Undercover Report From Foxconn's Hell Factory

I don't know though if one of the comments in the original page is right, but it is obvious that this is only pertaining to the specific factory of Foxconn in Shenzen. Although I understand that it is their largest, but the Apple products being manufactured there is the one being highlighted. An "undercover" operation in a different Foxconn factory (there are other "circles" in the "Foxconn Global distribution map" within China) which makes non-Apple products would make things more clear.
 
It doesn't sound as bad as I thought. Same as any factory worker, except less breaks, less days off, and you live in whatever their dorm is. Which of course is the Asian style of doing things. Futon on the floor and the squat toilets.

Also the thing about the futon on the floor being a waste of space, it actually frees up a lot of space. You will fold the futon up and put it away in a small closet during the day.

futon-ready-for-bed.jpg


I've been in hotels that use them.
 
Everyone seems to be thinking that they only work 8 hrs a day... they don't. They work 8 hours then stop for lunch, then work 8 hours more. If you follow the links to the original chinese articles, you'll find that the 8 hour periods are divided into the first 8 hour work period and the second 8 hour work period.

So working at least 16 hours a day, barely knowing anyone you work with, not socializing with them, only stopping to eat or sleep, every day of the week (save holidays)? That is much worse than any employer would be allowed in the U.S.

Articles like these make you not want to purchase anything made in China at all. :(
 
Foxconn workers only smile on the 10th of every month. That's the day when they get their salaries. That day, the ATM machines inside the factory are crowded with workers. Their monthly salaries start at 900 Chinese Yuan—about $130.

Most of the workers had nothing to say about the popular Apple products they assemble. Most can't afford to own an Apple product. Their salaries can only buy them knockoff versions. While gadget aficionados worldwide discuss which iPhone they should buy, Foxconn workers debate the merits of differing knockoffs.

While I'm not gonna say I'll never buy another foxconn product, I'll never complain about chinese knock-offs again. Poor fucking bastards.

At least the link to apple has been made clear. I hope somebody gets up their ass about this. Bring the jobs back here jobs you cheap fuck.
 
Wow, just wow. You really cannot read and comprehend a damn can you?

Actually, it's you who can't. According to this the average salary of manufacturing (that's an average of somewhere around 10 years experience) is 134$ an hour. Foxconn pay starts at 130$/hr with no experience and goes up from there. It's one of the better paying jobs in china, people are there because of that. No one forces them to work there.
 
Actually, it's you who can't. According to this the average salary of manufacturing (that's an average of somewhere around 10 years experience) is 134$ an hour. Foxconn pay starts at 130$/hr with no experience and goes up from there. It's one of the better paying jobs in china, people are there because of that. No one forces them to work there.

Vengence that link says a month man, not hour.
 
The USA had muckraking about Chicago meat factories, steel factories, and other early 20th century industrial working conditions. China is starting to do the same and the same workplace changes will eventually take place there. It was inevitable, the government can only crack down so hard without things blowing back up in their face.

One thought I had when reading someone's comment that 'It's not so bad that they can't afford what they make/they just buy Chinese branded knockoffs' is the idea Henry Ford had when setting up his factories and wages was that he wanted the workers to be able to afford the products they made. (other things he did bad aside) In that case it was to ensure some demand in a market that wasn't clear and developed, the difference here is that the Apple stuff is sold to different markets where they are affordable. China of course wants domestic consumer demand which is what the 'knockoffs' are for so the market and sales are a little more complicated than during the early 20th century. Apple's crazy margins (for an end-user hardware company) also don't help.
 
Actually, it's you who can't. According to this the average salary of manufacturing (that's an average of somewhere around 10 years experience) is 134$ an hour. Foxconn pay starts at 130$/hr with no experience and goes up from there. It's one of the better paying jobs in china, people are there because of that. No one forces them to work there.

If you look carefully, it says "monthly" not "hourly." Even witht he exchange rate and all, that's equivalent to a 16 year old's total paycheck for a day maybe 2 days of working at McDonalds flipping burgers. Like I said, I also considered in the exchange rate here. So in other words, I would hate to work in China if this is the type of wages they implore...
 
