'Hurt Locker' Sharers: Expect Docs Like This

Status
Not open for further replies.
Our argument isn't against the people that did it, at least I hope not. The argument is for people who didn't do this at all, and are probably wondering what the hell The Hurt Locker even is.
I know, but I've replied to a couple of howlers posted here like 50% of the identified IPs are innocent and people thinking of ways to deny it when it hasn't worked.

Of course if someone is innocent, they are going to have a problem on their hands and it may be very unfair if only in time spent defending themself. Should we let everyone out of prison because 3-4% are there for a crime they didn't commit?
 
You missed my point. Those defendants, once the appeals process is over, can file for bankruptcy.
Not all debts can be discharged through bankruptcy. :p You're wishing on a dream. Look up "nondischargeability" and get back to the thread later.
 
Not all debts can be discharged through bankruptcy. :p You're wishing on a dream. Look up "nondischargeability" and get back to the thread later.

From what I know of the law, civil judgments do not fall under this category. While debts and fines assessed from a criminal court cannot be dropped through bankruptcy, the majority of those from civil court can. I beleive Tenenbaum has already filed for bankruptcy form his ruling.
 
Fuck the RIAA and the MPAA, if I ever hit lottery Ill buy an island and Ill have such a huge pipe streaming shit out Exxon would be jealous. All in a country that doesnt recognize American law of course. :D

If they were anywhere NEAR the right pricing scheme on DVD/CD's wed be ok. But instead of the cost going down it went up when we went from VHS and Cassete tapes to DVD/CD. Theres no way it costs more money to press 1000 DVD's than to make 1000 VHS tapes.
 
As always, everyone's financial situation is unique, and it may be better to settle for $1,500 or $2,500. But, if you cannot afford that sum, which many can't, then most likely you will end up declaring bankruptcy, not paying $150,000 per violation.
My point is that you're going to end up paying money regardless.
Go to court and lose? It'll still cost you money long-term with creditors and whatnot.
Settle? $1500
Go to court and win? Still cost you money in legal fees.

My point being is that innocent people here are screwed regardless.

Should we let everyone out of prison because 3-4% are there for a crime they didn't commit?
Innocent until proven guilty, yes.

How'd you feel if you lived in a POS neighborhood with 90% drug lords living in it or something, and the Police just decided to bust everyone? Would you be willing to go to jail for the "greater cause"?

Even put yourself into these people's shoes. Say you get slammed for a notice about downloading "The Dance of the Butterflies" or some other frilly movie you not only would never see but have never heard of. "For the greater good", you'd be OK paying money????


Im sorry, but innocent people get screwed in this deal. Period. That's why this thing needs to be illegal. Fact of the matter is you can't tie packets of data to a physical person. They really have no hell the clue who downloaded that stuff, they're just taking shots in the dark with the ISP's records of what address happened to be assigned that IP at that particular time, and that the person paying the bill was the person that downloaded it.
 
This should make things interesting:

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/06/aclu-eff-seek-to-sever-gigantic-p2p-lawsuits.ars

The whole giant combined lawsuit is a joke and shouldn't be allowed. Even if someone did or didn't do something illegal, they shouldn't have to incur significant traveling costs to defend themselves. If my neighbor files a civil lawsuit accusing me of doing something in California, I shouldn't have to go to DC to defend myself. Luckily, there's a good amount of law to prevent this type of stuff already.
 
I usually don't like the ACLU but in this case, I do. Both the ACLU and EFF should be able to raise enough hell legally to at least make the judge look at dismissing all of these.
 
Although, the only problem with individualized cases is, IF THEY STILL GO THROUGH WITH IT, is the costs go up which means the settlement amounts probably will, to. However I'm not sure if you couldn't then just reference the current case and say "$1500 was fine then, why not now?"
 
I just checked PACER. They've filed a complaint but that is all. They have not submitted any sort of exhibit or evidence so do not expect to get any notices about this until they do so.
 
Although, the only problem with individualized cases is, IF THEY STILL GO THROUGH WITH IT, is the costs go up which means the settlement amounts probably will, to. However I'm not sure if you couldn't then just reference the current case and say "$1500 was fine then, why not now?"
Also the Jammie Thomas case capped the fine at $2250 per infringement. There's only one movie so I would think the court would not impose a fine over $2250.
 
I usually don't like the ACLU but in this case, I do. Both the ACLU and EFF should be able to raise enough hell legally to at least make the judge look at dismissing all of these.
Why and how? Seriously, I'm interested in the legal theory behind that.
 
Why and how? Seriously, I'm interested in the legal theory behind that.

if you read the article on arstechnica you would get all the legal theory you want Mr. Dunlap
 
if you read the article on arstechnica you would get all the legal theory you want Mr. Dunlap
LOL I was just reading it. Problem is that it didn't work several times in the past for these "does 1-x" consolidated suits. What was that saying about insanity again? :p

I think you're missing the point of these, and so are the people crying "extortion." The law firm is filing against those unknown persons, while getting ISPs to hand over customer details (to repeat the obvious: those individuals are being sued). The named federal lawsuits haven't happened yet, and like before, they will most likely be filed individually for the individuals who downloaded the individual moves they're being sued for. Or something.

