Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
You're very clever, young man, very clever. But it's turtles all the way down!If there was a beginning, in order for the universe to be what it is today there would have to been matter existing in the first place. With matter you also have gravity, time, and energy which would mean that it has always existed. Without the universe there can not be physics. Without physics there can not be a universe.
>> there would have to been matter existing in the first place
Not necessarily. We have observed the spontaneous creation and destruction of matter in nature, it's just that it exists for a really, really short time.
You're very clever, young man, very clever. But it's turtles all the way down!
Ugh. Can we get off this train please? God limits himself by being infallible, omnisicent, and omnipotent. You can't be all of those things and yet change nature on a whim. That would mean you failed to correctly predict something.
Go away and let us keep smashing things together until we find out what's really up, kay?
If there was a beginning, in order for the universe to be what it is today there would have to been matter existing in the first place. With matter you also have gravity, time, and energy which would mean that it has always existed. Without the universe there can not be physics. Without physics there can not be a universe.
That creation from nothing is a result from anti-matter. In other words there would have always have to been anti-matter.
Argument from ignorance. 'Dark' in this context refers to that which cannot be directly observed. We can, however, infer the existence of both dark energy and dark matter through observation of their effect upon the rest of the universe.
I'm not sure what you're talking about... God limits himself by being unlimited (e.g. omnisicent and omnipotent)? Ok, if you say nothing I'll drop it.
You don't know that matter (as we currently understand it) always exists. You can only say that matter (as we currently understand it) is the product of some prior cause. And since we have changing causes, something must have caused that. In effect, you would have to argue that the universe is a chain of infinite causes and effects with no starting cause. And yet every successive cause and effect we see today is "adding" to infinity. Like I said earlier, we have a train of boxcars without an engine to push it.
If the box cars were always in motion then... perpetual motion.
"Scientists re-create Big Bang in lab", but no Dark Energy was found, not even indirect evidence of Dark Energy.
To add to that, "an object in motion will stay in motion until an outside force acts upon it." If the universe has always existed in motion then there is no need for it to start.
This isn't floating through space. This is actual cause and effect, where one thing reacts to a prior cause, where each new moment adds to infinite past. Can you add to infinity like that?
What you guys have me wondering is what exactly infinity is. If infinity does not have a start or an end... does infinity have to be a cycle? At what point does a positive become a negative?
An intelligent question.
The question of what caused the big bang, or what created the universe is rarely asked.
The big bang is an explanation for the universe as we now see it. But what triggered the big bang? What what before it? When the vastness of space was utterly empty and there was nothing.
Many people say it is useless to ask such a question because it is unknowable. This was
Carl Sagan's point of view. But is it? What about basic cause and effect reasoning?
Lets look at this logically. We can know some things for sure. Lets ask a few basic question:
1. Does the universe exist?
Yes. We are part of it, and we exist. The earth exists, the moon, the stars, etc,etc.
2. Have we always existed throughout eternity? In other words is it infinite?
No, we and the universe are finite; material. Entropy is at work.
3. Did the universe created itself?
No. Because if it did, it would have to exist, before it existed. Something cannot exist and not exist at the same time.
Also, the idea that the big bang was the culmination of all the matter int he universe compressing itself into a finite dot and then exploding the known universe does not address the question of being. It is a round about way of saying that the universe (matter) always existed.
Then you must ask where did the matter that caused the big bang to come from?
If anything exist it must have a cause of that brought it into being.
Since nothing can be self caused there must be a cause that is above and beyond our comprehension. A power that can bring a universe into being? Does it make sense?
For every effect, there is a cause. For a finite being; the cause has a infinite being.
We are moving into new uncharted territory every moment
Good job using circular logic and ignoring all other posts against your original post, which, by the way, was a direct soapbox attack. You created and inserted yourself into this argument where there was nothing. (Your own little big bang, perhaps.)
Good grief. Now you are babbling. Nurse!You are like the AMD fanatic that goes into every Intel discussion. Someone is discussing the finer points of mounting a heatsink on an LGA1366 board and you come in screaming AMD is better.
You force your logic in topics that don't apply.
Congratulations, you are a Grade-A Troll, whether you meant to be or not. It would be absolutely hilarious if you were even 10% as ridiculous as this in person.
Of course then, you know that theories are meant to be tested and religions are not. I think you have mistaken the scientific process of testing the big bang theory for "belief" or "faith" in the big bang theory.
If you start at zero and move up forever... would that be going to infinity. The main concept of infinity is that it covers all numbers including negative numbers. What if infinity could be started and never stop?
I submit to you that to put blind faith (lack of empirical evidence) in scientific theories (or non scientific in this case) requires GREAT faith. And I have noticed people have argued against this with a religious fervor.
