Dell Axes the Penguin

The kernel developers are too undiciplined. They keep changing APIs in the kernel with minor kernel revs. Not just the underlying functionality, but the names and parameters of the functions that are called, often with no good reason. Old functions get replaced with a new set of functions which take the same data as inputs, and you can map from one to the other with macros. Often they even leave in the old function calls for a little while and they work just fine until the get removed a few minor revisions later.

And this is exactly why closed source drivers are so annoying on Linux. Just release the damn source and let the community maintain it.
 
Yes, so what?

Your original argument that I was countering is that Ubuntu hasn't added any features. Here, I'll repeat what you said:



My counter is that, for the masses, neither Vista or 7 added any useful features, either (except for UI). Now, you've countered with a list of features useful for YOU - which is great, but not the point. Ubuntu has added features over the years as well - features that Ubuntu users typically find as pretty good/useful.

For example, UAC and improved security in general with Vista, further improved with 7. Is it good? Sure. Is it worth upgrading from XP for? Sure. Do the masses care? Nope.

Then what features have been added to Linux that the masses care about? I was simply saying that Windows has added a lot more that the masses care about and considering the useage rates between Windows and desktop Linux I'd say there's something to this argument.
 
Then what features have been added to Linux that the masses care about? I was simply saying that Windows has added a lot more that the masses care about and considering the useage rates between Windows and desktop Linux I'd say there's something to this argument.

Again, my point is that Windows has only added *one* feature the masses care about (UI) because nobody gives a damn about the OS anymore, it has largely become irrelevant.

But if you really want to compare, here's a handy list of features: http://www.ubuntu.com/desktop/features (two that jump out are the cloud-based storage via Ubuntu One and the twitter/facebook integration)
 
And no one asked you of your opinions either my friend. There are plenty in this thread that have expressed similar sentiments. Talk to them as well.;)
No other person in this thread has suggested that the Linux community is doing a "piss poor job" with respect to advancing the capabilities of these distributions. That is the negativity I referred to and it hadn't been expressed in this thread prior to (or even after) that comment by anyone else.

No one asks that you hold Linux in the highest esteem or that you even consider using it, but considering the nature of its existence and the goals Linux developers have for it, and for its distribution, I think that criticizing it, and its developers, in such an offensive and disrespectful manner is absolutely unwelcome.
 
Again, my point is that Windows has only added *one* feature the masses care about (UI) because nobody gives a damn about the OS anymore, it has largely become irrelevant.

To some extent I agree with this. But the OS is more than just the OS, its about the things the OS supports like games, media, productivity apps, etc. If the OS were completely irrelvant then I would think that desktop Linux would be more widespread.

I think that you are making too many assumptions about what the hundreds and millions of people that use computers every day are actually doing with them. At the very least they are just claims that you have no way to prove. Not saying that you're wrong, I don't know and niether do you or anyone else for that matter.

It's called a PC for a reason, its a VERY personal device.
 
No other person in this thread has suggested that the Linux community is doing a "piss poor job" with respect to advancing the capabilities of these distributions. That is the negativity I referred to and it hadn't been expressed in this thread prior to (or even after) that comment by anyone else.

No one asks that you hold Linux in the highest esteem or that you even consider using it, but considering the nature of its existence and the goals Linux developers have for it, and for its distribution, I think that criticizing it, and its developers, in such an offensive and disrespectful manner is absolutely unwelcome.

All I am saying is that if desktop Linux were doing a good job of giving average people what they wanted wouldn't it have made better inroads. If Linux were doing a good job of giving people something of value to them, don't you think more people would use it?

How can desktop Linux advance and look at it and say "Job well done!" No too many people said that of Vista and Microsoft took that criticism and developed 7. Sometimes criticism can be a good thing if people actually take the time to LISTEN to the criticisms instead of arguing about it when clearly desktop Linux just didn't deliver as was promised by the community in the 90's.

But if this is the best that desktop Linux can do with average users, my bad. But you'd be selling pretty short I think.

Microsoft has LONG needed a true competitor on the desktop and I THOUGHT Linux was supposed to be that competitor. I'd like desktop Linux to get better. Doesn't seem like most Linux advocates want it to.

When Microsoft or
 
All I am saying is that if desktop Linux were doing a good job of giving average people what they wanted wouldn't it have made better inroads. If Linux were doing a good job of giving people something of value to them, don't you think more people would use it?
More people do use it. Is it going to displace Windows, with billion-dollar marketing budgets and their strong existing marketshare and various kinds of lock-in? No, at least not for a long time.

