Dell Axes the Penguin

Really? Sales were bad? No way! Maybe if you Dell didn't advertise it as being for open source programmers then it might have done better :rolleyes:
 
That advice page is really new, just a week or two old.

Dell separated the Windows and Linux models many years ago, and pretty much removed any direct links from the main pages for those Linux systems, except for the Linux Inspiron Mini models.

People act surprised by this, but what other tier 1 manufacturers are even advertising that they sell consumer (non-netbook) desktop and laptops with Linux installed? HP makes no mention of it on the system page. Even a search for Linux only brings up server information. Nothing on Acer's web site about consumer desktop or laptops with Linux. Ditto for Sony and Toshiba. Two years ago Lenovo did what Dell just did last week. No outrage back then? Of course not, Lenovo isn't Dell. :p

Anyways, you can still order consumer Dell Linux systems by phone, which puts Dell's "support" for Linux at the top of the tier 1 list.
 
They don't put it in their normal OS options and the price is higher than the computers with the MS tax. You'd be silly to buy one, even if you can manage to find it in their store.

Not surprised.
 
Really? Sales were bad? No way! Maybe if you Dell didn't advertise it as being for open source programmers then it might have done better :rolleyes:

And why shouldn't they? Dell has to provide support the machines they sell. If a bunch of computer-illiterate people buy Ubuntu machines and then complain to Dell because they suck then the company gets screwed on support and replacement costs.

I doubt Dell ever believed that Ubuntu would be a hit with typical users, Windows is by far the better choice for them anyway. They were just seeing how big of a niche there was for Ubuntu machines. It turns out that niche simply isn't big enough to be worthwhile for Dell.
 
And why shouldn't they? Dell has to provide support the machines they sell. If a bunch of computer-illiterate people buy Ubuntu machines and then complain to Dell because they suck then the company gets screwed on support and replacement costs.

I doubt Dell ever believed that Ubuntu would be a hit with typical users, Windows is by far the better choice for them anyway. They were just seeing how big of a niche there was for Ubuntu machines. It turns out that niche simply isn't big enough to be worthwhile for Dell.


This.
 
I don't see why it's such a big deal. They never sold the Ubuntu loaded pcs in stores. Besides, Ubuntu's free, and I'm sure any one who wants it knows how to install it. I wish Ubuntu would become more mainstream. I'm a big fan of open-source software and OSes but I don't ever see Ubuntu becoming a major OS sadly.
 
I don't see why it's such a big deal. They never sold the Ubuntu loaded pcs in stores. Besides, Ubuntu's free, and I'm sure any one who wants it knows how to install it. I wish Ubuntu would become more mainstream. I'm a big fan of open-source software and OSes but I don't ever see Ubuntu becoming a major OS sadly.

Open source is cool but what has been added to Linux in the last decade that's of use to the average person? Sure, all these distros trying to run on a Colecovision is cool but there's phones, iPads and devices that are all about being small and lightweight.

Linux needed to go BIG on this desktop, something useful and compelling and the community simply thought that free and open source would do the job. It didn't. You gotta add these things called useful features and the Linux community has simply done a piss poor job in that regard.
 
I'm really not all that surprised. Majority don't want another OS. Those that do, don't care what's on the machine, they'll reload it themselves.
 
Open source is cool but what has been added to Linux in the last decade that's of use to the average person? Sure, all these distros trying to run on a Colecovision is cool but there's phones, iPads and devices that are all about being small and lightweight.

Linux needed to go BIG on this desktop, something useful and compelling and the community simply thought that free and open source would do the job. It didn't. You gotta add these things called useful features and the Linux community has simply done a piss poor job in that regard.

What did Vista add? Or Windows 7? Jack shit, that's what. Windows 7 is good, but it didn't add any consumer-focused features. The biggest difference is that the UI has been polished and upgraded to not look like it was made by Fisher Price - which Ubuntu has had for longer (Compiz ftw!). Things like UAC and SuperFetch are great and all, but your typical user doesn't give a damn about them and, in the case of UAC, typically just turn them off anyway (because they are morons, but I digress)

Desktop OSes are feature-stagnant because nothing new is going on in that area.
 