You just called the Big Bang theory a "wild guess". That places you squarely in the 'ignorant' category. Not understanding what we're actually talking about here is no excuse for refusing to believe it. It's not a failure of science to make its case, it's a failure of an individual to assimilate and comprehend the science.When someone makes up a wild guess (Big Bang) and calls it a theory, he has some burden to defend his "theory" without accusing critics of arguing from ignorance for pointing out fatal flaws.
Finity can continue throughout time without stopping. And you wouldn't want to propose an infinity as starting somewhere, otherwise you admit that there was one great first event: "In The Beginning".
You just called the Big Bang theory a "wild guess". That places you squarely in the 'ignorant' category. Not understanding what we're actually talking about here is no excuse for refusing to believe it. It's not a failure of science to make its case, it's a failure of an individual to assimilate and comprehend the science.
You didn't watch the video I linked, did you? It might be over your head. Try starting with something easier, like Wikipedia's article on the Big Bang. There are plenty of links in there to get you going. Until you've educated yourself, you'll be ill-equipped to participate in a discussion of this caliber.
You just called the Big Bang theory a "wild guess". That places you squarely in the 'ignorant' category. Not understanding what we're actually talking about here is no excuse for refusing to believe it. It's not a failure of science to make its case, it's a failure of an individual to assimilate and comprehend the science.
You didn't watch the video I linked, did you? It might be over your head. Try starting with something easier, like Wikipedia's article on the Big Bang. There are plenty of links in there to get you going. Until you've educated yourself, you'll be ill-equipped to participate in a discussion of this caliber.
Very succinct. I also like how Krauss puts it in his lecture: "Knowing the answer means nothing; testing your knowledge means everything." Either way the point is the same, and I think that's what people don't understand about science.You have to research the evidence and determine whether the evidence is convincing enough or not, then explain why.
It's a common theme for people who don't actually understand the subject of discussion. And I don't mean to say that in a condescending way either. The information is out there and pretty consistent. Imagine how many people who said Crysis was poorly coded because it ran like shit on their system. A pure and simple logical fallacy right there.
The video was interesting, btw.
It's naive to think that video proves anything. The speaker piled dubious assumption on dubious assumption, over and over. I think he made two interesting points. One, he admitted that scientists really don't know much about the universe. Two, his argument about infinity destroys everything else he said. Given an infinite number of universes (a dubious assumption, but one he makes to dismiss the argument from design for God), everything happens an infinite number of times. That would include him being mistaken about his cosmology. By his own reasoning, he is wrong in an infinite number of universes.
Evolution is a fancy fairy tale made by some talented writer... ...evolution are nothing more than fancy stories.
Oh, really now? I see what you did there. I can do it too. "What you're saying is a fancy story." Read Darwin's Origin of Species and prove the decades of research wrong. How do you disprove several different species of the same genus that vary slightly dependent on the different climate and terrain environments? They look almost identical except for a few minor differences. Did they all start different that way? Your argument is full of logical fallacies.
Not to mention, as I pointed out earlier, when Darwin proposed evolution there was no such thing as genetics. This entire field was discovered ~100 years after Darwin and corroborates evolution independent of all other lines of evidence. Quite remarkable.
Evolution is one of the strongest theories in all of science and has proven to have tremendous predictive value. We can look at indels in genomes and see that they match up with the evolutionary tree (corroborated by other lines of evidence). We can look at the chimpanzees 24 chromosomes and match up exactly where two of them fused into one to get the 23 chromosomes that humans have. The sequences match just as we would expect.
The level of denial that some people have for science is shocking.
Science proves science false. Evolution is a fancy fairy tale made by some talented writer. The big bang test is just ridiculous as this was in a controlled environment. The original event was uncontrolled with significant chaos if were true. A catholic priest was the first to propose the idea of the big bang as it is. It was just an idea like me and you make up ideas every day. Turns things into self-fulfilling prophecies after awhile. Evolution in micro evolution is real but macro evolution is false. We have never seen or touched anything which turned from fish to mammoth. No transition fossils exist which account for this transition. Time doesn't do jack to anything. Things break down over time. What happen if you found a computer in the sand at the beach. Would you say evolution created that. Human cell is googolplexian times more complex than the computer. That shows that a designer is more at work than anything. 2nd law of thermodynamics explains it all(everything tends towards disorder), 1st also (matter cannot be created nor destroyed). Some evolutionists say it doesn't apply to evolution but thats bull. Everything in the natural world breaks down into simpler things. Nothing gets more complex as it decays over time. Over time things don't improve. As for the big bang the conservation of angular momentum proves it wrong also. If everything came from one single ball of mass and it exploded we would all have planets spinning in the same direction. That is not the case as there are planets that spin backwards and have moons that go the opposite direction that spin backwards. Some planets have counter clockwise and clockwise moons with some that spin backwards and some that don't. Matter doesn't collect together and create things either as things decay over time. The sun is getting older and dieing out while the universe is also. Big bang and evolution are nothing more than fancy stories. Made up by people so they can live their lives the way they want to comfortably without rules or boundaries. Evps and visual pictures and video of spirits is more than enough for a real awakening. I've experienced an actual ghost in real life and i didn't think it was possible either. I know many people that have hauntings also. The only thing holding back science is the people behind it that are thrusting atheism down peoples throats. Once we study more of the non-physical i bet much more things could be accomplished. Stuff we've never even dreamed of. Einstein even talked about it. Parallel universes and more.
