The Growing Geek iPhone Backlash

I think Sprint may be the best carrier in the nation right now, IMO...
Their CS has improved greatly, coverage isn't that great as compared to ATT, but it at least WORKS, and it's QUALITY coverage. They're even rolling out 4G when everyone else is still pretty much thinking about it (Verizon) or not even caring (ATT).
And to boot, they've got the best pricing.


Haven't really researched the Evo much other than the specs, but I'm wanting one pretty bad and to dump my 3GS.
 
Best? Not even.
There is a "best" phone for a given user and a "worst" phone for a given user. For some, iPhone may be the "best". For others, it may easily be the "worst".

I wish someone would just do a full port Android to an Iphone already!
It's possible to run Android on an iPhone.

Microsoft [has the] ...best DAP
Given my experiences with the Zune HD, I find it hard to imagine how anyone could claim it as the "best DAP" with a straight face.

...best phone OS
Windows Phone 7? The best phone OS? No application multitasking; no copy-and-paste; just as locked-up and as tightly controlled as iOS; no real indication that its going to have a strong selection of apps compared to iOS and Android. I don't see how these qualities make it a class-leading mobile platform.

...best desktop OS
Well, that's debatable.

It is still in a proprietary format. I want the plain .mp3 files.
MP3 is just as proprietary as AAC in an MP4 container. If you want non-proprietary lossy formats, your options are few.
 
Totally missed the point. Entire context of my post was talking about MICROSOFT leadership. The best in company history.
 
That $600 unsubsidized price tag of the iPhone... That's what you're asking for?
There's advantages to contracts and locked phones.

And some phone companies (TMobile I think?) give you free incoming calls/texts/photos/etc.

I want to be able to use my phone on any network that I choose. I don't think that's too much to ask. I hate contracts but I know they're reducing the price of the phone in exchange for your long term business.

I didn't know there were any wireless companies out that allowed free incoming calls. Good to know.
 
MP3 is just as proprietary as AAC in an MP4 container.
How could you possibly figure that? iTunes files play in iTunes (assuming you are logged in to the same account) and iPods/iPhones. MP3 has no restrictions, and can natively be played on anything under the sun, from portable players, computers, and even car stereo systems. I can't take iTunes-purchased content and move it to my iPod or iPhone with Media Moneky, can I? Nope. The point of an MP3 is that it isn't a proprietary format. That's why people like me, buy their music from Amazon, rather than iTunes, despite owning an iPhone.
 
How could you possibly figure that? iTunes files play in iTunes (assuming you are logged in to the same account) and iPods/iPhones. MP3 has no restrictions, and can natively be played on anything under the sun, from portable players, computers, and even car stereo systems. I can't take iTunes-purchased content and move it to my iPod or iPhone with Media Moneky, can I? Nope. The point of an MP3 is that it isn't a proprietary format. That's why people like me, buy their music from Amazon, rather than iTunes, despite owning an iPhone.
You're mistaken.

Firstly, the vast majority of "iTunes files", which is nothing more than AAC audio in MP4 containers, are now DRM-free. They will play back in any player on any device which supports both AAC audio decoding and can interpret MP4 containers. Content purchased from the iTunes store some time ago may have DRM, but the vast majority of music in the iTunes store is completely DRM free (these are iTunes Plus files). You can sync them to any iDevice with Media Monkey. You can play them back in any player that supports AAC in an MP4.

Secondly, MP3 is an ISO-standard format, but it is not free nor open. It is proprietary. AAC is also an ISO-standard format. MP4 is an ISO-standard container format. They are all ISO standards, yet they are also all proprietary technologies and must be licensed from their owners (through the intermediary MPEG-LA) in order to be distributed as encoders or decoders.
 
I want to be able to use my phone on any network that I choose. I don't think that's too much to ask. I hate contracts but I know they're reducing the price of the phone in exchange for your long term business.

Chose one or the other.
Lock in at $200. No lock at $600.

Actually, you can make this choice already NOW...

Now, perhaps a law forbidding lock-in to prevent you from running the no-lock device elsewhere (IE, if you pay the $600 to buy it out of contract, you should be able to do what the hell you want) might make more sense. But that's more of an Apple thing preventing the jailbreaking. Really the #1 person to bitch to about all this is Apple. Apple alone could fix many of these complaints by changing their practices.
 