What did Vista add? Or Windows 7? Jack shit, that's what. Windows 7 is good, but it didn't add any consumer-focused features. The biggest difference is that the UI has been polished and upgraded to not look like it was made by Fisher Price - which Ubuntu has had for longer (Compiz ftw!). Things like UAC and SuperFetch are great and all, but your typical user doesn't give a damn about them and, in the case of UAC, typically just turn them off anyway (because they are morons, but I digress)

Desktop OSes are feature-stagnant because nothing new is going on in that area.

Windows 7 - Multi-touch, improved ink support, HomeGroups, support for stand alone CableCard, Aero Snap, Play To and Remote Streaming, much better search and ability to search across machines with HomeGroups. 3D Surround gaming is only supported in 7.

Not an exhaustive list by any stretch but there's a LOT there. And almost anyone can find something useful here, I just happen to use pretty much all of this stuff and its either useful or adds entertainment value to my systems.
 
/facepalm

I got scared when I read MATC in the article. Sure enough, she's from Wisconsin. I gotta get out of this state. We seem to be leading the nation in smacktardism lately.

What did Vista add? Or Windows 7? Jack shit, that's what. Windows 7 is good, but it didn't add any consumer-focused features. The biggest difference is that the UI has been polished and upgraded to not look like it was made by Fisher Price - which Ubuntu has had for longer (Compiz ftw!). Things like UAC and SuperFetch are great and all, but your typical user doesn't give a damn about them and, in the case of UAC, typically just turn them off anyway (because they are morons, but I digress)

Desktop OSes are feature-stagnant because nothing new is going on in that area.

I never understood why XP was bashed for its lack of GUI refinement when compared to Compiz considering Compiz is third party, and Linux with KDE or Gnome by themselves are just as bland.

XP had Stardock and a few other cheap or free GUI replacement too.
 
I never understood why XP was bashed for its lack of GUI refinement when compared to Compiz considering Compiz is third party, and Linux with KDE or Gnome by themselves are just as bland.

XP had Stardock and a few other cheap or free GUI replacement too.

Fire up XP again - it is *terrible* looking. Fire up a stock Gnome or KDE, they are really quite good.

And Compiz isn't really "third party". Is it made by the Gnome/KDE guys? No, but Gnome/KDE aren't made the X11 guys either - the entire stack is "third party". Unlike XP's gui replacements, Compiz isn't treated like a second class citizen by the system, which is the difference to me. And since we are talking about Ubuntu, it also ships with the system ;)

Windows 7 - Multi-touch, improved ink support, HomeGroups, support for stand alone CableCard, Aero Snap, Play To and Remote Streaming, much better search and ability to search across machines with HomeGroups. 3D Surround gaming is only supported in 7.

Not an exhaustive list by any stretch but there's a LOT there. And almost anyone can find something useful here, I just happen to use pretty much all of this stuff and its either useful or adds entertainment value to my systems.

Multitouch? Not used on a desktop
Ink support? Not used on a desktop
Home groups? Cool, but still not used by your average masses, which is what we were talking about.
Cable card? Not used on a desktop
Aero Snap? Falls under the "UI improvements" I talked about
Play To and Remote Streaming? Not used by the masses.

Really, you just gave a list of features that aren't used by the people we are talking about (Dell buyers).
 
Multitouch? Not used on a desktop
Ink support? Not used on a desktop
Home groups? Cool, but still not used by your average masses, which is what we were talking about.
Cable card? Not used on a desktop
Aero Snap? Falls under the "UI improvements" I talked about
Play To and Remote Streaming? Not used by the masses.

Really, you just gave a list of features that aren't used by the people we are talking about (Dell buyers).

Multitouch? Not used on a desktop : Really? http://www.shopping.hp.com/webapp/s...anding=desktops&a1=Category&v1=TouchSmart PCs

Ink support? Not used on a desktop: Can be if you want and I know people that do: http://www.google.com/products?q=wa...esult_group&ct=image&resnum=3&ved=0CEsQzAMwAg

Home groups? Cool, but still not used by your average masses, which is what we were talking about. Want to bet that the number of people using HomeGroups in 7 EXCEEDS the install base of any other non-Windows desktop OS? I have no idea but then niether do you.

Cable card? Not used on a desktop : Funny that I've got two on order, on for my sig rig.

Aero Snap? Falls under the "UI improvements" I talked about : Fair Enough

Play To and Remote Streaming? Not used by the masses. - Once again, want to bet more people are using this feature than the install base of any other non-Windows OS. Once again, we don't know.

