Undercover Report From Foxconn's Hell Factory

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A reporter went undercover at Foxconn for a month to find out what is behind the recent rash of suicides. Obviously things aren’t too bad…the reporter came back alive.

Chinese newspaper Southern Weekly sent 20-year-old reporter Liu Zhi Yi undercover in Foxconn's factory in Shenzhen, China. For 28 days, he experienced dreadful conditions that the factory's 400,000 employees endure, churning out iPods, iPads, and iPhones for Apple nonstop.
 
The sad thing is that if Foxconn shapes up and starts being humane, their prices will likely be undercut by someone worse.
 
The article makes it sound like all they do is work, but then it says: "Workers spend achingly up to eight hours standing up"

Is that 8 hour shifts, or maybe how long they go til lunch break? Either that article blows or it just doesn't sound that bad.
 
If you have any military experience, probably using the Navy as the best example, imagine yourself stationed on a ship, say a carrier, with 5,000+ other people working with you inside that "floating city" 24/7...

Now imagine that same type of situation but with 300,000 other people all working inside the same facility which is effectively closed off 24/7 (meaning it ain't got a big retractable roof, probably not the greatest ventilation system, everybody eats, drinks, sleeps inside the place - in housing, of course - etc).

We here in the US simply have absolutely nothing to compare such a job with, we'd never allow such facilities to exist for a huge variety of reasons.

I can't even imagine what it must be like "working" in such a place...
 
the article is not as juicy as we wanted...

what is bullshit is apple supporting this bullshit and their emo customers as well.

as a liberal, at least republicans will admit "i dont care". when i was in college, all the hipsters/hippies/yippies and "save the world types" all had ipods lol.. made in sweatshops. then 200$ outfits made in sweatshops. they are a joke.
 
I bust my ass for 9.5 hour a day with only 30 mins for lunch. Where's my article?

And should I feel bad for having a Foxconn mobo?
 
so people that buy apple products really are evil... or at least supporting slave labour
 
So workers work standing for 8 hours. How is that different from the local mickey d's or burger king?
 
So thats the source of apples products allure.

The souls of the works assembling them are sacrificed in the process.

j/k :p
 
so people that buy apple products really are evil... or at least supporting slave labour

What the heck is with this Apple/Foxconn/Evil trio that everyone in the news has been harping lately?

Foxconn is huge. They are everywhere, they don't just make Apple devices. They contribute in one way or another with just about every electronic device on the planet. You simply cannot buy a gadget that doesn't have at least one part from Foxconn in it.

Don't believe me? Take a magnifying glass and go look at your motherboard. I guarantee you will find at least one Foxconn logo stamped on it somewhere.
 
Yeah uhm... At the restaurant I helped open, some days I'd start my shift at 10am, and finish at 3am... With no definite lunch period, and breaks whenever customers stopped ordering food. That and, for the majority of your (average) 10hr shift, you're standing over a blazing hot kitchen stove, or cutting your hands with knives, or accidently grabbing the searing hot pan set beside the cold pan by accident, all while trying to cook 4 orders of pasta, 2-3 steaks and while yelling at the stoned, 15 year old dish washer to bring you searing hot plates.

I want an article too.
 
/insensitive bastard

Am I the only one that would have paid more for an iPhone if there was proof that it was the last iPhone some poor worker assembled before taking their own life?
 
There's a bit of a pickle though, if they didn't have this factory, there would be that many people unemployed, and with almost half a million people, it has to be something said for any alternatives.

But when you look at their wages, damn. Just one device they assemble each out of countless many is their monthly wage. They can afford easily to pay workers more, or to provide better conditions in the ways of gyms, rec, etc, and keep the device prices the same, as with Apple, they make super profits each device. Hell, even if they went up $20 each to allow workers more rest periods, noone would really care as Apple devices cost so freaking much anyway, whats another $20?

Then you also have to take into consideration, it is china. Their people are bred to work and make the rich richer, and working in these places is about as good as it gets for them. That's communism for ya. No wonder they want to immigrate. Blame goes back far into Chinas history, and to today from exploiters such as Apple.