Actually, it's you who can't. According to this the average salary of manufacturing (that's an average of somewhere around 10 years experience) is 134$ an hour. Foxconn pay starts at 130$/hr with no experience and goes up from there. It's one of the better paying jobs in china, people are there because of that. No one forces them to work there.

I hope you meant a month.
 
The USA had muckraking about Chicago meat factories, steel factories, and other early 20th century industrial working conditions. China is starting to do the same and the same workplace changes will eventually take place there. It was inevitable, the government can only crack down so hard without things blowing back up in their face.

One thought I had when reading someone's comment that 'It's not so bad that they can't afford what they make/they just buy Chinese branded knockoffs' is the idea Henry Ford had when setting up his factories and wages was that he wanted the workers to be able to afford the products they made. (other things he did bad aside) In that case it was to ensure some demand in a market that wasn't clear and developed, the difference here is that the Apple stuff is sold to different markets where they are affordable. China of course wants domestic consumer demand which is what the 'knockoffs' are for so the market and sales are a little more complicated than during the early 20th century. Apple's crazy margins (for an end-user hardware company) also don't help.

This isn't the same as america because america was primary making products for themselves where china is making products for us. We as american are dependent on their cheap labor to keep status quo. Thus american business will do everything in there power to keep china labor as is.
 
So workers work standing for 8 hours. How is that different from the local mickey d's or burger king?

At Foxconn you actually have to work. At McDs or Burger King you just get high out back by the garbage cans and then screw up my god damn orders.
 
If you look carefully, it says "monthly" not "hourly." Even witht he exchange rate and all, that's equivalent to a 16 year old's total paycheck for a day maybe 2 days of working at McDonalds flipping burgers. Like I said, I also considered in the exchange rate here. So in other words, I would hate to work in China if this is the type of wages they implore...

Gotta remember the difference in wages.

Average salary for a baker is $70. That's without room and board. Course, I'm sure the baker isn't working near 16 hours a day. Salary rate goes up as you start moving into the city, cause cost of living goes up.

As time is going on, wages are going up though. Mostly due to lack of workers. The whole "one child" policy in effect. Less kids, less new workers.
 
He made a typo, people, geezus get over it. :)

Pretty much. Both links (OP and my link), both say per month.

The end result is you can work at foxxcon pays much better than average. It's a shame more people can't get past sensationalism.
 
You get no sympathy from me, sorry.

If you don't like a job, you're always free to get up and walk out, consequences be damned.

They have the same choice as I did, so again, where is my article?
 
If any of this is shocking, then one should look up Chinese labor. There are factories much worse than that and they manufacture everything.

2 billion people gotta do something.
 
That's my biggest question. Everyone here seems to be assuming things. Do they choose to work here or are they forced to? Can they quit? Is there any realistic alternative for them?

Maybe the original article had some more facts, but I don't read Chinese.

Sure, this sounds bad, as long as you make certain assumptions. Are there only 38,000 workers sequestered for Apple products? Are they where the suicides came from?

I think this is sensationalism. Maybe just enough to ask questions. But since I do not speak Chinese, I am not likely to get any answers.
 
Actually, it's you who can't. According to this the average salary of manufacturing (that's an average of somewhere around 10 years experience) is 134$ an hour. Foxconn pay starts at 130$/hr with no experience and goes up from there. It's one of the better paying jobs in china, people are there because of that. No one forces them to work there.

No. You imagined things that I just didn't say. Your first paragraph made no linkable sense, and your last, well, I said nothing about forced slave labour.

One thing I hope we can both agree on though, putting aside that my original thoughts were on giving them better conditions, (because you know, the demoralising thing), is that it is China, and there is no real point in trying to fit their wages into our western molds. I notice you sort of said that in your other post about sensationalism, yes, people like to immediately try and fit their "wealthy" situations to these without realising culture difference, it gets news readers afterall. ;)
 
Why is it so surprising that the conditions reported could exist in China? Their reputation has never exactly been glowing in the area of human rights,after all. Or has everyone already forgotten Tiananmen Square?
 