You know a feature doesn't have to be used by everyone to be EXTREMELY useful to some. Linux people say that all the time and they are quite right. Give people the power, let them make up their minds if its useful or not. I'm sure glad you weren't in charge in the features that went into Windows 7.
 
I think the problem is as follows.

People see that windows 7 can cost over $200 retail.

At the same time it is widely publicized that Linux is a free operating system.

The expectation - thus - is that the ubuntu versions should be significantly cheaper, which they aren't.

My guess is that people figure, well they cost the same, so I'm going to get the one with the more expensive OS.

Who can blame them?
 
^^^ that is my thought and considering how much people fought Vista and possibly windows 7, what makes you think they want to move to a completly new OS they know nothing about when they dont even want to give up windows xp for another version of windows.....

Now imagine all those people with digital cameras, old printers and so on... not sure how linux support is these days?

Also, kllrnohj, love to see your hard fact numbers that the masses aren't using those features, how do you know this for a fact?
 
Also, kllrnohj, love to see your hard fact numbers that the masses aren't using those features, how do you know this for a fact?

Here's the thing. If just 2 or 3 percent of Windows 7 users are actually using any of these features, and I'm willing to except that is probably a small percentage, wouldn't that population equal or exceed the entire user population of desktop Linux?
 
It's probably better the general user stays away from Linux even though it has become more user friendly over the years.
 
And why shouldn't they? Dell has to provide support the machines they sell. If a bunch of computer-illiterate people buy Ubuntu machines and then complain to Dell because they suck then the company gets screwed on support and replacement costs.

I doubt Dell ever believed that Ubuntu would be a hit with typical users, Windows is by far the better choice for them anyway. They were just seeing how big of a niche there was for Ubuntu machines. It turns out that niche simply isn't big enough to be worthwhile for Dell.

Yep. You already have loads of computer illiterate people as it is using Windows and Macs. Give them Linux and tech support would go nuts.
 
Here's the thing. If just 2 or 3 percent of Windows 7 users are actually using any of these features, and I'm willing to except that is probably a small percentage, wouldn't that population equal or exceed the entire user population of desktop Linux?

Why do you twist any discussion that mentions Linux into a Windows vs. Linux debate? I mean I know this forum is very pro-MS, but it gets tiresome.

This is not at all surprising, but not because Ubuntu is any worse than Windows. Dell priced these machines higher than their Windows counterparts, and then buried them so they're difficult to buy even if you're looking for them specifically. It didn't make sense for anyone to buy them, even Linux enthusiasts.
 
Why do you twist any discussion that mentions Linux into a Windows vs. Linux debate? I mean I know this forum is very pro-MS, but it gets tiresome.

This is not at all surprising, but not because Ubuntu is any worse than Windows. Dell priced these machines higher than their Windows counterparts, and then buried them so they're difficult to buy even if you're looking for them specifically. It didn't make sense for anyone to buy them, even Linux enthusiasts.

http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1035989775&postcount=1
 
Why do you twist any discussion that mentions Linux into a Windows vs. Linux debate? I mean I know this forum is very pro-MS, but it gets tiresome.

Perhaps, but this is a PC gaming site after all, the VAST majority of people here run Windows for that purpose. For a lot of us it's kind of difficult to get enthused about an OS that doesn't support one of our favorite pastimes that well. Nothing personal.;)
 
This title is a bit out of context and sensationalized dont you think?
Dell did not axe Ubuntu. It was removed from online sales because to many people were to moronic to understand or research what they are buying.
So if you want a system with Ubuntu on it, call in to place your order.
 
Here's the thing. If just 2 or 3 percent of Windows 7 users are actually using any of these features, and I'm willing to except that is probably a small percentage, wouldn't that population equal or exceed the entire user population of desktop Linux?

Yes, so what?

Your original argument that I was countering is that Ubuntu hasn't added any features. Here, I'll repeat what you said:

You gotta add these things called useful features and the Linux community has simply done a piss poor job in that regard.

My counter is that, for the masses, neither Vista or 7 added any useful features, either (except for UI). Now, you've countered with a list of features useful for YOU - which is great, but not the point. Ubuntu has added features over the years as well - features that Ubuntu users typically find as pretty good/useful.

For example, UAC and improved security in general with Vista, further improved with 7. Is it good? Sure. Is it worth upgrading from XP for? Sure. Do the masses care? Nope.
 
