Tech Support Showdown 2010

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The results of LAPTOP Magazine’s Tech Support Showdown 2010 are now online. See how twelve of the biggest names in the PC industry fared when their tech support was put to the test.

During our tests we encountered, on average, 13-minute call times with less than 4 minutes of time spent on hold. That's down by more than a minute compared to last year's results. However, a few of the big brands refused to answer our questions unless they were strictly in reference to broken hardware, pitching some fairly pricey support packages instead. This disturbing trend aside, there were some pleasant surprises.
 
Pretty much as expected on the summary page. Most support is mediocre. It's pretty sad that only Apple aced these basic tech support questions.
 
Too bad they don't include support related to "hardware" issues and replacing hardware, as most of those companies are hardware companies, not software companies.
 
I have issues with that too. The difference between Apple and the others is that Apple provides support for both "its hardware and its software." Calling a company expecting technical support for anything other than their own hardware doesn't make sense. When I read the metric it was tested I knew this article was pretty bogus.



Overall I give the Article a capital T for trash.
 
This is a loads of fluff because it doesn't include hardware...
And since when has being obnoxious and lying to your customer while accusing them of everything been A+ service!?
 
Too bad they don't include support related to "hardware" issues and replacing hardware, as most of those companies are hardware companies, not software companies.

I agree, I looked at their question set (and the first one wasn't even similar between the Apple and PC vendors) and this makes no sense.
 
WOW.. Steve actually posted something that puts Apple in a good light!! Think Steve's account has been hijacked and Skynet actually posted this.. we are all GOING TO DIE!!

skynet-20091209-122903.jpg


Back on topic.. I guess it is true that most tech support people are about as competent as these guys..

the-it-crowd.jpg


who give advice about as useful as this..

ctrl_alt_delete.png
 
I've never been impressed with Apple's support myself... Never understood why they rank so high. I can spend less time screwing with getting a failed component replaced with Dell than I ever would with Apple.
 
I've never been impressed with Apple's support myself... Never understood why they rank so high. I can spend less time screwing with getting a failed component replaced with Dell than I ever would with Apple.

My mother's keyboard had keys eaten off by her bird. I called dell at her request and told them keys were broken off/removed/missing and they were like "sure, well send out a replacement free of charge" I nearly crapped myself. Few other occasions were they swapped parts out free, no questions asked. Their customer support for non-business service is absolute balls, but I have to say their parts replacement programs are damn nice; unless you're ordering extra/replacement screws. God damn, sent me eight individual boxes separately all containing one screw. Seriously, wtf?

Uh, but yeah, unfair/biased "showdown" is unfair/biased. :p
 
Whether you're looking to make the switch or upgrade to a new machine, no other company comes close to Apple's combination of web-based help, friendly phone service, and in-store support options.
I've only been in an Apple store once (with a friend who needed something), but when I was there I do agree the employees were very helpful. Of course, I've never been in an HP/Dell/etc. store (do they exist?), so I can't compare the two.

Apple's site requires you to go through a short series of drill-down menus to describe your problem before giving you the option of having Apple call you now, later, or calling them yourself. This approach saved time because the technicians received this information and knew what our issue was without us having to explain it.
This makes no sense. Whether you do A before B or B before A, you're still doing both.

As for the hardware vs. software support issue, Apple makes both. PC manufacturers don't make the software (OS, etc.). Therefore it makes sense to me that Apple would offer support for both whereas PC OEMs would only support their own hardware.

Although Apple and and it's blind followers (not saying all Apple fans follow blindly) annoy the crap out of me at times, I give the company props for providing support pertaining to Macs interacting with PCs. I wouldn't expect any given OEM to provide support for Windows/Office/whatever. For F's sake, don't people know how to Google yet? Think for 5 seconds: "OK, I have a question about Windows. Who makes Windows? Microsoft. OK, let me contact Microsoft." How hard is that? Yeah, yeah, I know I'm preaching to the choir here... :p
 
They are asking PC vendors how to speed up Windows 7 booting?
It would be equally (ir)relevant to ask Apple how to speed up Windows 7 boot. Yet, they did not even ask them how to speed up the OS X boot (my mac mini boots slower than my Win HTPC).