Maybe they can wipe chicken blood on their doormats to keep away the process server. There's lots of good ideas coming out of here. Keep 'em coming so that "sharing" can continue and keep those $1 bills in your pocket. Geez, the unfairness... of getting caught.
 
I think you're missing the point of these, and so are the people crying "extortion." The law firm is filing against those unknown persons, while getting ISPs to hand over customer details (to repeat the obvious: those individuals are being sued). The named federal lawsuits haven't happened yet, and like before, they will most likely be filed individually for the individuals who downloaded the individual moves they're being sued for. Or something.
I don't think it's that simple, or ACLU and EFF wouldn't be partnering up to stop it. They wouldn't be getting together to stop something that'll never happen.
 
If I parked my car and accidentally left the keys in it and someone stole it and killed a pedestrian... would I be held liable? I'm actually being quite serious, because buying a router and not securing it accidentally is more or less the same.

I have to think the law would say locked or not, you're not supposed to steal a car, so one has to wonder why the same isn't true for unsecured routers...
 
LOL I was just reading it. Problem is that it didn't work several times in the past for these "does 1-x" consolidated suits. What was that saying about insanity again? :p

I think you're missing the point of these, and so are the people crying "extortion." The law firm is filing against those unknown persons, while getting ISPs to hand over customer details (to repeat the obvious: those individuals are being sued). The named federal lawsuits haven't happened yet, and like before, they will most likely be filed individually for the individuals who downloaded the individual moves they're being sued for. Or something.

Maybe they can wipe chicken blood on their doormats to keep away the process server. There's lots of good ideas coming out of here. Keep 'em coming so that "sharing" can continue and keep those $1 bills in your pocket. Geez, the unfairness... of getting caught.

You're missing the point that they're trying to save "$1 bills" in their pockets too. Despite having the IP addresses and could very easily trace route the IP address to the applicable district the defendant is in they'd rather put the burden of defense and travel on the defendant by filing this lawsuits in one district. They're also combining these lawsuits into one giant lawsuit to save the $350 filling fee and the paperwork that goes with it. They're making the ISPs do thousands of lookups and not offering to compensate them the least bit.

So before you mock file sharers for trying to save "$1 bills" you should really look at the other side. Corporations and businesses will do anything to save money, from destroying the environment to poisoning people.

The documents filed from TWC and the EFF/ACLU team have a very good chance of succeeding. Coupled with the fact that there is already precedents that limit the amount of damages to $2250 per infringement and the fact that it will be hard to get statutory damages because they're suing everyone it's looking like it's going to be harder and harder for them to make those sweet sweet $1 bills.
 
Geez, the unfairness... of getting caught.
It's not the unfairness of getting caught; it's the unfairness of the punishment, which outside of settling, would financially devastate almost every single person.

The legal system should have a fairly dealing with these individuals, without relying on "charitability" of the copyright holders in settlement.
 
if you ignore the letters do they have to pay somebody to come and physically serve it to you?
 
I wonder what would happen if they asked "show us proof of purchase of a BluRay and we'll call it good and not end up in court", but that sounds like blackmail too much.

if you ignore the letters do they have to pay somebody to come and physically serve it to you?
Not if they end up sending one certified mail.
 
What's with the title "'Hurt Locker' Sharers: Expect Docs Like This" ??

It's not sharing were talking about, it's piracy ...
 
Maybe trackers/clients should implement some kind of spoofing as part of the protocol. (Double traffic, send a copy to a fake IP for every real IP or something. Or maybe some kind of unlogged NAT?) It would be noisy as hell, generate a ton of excess traffic and guarantee some plausible deniability. Also, anyone sending out blanket IP blackmail would be guaranteed to hit innocent victims. Which would certainly be extortion for the 50% of innocent IP's and cost a hell of a lot more than 1,500$ per IP for the countersuits.

As soon as someone implements a tracker like that, then woulnd't the burdon of proof be on the MPAA to prove it's not a spoofing tracker? I'm not for pirating movies (I don't do it), but I am for privacy and secure communication. Especially because I think 1,500$ for watching a 1-5$ movie is excessive and the laws have become abusive, so I take a F the man stance in general now.

What the hell is this? Since when does this forum allow this kind of discussion ideas of how to "improve," the piracy process. I thought piracy was a banned subject here, and yet it's being discussed in this thread ideas and methods for piracy ?
 
What the hell is this? Since when does this forum allow this kind of discussion ideas of how to "improve," the piracy process. I thought piracy was a banned subject here, and yet it's being discussed in this thread ideas and methods for piracy ?

Anyone using a torrent is a pirate? I don't see anything wrong with talking about how to make bittorrent more anonymous.
 
...
Anyone who knows their wifi is unprotected knows full well the implications of having it that way.
...

