Games Don’t Convey Emotion

What an imbecile. He may be correct if we're talking about games like mario where detail was so limited it simply wasn't possible... but games today have incredible graphics capable of conveying or displaying nearly any emotion. It's only a question of do developers take the time to utilize the resources fully...

I don't even think it's a matter of the graphics, just the way in which the game is written, with a compelling storyline. This could ahve been done back in the mario days, but it really wasn't, as the art of video games was in it's infancy.

Still today, there are games that are completely void of any story or emotion (but that have beautiful graphics) and there are games that completely suck you in to their world, despite the fact that there may be games with better graphics out there.
 
System Shock
Starcraft 1
Dues Ex

A story can be gripping in any media when done well , and can be nearly unbearable when done poorly ...even when based on a solid core tale. He ruined what should have been an easy blockbuster, if he had stuck closer to the game he would have been much better off. Basically most directors think only of themselves and how they reflect in the story telling... versus being true to the core work.
 
Zarathustra[H];1036009857 said:
I don't even think it's a matter of the graphics, just the way in which the game is written, with a compelling storyline. This could ahve been done back in the mario days, but it really wasn't, as the art of video games was in it's infancy.

Conveying emotion has more to do with even graphics and storyline. That's why movies have composers, as it's a simple way to convey emotion without seeing a damn thing.

Haunted House was creepy/scary for kids. ET might have sucked, but it was sad and great use of sound. Superman, Pitfall 1/2, hell, lots of games shortly after Pong.

The sound of games has always drawn you in, even in the infancy of gaming. Pac-Man's intro music lets you know to get ready for action, ghosts and sound clearly convey fear when you ear a power tablet, when you die you see and hear yourself croak...

Hell, Pac-Man was even the first game I can think of that had cutscenes!!! Remember the even cuter ones in Ms. Pac-Man and Pac-Man Jr.? Those were cute and funny, and some of them sad...

http://www.paranoidproductions.com/gamingandgraphics/second.html
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5U4Prl0nKyI&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n2a_ESh_-58&feature=related
(the last one shows not much graphics have to be used to describe a scene and be, ummm... graphic)

The cutscenes are definitely enhanced by the sound...

The Pac-Man game's ghosts even had personalities:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/51/Pacman_title_na.png
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pac-Man

If you don't believe simple sounds convey emotion, read up on the psychology of sounds in casinos... You never hear the sound of losing in a casino... Never a sound of despair, of futility... Always the sound of excitement and hope...

As a director, the man's well understanding in the use of sound in film...
 
Conveying emotion has more to do with even graphics and storyline. That's why movies have composers, as it's a simple way to convey emotion without seeing a damn thing.

Haunted House was creepy/scary for kids. ET might have sucked, but it was sad and great use of sound. Superman, Pitfall 1/2, hell, lots of games shortly after Pong.

The sound of games has always drawn you in, even in the infancy of gaming. Pac-Man's intro music lets you know to get ready for action, ghosts and sound clearly convey fear when you ear a power tablet, when you die you see and hear yourself croak...

Hell, Pac-Man was even the first game I can think of that had cutscenes!!! Remember the even cuter ones in Ms. Pac-Man and Pac-Man Jr.? Those were cute and funny, and some of them sad...

http://www.paranoidproductions.com/gamingandgraphics/second.html
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5U4Prl0nKyI&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n2a_ESh_-58&feature=related
(the last one shows not much graphics have to be used to describe a scene and be, ummm... graphic)

The cutscenes are definitely enhanced by the sound...

The Pac-Man game's ghosts even had personalities:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/51/Pacman_title_na.png
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pac-Man

If you don't believe simple sounds convey emotion, read up on the psychology of sounds in casinos... You never hear the sound of losing in a casino... Never a sound of despair, of futility... Always the sound of excitement and hope...

As a director, the man's well understanding in the use of sound in film...

The effect of sounds and music is truly underestimated. Star Wars would be half the movie it was without John Williams. Even George Lucas, when producing one of the episodes said something to the effect of "When this thing is ready, people won't be watching the movie, they will be listening to the music." (Can't remember exact quote verbatim) Even the latest two batman movies, which were epic btw, really stood on the shoulders of capturing music. But not to diminish the importance of character personalities and plot though.
 
The effect of sounds and music is truly underestimated. Star Wars would be half the movie it was without John Williams. Even George Lucas, when producing one of the episodes said something to the effect of "When this thing is ready, people won't be watching the movie, they will be listening to the music." (Can't remember exact quote verbatim) Even the latest two batman movies, which were epic btw, really stood on the shoulders of capturing music. But not to diminish the importance of character personalities and plot though.

You just made me realize how well Jaws used sound to convey fear and tension, when you're really not seeing much, if anything...

And then Asteroids (before Pac-Man) used the same sounds...

I won't dare say Pong used sounds this way that I can recall, but it was shortly after and darn in the infancy of gaming that sound was used to draw you in...

You could grab a blind person and have them listen to a game, and I bet they can tell you what's happening in the game...
 
