone bitched at them for it. Now people complain UAC is worthless. I just outlined an easy solution you can foist on your more tech-disinclined friends and relatives. Windows isn't perfect, but it's sure not as bad as some people are making it out to be.
 
UAC is good, one of the best first line of defense. Once your machine is set up you hardly know its there. Or shut UAC down until you have all your legit programs installed and save the ones that have to call home for last. I really see and appreciate what it does when I log on to my server as a standard user and have to enter my admin password when I make changes to my os. Its a friendly reminder of changes that could be happening without my knowledge.
 
If you're too stupid to control the content that goes on your computer, you deserve what you get.
User Account Control is about control. It's all about control: controlling which applications have the right to carry out administrator-level processes and which do not. Without selective privilege escalation (in any form), you have no control.

Until you click through the UAC prompt. Can't fault UAC or the OS for stupid users I guess.
Stupid users will always be stupid, yes. UAC can't fix that.

I feel so safe and secure with windows ya right LOL !!! Lies MS is all Lies about every OS they release. Best ever, most secure...whatever :rolleyes:
To say that Windows 7 is the most secure Windows Microsoft has released is a statement of fact. The most secure OS? Heh, no. But the most secure Windows? Yeah. Sometimes marketing and reality are one and the same.
 
UAC is great for keeping computers safe --when--operated--by--a--novice. If your an experienced computer user with 8 years+ experience who does all kind of tasks on his pc with degrees in MS this, BS.CS this, CISCO, then yes, its more of a nucence and not intended for you. If only there was a way to turn it off.... oh wait, they included that feature :).

Its better Microsoft at least tries to improve security than does nothing. If Microsoft attempting to do nothing to help security, those people whom do not have much computer experience would have to rely on semi sleezebag companies like ..Norton...and ...Mcaffe.
 
If your an experienced computer user with 8 years+ experience who does all kind of tasks on his pc with degrees in MS this, BS.CS this, CISCO, then yes, its more of a nucence and not intended for you.

Have you read the rest of the thread? This misinformation needs to go away.

Privilege elevation controls are a vital security feature in modern operating systems. UAC prevents software from installing in the background or making administrative changes without the user's permission. It's also part of the framework that allows software that would normally require admin privileges to run in a safe limited user "sandbox." It dramatically improves security for all users regardless of their experience level by providing an additional layer of protection against new malware and zero-day exploits.
 
Back
Top