Sometimes criticism can be a good thing if people actually take the time to LISTEN to the criticisms instead of arguing about it when clearly desktop Linux just didn't deliver as was promised by the community in the 90's.
So what, you're saying that Linux developers aren't listening to criticism and improving the OS? Seriously? This is just completely bogus.

The biggest arguments I hear against it are that it doesn't run Windows programs well and that weird gadgets don't work with it. Neither of those things are problems fixable by the community. As a desktop operating system, filling the tasks that a desktop operating system is designed to do, it does a pretty good job. No it doesn't handle edge cases like your obsession with tablets very well, but for the vast majority of users I haven't seen any worthwhile criticism on this board or elsewhere.

Microsoft has LONG needed a true competitor on the desktop and I THOUGHT Linux was supposed to be that competitor. I'd like desktop Linux to get better. Doesn't seem like most Linux advocates want it to.
What, exactly, do you suggest they do differently? Launch lawsuits to force Dell and other OEMs to treat it equal with Windows and sell Linux-equipped laptops at a lower price than their Windows counterparts? It's making inroads in government and enterprise installations, and I think they're doing a pretty good job of selling the benefits of open-source to these communities. Getting end users off Windows is a much harder nut to crack for various reasons all completely unrelated to the quality or experience of using Linux.
 
But if you really want to compare, here's a handy list of features: http://www.ubuntu.com/desktop/features (two that jump out are the cloud-based storage via Ubuntu One and the twitter/facebook integration)

Ok the list here lets seen:

Browse the web
Create professional documents and presentations
Get free software
Email and chat
Social from the start
Buy music while you listen
View, store and edit photos
Mobilise your digital life! - cloud
Make, play and edit video

Please tell me something in this list that even phones don't do now? These things simply aren't unique and anyone with a Windows computer has been doing these things since day one. These features simply aren't enough to push Linux. It needs to be special and do something interesting. I just thought all that open source talent and enthusiasm would have done something special or interesting by now is all.
 
Please tell me something in this list that even phones don't do now? These things simply aren't unique and anyone with a Windows computer has been doing these things since day one. These features simply aren't enough to push Linux. It needs to be special and do something interesting. I just thought all that open source talent and enthusiasm would have done something special or interesting by now is all.

It's an OS. It's a commodity product these days. Nobody is really doing anything interesting, including MS and Apple. Nifty features here and there, but hardly anything game changing.

If there were one thing I'd say Linux does much better than anyone else, it's proper software installation and upgrade management. Also have a central repository for good software, all installed exactly the same way and in a centralized manner is far nicer than users searching random websites and downloading malware when they want to do something.
 
It's an OS. It's a commodity product these days. Nobody is really doing anything interesting, including MS and Apple. Nifty features here and there, but hardly anything game changing.

I think you're underestimating some things. I got my 3D Vision Surround setup over the 4th of July weekend and had family at the house. Now I totally understand the few people are going to go build a $5k setup to play a few 3D games, but when my family saw this setup, they all were picking their jaws off the floor, like when the heard the price.

But see, it was ALL powered by Windows 7. Don't think they didn't realize that. And when they go buy another computer guess what OS they want? Sure not to do this, but hell if it can do all of what they saw then why not use it for more mundane things?

If you think that the high end of tech isn't impressive, you simply haven't used enough of it lately. There's plenty to make people go wow even if they won't buy it. But they do know that that little cheap netbook is running the same OS. Don't think that people discount the OS entirely.
 
If Linux were doing a good job of giving people something of value to them, don't you think more people would use it?
Part of it is the ubiquity of Windows (and to some extent Macs and OS X). People know Windows; people like Windows; people have little reason to stop using Windows. If they're comfortable paying the price of admission, then these users have little reason to jump ship, and I wouldn't advise that anyone should jump ship simply because Linux is at a point now where it's highly functional for a large majority of computer owners. I'm a strong proponent of Linux but don't necessarily recommend that people switch from some other OS to it, not because it's a bad platform but due to other reasons, so you can understand the hesitancy users have in adopting it. And I genuinely question the need for a large user base anyway.

The reality is that Linux has very little presence, it isn't particularly business-savvy and has no substantial marketing effort behind it, which explains why its rate of adoption is slow. Would it offer many users a great value, though? Absolutely.