This man has obviously never played a Blizzard, Valve or BioWare game. That said; how are you going to hire a director to direct a movie based on a video game, when the director doesn't even believe in the product? I mean, I've yet to meet anyone who expected anything good of movies based on video games (e.g., Doom the movie; nuff said), but this certainly doesn't help.
 
Since he hasn't played games beyond touching a gamepad (or mouse/keyboard) for a minute, maybe he has drawn his conclusions from watching Uwe Boll movies.
 
You want emotion?

Try FF7, Xenogears (omg xenogears!), Mass Effect, Metal Gear Solid 3, FF9, and the list goes on and on and on.

RPGs are better able to convey emotion because we invest so much in the characters. The same can be said when you're reading a book and you actually get to peer into what the character is thinking.

In movies, the element of love interest is thrown in there for absolutely no reason. Some movies are excellent for conveying emotion, but even those only happen once in a blue moon.

An example of terribad "love interest", remember in AvP with that chick and the predator, and how they "shared a moment"? *shudder*

This is the second 'video games have no emotion/art/value' story coming from an older, non-game playing person (first one was the thumbs up/down movie reviewer guy). Really they just need to play any damn RPG instead of watching their kids/grandkids play an action game.

I think movies have a harder time conveying emotion. Its hard to care about a character you only see for an hour or two. So we end up with a lot of crappy movies that try too hard.

What an imbecile. He may be correct if we're talking about games like mario where detail was so limited it simply wasn't possible... but games today have incredible graphics capable of conveying or displaying nearly any emotion. It's only a question of do developers take the time to utilize the resources fully...


Exactly!!! I agree that Mario Brothers and Street Fighter and other games back in the day really didn't convey much emotion. You had fun playing and made your own emotions to go along with it, but he's right about those games. They were pretty much just button mashing repetitive fun.

But this is 2010. The music, voice acting, storylines and levels of interaction are considerably greater nowadays. In a good modern RPG you could have WEEKS or even more time investing your efforts into building up a character, advancing a complex plot, building up stockpiles of customized weapons and armor, or vehicles, possibly building up a complex combination of party members, etc. There's so much story, artwork, and if it's a quality title, cinematography that draw you in just like a great movie or a great book ... And then there's a plot twist and a main character dies, perhaps your favorite party member dies. Maybe someone betrays you. Maybe there's a lightning strike that destroys your computer and you lose all your saved games :eek::eek::eek: Talk about emotions!!!

Again, even today there are some action games that really are devoid of emotion, but you can't judge the entire scope of gaming by a few bad apples. Some of the most successful gaming titles have some of the most gut-wrenching emotion in them, and rightly so. People typically don't play games that suck for very long, and they typically don't sell well either, barring some exceptions.

I can't WAIT for Mass Effect 3, or Half Life Episode 3, or Starcraft II.
 
You've posted lots of great examples of games with great storylines and emotion... But let's not forget that games will have infinitely more emotion than movies because we are in them.

A movie has never given me the same thrills, highs, triumph and defeat that a few good rounds of Tribes 1 or 2 gave me.

Tied game, soaring through the air at 350kph with the flag strapped to my back, near death from the disc jump, 2 flares left, half way home... 3 guys tailing me, chaingunning my light armor to bits... jet pack's running low on engery... mortars going off everywhere altering my run... missle lock alarms screaming in my ears... I'm praying that I'll reach the protection of our heavies and LD... then, zap! a headshot from a sniper in the mountain and it's all over... 32 guys around the world cheer as their team races to grab the flag... 32 guys yell shazbot...
 
Surprised nobody has mentioned Phantasy Star IV yet.

If you've played this game, you know what I'm talking about.

Alys death scene is quite well made, really want to made you punch Zio in the face, not to mention the Rune/Lutz prep talk with Chaz.
 
Alys death scene is quite well made, really want to made you punch Zio in the face, not to mention the Rune/Lutz prep talk with Chaz. Sadly nowdays when people talk about phantasy star, they talk about the crapfest with online and universe. While I know there can never be a phantasy star V due to the ending of iv, but still... can you imagain if they remade psiv with modern 3d graphic, it would be beautiful. I am getting off topic here... I am one of the people who buy psiv on launch day for like 70-80 bucks.
 
You've posted lots of great examples of games with great storylines and emotion... But let's not forget that games will have infinitely more emotion than movies because we are in them.

A movie has never given me the same thrills, highs, triumph and defeat that a few good rounds of Tribes 1 or 2 gave me.

Tied game, soaring through the air at 350kph with the flag strapped to my back, near death from the disc jump, 2 flares left, half way home... 3 guys tailing me, chaingunning my light armor to bits... jet pack's running low on engery... mortars going off everywhere altering my run... missle lock alarms screaming in my ears... I'm praying that I'll reach the protection of our heavies and LD... then, zap! a headshot from a sniper in the mountain and it's all over... 32 guys around the world cheer as their team races to grab the flag... 32 guys yell shazbot...

good point but I think we are talking about single player / coop.
 
Back
Top