Open source is cool but what has been added to Linux in the last decade that's of use to the average person? Sure, all these distros trying to run on a Colecovision is cool but there's phones, iPads and devices that are all about being small and lightweight.

Linux needed to go BIG on this desktop, something useful and compelling and the community simply thought that free and open source would do the job. It didn't. You gotta add these things called useful features and the Linux community has simply done a piss poor job in that regard.

Linux has come a long way towards being user friendly. However, supporting all the different and constantly changing hardware configurations that are out there is an incredibly huge task. Linux is a small part of the market, and from personal experience I can tell you that supporting device drivers on Linux is a time and money consuming nightmare.

The kernel developers are too undiciplined. They keep changing APIs in the kernel with minor kernel revs. Not just the underlying functionality, but the names and parameters of the functions that are called, often with no good reason. Old functions get replaced with a new set of functions which take the same data as inputs, and you can map from one to the other with macros. Often they even leave in the old function calls for a little while and they work just fine until the get removed a few minor revisions later.

A few times a year you have to make an updated copy of your development environment with the latest kernel, figure out what was changed, modify a handful of lines of code, rebuild everything and then either spend days regression testing, or just wait and hope you don't get those calls saying that the new kernel broke your driver and it has become an instant emergency that you get it fixed so that the customer that went and upgraded all their systems to the new kernel and insists they absolutely must use that version is dead in the water. Yes I'm a bit bitter. Windows drivers have their own issues, but at least the DDK APIs remain reasonably consistent even between major revisions, and over years not months. If you keep having to spend a lot of time supporting a Windows driver it means you likely did it wrong or half-assed in the first place, not because the kernel changed.
 
For a lot of us it's kind of difficult to get enthused about an OS that doesn't support one of our favorite pastimes that well.
No one was asking for you to be enthused. No one had requested your excessive and largely unwarranted negativity toward Linux, either, but it'd be foolish of us not to expect at least that in any Linux-related thread (and as such, the negativity is simply par for the course).
 
No one was asking for you to be enthused. No one had requested your excessive and largely unwarranted negativity toward Linux, either, but it'd be foolish of us not to expect at least that in any Linux-related thread (and as such, the negativity is simply par for the course).

And no one asked you of your opinions either my friend. There are plenty in this thread that have expressed similar sentiments. Talk to them as well.;)
 
Yes, so what?

Your original argument that I was countering is that Ubuntu hasn't added any features. Here, I'll repeat what you said:



My counter is that, for the masses, neither Vista or 7 added any useful features, either (except for UI). Now, you've countered with a list of features useful for YOU - which is great, but not the point. Ubuntu has added features over the years as well - features that Ubuntu users typically find as pretty good/useful.

For example, UAC and improved security in general with Vista, further improved with 7. Is it good? Sure. Is it worth upgrading from XP for? Sure. Do the masses care? Nope.

Well, if we are going to start talking about the average user, then Ubuntu does the job just fine.

The average user expects to be able to browse the web, type email and watch Youtube videos. It's becoming more and more difficult to find a computer (or even a cellphone) that can't do this these days... Ubuntu certainly does this just fine, and is free :p
 
Zarathustra[H];1035993898 said:
Well, if we are going to start talking about the average user, then Ubuntu does the job just fine.

The average user expects to be able to browse the web, type email and watch Youtube videos. It's becoming more and more difficult to find a computer (or even a cellphone) that can't do this these days... Ubuntu certainly does this just fine, and is free :p

As I see it there are 4 major groups of computer users.

1.) Computer illiterate. Won't need a computer anyway, and if they get ont it's probably a mac because its "easier".

2.) Average user: Essentially, the average user is looking for Web TV functionality, and they can get that anywhere.

3.) Above average user: The next level up of user is slightly savvier. They may want to install turbotax or photoshop, or games for their kids, and may be frustrated when they find that exactly what they want may not work on Linux (at least not without some serious tweaking) even though free linux workalikes may exist. These people should probably have Windows (or a mac)

4a) Gaming Computer Geek: It's all about games and performance. The OS for this is Windows. No questions about that.

4b) Nerdy computer geek: Appreciates linux for the sake of linux. Likes compiling their own programs, and appreciates the level of customization and security that can come with a linux box. Sees Windows as a necessary evil for a limited few programs that won't run on Windows.


Personally I am about 20% 4a and 80% 4b. :p
 
Back
Top