How are PS3 graphics still so good?

  • Thread starter Deleted member 217897
  • Start date
D

Deleted member 217897

Guest
Been looking at the new god of war and gran turismo 5 game. The graphics are crazy.
How do they keep getting better and better if the hardware stays the same?
Is the Dx9 chip really all that powerful?
How does the graphics work on the ps3?

Why haven't I seen too many PC games with better graphics and we have 480s and dx11?
 
1. Less pixels to drive. Games are generally rendered at a lower resolution then upscaled to 720p/1080i/p.
2. Highly optimized software due to everyone using highly similar machines. PC games have to support thousands of hardware configurations. PS3 games just have to support the different PS3 versions.
 
Short answer... if developers targeted only 4870s (etc) and core i7 then you'd have games that looked so ludicrously good that they'd make the PS3 look like the PS2. But they never will, because they need to make sure the games will run on as much as possible.

As for the PS3, the GPU isn't particularly impressive, but the best devs offload a lot of the graphics work onto the CPU, which is. Even so, a GPU like the 5870 is roughly 10x as powerful as the CPU and GPU combined on a PS3.
 
Been looking at the new god of war and gran turismo 5 game. The graphics are crazy.
How do they keep getting better and better if the hardware stays the same?
Is the Dx9 chip really all that powerful?
How does the graphics work on the ps3?

Why haven't I seen too many PC games with better graphics and we have 480s and dx11?

Not many games with better graphic on PC? I bet you haven't play PC game much or at all..

Every single title from PC is far more superior than console, especially when there is a Console and PC version, its clearly a win on PC no matter what, beside those horribly coded game, which are somewhat rare.

PS3 graphics are good? for a console owner yes, for a PC owner... NO WAY...
 
simple, 4 years later they finally got an idea of how to fully exploit the hardware so the games will look better as a result. happens with every console......
 
There's a few reasons.
  • Sony is also continually updating the PS3 OS itself. This actually has lowered the memory footprint which gives more memory to games. Sony said they free'd up 40 some MB so far.
  • Companies are starting to understand how to take better advantage of the PS3's SPE's which are similar to having extra processing power.
  • PS3 uses Blu-Ray disc which can hold much more data than a standard DVD. This lets developers use higher detailed textures and zero compression with audio. Sure, you could use a bunch of DVD's but they don't want to do that because disc cost money when your making millions of copies.
 
Last edited:
Same for 360 as well, actually the 360 has a more powerful GPU than the PS3. It has nothing to do with Blu Ray, or Cell.. its good old fashioned hard work, learning the dev kits and hardware underneath. Regardless both are years old, but the reason the graphics get better is because of a standardized platform. Developers optimize every inch of their game for 1 set of hardware.. which is the exact opposite of the pc market.

Is this your first generation as a gamer?
 
No, just have a bitch ass PS3 fan boy co worker. Who keeps going on and on about how great PS3 is.
 
It has nothing to do with Blu Ray, or Cell.. its good old fashioned hard work, learning the dev kits and hardware underneath. Regardless both are years old, but the reason the graphics get better is because of a standardized platform. Developers optimize every inch of their game for 1 set of hardware.. which is the exact opposite of the pc market.

+1
 
It has nothing to do with the cell? Wow ... not sure how to respond to that. You must not own a PS3 and this is your first generation as a gamer? All of the Triple A PS3 games heavily use the cell which allows for sound, graphic and physics that are not seen in the 360. The 360 is a great system but the Cell cpu is the PS3 and why it has superior exclusive games. Most of them take full advantage of it. However, most cross platform games do not because they are usually ports from one system to another. If this is what you believe to be true I feel sorry for you that you're in la-la land.
 
