A Video Game Does Not A Soldier Make

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Regardless which side of the debate you are on, this editorial is thought provoking, to say the least.

I honestly don't like that Medal of Honor depicts the war in Afghanistan right now, because — even as fiction — it equates the war with the leisure of games. Changing the name of the enemy doesn't change who it is.
 
Actually, that is a view point I can honestly agree to. I wouldn't use the word equate, but it does kind of downplay the seriousness. Then again those who aren't taking it seriously probably aren't going to take it less seriously because of a game.

I don't like the way the team tried to back pedal changing the name, it's something they should have considered long before announcing the game even.
 
With all due respect to George Santayana:

Only the dead have seen the end of war depicted as a leisurely game.
 
A game is a game, war is war. It doesn't equate the war as a leisurely game. Only a fucking idiot would assume that. There's no re-spawn in war.
 
Stupid argument.

We've been playing with guns, GI Joes, and as soldiers in video games for many years. Really its just a tool for recruiting people in the military. Unfortunately now games are getting so realistic it kind of does the opposite effect I believe.
 
Wait, just wait. In the past it was courtesy to wait til the soldiers were home and a couple years had passed b4 we started seeing novels, movies, TV specials, action figures, and other exploitations outside of the news in any quantity.
If you just wait for a little while after the soldiers are home, you will catch a great deal less grief from people. Not saying it's immoral or wrong, just that it is not in good taste.
 
Stupid argument.

We've been playing with guns, GI Joes, and as soldiers in video games for many years. Really its just a tool for recruiting people in the military. Unfortunately now games are getting so realistic it kind of does the opposite effect I believe.

He has earned the right to a stupid argument. Also I don't care how realistic games get until your friends start dying or your conosle/computer go ka boom, it will never have the opposite effect. In fact his point will become even more valid when it looks like it does on tv!
 
The fact that this is an ongoing conflict doesn't bother me. In fact there is going to be quite a few soldiers rushing to buy this game who have seen combat and will enjoy it. Soldiers play video games too. The subject will not offend them as much as the media made it out to be. People have a right to entertain themselves however they choose . Especially military people who can die for their country at 18 but can't drink till they are 21. #bullshit

Anyone who is talking about how serious this war is because it is currently happening please show me proof you have been involved in the politics of it and have a stake in it. why? because the ones doing the fighting and the dying are those less fortunate. why? because this war has been around forever and in all seriousness just like Iraq it is a misuse of military force. I want my government to say "go in there, kick ass and win" and not this bullshit nation building we are doing.

Also the Army's mission has not changed..."to deter war and if in war to win"...but instead we go into these conflicts with great expectations only to have civilian leadership make us adhere to bullshit rules of engagement that puts our soldiers in danger.

but anyways, another trumped up media controversy. remember the outrage when cod4 came out? oh that's right they called what were obviously Insurgents "OpFor" so it was ok.
 
Interesting. "Weekend Warrior" paintballers were enough to keep me away from pretend soldiering in first-person shooters. Didn't keep me from more abstract titles like Panzer General or completely fictional ones like Half-Life or Tie Fighter, though. He's right about control--I wouldn't have gotten through those games without the ability to save and reload.

My wife and I finally got around to watching Band of Brothers. There is *nothing* about that series that makes me want to pick up an M1 and play. In fact, I'll be putting on my poppy a little bit earlier this year...
 
Maybe they should petition to ban Microsoft Flight Simulator as well. Afterall, our current service members are essentially doing the same thing with flying drones. Or we should ban paintball and airsoft. Can't have any fun depicting war now can we. But, why stop there? Lets ban all first person shooters.

It's not in bad taste. If these parents don't want their little Johnny over there potentially being blown up by some towely then they should tell little johnny to shove his mark 10 up his ass and claim section 8.

If I remember correctly, and I do, parts of Call of Duty 4 were in the middle east. They didn't use Taliban specifically, but honestly does it matter? No one threw a shit fit then.

