Google Balks at Turning Over Data to Regulators

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Wait, how do you cite privacy laws when refusing to turn over data you secretly collected?

“As granting access to payload data creates legal challenges in Germany, which we need to review, we are continuing to discuss the appropriate legal and logistical process for making the data available,” Peter Barron, a Google spokesman in London, said, in a statement. “We hope, given more time, to be able to resolve this difficult issue.”
 
when you accedentaly take info, why would you turn it over when all you have to do is destroy it. but you would need some kind of police oversight to confirm all the data is deleted. you can just walk into a government office and drop down a whoel shitload of hard drives. what if the government just wants to go through the data for thier own reasons? You have no idea what the intention why they want the data "released".


right now google cant even destroying because it might be classified as destroying evidence.

its pretty tricky actually.
 
when you accedentaly take info, why would you turn it over when all you have to do is destroy it. but you would need some kind of police oversight to confirm all the data is deleted. you can just walk into a government office and drop down a whoel shitload of hard drives. what if the government just wants to go through the data for thier own reasons? You have no idea what the intention why they want the data "released".


right now google cant even destroying because it might be classified as destroying evidence.

its pretty tricky actually.

probably what is more pertinent is did google actually do anything wrong?

if your wifi is open, what is the legality of connecting to it?

until the courts decide whether what google did was wrong. eg. by deteriming that connected to an open wifi without persmission is illegal, i doubt google will turn over anything.


infact in florida (not sure about other states)

it is legal to

to intercept or access an electronic
communication made through an electronic communication system
that is configured so that such electronic communication is
readily accessible to the general public;
 
Whether what Google did, and whether they did it in secret or not is irrelevant. The fact is that they now have a collection of data that may contain private information they aren't legally allowed to disclose. Hence this issue; giving that data out to anyone is possibly disclosing details that Google collected legally, but is not allowed to redistribute. Even if they collected the information illegally (which I find highly unlikely given plenty of precedent and common sense concerning radio transmissions).

It's a bit of a 'damned if you do, damned if you don't' situation where not disclosing the details leaves Google open to at least public opinion attack, while disclosing it opens them to legal liability and possible privacy law violations. Personally, since I don't find anything illegal about their collection of this data, intentional or otherwise, I think they're doing the right thing here.
 
probably what is more pertinent is did google actually do anything wrong?

if your wifi is open, what is the legality of connecting to it?

until the courts decide whether what google did was wrong. eg. by deteriming that connected to an open wifi without persmission is illegal, i doubt google will turn over anything.


infact in florida (not sure about other states)

it is legal to

it is legal to intercept or access an electronic
communication made through an electronic communication system
that is configured so that such electronic communication is
readily accessible to the general public;

Really, well, go record a cell phone conversation and release it to the public. You might find that that act is not so legal. The companies who make police band scanners took those frequencies off their gear a long time ago because they ended up in court, even in Florida.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_tapping

It is a Federal violation.

On the other hand if you are the Fed you can do pretty much as you please; See Patriot Act. Prior to that Gov. Wire Taping started back in the 1890s.
 
The German government needs to present Google with at least four or five choices for companies not tied to the German government to analyze, and confirm destruction of, the data, on Google's dime. Google will pay dearly, in cash, because the time of people with secret clearances who are employed in the private sector is EXPENSIVE.

Google should NOT hand this data over to the government. They also cannot destroy it, because that would absolutely be destroying evidence.
 
Really, well, go record a cell phone conversation and release it to the public. You might find that that act is not so legal. The companies who make police band scanners took those frequencies off their gear a long time ago because they ended up in court, even in Florida.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telephone_tapping

It is a Federal violation.

On the other hand if you are the Fed you can do pretty much as you please; See Patriot Act. Prior to that Gov. Wire Taping started back in the 1890s.

well, your talking about a cellular conversation, which would require decrypting the GSM/CDMA signal... which in itself would be illegal, technically capturing the radio signal itself would not be illegal, just useless
 
There were some judgements way back when cellular was new that restricted this in the US (and only in the US, as far as I can tell), making the no-wiretapping regulation stronger than the common sense of standard radio regulation. However this was specific to cellular telephone calls, and based on the fact that wiretapping is illegal. It's hard to say how US courts would interpret these judgements in the context of open WiFi.

My personal opinion is that this US precedent was a mistake and goes against common sense. Most other countries apparently agree As a radio receiver, you should not be expected to obtain some kind of permission or license to tune your radio to a particular frequency and listen to what's there, that's just absurd.
 
http://cybernetnews.com/helpful-tip-is-it-illegal-to-use-someone-elses-wifi/

"While many of you may see no harm in using someone else’s WiFi Internet over an unsecured network, it is in fact illegal! Even further, you could get arrested and fined for it!"

"How’d you like to get arrested for stealing Wi-Fi? As odd as that sounds, it happens. One perfect example of this came out of St. Petersburg Florida in July of 2005. A man was arrested on charges of “unauthorized access to a computer network,” which is a third-degree felony. This guy actually made the act obvious though, after he pulled his SUV into a stranger’s driveway and sat there with his laptop visible. The homeowner noticed this and called the police."

I'm not saying I agree, just pointing out that using someone else's wifi can get you in big trouble.
 
Another:

http://compnetworking.about.com/gi/...s/2007/052307-fine-using-free-wifi.html?t51hb

A Michigan man has been fined $400 and must work 40 hours of community service for using a local café’s Wi-Fi connection from his parked car to check his e-mail and surf the Web.

He got off easy, according to the local TV station that reported the case: under Michigan computer access law, using a Wi-Fi connection without authorization is a felony, punishable by as much a $10,000 fine and five years in prison.
 
You're talking about using a wifi connection, which requires connecting to the AP and making use of it. Google just listened to unencrypted data wifi devices were broadcasting out into the world. No ones router is going to show Google's van connecting and doing anything, the van didn't send anything out, it just listened.

Also for the most part police scanners are not illegal, varies slightly with where you are. Most often it is illegal to have one in your car, though.
 
I am really curious about the kind of data they collected. There needs to be an independent third-party audit of this data, to report what kind of data was collected, to let people know what was collected and determine if Google stepped across any legal boundaries. Then the data needs to be destroyed. If I was Google, I would be publicly offering this as a solution and criticize any government that didn't except this.
 
This is an excellent chance for Goog to quell fears about its information retention and privacy practices. They didn't want to be in this position, but if any company has the ability to fight this it's them. The government has no business getting its hands on that data.
 
Back
Top