You're mistaken.
So I could put those files on a USB stick and play them in a car stereo with a USB input? Not likely. Could I burn those files to a disc (getting up to 99 songs on a disc) and have it playable in my wife's car stereo? Nope, but an MP3 disc plays just fine. How about on a generic MP3 player that my nephew uses? Nope, only plays MP3. How about non-Apple phones? They wouldn't play on my Samsung Blackjack II. Could I copy those files to my Zune 30 GB player? Nope.

Mistaken? Hardly.
 
Could I burn those files to a disc (getting up to 99 songs on a disc) and have it playable in my wife's car stereo? Nope, but an MP3 disc plays just fine.
So you believe the capability to play back a format that your wife's car's stereo supports makes that format non-proprietary. By that logic, if your wife's car's stereo supported FairPlay-protected MP4s, that format, too, would be non-proprietary.

That's absolutely brilliant.
 
Proprietary, to me, means I need to jump through owner-defined hoops to play the file back, on an approved device, using approved software. Non-proprietary, in contrast, means I can play it on anything I want, when I want, how I want.

Let me give you an example. Mac OS is proprietary. It can only be installed on their computers. Linux, is open. I can install it on an Apple, a PC Compatible system, a game console, an old PDA...whatever I want, how I want.

Here's another example. Sony's MemoryStick. SDHC cards are much more standard, aka non-proprietary, and aren't tied or controlled by one brand.

Proprietary formats have more restrictions and less industry support. Apply it to whatever you want...hardware, software, corporate information, etc. It doesn't need to be brilliant....because it's really that simple.
 
I understand factoring the cost of the phone into a 2 year contract, but why don't we get reduced rates when using an unlocked phone that wasn't bought under contract.
 
I understand factoring the cost of the phone into a 2 year contract, but why don't we get reduced rates when using an unlocked phone that wasn't bought under contract.

Ummm, that makes no sense. The rates are (at least on paper) what it costs them to give your device connectivity to the network. Those shouldn't change regardless of how you bought the device.
 
Proprietary, to me, means I need to jump through owner-defined hoops to play the file back, on an approved device, using approved software. Non-proprietary, in contrast, means I can play it on anything I want, when I want, how I want.

I'd agree. But by that token as well... You're saying the most popular methods are the least propriety since it has the highest compatibility. Perhaps you're confusing compatibility with proprietary?

Good example is the iPod. Most popular DAP around, therefore, it's probably the most compatible device. If I can buy a vehicle interface adapter, it'll work with a larger number of iPods than anything else. Though it's still proprietary.
 
I think Sprint may be the best carrier in the nation right now, IMO...
Their CS has improved greatly, coverage isn't that great as compared to ATT, but it at least WORKS, and it's QUALITY coverage. They're even rolling out 4G when everyone else is still pretty much thinking about it (Verizon) or not even caring (ATT).
And to boot, they've got the best pricing.


Haven't really researched the Evo much other than the specs, but I'm wanting one pretty bad and to dump my 3GS.

there is no "best" carrier, they are all equally shitty...
 
there is no "best" carrier, they are all equally shitty...

The only carrier that comes to mind (other than a couple regional ones here) is ATT when I hear the word "shitty".
Sprint and Verizon both work well, given you've got the signal.
 
I am not really otherwise a big apple fan, and there ARE 1-2 tech limitations that really bother me (no flash, the inability to use it as a storage device or viewer of pretty much any video file type outside of .mov).

But I will say outside of that I still think the Iphone is an excellent phone. In fact, I thin kthat is apples true niche in a way. I want my phone to be easy, hassle free, and yes retard proof, which in a way is what Apple has always been about in my mind.

I am having a little geek backlash of my own amongst my friends droid superiority. I do thin kthe Droid is nifty yes, but it's not nearly "that much better" than the Iphone, in fact in some ways I still like the Iphone better. So yeah, whenever I have a droid shoved in my face with my friend saying "look how much more customizeable mine is! I can have this cool background and text tone!" I am kind of not that much bowled over.

Of course why it seems to so difficult to pick a text sound outside the presets on my iphone is a bit beyond me.
 
I think ATT was a must for iPhone. The world is largely GSM, as is ATT. If it Apple eventually gets around to a CDMA phone, then it can offer Verizon/Sprint coverage. Until then there is little point for them to break the exclusivity with ATT. I also think CDMA is more expensive to build/license.

So it was a no brainer to go GSM/ATT to start. They probably got something from ATT for being exclusive even though they weren't really going to do different carrier anyway.
 
I'd agree. But by that token as well... You're saying the most popular methods are the least propriety since it has the highest compatibility. Perhaps you're confusing compatibility with proprietary?
It's a fine line between the two, in this case. Since the format can be used on pretty much any medium, rather than the owner's specific brands, you can make the case that it is very similar to compatibility. If I buy a product, and need to use your specific hardware and software to use it, that makes it proprietary. If I buy your product and can use it across many products, brands, etc, because it is a common fomat, that is not proprietary.
 