Goes the old saying "don't like what you're watching on tv? don't complain about it, change the fucking channel"
 
The fact that this is an ongoing conflict doesn't bother me. In fact there is going to be quite a few soldiers rushing to buy this game who have seen combat and will enjoy it. Soldiers play video games too. The subject will not offend them as much as the media made it out to be. People have a right to entertain themselves however they choose . Especially military people who can die for their country at 18 but can't drink till they are 21. #bullshit

Anyone who is talking about how serious this war is because it is currently happening please show me proof you have been involved in the politics of it and have a stake in it. why? because the ones doing the fighting and the dying are those less fortunate. why? because this war has been around forever and in all seriousness just like Iraq it is a misuse of military force. I want my government to say "go in there, kick ass and win" and not this bullshit nation building we are doing.

Also the Army's mission has not changed..."to deter war and if in war to win"...but instead we go into these conflicts with great expectations only to have civilian leadership make us adhere to bullshit rules of engagement that puts our soldiers in danger.

but anyways, another trumped up media controversy. remember the outrage when cod4 came out? oh that's right they called what were obviously Insurgents "OpFor" so it was ok.

There are too many feel good idiots who would flip shit if we opened up the ROE and just said annihilate the fuck out of them. There is always civilian casualty in war, I can't imagine too many innocent civvies running towards gunfire though...
 
The difference between Medal of Honor and real life, is that when you kill someone, you're never the same again. Taking a human life will haunt you for the rest of your life. Solders come home depressed, and suicidal. You come back from a game, happy and gleeful.

Lets not forget, there's no extra lives on the battlefield. Though, the only good thing about War games, is it gets the solder onto the field. It doesn't prepare them for the horror they are about to endure.
 
Sorry but I have to disagree. Not that playing a video game makes you a soldier, that much is obvious, but that for some reason war should be off limits for games. No, not really. It is part of the human experience. You can argue it shouldn't be, can't argue that it is. What's more, playing war video games is somethign that all species do: Play fighting. Ever have a couple of kittens together? They'll start wrestling around, biting, clawing, etc. Neither gets hurt, of course, they are playing. However their play is based around what cats do when they are actually fighting.

All species, not just humans, like to play fight. Just unlike most of them, we have Xboxes, so we can play fight in whole different ways. Doesn't mean that it is at all the same as real fighting and it isn't supposed to be. It is just something we like to do, and are genetically programmed to like to do.

I also really don't buy in to this "It isn't ok because it is a current war." Why does that make anything any different? Nobody seemed to have a problem with Bad Company 2, which put the modern US and Russian Federation fighting each other, because it wasn't a real war. Nobody seems to have a problem with WW2 games because that was a long time ago. So why the hell is a game about a current war so bad? What makes it any different?

Really I think this is just whining. You need to accept that people like to play fight. Kids play "cops and robbers" people play paintball, and people play video games. That's life. Bellyaching that it isn't like real combat is silly. Of COURSE it isn't. It is play, not real.
 
The difference between Medal of Honor and real life, is that when you kill someone, you're never the same again. Taking a human life will haunt you for the rest of your life. Solders come home depressed, and suicidal.

I do not agree with this from personal experience. If you don't have any experience with that situation you really have no right even commenting on it.
 
This is just like the Mosque at Ground Zero. Is it a bit insensitive? Yes. Do they have the right to do it anyway? Yes. Offensive content is the price we pay for freedom of speech.
 
In poor taste? I don't see how or why it is considered such. A good friend of mine is recently back from Afghanistan and owns the game. He seems to think it is a good game.
 
In some ways playing a war game has given me more respect for what our soldiers have to do...honestly how many times have we been shot in a game and had no idea where it came from... (insurgency mod for hl2). One of the things that has always stuck out to me about war its that it doesn't matter if you are the world's best marksman or have the greatest endurance or tactical ability...sometimes you just get shot and there is not a goddamn thing anyone can do about it... Any veterans or actives chime in here but I can only imagine that every soldier realizes this, tries to put it out of their mind, and goes to work...I have been unsure in the past about certain wars as a whole but I will never, EVER, speak ill of our troops.
 
This is just like the Mosque at Ground Zero. Is it a bit insensitive? Yes. Do they have the right to do it anyway? Yes. Offensive content is the price we pay for freedom of speech.