Look in your closet and count how many pieces of clothing you have that were made in the USA or some other developed nation. Are some people seriously just starting to notice the shady employment practices in the world?

What got me was the "voluntary" overtime agreement/waiver they had to sign. Nowhere in that article is there a statement of how many hours they actually work, but I'd have to guess at least 12.
 
No. You imagined things that I just didn't say. Your first paragraph made no linkable sense, and your last, well, I said nothing about forced slave labour.

One thing I hope we can both agree on though, putting aside that my original thoughts were on giving them better conditions, (because you know, the demoralising thing), is that it is China, and there is no real point in trying to fit their wages into our western molds. I notice you sort of said that in your other post about sensationalism, yes, people like to immediately try and fit their "wealthy" situations to these without realising culture difference, it gets news readers afterall. ;)

You are correct. Even if you convert Chinese wages to US dollars you do not have an accurate representation of the purchasing power for a single RMB. I am astonished on how little money/month a Chinese family can not only survive but also dump some cash into savings. I make several times above what a Chinese teacher earns and even their wages, while not high, are livable.

The factory workers do make sacrifices, there is no question of that, but their earnings are far and above what they can get elsewhere (with overtime) with little to no education. Put it this way, in China there are stores that have women or men standing outside and clapping all day long in order to help drum up business. Sound like a fun job? No, it isn't. When your alternatives are things like clapping all day or working at a factory that pays overtime or working on a farm for significantly less money and harder work....the choice becomes obvious.

The culture difference is monstrous. I struggle with it daily. The Chinese simply do not look at anything from the same angle we do. I am not going to say one way is right and another is wrong, it is just different.

'Give them better working conditions' sounds great and the bleeding hearts can pat themselves on the back but for every suicide and every complaint about the factory there are a thousand or so people lining up for the same jobs. How many companies in your native countries go about spending money and time to make employees happier while potentially decreasing productivity when there are boatloads of others fighting for an open position. Pretty much none I imagine.
 
It doesn't sound as bad as I thought. Same as any factory worker, except less breaks, less days off, and you live in whatever their dorm is. Which of course is the Asian style of doing things. Futon on the floor and the squat toilets.

Also the thing about the futon on the floor being a waste of space, it actually frees up a lot of space. You will fold the futon up and put it away in a small closet during the day.

futon-ready-for-bed.jpg


I've been in hotels that use them.

Not necessarily "Asian style" but most probably "Chinese style". Large factories with their own dormitories are quite rare over here in the Philippines. Workers usually use public transportation (jeepneys most of the time) to get there. The ones who have their own "lodgings" are usually the small factories manufacturing "imitation" products.
 
This is the nth time I read about these facilities and the horrific treatment of their workers.

The worst thing is that it is nearly impossible to be an ethical consumer these days. The intricacies of the global value chain are totally opaque. There is no way of knowing exactly what you support through your purchase in many cases.

Another company to add to the list of my personally boycott companies... sigh
 
That's my biggest question. Everyone here seems to be assuming things. Do they choose to work here or are they forced to? Can they quit? Is there any realistic alternative for them?

Maybe the original article had some more facts, but I don't read Chinese.

Sure, this sounds bad, as long as you make certain assumptions. Are there only 38,000 workers sequestered for Apple products? Are they where the suicides came from?

I think this is sensationalism. Maybe just enough to ask questions. But since I do not speak Chinese, I am not likely to get any answers.


It is easy. You work and get paid or you are taken care of by your family. Since the latter does not happen much you need to work and everyone in China is working and the conditions are the same for the workers in every factory.

This has been going on for a good decade now, no one gives a damn as long as they can get cheap products.

Try find toys of your kids that haven't stamped made in China on it. Goodluck.
 
By the way, $130 a month salary should be considered "real high", salaries hovering around $13 a month in "servant world" environments are more the norm in China.

I try not to buy anything Chinese, but its almost impossible. I do support Lian Li though, and as far as I know there is no problem with their methods..to my knowledge.
 