Science proves science false. Evolution is a fancy fairy tale made by some talented writer. The big bang test is just ridiculous as this was in a controlled environment. The original event was uncontrolled with significant chaos if were true. A catholic priest was the first to propose the idea of the big bang as it is. It was just an idea like me and you make up ideas every day. Turns things into self-fulfilling prophecies after awhile. Evolution in micro evolution is real but macro evolution is false. We have never seen or touched anything which turned from fish to mammoth. No transition fossils exist which account for this transition. Time doesn't do jack to anything. Things break down over time. What happen if you found a computer in the sand at the beach. Would you say evolution created that. Human cell is googolplexian times more complex than the computer. That shows that a designer is more at work than anything. 2nd law of thermodynamics explains it all(everything tends towards disorder), 1st also (matter cannot be created nor destroyed). Some evolutionists say it doesn't apply to evolution but thats bull. Everything in the natural world breaks down into simpler things. Nothing gets more complex as it decays over time. Over time things don't improve. As for the big bang the conservation of angular momentum proves it wrong also. If everything came from one single ball of mass and it exploded we would all have planets spinning in the same direction. That is not the case as there are planets that spin backwards and have moons that go the opposite direction that spin backwards. Some planets have counter clockwise and clockwise moons with some that spin backwards and some that don't. Matter doesn't collect together and create things either as things decay over time. The sun is getting older and dieing out while the universe is also. Big bang and evolution are nothing more than fancy stories. Made up by people so they can live their lives the way they want to comfortably without rules or boundaries. Evps and visual pictures and video of spirits is more than enough for a real awakening. I've experienced an actual ghost in real life and i didn't think it was possible either. I know many people that have hauntings also. The only thing holding back science is the people behind it that are thrusting atheism down peoples throats. Once we study more of the non-physical i bet much more things could be accomplished. Stuff we've never even dreamed of. Einstein even talked about it. Parallel universes and more.
Good Grief.
The Big Bang is a theory.
Nothing more.
Just because it is the theory that most people hang their hat on does not change the fact it is a theory; a GUESS.
The same with evolution and the rest of the theories people pick and chose from to complete the portfolio that makes up what they believe.
And to ridicule people that believe God had something to do with it is being rather hypocritical since it is a matter if faith to believe in a theory.
Science proves science false. Evolution is a fancy fairy tale made by some talented writer. The big bang test is just ridiculous as this was in a controlled environment. The original event was uncontrolled with significant chaos if were true. A catholic priest was the first to propose the idea of the big bang as it is. It was just an idea like me and you make up ideas every day. Turns things into self-fulfilling prophecies after awhile. Evolution in micro evolution is real but macro evolution is false. We have never seen or touched anything which turned from fish to mammoth. No transition fossils exist which account for this transition. Time doesn't do jack to anything. Things break down over time. What happen if you found a computer in the sand at the beach. Would you say evolution created that. Human cell is googolplexian times more complex than the computer. That shows that a designer is more at work than anything. 2nd law of thermodynamics explains it all(everything tends towards disorder), 1st also (matter cannot be created nor destroyed). Some evolutionists say it doesn't apply to evolution but thats bull. Everything in the natural world breaks down into simpler things. Nothing gets more complex as it decays over time. Over time things don't improve. As for the big bang the conservation of angular momentum proves it wrong also. If everything came from one single ball of mass and it exploded we would all have planets spinning in the same direction. That is not the case as there are planets that spin backwards and have moons that go the opposite direction that spin backwards. Some planets have counter clockwise and clockwise moons with some that spin backwards and some that don't. Matter doesn't collect together and create things either as things decay over time. The sun is getting older and dieing out while the universe is also. Big bang and evolution are nothing more than fancy stories. Made up by people so they can live their lives the way they want to comfortably without rules or boundaries. Evps and visual pictures and video of spirits is more than enough for a real awakening. I've experienced an actual ghost in real life and i didn't think it was possible either. I know many people that have hauntings also. The only thing holding back science is the people behind it that are thrusting atheism down peoples throats. Once we study more of the non-physical i bet much more things could be accomplished. Stuff we've never even dreamed of. Einstein even talked about it. Parallel universes and more.
We're talking about this universe. In this universe, this universe's science applies. The notion of infinity does nothing to discredit anything else that was said. It's shocking to hear that you interpreted it that way (though this does begin to explain why you reject science). And no, you're right that the video doesn't prove anything. The proof was found in laboratories and through telescopes. You know, through science. But... whatever. That clearly doesn't interest you.By his own reasoning, he is wrong in an infinite number of universes.