Actually that's far less offensive than all of the Catholic rape counseling clinics that have been erected 'round the country and the world.

It's offensive to be treated and counseled by those that perpetrated the crime... Not that religious folk would ever understand such non-sense.

That idiot that wanted to burn the Quran should really consider burning his church if he had any decency. Then again, I guess freedom of religion gives his flock the right to follow their nut.

Sad I won't live to see the day when religion is outlawed.
 
Wait, just wait. In the past it was courtesy to wait til the soldiers were home and a couple years had passed b4 we started seeing novels, movies, TV specials, action figures, and other exploitations outside of the news in any quantity.
If you just wait for a little while after the soldiers are home, you will catch a great deal less grief from people. Not saying it's immoral or wrong, just that it is not in good taste.

Clancy would like a word with you
most of his best Cold war stuff was done in the early 80's
Rainbow Six could be now and was done 15 years ago
people need to get the stick out of there ass
 
"I honestly don't like that Medal of Honor depicts the war in Afghanistan right now, because — even as fiction — it equates the war with the leisure of games."

That's fine, vote with your wallet and don't purchase it. You're not missing out on much, the single player is horrible and the multiplayer alone is definitely not worth the asking price.

Personally, I think they could have upped the realism by having a few missions where your primary purpose for being in country was to protect pipeline development.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Afghanistan_Pipeline
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article23906.htm
 
Wait, just wait. In the past it was courtesy to wait til the soldiers were home and a couple years had passed b4 we started seeing novels, movies, TV specials, action figures, and other exploitations outside of the news in any quantity.
If you just wait for a little while after the soldiers are home, you will catch a great deal less grief from people. Not saying it's immoral or wrong, just that it is not in good taste.

The problem with the wars we are in is that we will never be home. It will not end. There are people on their 7th and 8th deployment since this all started. I see the games as a relaxation and a way for us to actually kill the bad guy without killing the bad guy.
 
"War IS a videogame, what better way to raise the ultimate soldier?" - Solid Snake, Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
 
The problem with the wars we are in is that we will never be home. It will not end. There are people on their 7th and 8th deployment since this all started. I see the games as a relaxation and a way for us to actually kill the bad guy without killing the bad guy.

Besides, Hurt Locker already won Best Picture. Seems like Hollywood approves.
 
Clancy would like a word with you
most of his best Cold war stuff was done in the early 80's
Rainbow Six could be now and was done 15 years ago
people need to get the stick out of there ass

Clancy knows the difference between a Cold war, and a hot lead killing numerous soldiers, civilians, and everything else, on a daily basis war. Do you?
And it is because Rainbow Six could have happened at anytime over the last 10 to 20 years that it allows a level of separation from reality that will keep people off your ass.

Again, I am not against this at all, use the material like you like, but you will see a lot bitching from various directions if you don't just wait a little bit b4 you start exploiting a war in entertainment media.
 
If I'm not mistaken, the military uses video games to mentally prepare the troops for battle.
 
A game is a game, war is war. It doesn't equate the war as a leisurely game. Only a fucking idiot would assume that. There's no re-spawn in war.

Stupid argument.

We've been playing with guns, GI Joes, and as soldiers in video games for many years. Really its just a tool for recruiting people in the military. Unfortunately now games are getting so realistic it kind of does the opposite effect I believe.

He has earned the right to a stupid argument. Also I don't care how realistic games get until your friends start dying or your conosle/computer go ka boom, it will never have the opposite effect. In fact his point will become even more valid when it looks like it does on tv!

Benjamin Bush, author of that editorial = Capt f'n Obvious!
Before the usual rush to utterly uneducated opinions regarding Benjamin Busch, you might want to look into the complete context of the situation.

His editorial was in response to the military's decision to pull MOH from the shelves of all of its PX's, as well as influencing Gamestop into pulling the game from the shelves of their on-base stores.

As Major Busch explained in the comments section of the article, he was making the point that it is stupid to pull the game, since it cannot be mistaken for the "real" thing by anyone with more than one brain cell and an awareness of reality (my characterization, not his).