It has nothing to do with the cell? Wow ... not sure how to respond to that. You must not own a PS3 and this is your first generation as a gamer? All of the Triple A PS3 games heavily use the cell which allows for sound, graphic and physics that are not seen in the 360. The 360 is a great system but the Cell cpu is the PS3 and why it has superior exclusive games. Most of them take full advantage of it. However, most cross platform games do not because they are usually ports from one system to another. If this is what you believe to be true I feel sorry for you that you're in la-la land.

full of fanboy crap this post is..........and I have all 3 systems.......the guy had it right it IS called hard work and learning to to exploit the machine's hardware..
 
I too have all three systems, and the 360 exclusives are just as great as the PS3 exclusives. The Cell didn't make the PS3. That's a farce.

And to the guy that said PC games are better on PC period...That's wrong too. I prefer PC games generally, but there are games that run better on the console - not only due to the controls. Need for Speed Carbon comes to mind. When it came out all the PC guys were complaining that they only got 7 fps on their top of the line systems. The 360 version demo I played was smooth as butter. The resolution doesn't mean anything when you are playing on a TV or projector across the room.

Games like Drakes fortune, and Gears of War are still drool worthy on the consoles --- even for a graphics hound like me.
 
Last edited:
The best console exclusive game I've played on the 360 have to be Gears 1&2, and 3 seems to take it up a notch in the visuals department. Also Mass Effect 2 was up there in the top.

But I do believe GT5,Uncharted 2, and God of War 3 visually look better than the 360 games I listed above. But I think it has more to do with Sony's 1st party developers because they're pretty much the cream of the crop when it comes to developing games.

So I would say it's more on the Devs than the hardware itself. But looks aren't everything because I played gears 2 alot longer than I did Uncharted 2.
 
2. Highly optimized software due to everyone using highly similar machines. PC games have to support thousands of hardware configurations. PS3 games just have to support the different PS3 versions.

but the reason the graphics get better is because of a standardized platform. Developers optimize every inch of their game for 1 set of hardware.. which is the exact opposite of the pc market.

Right. PC space is totally unstandardized. I mean the PCI-E bus spec is just a suggestion, and the Open GL and CL feature set standards aren't really interface standards. Same goes for the Direct X API suite, when Nvidia and ATI implement them sometimes they forget some of the components in direct draw and thus performance is impacted...
/sarcasm

comon guys I figured a board full of IT pros and devs would know better than the mainstream gaming press who like to spout this stuff as rhetoric.

IBM's POWER is elegant, and X86 is hideous, but with Visual Studios 2010 and GCC 4.5 compiler optimizations that isn't a huge issue, and thats an excellent example of my next point: software is getting better at the same rate hardware is, something people often forget.

Completely aside from optimizations the developers make, optimizations in the API's, compilers, and other various 3rd party misc code make any given piece of C code run faster on any given set of hardware the later its compiled and run for the platform --think about the performance advantages we get from Forceware and CCC revisions. Microsoft and Sony are hard at work doing the same things. When microsoft updates an SDK to do a shader that's the exact (or close to) effect you were looking for, you can bet your ass that its going to be more than twice as efficient than if you tried to cobble something together using the previous code.

The simple fact is that the way developers for the 360 and PS3 look at faster hardware in PC space is: "great, less time spent optimizing for PC, more time spent making game content AND/OR optimizing for console".

But yeah, in terms of IQ on the console when you see it side-by-side with a PC the difference is huge. The texture memory on old consoles simply isn't there, so higher res textures always exists in PC space. Even short of side-by-side, when I played COD4 in "glorious 1080P (on a nice Sony Bravia-Z color corrected and everything)" I was completely underwhelmed, and was really looking forward to playing it again on my (crap) 1680X1050 22" monitor. From the two people I've heard talk about RAGE on the PC vs on the console, both of them say the game looks vastly better on PC.
 
http://ps3media.ign.com/ps3/image/article/109/1099424/gran-turismo-
5-20100616063800732.jpg

Check out the backgrounds, the trees, etc. It all looks like shit. They simply don't have the power to spare and it shows... there's lots of clever artwork and budgeting in console titles.

Billion hardware combination's aside, you'd be kidding yourself if you think it's not possible to savagely optimize PC code. Engines made for PC and ported to consoles run like shit on the consoles, it works both ways.