Not necessarily "Asian style" but most probably "Chinese style". Large factories with their own dormitories are quite rare over here in the Philippines. Workers usually use public transportation (jeepneys most of the time) to get there. The ones who have their own "lodgings" are usually the small factories manufacturing "imitation" products.

Oh no, I didn't mean the factory is Asian style. Just the futon on the ground. Chinese, Koreans, Japanese, and probably other Asian races do the futon on the ground. I'm Laotian and even we do it.
 
Lian-Li is a Taiwanese company are they not?

Their URL is .tw so I'm gonna assume yes. What technologies they use to produce their product, is unknown.

Regardless. China will be voted the United Nations civil liberties and civil rights department with the path they are taking.

I mean we have Iran now heading up the Woman's rights division. Who can argue with that, if you're raped as a woman, you get a stoning in the center of town, that is if you don't already have your labia cut off because enjoyment is secondary to tradition.

Yet the U.S. is bad guy according to so many scumbag journalists and pieces of shit inside our borders. I hear there's openings @ Foxconn in ...3...2...1 (suicide bell ding) there ya go, lets ship some L.A. Times reporters over there for an in depth coverage piece shall we? :)

Foxconn used to have more of a prescence in the PC Market here than it does now, at least you used to be able to buy Foxconn boards relatively often. A quick search on Newegg reveals that Foxconn is apparently doing just fine for AMD and Intel motherboard manufacturing both, along with chassis, and memory card readers.

So if we're so concerned about the health of its workers, why are U.S. companies selling their products? In the end, we aren't concerned. You'll go to work today just like I will, more of them might suffer, die, or commit suicide. In the end, its not an issue, as long as we get cheap HDTV's and iPhones, thats all that matters in the end. Its just a life, they'll produce more people to replace those, and they'll keep churning out products at rates impossible for you and I to compete with, till eventually, there is only 1 source of manufacturing left in the world.

But who am I to sound so Doomsday like
 
It is easy. You work and get paid or you are taken care of by your family. Since the latter does not happen much you need to work and everyone in China is working and the conditions are the same for the workers in every factory.

This has been going on for a good decade now, no one gives a damn as long as they can get cheap products.

Try find toys of your kids that haven't stamped made in China on it. Goodluck.

Funny you mention that sticker. We have a GSA contract at our company. According to the contract government funds are to go to made in USA product or certain other countries GSA has approved. They are not allowed to use funds to buy anything from China.

But guess what........... guess who makes %99 of the product we need to assemble the product that they requested........ or to even come close to the price cap they have budgeted. I work at an awards company. I mean there is not jack shit we get from out distributors that is not made in China. And when it is USA made it is typically 3 times higher....... but since everyone wants it at cheap as possible what choice do they have.
Hell even our wood manufacture who used to make solid american walnut boards for us...... now they try to sell us these cheap ass knock off China made prefab boards. Man they look real as shit....... 1/3 of the cost too.
 
so yea its their choice to work there and i hate supporting it, but i dont buy much apple stuff besides ipods anyways...
 
It doesn't sound as bad as I thought. Same as any factory worker, except less breaks, less days off, and you live in whatever their dorm is. Which of course is the Asian style of doing things. Futon on the floor and the squat toilets.

Also the thing about the futon on the floor being a waste of space, it actually frees up a lot of space. You will fold the futon up and put it away in a small closet during the day.

futon-ready-for-bed.jpg


I've been in hotels that use them.

Dormitory to me means packing as many people into a given amount of space as possible. That pic is not a dormitory. Too much wasted space, Futons? Hello bunkbeds. Hello stacking 3 or 4 high in a tier. Still think futons save space? Try again. The living space available is a non issue plus the Chinese are far more comfortable being close to other people than many in the west. Walk the streets anywhere in China or ride a bus, proximity is a non issue. Personal space is a western concept, let me assure you it's not something understood by many Chinese.
 
These people make a choice to live/work there. If they are not happy they can go farm in the country with their parents. Cry me a river. 60 years ago the US had steel workers who were 30 stories up with no safety ropes.
 
Back
Top