Since Major Busch is an intelligent man, as well as an active officer, I would guess that he makes it a habit of being somewhat circumspect when critizing the military leadership's actions.

For those of you who struggle with how to work that interw3bz thing, I give you the entirety of his comments on theNPR piece.


Benjamin Busch (BBusch) wrote:
My thanks to all who have posted supportive comments in response to this brief essay. In seeing some trends I feel it necessary to address a few of these comments.
James Dilisio asked, "Is the title a mistake?" I titled it "Talibanned" when I submitted it. NPR gave it the more literate title, "Why A Video Game Does Not A Soldier Make". In doing so, some listeners/readers have made the assumption that my focus was simply denouncing a video war game's capacity and intention to train game players to be soldiers. It is, of course, obvious that they cannot, and I did not state that anyone had said that it was their purpose. I reiterate that they can't produce soldiers to bridge the point that they can also not produce Taliban fighters. For readers who were following my message, this particular truth of the game lessens the justification for our military banning it as if it were a threat. For readers who missed the lead story to my opinion piece, I respond to the fact that "Medal of Honor", a video war game based in Afghanistan during our current war there, has been banned from sale on US military bases as well as those of several allied nations. Tim Myers corrected that misunderstanding best in his comment which I will repost.


Tim Myers wrote: "I don't think Mr. Busch is disputing a claim that video games accurately represent combat, or the life of a soldier. I read his point as being that politicians are misrepresenting what video games do. It is disingenuous - not to mention out of their jurisdiction - for the Pentagon to demand that the makers of Medal of Honor change the names of the enemy from the Taliban to another, fictitious enemy. In my mind, this is tantamount to banning the portrayal of the remains of American servicepersons from being represented to the American public in any form. It is an example of undue government intervention, and a propaganda tool.

No rational person believes that playing video games adequately prepares someone for the realities of war. But our government seems to think that they strike close enough to home to censor them. And therein lies the rub."

Tim may as well have written my essay. It might have been clearer. But NPR would have only given him 3 minutes 12 seconds as well, and that is what took away some of my connective tissue. I'm even running out of space to type this post. The essay began at 832 words. It is now 545. Exact time is difficult to write for.


In open response to Slade Villena's open response to me, thank you for your study on the subject, and for your grasp of the matter.
And to Phil Hostetter, Michael Difani, Joyce Ouellette's father, and SSgt Greg Thomas...thank you for your service, voluntary or otherwise.
I hope that these three short posts aid your understanding of the piece. For those who consider me a master of the obvious, well then I must admit that we are in agreement on that. I am pleased to see anyone engage in public discussion. I feel the danger to our country is our unwillingness to publicly confront statements, or to voice our approval of them. We are lucky to have a National Public Radio with a mission to encourage us to talk as well as to listen. Thank you all for paying attention.
Semper Fidelis.
 
<quote>I honestly don't like that Medal of Honor depicts the war in Afghanistan right now, because — even as fiction — it equates the war with the leisure of games. Changing the name of the enemy doesn't change who it is. </quote>

A war game does not equate war with a game. 99.999% of people understand the difference between the imaginary and reality quite well. Kids who play cops and robbers do not grow up to go on mass murdering crime sprees.

I can generally grasp the idea that someone how has experienced war first hand might be offended by a game loosly based on the same conflict because of how that conflict has so seriously effected them. However, to people playing the game aren't reliving such a life changing experience, they are just playing a game.

It is not the gamers who are equating the two. It is the warrior who is overwhelmed with the experience of war that is having problems seperating reality and the imaginary, not the gamer. While we should respect those who have made such great sacrifices for all of us, I'm not sure that avoiding games that some might be in some way offended by is a rational response.
 
dont-worry-sir-im-from-the-internet.jpg
 
Changing the name of the enemy doesn't change who it is.
So... would this guy be willing to pay the legal fees to Kojima and any other game development company that uses real-life identifications (ie. "Taliban")? Politics. ;)
 
"I honestly don't like that Medal of Honor depicts the war in Afghanistan right now, because — even as fiction — it equates the war with the leisure of games."