L4D / TF2 doesn't run nearly as smooth as the PC counterpart
RE5 barely manages 30 fps... I scored over 100 on the benchmark
Call of Jaurez 2 looked beautiful on the PC and framerates were sky high
Just Cause 2 looks and runs great because there was actual effort done for the port


If devs spend the time optimizing for a certain platform, be it PC or Console, then it's going to have the advantage while the other suffers. Even 360 to PS3 ports don't always go so well. :)
 
The best console exclusive game I've played on the 360 have to be Gears 1&2, and 3 seems to take it up a notch in the visuals department. Also Mass Effect 2 was up there in the top.

But I do believe GT5,Uncharted 2, and God of War 3 visually look better than the 360 games I listed above..

I have to agree there, the Gears game are by far the best looking games on the 360 I've played and they don't hold a candle to Uncharted 2 and God of War 3. I'd say both those games looks much better than most PC games out today, and their production values are so far beyond anything the PC has it's ridiculous.

Unless resolution, AA and AF are the only things you judge graphic fidelity on.....

Ports on the other hand, totally different story.
 
a game can have awesome graphics and still suck bad. a well written fun to play game can be better even if it has bad graphics. You can't hide a bad game behind graphics.
 
Right. PC space is totally unstandardized..(SNIP the rest of the dripple posted here)



compared to a console where you write to a specific set of hardware, the PC is not standized hardware. You have a whole range of CPUs, video cards, sound cards, network controller, etc that the game has to run on......

PC does not even have a standard OS to write to as there are people using 2K/XP,Vista, and Win 7 PCs with DX9,10, and 11........
 
compared to a console where you write to a specific set of hardware, the PC is not standized hardware. You have a whole range of CPUs, video cards, sound cards, network controller, etc that the game has to run on......

PC does not even have a standard OS to write to as there are people using 2K/XP,Vista, and Win 7 PCs with DX9,10, and 11........

I dont think developer even care about making game specific to work on XP.

work on vista almost automatically work for Win 7.

also, DX11 is downward compatible, which can be run in DX9/DX10 without a specific workaround, no need to even worry about the development process for that..:p
 
I dont think developer even care about making game specific to work on XP.

work on vista almost automatically work for Win 7.

also, DX11 is downward compatible, which can be run in DX9/DX10 without a specific workaround, no need to even worry about the development process for that..:p

wrong, DX10/11 are not backwards compatable with eariler versions, this is why you have to install DX9 on vista and 7 in order to play DX9 and earlier titles.

nice try though
 
Hm? I have seen no PS3 games that have cutting edge graphics. I recently played Uncharted 2, it did look pretty nice, but it didn't "wow" me. Nice use of colors, though.
 
I haven't seen many PC games that impressed me recently. I've been impressed by PS3 games (Uncharted, Uncharted2, etc) because of the TV I have and the fact that it's coming from a console.

I believe I would be less impressed on a PC game because I expect more.
 
wrong, DX10/11 are not backwards compatable with eariler versions, this is why you have to install DX9 on vista and 7 in order to play DX9 and earlier titles.

nice try though

that is call "UPDATES".

there are new updates in DX9 that require for games to run correctly..

And since DX9 is not fully update in Vista and 7, they need to use the installer to update it.

good try....:p
 
Most PC people don't think they look good cause they lack high resolutions and textures and AA. I honestly don't care about that stuff. A care more about the actual work the artist did rather then some AA on a character.
 
that is call "UPDATES".

there are new updates in DX9 that require for games to run correctly..

And since DX9 is not fully update in Vista and 7, they need to use the installer to update it.

good try....:p

since you said that "DX11 is downward compatible, which can be run in DX9/DX10 " I was just simply pointing out the known fact that DX10/11 cannot run DX9 and earlier games natively and that you actually have to install DX9 on vista and 7 in order to run games for it.

and if developer did not care about writing for XP, then they would not make the game compatable for it but since there are a lot of people still running that OS, they will ensure their game runs on it.
 