A legitimate article would call Microsoft and Apple and ask about software, or test hardware problem resolving with Apple and the other manufacturers. As it is, the article is pure BS.
 
Yeah, I was wondering why they were calling computer manufacturers and asking about Windows help. They should be calling Microsoft and asking that and asking the manufacturers about their hardware. Definitely a pro-Apple slant in that article as it makes the grade based on a very biased subject.
 
This makes no sense. Whether you do A before B or B before A, you're still doing both.

What they are saying is that the online/automated system isn't just for show. Often when you call support with some companies they ask you to type in your phone number, account number, pick your problem from a list and on and on, and when you finally talk to a tech they ask you the same questions all over again. The automated system is useless because it's collecting info that the tech never sees.
 
What they are saying is that the online/automated system isn't just for show. Often when you call support with some companies they ask you to type in your phone number, account number, pick your problem from a list and on and on, and when you finally talk to a tech they ask you the same questions all over again. The automated system is useless because it's collecting info that the tech never sees.

Touche.
 
What they are saying is that the online/automated system isn't just for show. Often when you call support with some companies they ask you to type in your phone number, account number, pick your problem from a list and on and on, and when you finally talk to a tech they ask you the same questions all over again. The automated system is useless because it's collecting info that the tech never sees.

EXACTLY. Drives me nuts.

Although I must say ATT Wireless is one company I have to give Kudos for here, the phone # does populate through the system and the tech then just asks for your PIN and name on the account or whatnot.

But to get there, I just hit the 0 twice. Following the menus does no good... If you truly need an escalated form of help, you can't get to them through the automated menus anyway.
 
Yeah, I was wondering why they were calling computer manufacturers and asking about Windows help. They should be calling Microsoft and asking that and asking the manufacturers about their hardware. Definitely a pro-Apple slant in that article as it makes the grade based on a very biased subject.

because OEMs are supposed to provide support for Windows.

licensing terms of an OEM Windows license, is that the seller of the software provides the support, not Microsoft. Therefore, Dell, HP, Acer, etc, provide the Windows support.

Why do you think OEM OS licenses are so much cheaper than a retail license?
 
Support for Windows as in resolving conflicts with thier installed software or troubleshooting crashes, something actually related to the computer.

Not configuring your home network for you.
 
Support for Windows as in resolving conflicts with thier installed software or troubleshooting crashes, something actually related to the computer.

Not configuring your home network for you.

it's not Microsoft's job to provide free tech support for their OEM products. Period.
Whether or not the OEM wants to is up to the OEM.

regular Joe Public is going call the computer manufacturer. Plain and simple.
 
I didn't say it was MS's responsibility either. The questions they asked had little to nothing to do with actual warranty support for a PC. They were usage questions, which are not covered under warranty.
 
it's not Microsoft's job to provide free tech support for their OEM products. Period.
Whether or not the OEM wants to is up to the OEM.

regular Joe Public is going call the computer manufacturer. Plain and simple.

Umm say what?

Microsoft does support for their software. It is not the responsibility of the Hardware supplier to do the support. Microsoft has whole sections of its support site dedicated to OEM support.
 
Umm say what?

Microsoft does support for their software. It is not the responsibility of the Hardware supplier to do the support. Microsoft has whole sections of its support site dedicated to OEM support.
Just because you think the manufacturer shouldn't support it doesn't make it true. The manufacturers do in fact provide support for Windows and MS will point the user back to the manufacturer if they call and don't want to pay. MS supports retail boxed copies, users/organizations with support contracts and per incident paid support.

This is an example from the Windows OEM booklet that is shipped by computer manufacturers:
Because Windows was included with the purchase of your new computer, your computer manufacturer provides support for this product. For contact details go to:
http://support.microsoft.com/directory/directory/oemdirectory.asp
(link no longer works)
 
Its a shame that they don't review the premium brand PC's that cost about as much as an apple. I was over a friends house when we swapped out the CPU, motherboard and video cards in his falcon northwest, he called a direct number that was answered on the first ring. My jaw dropped as the technician walked him through setting up his ram timings over the phone, setup his raid array, and even offered to help him overclock his new CPU.
 