But back to that pickle, if they didn't manufacture there and employ so many people, they'd be manufacturing in Vietnam instead.
 
I had a job for a short time that required me to work 13-15 days in a row and do 12-16hr shifts. Physical work crawling in attics, running cabling, that kinda stuff. If you couldn't do it you got fired, I quit. I don't live in China and won't contribute to employers that treat workers like that.
 
Every time you unlock your iDevice, Jobs kills a Foxconn worker.
 
There's a bit of a pickle though, if they didn't have this factory, there would be that many people unemployed, and with almost half a million people, it has to be something said for any alternatives.

But when you look at their wages, damn. Just one device they assemble each out of countless many is their monthly wage. They can afford easily to pay workers more, or to provide better conditions in the ways of gyms, rec, etc, and keep the device prices the same, as with Apple, they make super profits each device. Hell, even if they went up $20 each to allow workers more rest periods, noone would really care as Apple devices cost so freaking much anyway, whats another $20?

Then you also have to take into consideration, it is china. Their people are bred to work and make the rich richer, and working in these places is about as good as it gets for them. That's communism for ya. No wonder they want to immigrate. Blame goes back far into Chinas history, and to today from exploiters such as Apple.

But back to that pickle, if they didn't manufacture there and employ so many people, they'd be manufacturing in Vietnam instead.

It's china, they are already paying them great wages for china. If someone asked you to work in these conditions for 250,000$ a year would you do it? We'll assume the device you are building costs a million dollars. I'd say damn my engineering degree and sign up in a heartbeat, and you're lying to your self if you say you wouldn't do the same. But now you are saying that because in countrythatdoesnotactuallyexist people are use to getting paid 10,000,000$ a year, they should not offer for you to get paid 250,000$ a year?

It's not slave labor. If you can send an under cover worker in, have them work, and then have them leave of their own accord then anyone in that factory could walk out just the same. They don't leave because it's great money for the part of the world they live in.
 
I was really hoping for stories of public whippings or something. Sounds like a laborious job, but not one that I'd classify as brutally inhumane. Standing 8 hours a day? The humanity.
 
The day before I turned 18 I left for a job with Disney On Ice, and all I can say is 8 hours a day standing? I worked 20 hours a day, 140 hours a week, I was a seat vendor, most days we had 2-3 shows, I spent 9 hours out of the day carrying a 75lb bag of show lights up and down stairs, the rest of the time I was walking or standing behind my stand selling crap, and if I was not doing that I had stock call where I had to help unload several rigs of new stock. We got no days off and worked through holidays, I got the flu and was told I still needed to work, I ended up passing out on the concourse with a 104 temp, I was then allowed to go back to my hotel room for a whole 2 days, after which I would be let go if I was not back. I was young and stupid back then, they get away with things like that because we were "contract" and "self employed".

Where is my article?
 
I'm sure its a hell of a lot easier then the sustenance farming their parents and still the vast majority of Chinese have to do.
 
Some of the posts here are disgusting. I just heard two guys doing nerd talk. It is basically reduced to who's got the biggest hardware or who knows more about computers, obviously Mac was praised over and over again. Great way to cover insecurities. To think I just to be one of those. Not anymore!!!

Thank you.
To some of you, don't complain later when you can't find quality women.
 
The day before I turned 18 I left for a job with Disney On Ice, and all I can say is 8 hours a day standing? I worked 20 hours a day, 140 hours a week, I was a seat vendor, most days we had 2-3 shows, I spent 9 hours out of the day carrying a 75lb bag of show lights up and down stairs, the rest of the time I was walking or standing behind my stand selling crap, and if I was not doing that I had stock call where I had to help unload several rigs of new stock. We got no days off and worked through holidays, I got the flu and was told I still needed to work, I ended up passing out on the concourse with a 104 temp, I was then allowed to go back to my hotel room for a whole 2 days, after which I would be let go if I was not back. I was young and stupid back then, they get away with things like that because we were "contract" and "self employed".