Sometimes criticism can be a good thing if people actually take the time to LISTEN to the criticisms instead of arguing about it when clearly desktop Linux just didn't deliver as was promised by the community in the 90's.
Has nothing to do with this. Your criticisms are generic and lack any kind of meaningful, constructive specificity and aren't targeted toward Linux developers who actually stand to make changes based on those criticisms. Do you believe that "you gotta add features" and "[you're doing] a piss poor job" are in any way constructive to any end?

With respect to those so-called "promises", we've discussed this previously. Not doing it again.

Doesn't seem like most Linux advocates want it to.
There's segmentation and disagreement. There is no single guiding hand as there is with Microsoft and Apple. That doesn't mean that developers don't want Linux to become a more viable, more useful alternative OS, however.

Please tell me something in this list that even phones don't do now?
You're redirecting the argument. Your argument was that the Linux development community wasn't adding "useful features". If that's your contention, then provide a suitable counterpoint to that list of features that have been added rather than redirecting the argument into new territory as some sort of fallback.
 
I think you're underestimating some things. I got my 3D Vision Surround setup over the 4th of July weekend and had family at the house. Now I totally understand the few people are going to go build a $5k setup to play a few 3D games, but when my family saw this setup, they all were picking their jaws off the floor, like when the heard the price.
Uhm, okay. And what exactly about that has anything to do with the OS? It's not an OS feature, and doesn't require any support from the OS either. No reason nVidia couldn't add this to their Linux drivers...

If you think that the high end of tech isn't impressive, you simply haven't used enough of it lately. There's plenty to make people go wow even if they won't buy it. But they do know that that little cheap netbook is running the same OS. Don't think that people discount the OS entirely.
If you think the high-end of tech has anything to do with the OS powering it, you don't know anything about tech.

And LOL. That cheap netbook runs Windows 7 starter, which is far less capable than Ubuntu.
 
People that know they need/want linux do not need to buy a computer with it pre-installed anyways. If you are someone who wants to 'try it' you probably have a Linux friend that can help you out anyways.
 
Has nothing to do with this. Your criticisms are generic and lack any kind of meaningful, constructive specificity and aren't targeted toward Linux developers who actually stand to make changes based on those criticisms. Do you believe that "you gotta add features" and "[you're doing] a piss poor job" are in any way constructive to any end?

My argument is VERY SPECIFIC. As I said earlier, I can take my sig rig and my Tablet PC and show the average Joe something they may not even knew was possible with a computer. Something that TOTALLY knocks their socks off. Something, to coin as phrase, is magical because they day before they may not have even known it was possible.

Desktop Linux could REALLY use tech like this. Sees when the average person sees what this tech can do, they may not buy it but they certainly wouldn't mind it and they certainly know that it runs on Windows.

Some of you seem to have lost your thirst for cool shit. Cool shit still sells computers just by word of mouth.

With respect to those so-called "promises", we've discussed this previously. Not doing it again.

Anyone working in IT in the 90's knows that these promises were quite real. Why do you think Microsoft got all aggressive attacking Linux? Linux was a threat to Windows and the Linux community said so. The Linux community simply over promised and under delivered, a no no in IT. If you don't think that this hurt Linux you're simply wrong. I know several IT managers that got burned by this.

If you think history has nothing to do with, how many people STILL keep talking about Microsoft's EVIL monopoly and the anti-trust suit from the 90's?
 
Uhm, okay. And what exactly about that has anything to do with the OS? It's not an OS feature, and doesn't require any support from the OS either. No reason nVidia couldn't add this to their Linux drivers....

No reason other than how many Linux users are going to by $5k computers.

If you think the high-end of tech has anything to do with the OS powering it, you don't know anything about tech.

Well, fine. Windows doesn't matter. Thing is where another OS that can drive it? So the OS doesn't yet I can't run this stuff on any other OS. Strange argument to make.

And LOL. That cheap netbook runs Windows 7 starter, which is far less capable than Ubuntu.

True but the BRAND associataion has been made. If a person wants a computer that can do anything, they are going to think it NEEDS to run Windows, even if their starter version can't. If you think that there is no brand association with Windows and the power to do a lot with a computer then you don't know people.
 
No other person in this thread has suggested that the Linux community is doing a "piss poor job" with respect to advancing the capabilities of these distributions. That is the negativity I referred to and it hadn't been expressed in this thread prior to (or even after) that comment by anyone else.