Most PC people don't think they look good cause they lack high resolutions and textures and AA. I honestly don't care about that stuff. A care more about the actual work the artist did rather then some AA on a character.

True that, never under estimate a good art design.
 
since you said that "DX11 is downward compatible, which can be run in DX9/DX10 " I was just simply pointing out the known fact that DX10/11 cannot run DX9 and earlier games natively and that you actually have to install DX9 on vista and 7 in order to run games for it.

and if developer did not care about writing for XP, then they would not make the game compatable for it but since there are a lot of people still running that OS, they will ensure their game runs on it.

developer does not specific make games for XP now, none of them does unless its asian MMO. Not many people still use XP these days unless you are one of those who think XP is still better person. Plus, Vista and 7 users amount are way surpass XP now, not mention in future will be even less XP users..

also, DX11 downward compatible as in development process and game can be run on DX9 without much of a issue.

Consoles do firmware update to run games correctly sometimes too, obvious, there is no comparison here.

But talking about how good graphic console have compare to PC, you either need a eye check or ignorance is taking the place.

There are plenty of games that looks better on PC when its on both PC and console, or I should say all of them.

Just cause 2, Mafia 2, SF4, DMC4, RE5, GoW, Batman, AC, CoD, ME... you says it I name it.

Any more comments?
:p
 
^ are you a tool? can you not read? are you stuck on "I didn't understand anything said in this thread' or what?

OP asked why PS3 games look soo good. The simple answer is They only have to develop for a specific platform where as PC games have to pretty much cover a wide user base with varying hardware.

I know this is hard for you to grasp but there are plenty of people that are still using XP so yes developers have to ensure that their games run on that platform.

and btw while you were all stuck up on yourself about how developers don't target XP, lol I never said they did, I just stated that they will make sure that their game runs on that platorm.....the same thing happened when people made the transition from 9x to NT based OS

and no DX 9 and 11 are not compatable with each other jiust take a look the two different code paths that are in use one for DX 11 and one for DX9
 
OP asked why PS3 games look soo good. The simple answer is They only have to develop for a specific platform where as PC games have to pretty much cover a wide user base with varying hardware.

It's been mentioned before, but API's such as DirectX make the varying hardware a thing of the past. If anything, it's the hardware manufacturer who's at fault, and not the game developer. The only thing they have to worry about is allowing varying degrees of graphical quality.

The true reason is art style as another person mentioned. Good art will appear to look good even at lower resolutions.

But in terms of apples to apples, there's no comparison. The PC is at a disadvantage though in that with a console, because with a console, there's nothing to compare it too. A PS3 game will only look as good as another PS3 game. But with PC's, people subconsciously can't accept anything less than maximum settings for some reason. It doesn't matter if low quality is greater quality than the XBox or PS3. It's not high quality on the PC, therefore, it must be worse than the PS3 or XBox.

The thing is, 720p resolution vs 1080p resolution is insignificant when you're using the viewing distance of a TV. But with a computer monitor, what appears good at 10 feet away may appear aweful at 10 inches away.
 
Last edited:
^ are you a tool? can you not read? are you stuck on "I didn't understand anything said in this thread' or what?

OP asked why PS3 games look soo good. The simple answer is They only have to develop for a specific platform where as PC games have to pretty much cover a wide user base with varying hardware.

I know this is hard for you to grasp but there are plenty of people that are still using XP so yes developers have to ensure that their games run on that platform.

and btw while you were all stuck up on yourself about how developers don't target XP, lol I never said they did, I just stated that they will make sure that their game runs on that platorm.....the same thing happened when people made the transition from 9x to NT based OS

and no DX 9 and 11 are not compatable with each other jiust take a look the two different code paths that are in use one for DX 11 and one for DX9

like someone else already mention how DX11 work, either take a look at it and take it or ignore it if u want.