The only carrier that comes to mind (other than a couple regional ones here) is ATT when I hear the word "shitty".
Sprint and Verizon both work well, given you've got the signal.

AT&T has been great near me. 4 bars and 3G pretty much everywhere I go. Zero troubles in over 3 years.
 
I think ATT was a must for iPhone. The world is largely GSM, as is ATT. If it Apple eventually gets around to a CDMA phone, then it can offer Verizon/Sprint coverage. Until then there is little point for them to break the exclusivity with ATT. I also think CDMA is more expensive to build/license.

So it was a no brainer to go GSM/ATT to start. They probably got something from ATT for being exclusive even though they weren't really going to do different carrier anyway.
And yet GSM wasn't their first choice...
So if it was "no brainier" to go GSM, by Apple pursuing CDMA technology first, that means they've got no brain? FINALLY an Apple supporter that admits it!

It's a fine line between the two, in this case. Since the format can be used on pretty much any medium, rather than the owner's specific brands, you can make the case that it is very similar to compatibility. If I buy a product, and need to use your specific hardware and software to use it, that makes it proprietary. If I buy your product and can use it across many products, brands, etc, because it is a common fomat, that is not proprietary.
What if it requires a special adapter (iPod adapter versus mini USB), but anyone can make said adapter?

LOL... I mean you can discuss this thing a hundred different ways. I see both of you guys argument.

AT&T has been great near me. 4 bars and 3G pretty much everywhere I go. Zero troubles in over 3 years.
Like I said before, signal isn't the issue. It's the quality of said signal.
That said, I think the iPhone is also particularly crappy when it comes to phone reception though.
 
I think the iPhone is also particularly crappy when it comes to phone reception though.
The iPhone has been the clearest phone I've ever used. I'd give that vote to Blackberry, for having poor call quality, but that's been a ding against RIM for some time now. I can definitely tell a difference between someone calling my office with their BB versus another phone, even on the same service, sitting in the same conference room.
 
Proprietary, to me, means I need to jump through owner-defined hoops to play the file back, on an approved device, using approved software. Non-proprietary, in contrast, means I can play it on anything I want, when I want, how I want.

Let me give you an example. Mac OS is proprietary. It can only be installed on their computers. Linux, is open. I can install it on an Apple, a PC Compatible system, a game console, an old PDA...whatever I want, how I want.

Here's another example. Sony's MemoryStick. SDHC cards are much more standard, aka non-proprietary, and aren't tied or controlled by one brand.

Proprietary formats have more restrictions and less industry support. Apply it to whatever you want...hardware, software, corporate information, etc. It doesn't need to be brilliant....because it's really that simple.

Playing fast and loose with language will lead to gross misunderstandings like this. Referring to a proprietary format as not so simply because it's widely compatible does not make it less proprietary. I genuinely could not understand where you were coming from and it seems nobody else did until you provided your own supplementary definition of the word.

Looking back at your older post about simply wanting plain MP3 files, which are indeed a proprietary format, it's easy to realize that you meant you wanted the most widely compatible format.

Also, I don't know what sort of stereo your wife's car has but, you mentioned Zune and Zune does play AAC/MP4 along with Microsoft's equally proprietary WMV/A and MP3, etc. Conversely, I don't believe iDevices play WMV/A at all. You've confusingly brought up proprietary formats once again, and I reiterate that you should look into OGG if you are looking for non-proprietary formats.
 
And yet GSM wasn't their first choice...
So if it was "no brainier" to go GSM, by Apple pursuing CDMA technology first, that means they've got no brain? FINALLY an Apple supporter that admits it!

Sure thing Beavis. Having an open mind means I am an Apple supporter. :rolleyes:

Do you have a cite about their attempt at CDMA technology first? If that was their first choice, it wasn't the best one for reasons already given.
 

In that case they must have had both designs ready and let the negotiations decide it.

But you will have to look elsewhere for your "Apple supporter", because I never owned anything Apple in my life and have no interest in their computer line which is mainly like laptops without batteries, nor would I buy any smartphone because I think they are all a waste of money. I have a pay as you go cell that I spend about $100/year on.

The only thing that Apple does that interests me is the iPad, but I am still in wait an see mode. But then again, that is probably enough here. I didn't condemn everything Apple so I am a Steve Jobs RDF blinded kool aide drinker. :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top