No one asks that you hold Linux in the highest esteem or that you even consider using it, but considering the nature of its existence and the goals Linux developers have for it, and for its distribution, I think that criticizing it, and its developers, in such an offensive and disrespectful manner is absolutely unwelcome.

heatlesunn is a well known linux troll/MS shill... so I really dont know why you guys keep paying him so much mind... dont mention to him that apple is bigger than MS in market capitalization now, and that android (linux) phones are currently tearing up the mobile space, or his head might explode....


anyway, with regards to TFA, dell didn't advertise, or really make linux systems readily available at all....., add to that the fact that windows systems were often slightly cheaper, or the same price, and its easy to see why most people failed to buy one...most (like me) just figured they'd buy the regular windows laptop, and just simply format if they want linux..... at least in that way, if you want to dual boot, you have a windows license ready to go.....

BTW, bought a dell mini 10 on sale today for 200 bucks shipped, excited to get it, format the bloatware off it, and install a sweet windows 7/gentoo dual boot....

mm, havent had a laptop in a while....
 
Uhm, okay. And what exactly about that has anything to do with the OS? It's not an OS feature, and doesn't require any support from the OS either. No reason nVidia couldn't add this to their Linux drivers...
Something AMD did today: Eyefinity is now supported in Linux. I would imagine that when AMD gets around to offering supporting for 3D Eyefinity, that too will eventually make its way to Linux systems.

If you are someone who wants to 'try it' you probably have a Linux friend that can help you out anyways.
Or just install Ubuntu, or some other distributions, from within Windows and automagically get dual-boot capability. Requires next to no technical knowledge to get started with Linux these days.

My argument is VERY SPECIFIC.
Then direct those criticisms and/or suggestions to the appropriate parties. Don't come in here suggesting that they need stop doing a "piss poor job" and suggest that you're merely voicing constructive criticisms when called out about it. That's well beyond absurdity.
 
No reason other than how many Linux users are going to by $5k computers.
Uhm? Okay? Your arguments just get more and more absurd.

Well, fine. Windows doesn't matter. Thing is where another OS that can drive it? So the OS doesn't yet I can't run this stuff on any other OS. Strange argument to make.
When are you going to get it? That stuff is not available because it was built on Windows, not because of any inherent limitation in Linux. Yes, Windows has more software available for it. Nobody is disputing that, and it is indeed one of the reasons holding back Linux adoption. However it has nothing to do with the operating system itself.

True but the BRAND associataion has been made. If a person wants a computer that can do anything, they are going to think it NEEDS to run Windows, even if their starter version can't. If you think that there is no brand association with Windows and the power to do a lot with a computer then you don't know people.
Yes, we've said that multiple times already in the thread. MS has marketshare, and it's hard to break that when they're selling a commodity and people are largely happy with their experience.

I am curious to see how ChromeOS does, being an extremely crippled OS, but with what will probably be strong backing by Google. If this OS can succeed, it says a lot about what's holding back Linux.
 
I am curious to see how ChromeOS does, being an extremely crippled OS, but with what will probably be strong backing by Google. If this OS can succeed, it says a lot about what's holding back Linux.

meh, as a huge Linux and Google fan, Chrome OS just confuses me.... seems like a failure in the waiting to be honest...

if you really want to see an example of Linux being an incredible and undeniable success with the backing of a powerful backer (and kicking the shit out of windows in the process), look to Android OS
 
Uhm? Okay? Your arguments just get more and more absurd.

When are you going to get it? That stuff is not available because it was built on Windows, not because of any inherent limitation in Linux. Yes, Windows has more software available for it. Nobody is disputing that, and it is indeed one of the reasons holding back Linux adoption. However it has nothing to do with the operating system itself.
[/QUOTE]

I never said it was an inherent limitation but how does the technology get to the platform? You need people to buy this stuff don't you? And you're not going to get people to spend money on desktop Linux until it does something worth buying. Now that Eyefinity is supported in Linux lets see what kind of support it gets.

But this is still just trailing. I guess I just thought that with all the brain power that's supposed to be in the desktop Linux comminuty they would have come up with something that people would REALLY want by know.

Look if you want desktop Linix to remain niche that's fine, there's nothing wrong with that, hell I more niche than a dozen Linux users but if you don't it simply needs to do something that's not already done elsewhere.
 
Back
Top