Where is my article?

What choice did you made? You had a blotload of choices baby.
 
The day before I turned 18 I left for a job with Disney On Ice, and all I can say is 8 hours a day standing? I worked 20 hours a day, 140 hours a week, I was a seat vendor, most days we had 2-3 shows, I spent 9 hours out of the day carrying a 75lb bag of show lights up and down stairs, the rest of the time I was walking or standing behind my stand selling crap, and if I was not doing that I had stock call where I had to help unload several rigs of new stock. We got no days off and worked through holidays, I got the flu and was told I still needed to work, I ended up passing out on the concourse with a 104 temp, I was then allowed to go back to my hotel room for a whole 2 days, after which I would be let go if I was not back. I was young and stupid back then, they get away with things like that because we were "contract" and "self employed".

Where is my article?

You get no sympathy from me, sorry.

If you don't like a job, you're always free to get up and walk out, consequences be damned.
 
If you have any military experience, probably using the Navy as the best example, imagine yourself stationed on a ship, say a carrier, with 5,000+ other people working with you inside that "floating city" 24/7...

Now imagine that same type of situation but with 300,000 other people all working inside the same facility which is effectively closed off 24/7 (meaning it ain't got a big retractable roof, probably not the greatest ventilation system, everybody eats, drinks, sleeps inside the place - in housing, of course - etc).

We here in the US simply have absolutely nothing to compare such a job with, we'd never allow such facilities to exist for a huge variety of reasons.

I can't even imagine what it must be like "working" in such a place...


thats how the steel mills, mines and a lot of industry used to run in the united states during the industrial revolution
 
I dont understand do the workers live there? They only work 40 hours a week plus overtime but no mention to it is made outside of signing the paperwork.

They mention that they workers could use a shopping mall and a theatre really? Like if they live there maybe but if not WTF Boeing employees 40k+ people also they have no theatre that I know of or a shopping mall(they do have their own highway)

That article sucked the Chinese are weak russia will pwn them someday
 
It (the facility) is one big huge gigantor massive fucking complex, fully contained, and people eat, sleep, live, work, "play" if they're lucky, and of course the obligatory die there too... it has shopping "malls," theaters, etc.

Imagine taking something like downtown Seattle, removing buildings more than 4 stories tall (no skyscrapers) and then containing it inside a big ass dome/roof/walled enclosure.

Something like that, more or less, but a lot more compact and stressful - yes, even more stressful than Seattle living.
 
The article in question and the one that supposedly shows how 30 people tried to commit suicide in the past few weeks is utter bullshit. If I had to guess, the 'stress' hotline Foxconn set up received 30 calls and that horrible reporter is equating each of those to a suicide attempt.

The reporter mentions the lowest possible wages and not one word on how much the typical line workers actually make with overtime. He worked there for a month and could not bother to mention his own wages? Could not show a pay stub? Interesting.

He talks of the man who lost a finger but not the fact that his medical bills were taken care of and that he is employed by the company to this day, just in a more suitable role for one with a missing digit.

For being undercover in the plant for a month the whole article seems light on any actual verifiable facts and heavy on one sided comments meant to elicit a specific emotional response. Pathetic. It is propaganda the like of which has not been seen in China for awhile. His gov't should hire him. He'd be a rockstar.

His proposed solution to the issues workers face is to have Foxconn add a shopping mall and a movie theater. Brilliant. On one hand he tells you how the employees make nothing and on the other he suggests ways for them to spend money they don't have according to him. wtf? Boohoo, the factory employees can not all afford the products they make. This is uncommon? The factory workers in Germany building BMW's I am sure must all have one in their garages right? I do earn a quite nice salary in China and I wouldn't even buy an Apple product. Some of the knockoffs are actually decent quality and a fraction of the cost.

The article is just absolute bullshit and the author should be punched in the dick.
 