That's fine, vote with your wallet and don't purchase it. You're not missing out on much, the single player is horrible and the multiplayer alone is definitely not worth the asking price.

Personally, I think they could have upped the realism by having a few missions where your primary purpose for being in country was to protect pipeline development.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Afghanistan_Pipeline
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article23906.htm

Oh, aren't you clever. Our reasons for being in Afghanistan couldn't possibly have anything to do with a major terrorist attack.

Idiot.
 
Sad I won't live to see the day when religion is outlawed.

Typical anti-religious troll is typical.

Get one thing straight here. Regardless of the cause - religious convictions, political convictions, over a scrap of meat, or just plain hostility - it's still a HUMAN causing harm to another HUMAN. You're not above the failings of human nature any more than anyone else just because you don't follow a certain set of beliefs. There are good and bad Christians, there are good and bad Muslims, there are good and bad Atheists. If you want to a cause to blame for human suffering you need look no further than the mirror. The same capacity to help and harm exists in everyone regardless of what god or gods they choose to pray to. Get off your high-horse. Learn to live in peace with those you differ from. If you cannot do that, then you are just a brainwashed idiot and guilty of the same mindless bigotry that you ascribe to those you look down upon.
 
"But what nation or military has the right to govern fiction? Banning the representation of an enemy is imposing nationalism on entertainment. The game cannot train its players to be actual skilled special operations soldiers, nor is it likely to lure anyone into Islamic fundamentalism. It can grant neither heroism nor martyrdom. What it does do is make modern war into participatory cinema. That is its business."


That folks is the next paragraph after kyle took his headline out.. completely distorting the context.. just to grab headlines...

The really sad part is.. i would be 90% of you never read the whole article...which is about the average...
 
A game is a game, war is war. It doesn't equate the war as a leisurely game. Only a fucking idiot would assume that. There's no re-spawn in war.

I also think that it's a baseless assumption. He even talked about playing war, and playing with soldiers when he was a kid. Kids have always played war. The only difference is it's digital now.
 
Wait, just wait. In the past it was courtesy to wait til the soldiers were home and a couple years had passed b4 we started seeing novels, movies, TV specials, action figures, and other exploitations outside of the news in any quantity.

You have any idea of how many WW2 films were made before the war was even over?
 
You have any idea of how many WW2 films were made before the war was even over?

Are you referring to our propaganda films? The ones the US government encouraged or persuaded, or in some cases even paid, a number of studios to make, and in a way that incited the least horror and the maximum nationalism, and anti German/Japanese sentiment? The ones that had "buy war bonds" and "enlist today" ads b4, during intermission, and after the film? You can count those if you like.

I still remember the screaming over Apocalypse Now, and it was five years after the War had ended. I remember my father and uncle, (they both went), complaining to each other over beers in the garage/man cave, that it was just too soon for that sort of realism. And it was actually a damn good movie.

While Today's Hollywood might still applaud you, a great many people will give you grief if you just don't wait b4 putting out an entertainment medium based off of a recent/current war
While all sorts of rudeness and poor taste has become more accepted over time, you will still see complaints if you don't just wait.

For the third time, I am not even against this. You can use the war how you like as far as I am concerned.
I am just saying that you will either wait, or you will see complainers, products pulled from shelves, and the like. It is the way it is.


I have said "wait" too much. I think I broke it. :eek:
 
Are you referring to our propaganda films? The ones the US government encouraged or persuaded, or in some cases even paid, a number of studios to make, and in a way that incited the least horror and the maximum nationalism, and anti German/Japanese sentiment? The ones that had "buy war bonds" and "enlist today" ads b4, during intermission, and after the film? You can count those if you like.

No, I'm talking about films made for entertainment. Like Casablanca in 1942, you have heard of Casablanca haven't you? You've heard of Humphrey Boggart? After Casablanca he made Action in the North Atlantic (1943), Sahara (1943), Passage to Marseille (1944), To Have and Have Not (1944), which are all fictional movies that involve the war.

There must of been over a 100 war movies during WW2. Here's Wikipedia's list, which isn't even complete. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:World_War_II_films_made_in_wartime
 
Back
Top