I do agree with your primary intent and point, that they are and should be responsible, however, this one point you made is completely false. How the heck can you expect the typical person, let alone the older, more tech-naive, who might seriously not even understand the basic concepts behind wireless communication, let alone the details of security, authentication, encryption, etc etc...


Sorry about the multiple replies, wasn't expecting to see so much to reply to here. No worries, I am seriously saddened by what I've read so far here that I don't want to read any more... :(
 
Anyone using a torrent is a pirate? I don't see anything wrong with talking about how to make bittorrent more anonymous.

Right. Don't buy that one. Are you honestly saying his point was purely about making bittorrent "as anonymous as possible," for completely legal reasons and uses, in a thread that is about piracy, when talking about something of which 98.5% of data transfers is for piracy?

If so, why on earth are you so concerned about making your legitimate bittorrent transfers as anonymous as possible? Bittorrent, by its very nature is extremely public and NOT anonymous. Use email, usenet, FTP, HTTP, flash drives, mailed CD's, LAN's, skype, pigeons to transfer your legitimate and legal data that needs to be private, because if you are using bittorrent to transfer somthing sensitive, then you are quite foolish and no smarter then someone who leaves their WiFi router un-encrypted and unprotected.
 
Right. Don't buy that one. Are you honestly saying his point was purely about making bittorrent "as anonymous as possible," for completely legal reasons and uses, in a thread that is about piracy, when talking about something of which 98.5% of data transfers is for piracy?
I didn't say that, don't put words into my mouth. I don't know him personally or his intentions. Pretty sure you don't either.

If so, why on earth are you so concerned about making your legitimate bittorrent transfers as anonymous as possible?
Once again I never said I was overly concerned about it, but I wouldn't mind if all trackers had some functionality of obfuscating the IP's somehow.

Bittorrent, by its very nature is extremely public and NOT anonymous. Use email, usenet, FTP, HTTP, flash drives, mailed CD's, LAN's, skype, pigeons to transfer your legitimate and legal data that needs to be private,
No kidding, desiring it to be a bit more anonymous shouldn't automatically make you an evil pirate.
because if you are using bittorrent to transfer somthing sensitive, then you are quite foolish and no smarter then someone who leaves their WiFi router un-encrypted and unprotected.
Big difference between transferring sensitive data and not broadcasting your IP for anyone else to see. Anyone that's played WOW has most likely connected to blizzards trackers and given out their IP address to many others including Chinese farmers and account hackers. But hey, wanting to be more anonymous makes you a criminal I guess.
 
I didn't say that, don't put words into my mouth. I don't know him personally or his intentions. Pretty sure you don't either.

Actually, I think I do. Talking about "improving," bittorrent anonymity in a thread about piracy and content owners getting IP information about people using bittorrent, largely a piracy platform, to pirate their content. That's pretty compelling, and nothing is 100% of course. I've seen judgements made with much less evidence. :p

Once again I never said I was overly concerned about it, but I wouldn't mind if all trackers had some functionality of obfuscating the IP's somehow.

No, you didn't but you were defending one who was, so that's why I snapped I guess. I am sorry about that.

No kidding, desiring it to be a bit more anonymous shouldn't automatically make you an evil pirate.

Yes, I agree! Hell no it doesn't. We deserve the right to anonymity in most reasonable situations, It's a human right, IMO. Definitely. But talking about improving anonymity on a platform which is inherently by its very nature not anonymous, which also happens to be composed mostly of piracy, in a thread about piracy. C'mon now. Seriously? That's all I'm sayin'.

Big difference between transferring sensitive data and not broadcasting your IP for anyone else to see. Anyone that's played WOW has most likely connected to blizzards trackers and given out their IP address to many others including Chinese farmers and account hackers. But hey, wanting to be more anonymous makes you a criminal I guess.

I don't follow a point here.
 
Yes, I agree! Hell no it doesn't. We deserve the right to anonymity in most reasonable situations, It's a human right, IMO. Definitely. But talking about improving anonymity on a platform which is inherently by its very nature not anonymous, which also happens to be composed mostly of piracy, in a thread about piracy. C'mon now. Seriously? That's all I'm sayin'.

This is a message board for discussion, and threads go off topic or on tangents all the time. Whether it's a thread that started about piracy or not, talking about being more anonymous online shouldn't be considered a violation of rules. If you feel that being anonymous is a right, why should talking about it be breaking the rules and why do you feel compelled to complain about someone wanting to do so? Obviously that's up to the mods/admins to enforce the rules, and I'll still post here either way they decide but it seems pretty nit-picky to call a post out for a supposed rule violation in this case.

Why do I care so much and felt like arguing about it? I have no idea, but it's Friday and work is slow.
 
If so, why on earth are you so concerned about making your legitimate bittorrent transfers as anonymous as possible?

I guess since I'm not doing anything illegal on my laptop, I shouldn't be using TrueCrypt?
Or since legit businesses aren't doing anything illegal they shouldn't care about encryption?

You do have a point about BT being by nature public, however.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top