I've never used quotes from other people in my sigs, but dammit... that one is just too good to pass up.

Done. ;)

i wanted to quote it too but no bbcode. then i realized i coulda just did what you did. too funny.
 
The true face of the Ipod/pad.

f1a6312156f4ba9228ae-ll.jpg
 
Imagine taking something like downtown Seattle, removing buildings more than 4 stories tall (no skyscrapers) and then containing it inside a big ass dome/roof/walled enclosure.

.

You mean like the Gaylord Texan?
 
I worked for Foxconn, aka Hon Hai, and I visited that plant. Americans are treated a little bit different than Chinese. If you are Chinese but not from mainland China, you are a 3rd class citizen. If you have a PhD in any crap thing, you work 5 8 hour days; if not, you work 10 hour days with every other weekend off.

As far as the dormitories, yes I stayed there also. Let just say the concept of a bed frame does not exist ... mattresses on the floor. Communal restrooms ... holes in the floor with a container of water nearby. Thus, is why we bow when greeting each other.

Managers scream at the employees. The employees have no other choice but to take it. You have never known what a bad review is until you have had one there. Lets just say that it does not stop at the company gate.
 
I bust my ass for 9.5 hour a day with only 30 mins for lunch. Where's my article?

And should I feel bad for having a Foxconn mobo?

I used to work 18 hours a day 6 days a week.. over 3.5k hours in a year wheres mine? :p
 
I worked for Foxconn, aka Hon Hai, and I visited that plant. Americans are treated a little bit different than Chinese. If you are Chinese but not from mainland China, you are a 3rd class citizen. If you have a PhD in any crap thing, you work 5 8 hour days; if not, you work 10 hour days with every other weekend off.

As far as the dormitories, yes I stayed there also. Let just say the concept of a bed frame does not exist ... mattresses on the floor. Communal restrooms ... holes in the floor with a container of water nearby. Thus, is why we bow when greeting each other.

Managers scream at the employees. The employees have no other choice but to take it. You have never known what a bad review is until you have had one there. Lets just say that it does not stop at the company gate.

I have a bed frame and a plywood plank on top of it that I sleep on with only a very thin cushion on top if it.. Sounds uncomfortable but I have not slept better in a long time. Mattresses on the floor is not exactly the barbaric conditions some articles try to represent. I do wonder why they would do such a thing in a dorm though, such a waste of space. Seems odd.

The communal toilet thing is not uncommon. The hole in the floor style of crapper is also FAR from uncommon. I currently have what boils down to a western toilet sitting on top of one of those holes. I flush with a bucket of water next to the toilet. Big deal.

I have not seen much bowing in China. Actually, the only time I have seen it is at posh restaurants/shops where the staff will bow their heads slightly as you enter in greeting. I imagine it's also done for business meetings though it's not the bend deeply from the waist kind of thing I imagine. Handshakes are also not usually seen, it's not how most greet others in China from what I see.

Having employers contact you for any reason including yelling outside of work hours is normal as well. My girlfriend gets calls on her day off and late (11ish) at night that are work related. She does not work in a factory. She and her friends often can be found working some hours on their days off as well, it gets on my nerves when we are out having a good time but different culture different rules *shrug*.
 
Don't forget Foxconn makes stuff for many companies, not just Apple.

Yep, look at their Wiki page. :)

It's china, they are already paying them great wages for china. If someone asked you to work in these conditions for 250,000$ a year would you do it? We'll assume the device you are building costs a million dollars. I'd say damn my engineering degree and sign up in a heartbeat, and you're lying to your self if you say you wouldn't do the same. But now you are saying that because in countrythatdoesnotactuallyexist people are use to getting paid 10,000,000$ a year, they should not offer for you to get paid 250,000$ a year?

It's not slave labor. If you can send an under cover worker in, have them work, and then have them leave of their own accord then anyone in that factory could walk out just the same. They don't leave because it's great money for the part of the world they live in.

Wow, just wow. You really cannot read and comprehend a damn can you?
 
Back
Top