I followed the [H] links and read the article on "Laptop," and at the bottom of the page I added a comment of my own that mentioned what I thought were the really weak points in their approach. Basically, I thought the article should have been entitled "How to give an A to Apple for tech support while giving everybody else a D or an F!" Heh...;) I did not, of course, make that line a part of my comment.

Anyway, after I hit the submit button a little box popped up that said that my post was being "evaluated" by a moderator and would show up later, provided it passed the moderator's screening, presumably. Ah, gee, well it's been 20 minutes and so far the "moderator" isn't posting my comments. So I thought I'd paste what I said to them here:

I hope I'm not the only one who feels this article was heavily biased from the start...;)

Why *not*, for instance, go ahead and ask Mac tech-support about booting "faster" into OS X? You know, saying that you didn't ask this question of the Mac personnel because "OS X already boots faster" is really, really lame. Maybe that's the *answer* you got, though, which is really a poor answer, and so you decided to change around the questions you'd ask Apple.

Big mistake--not asking the *same questions.* I'l bet the Mac guy would have responded to that question by saying "Duh! You want to do what? Why?" and that you'd have gotten no farther than that. But gee, "booting faster" has to do with turning off programs that normally run at boot, so maybe that's just much easier done under Windows 7 than it is in Mac OS X. But who knows? We don't know because you chickened out on the question. But it's without a doubt a *much* more difficult question for a hardware tech person to answer than was the simple question you asked the Mac people instead, because there are several different approaches you can use to solve it.

Then there's the 90-days of phone support Apple provides before you have to pay for it. Compared to the year offered by the others, which is what I presume based on the spotty way in which you compared the terms of the companies' differing warranties. For instance, a *table* comparing all facets of the warranties, including duration, would have been nice to see--but you didn't give it to us. While you told us what Acer's more in-depth for-sale phone support would have cost you--you didn't even mention Apple's optional phone support costs. Why? I mean, 90-days really sucks...;) I'd have to give Apple a D or an F just for that, because suppose you didn't need to call Apple until day 105? Your phone support is covered by the other guys, but not by Apple.

Next, you make big beans about Apple's online tech support, and speak prodigiously of how much better it is than anybody else's. I went out there and looked around and I thiought it was just "OK" *provided* you understood clearly every term Apple mentions in its printed tech-support instructions. There's the rub, isn't it? Unless you thoroughly understand your system already to a degree that you can sit around and discuss it using the terms Apple uses on its web site, then most likely the Apple web site isn't going to be of much help to you, is it? Which is why you need the phone...but it's only for 90 days unless you pony up the big bucks for Apple's after care phone support--which you barely mentioned if at all.

Then, you also threw in calling individual Apple stores--even if you did not presumably purchase your Mac there--which is not the same thing as calling Apple directly--but you declined to mention to people that should they buy their computers through a *store* environment, instead of by blind Internet transaction, that *they* also might benefit from in-store tech support provided by the people who own the store in which they purchased their computer. Why so lopsided in your coverage of Macs? It's as though you think all of this stuff was invented by Apple and that nobody else ever heard of these things--there are millions of mom&pop computer centers around the world that give out reams of free advice and support every day to their *customers* via the phone. There are even some national chains who provide such local support options as well. But apparently you didn't know any of this...

Last, major beef here: Aside from screwing the pooch in ducking what would have been a challenging question to ask Mac tech support ("How can I get my Mac to boot faster?"), you also failed to take into account Apple's warranty responsibilities and duties to its customers that differ from any of the OEMs you queried. Namely, Apple's warranty has to support not only the hardware in the Mac (which differs little if at all from any of the other notebooks made by the OEMs you featured in this article), but Apple is also the author, and copyright and trademark holder of OS X, which is the OS these Macs ship with. And that means Apple is directly responsible for providing tech support for OS X as well as the Mac hardware it sells. That's a big difference, and a difference you didn't mention.

The fact is that most hardware OEMs leave the support of the software products they sell you to the manufacturers of the software. If its OEM custom software then, yea, they'll support it because they know that there is nobody else who will....;) Just like Apple with OS X--if Apple doesn't support it then who will?

