Quiet and reliable drives?

Tudz

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
7,434
G'day all,

I was thinking of picking up a 1.5TB 5400rpm Samsung HD154UI as there's some going dirt cheap at a nearby store, when I looked on Newegg and saw a huge amount of 1 egg ratings for the drive, and even some of the 2-3 egg ratings were saying they were on their 2nd drive after an RMA or it went bad after a few months.

After looking at the WD Cavier Green and a couple of 1.5TB Seagates it seems like all of the 1.5TB drives have really bad DOA or short life span rates.

My current drive is a 1TB WD Cavier Black with a 500GB Seagate Barracuda, but I find them both quite noisy and its almost full.

What do you guys recommend in the 1TB-2TB range that should be reliable and also relatively quiet? I would like something bigger than 1TB, but if there's nothing good I dont mind getting another 1TB drive or two.
 
I'm in Australia so no real go on that one ;) Though I could grab the same model from an Aussie retailer, they aren't too expensive. However my concern is more with reliability, it seems all the large capacity drives are getting really bad feedback with regards to their reliability.
 
I do not think its just large drives. I believe drives in general are less reliable now than they were 3 years ago and less yet then they were 5 years ago. With that said I have a 2TB green at home and I would buy a second. At work I have only a few other drives larger than 1TB that and none of them have failed.
 
However my concern is more with reliability, it seems all the large capacity drives are getting really bad feedback with regards to their reliability.

Then check the feedback on the drive I linked?

My point was to show a reliable drive (that also was about to go on sale). If you want reliability beyond that, consider the RE line with the premium price.

I believe drives in general are less reliable now than they were 3 years ago and less yet then they were 5 years ago.

I bought twenty 80GB Maxtors back in 2001. I spent most of 2002 RMAing the drives, an average of two a month. I did this 'til Maxtor started denying the warranty.

I've owned Deathstars that are still working today, and I've bought the dreaded Seagate models that are working fine.

Buying hard drives is just a game of Russian roulette. But even the recent worst-of-the-worst drives' reputations don't compare to my 2002 experience.

Seagate may be making poor-quality drives. It may be that they are. But I have not heard that they have dropped warranty on them.
 
and I've bought the dreaded Seagate models that are working fine.

Last year at this time I would have said there is nothing wrong with 7200.11s. However this year I have sent back 5 of them at work. That was 5 of the 8 drives that have died in our department. The other 3 were 5 to 6 year old WDC 250GB SATA 1 drives that were in a raid since 2005.
 
What do you guys recommend in the 1TB-2TB range that should be reliable and also relatively quiet? I would like something bigger than 1TB, but if there's nothing good I dont mind getting another 1TB drive or two.

I recently purchased 4 of the Samsung F3 EcoGreen 2TB drives and am extremely pleased with them. They run cool, quiet, and have been reliable so far. It's only been a few weeks so we'll see.

I also have a few 1TB WD Blacks and Greens (all of which were great) but with my increased storage needs it was time to consolidate drives. If you're skeptical of the 1.5-2TB drives you could check out the 1TB Samsung F3; it's a fast drive that gets excellent reviews as well.
 
I recently purchased 4 of the Samsung F3 EcoGreen 2TB drives and am extremely pleased with them. They run cool, quiet, and have been reliable so far. It's only been a few weeks so we'll see.

I also have a few 1TB WD Blacks and Greens (all of which were great) but with my increased storage needs it was time to consolidate drives. If you're skeptical of the 1.5-2TB drives you could check out the 1TB Samsung F3; it's a fast drive that gets excellent reviews as well.

I'm considering the 1tb F3 actually. It's quite cheap and I can get a pair for not much more than a single 2tb drive. Not as good value as the 1.5tb drives though, but they seemto be much faster. I wonder how thenoise compares to the slower spinning but higher capacity drives.
 
Well I ended up buying a pair of Samsung 1TB F3s, the HD103SJ. It ended up not much more expensive than a single 2TB drive, but its quite a bit faster and seems relatively quiet. Can't hear it over my other drives, but I plan to install an OS on one of the HD103SJs and remove the old drives and then we'll see how quiet it really is when it doesn't have to compete with other drives.

Its actually a decent amount faster than my 1TB Cavier Black for file transfers, going black -> F3 was 80MB/s for my big files, but going from one F3 -> other F3 was 120MB/s, I'm almost tempted to get rid of the Cavier Black and just get an SSD as an OS drive then use the Samsungs for everything else. I can't tell if the Samsung is quieter or louder than the Black because the loudest thing in my system is a 500gb Seagate which overwhelms both the drives, of which I hope I get rid of now.
 
Based on my experience with Samsungs and WD Blacks (though I haven't owned/used the 1TB F3), I'm willing to bet that the Samsung is quieter. As you noticed, the Samsungs tend to do better when it comes to transfer rates but the Black should have the edge when it comes to access times. Both are excellent drives. Enjoy!
 
Till WD proves to me their Black line of drives is anything but high quality, its what I'll use. They're performing just fine in RAID 0 for me.
 
I've been using 6 of the Samsung Spinpoint F1 HD103UJ 1TB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache for just over two years now. They are all in my server and run 24/7. None of them have ever failed (knock on wood) and the performance has always been good. I would think the newer versions are just as good if not better.
 
Back
Top