Anyway.. I just find the graphic looks better if u stay a long distance from the monitor, rather than sitting close to it..
 
compared to a console where you write to a specific set of hardware, the PC is not standized hardware. You have a whole range of CPUs, video cards, sound cards, network controller, etc that the game has to run on......

PC does not even have a standard OS to write to as there are people using 2K/XP,Vista, and Win 7 PCs with DX9,10, and 11........

I know what your saying sounds intuitive and thats probably why so many people repeat it, but its just not correct. The whole foundation of modern computing is based on black boxing and interfacing. Intel makes their CPU's better and better, but a core i7 cpu still adheres to the exact same logical interface as a core 2 CPU: thus you don't have to write for a CPU you write for the interface.

Hell, we're getting so good at this black boxing and interfacing thing, thanks to virtual machines such as JVM and OS DLL'd languages such as VB, that if you write in the really high level languages, you don't even have to recompile to get your code operating on multiple architectures. Microsoft's whole claim-to-fame for Windows Phone 7 is that alot of their .net 4 UI API function signatures are identical between 360, PC, and WinPho 7.

The same goes for every other component you listed. I don't know why you mentioned sound cards and NIC's, because while there is some deviation in video cards (although, again, you write for the Direct X 9 or Open GL 3 API'd and 95% of your target audience is ready to run your software), there is absolutely no deviation in NIC's or sound cards: if you're writing code thats NIC or sound-card specific you are doing something horribly horrible wrong. Those pieces of hardware are so far and away abstracted from any working code you cant possibly claim that a piece of network code written for one PC doesnt work on another --you cant even claim that a piece of network code written for consoles wont work on a PC (well maybe you could, I dunno, safe to say it wouldn't require much to port it).

And yeah, there are multiple versions of windows APIs, but fundamentally if you include it, and use some code that was released in the XP time frame, your code is going to run on every windows PC since then --hell, alot of it is the same code.

No: this whole "millions of configurations" bullshit is exactly that, because it has nothing to do with the actual as opposed to the count of interfaces that hardware adheres to, and that count is very similar between consoles and PCs. Dev's --at least the good ones-- don't build thinking about how some customers have Core 2's and others have Phenom II's because they're functionally identical if you stick to everything short of SSE9000.
 
... this is why you have to install DX9 on vista and 7 in order to play DX9 and earlier titles.
YeuEmMaiMai said:
the known fact that DX10/11 cannot run DX9 and earlier games natively and that you actually have to install DX9 on vista and 7 in order to run games for it.

Thats just straight up wrong.

Newer Direct X API's are backwards compatible: of course, they are not forward compatible, obviously (tough to be compatible with features that haven't been thought up yet).
 
Last edited:
Uncharted 2 and Killzone 2 look great by console standards but look absolute shit by PC's, considering both have no AA and are sub-720p.

I think the most impressive-looking console titles are actually multiplatform - Far Cry 2 and Resident Evil 5.
 
Uncharted 2 and Killzone 2 look great by console standards but look absolute shit by PC's, considering both have no AA and are sub-720p.

I think the most impressive-looking console titles are actually multiplatform - Far Cry 2 and Resident Evil 5.

I disagree. If you take uncharted 2 on a nice plasma tv and put it up against any other pc game on a decent lcd monitor it holds it's own.
 
I disagree. If you take uncharted 2 on a nice plasma tv and put it up against any other pc game on a decent lcd monitor it holds it's own.

I have play that game on a 50" LED monitor before, the game does not look that good against any other PC game, it still look horrible compare to PC games. But for console itself, its pretty darn good..
 
I have play that game on a 50" LED monitor before, the game does not look that good against any other PC game, it still look horrible compare to PC games. But for console itself, its pretty darn good..

You cant compare a game at 1920x1080 to a game at 720p. Thats like comparing oranges and apples. Put them all on same settings.. and you will see the best game with the best gfx. Put RE5 at the same settings.. and they will look the same. Real gfx come from artist.. not better hardware for better resolutions/aa etc...
 
Back
Top