OK, for Windows 7 that manufacturer would be Microsoft, not Dell, not Acer, etc. My feeling is, however, that if one of the other non-Mac OEMs had to slog through problems in Win7 in order to diagnose what is likely a hardware problem--they would do that in a skinny, since that is really what their warranties are concerned with. But, you didn't ask them to actually address a *hardware issue*, did you?

For instance, I think this would have been a more telling question to have asked everybody: "I keep getting error messages on my hard drive at various times. What's wrong, or what should I do?" and then mark down the responses. Such a question indicates a hardware problem with your hard drive, and so all of these tech people, including Apple, would have been compelled to help you because the underlying problem might be related to the hardware you just purchased, which is still under warranty.

One last, last remark...;) It would have been interesting for you to have asked Apple the question: "I just used the Apple-supplied Bootcamp utility to install Windows 7 to my Macbook, and I'm having a couple of minor problems in Win 7 and wondered if you could help me out!...?" The answer would have been, "Sorry, but Apple doesn't support any version of Windows," even though Apple provides the software needed to install Windows alongside OS X. Wouldn't it?

I remember that you mentioned that Apple's phone support warranty was 90 days, but I can't recall if you said whether this corresponded to Apple's hardware support as well. Does it? If it does, the Apple's purchase warranty support sort of stinks all around, imo. Hopefully, Apple will at least stand by its hardware for a year at no charge to the Apple customer. Last question, I promise: what happens if my Mac hard drive does go bad in the sixth month after purchase? Do you I have to pay for extra phone support in order to get my hard drive replaced, assuming Apple's hardware warranties last longer than 90 days?

Not trying to be rough here, but it seems to me you are treating Apple with kid gloves compared to everybody else.
 
I was going to edit my above post to add the following comment but just discovered that I'm not allowed to do edits on my own posts in this forum. Does anybody know if that's the norm? A glitch, maybe?

Anyway, I wanted to add that another great web-based resource for handling tech-support problems of all kinds is a bing/google, etc., search. I do this often, myself, especially when the problem I want to address isn't readily available via normal commercial web resources. Like, say, I want to find out some information about installing a very old game I have into Win7. A bing/google search is not only probably going to supply me with the best answers available, but it may actually provide me with the *only* answers available--especially if my questions have to do with software originally sold by now-defunct companies. It's odd to see a tech-support article that doesn't mention this, because it is something that might occur to a novice as well as an experienced user. Frequently when I use a search engine to try and answer a technical question I may have I'll find no shortage of new/inexperienced people who are asking it, too, and who often spell out their answers at the technical level of n00bs--which means that this kind of activity could benefit a n00b as well as an experienced person. I actually intended to add this comment to the "Laptop" comments I made above, but now, after 45 minutes, my post still isn't there, so I guess it won't be published at all.
 
WaltC, I salute and applaud you for your comment on the thread. Very good breakdown of the issues.
 
Just because you think the manufacturer shouldn't support it doesn't make it true. The manufacturers do in fact provide support for Windows and MS will point the user back to the manufacturer if they call and don't want to pay. MS supports retail boxed copies, users/organizations with support contracts and per incident paid support.

I didn't say "shouldn't", I said it is not their prime responsibility. And I have no idea where you are getting all your information from. I have called Microsoft and used Microsoft Chat, Microsoft Forums, e-mails to Microsoft to get support for their products and never once was I referred back to the manufacturer of the computer. Remember, OEM products are also purchased through self-build computers too. Is NewEgg then responsible for doing Microsoft support because you bought a bunch of parts from them and OEM licenses from Microsoft?

This is an example from the Windows OEM booklet that is shipped by computer manufacturers:
(link no longer works)

Nice one to a link that doesn't work... You can say all you want, but it really isn't going to make a dent. I have dealt with Microsoft for years, the good, the bad, the horrendous. But never have they just completely pawned off their support to a manufacturer, unless it was a possible hardware issue, drivers, or non MS software.
 
Walt, Nobody can edit in here in the News...

Good breakdown, pretty much agree with it.

There is an ADVANTAGE to having one contact for everything, for end users in general. However, as we all know here: that doesn't mean they'll anymore easily solve real problems than Dell would (IE, the boot question).
 
Back
Top