New to Xbox360 coming from PC

RagingSamster

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Jun 6, 2003
Messages
3,162
ARRG - the growing pains!

How long does it take to get proficient with a "controller" in FPS games?
First time playing an Xbox360 this weekend I attended a 15 person LAN. It was fun - but I'm thinking I was looking like MasterChief after a few too many adult beverages. I did get some kills, a few headshots (luck) and had a good time.

To represent clan Stratton since My son moved to Australia, I have been attending a LAN that his friends put on. Last year I bought a whole bunch of Pizzas and watched, this year I brought over a whole bunch of mountain dew and bought the Elite with Halo/Forza combo - I brought over my projector and played Halo for most of the evening.

Or... tried to play :D had a great time though.

Hopefully the controller will feel more natural after a few days.
 
It takes a while but you will get used to it. Matter of fact, I am so used to a controller now I have a hard time using a keyboard/mouse. While the controller is never as accurate as a mouse, the rest of the buttons are more convenient to use on a controller (for jump, crouch, meele, reload, ect). There are pros/cons to it, but you will get used to it.
 
The only FPS I got decent at on 360 was COD4 & MW2. I dunno why, but this is the only game that makes it really easy to aim with. It just seems much more smooth with the perfect amount of dead zone for me. Otherwise, I stick to the PC for my FPSs, hah. It's funny that all the console makes would have to do is add kb&m support to their FPSs and they would instantly attract a good chunk of the PC gamers to them. At least it would me. I know this would bring an unfair advantage to the kb&m players online, but that could be easily fixed by giving the players the option of playing in "controller only", "kb&m only", or "mixed controller" matches. If they did this in MW2, then I would finally be able to settle the debate between my friends on which is better, hah.

Oh and try these out, I've heard/read they work wonders for FPSs, but I haven't tried them yet.
 
Just like anything, it takes time. You'll get the hang of it before long. I grew up on a controller (Atari, NES, SNES, N64) and I love the customization of the keyboard and mouse, but I also love the simplicity of a controller.

These people you played against more than likely have a lot more experience on these games than you so I wouldn't expect to jump right in and be competitive with them. If you keep working at it, you'll get the hang of it before long.
 
It takes a while but you will get used to it. Matter of fact, I am so used to a controller now I have a hard time using a keyboard/mouse. While the controller is never as accurate as a mouse, the rest of the buttons are more convenient to use on a controller (for jump, crouch, meele, reload, ect). There are pros/cons to it, but you will get used to it.

Agreed 100%. I'm still faster and more accurate with a mouse, but there's something about the simplicity of using a pad. It's nice to have your actions streamlined sometimes.
As far as aiming and getting used to it - just keep in mind that it'll NEVER be as fast as a mouse, but you'll find over a few months you can be just as precise within a smaller radius. For instance I'm not going to be able to turn 90 degrees and headshot a sniper simply because of the speed of the analog aiming. However, it'll make you a better strategic gamer because you'll realize you can't do this and you have to really know your surroundings well. Give it a few months and you'll get it down.
 
It takes some time to get use to it, and everybody is different. Most games, if not all, give you the ability to adjust the sensitivity of the controls. So you can speed up your look/turning, and of course invert the Y axis (which is something I always do). Just keep at it, and it should eventually become quite easy for you. I remember when I first got the original Xbox, and Halo. It was the first FPS I played using dual analogue sticks for the controls. It took a while, but eventually I grew to love using the controller. I still have nothing against a mouse and keyboard though.
 
i have a ps3, 360, and a PC, I buy all of my FPS on PC cause

1. it is cheaper
2. better control layout
 
I think it's the game really. I like FPS more on a pc too, but I buy for consoles and play a lot. Games that are slower such as Halo I tend to suck a lot more when playing others (Single player no problem and still have lots of fun) But games like CoD I'm ok and do a lot better.
 
ARRG - the growing pains!

How long does it take to get proficient with a "controller" in FPS games?
First time playing an Xbox360 this weekend I attended a 15 person LAN. It was fun - but I'm thinking I was looking like MasterChief after a few too many adult beverages. I did get some kills, a few headshots (luck) and had a good time.

To represent clan Stratton since My son moved to Australia, I have been attending a LAN that his friends put on. Last year I bought a whole bunch of Pizzas and watched, this year I brought over a whole bunch of mountain dew and bought the Elite with Halo/Forza combo - I brought over my projector and played Halo for most of the evening.

Or... tried to play :D had a great time though.

Hopefully the controller will feel more natural after a few days.

kb&m is absolutely horrible for vehicles and everything that doesn't have to do with aiming. i don't think the mouse is anymore accurate than the analog stick, i always play at the highest sensitivity in all my console games and i can make smooth nonjuttery movements that most console players do
 
kb&m is absolutely horrible for vehicles and everything that doesn't have to do with aiming. i don't think the mouse is anymore accurate than the analog stick, i always play at the highest sensitivity in all my console games and i can make smooth nonjuttery movements that most console players do

Pretty much true with the mouse really being pretty pointless for anything besides aiming or pointing with a cursor.
In terms of accuracy, it's technically no less accurate, but it's definitely slower. No matter how sensitive you have things set, a mouse is going to be quicker to line things up. Analog sticks will always be speed limited, especially when you're looking to something that isn't near the middle of your screen. However, I think it forces people to play smarter. Because you can't turn 180 degrees in a milisecond, you're forced to use your environment a little more.
 
I too am afected by this dilema, I bought my 360 strictly to lay thru the halo series, im still one CE, I ahted the controller so much i bout an xfps...it works all right but not great im lloking forward to the xim3 thingy.....I wish they would just realse halo 3, odst and reach on pc....
 
Personally, coming from a PC, I was adept at console fps gaming right away. Coming from PC is a huge advantage, and the 360 controller is easy to use. There's nothing to it, really.
 
if you fire enough bullets, you don't need to aim...

lol... spray n' pray...

I used to be anti-console for FPS like COD4 online on the PS3, but i quickly adapted to the controller and prefer it to M&K now, just takes a bit of time to get used to the sticks sensitivity and setting it to how you like it.
 
Up until that last 6 months i had been purely PC, the newest console I owned was a gamecube (no fps) so I can probably give you some good information. It took me a month or so to get adept at using a controller, I do not play with fast sensitivity as i did with the PC, i almost find anything over medium sensitivity (3 out of 10 or so) impossible to use. However, at this point, i'm nearly unable to go back to PC shooting, using a tiny stick to aim around a whole screen is much more natural than moving my mouse a number of inches to aim. Just stick with it, you'll lose a whole bunch early, but you'll get better after a short period of time.

-BD
 
lol... spray n' pray...

I used to be anti-console for FPS like COD4 online on the PS3, but i quickly adapted to the controller and prefer it to M&K now, just takes a bit of time to get used to the sticks sensitivity and setting it to how you like it.

ya it took me much less time to get used to the controller vs kb/m setup than i thought i would, being that i spent so many years playing shooters on my PC. it turns out, if you stop comparing the two while you're playing, and just try to enjoy the game, you get much, much better.
 
Umm... have you tried Valve's games on the Xbox 360? Left 4 Dead I found amazingly smooth. Best controlling first-person shooter with a console controller I've found yet. And I've played a lot of shooters on the Xbox. Probably 100+ hours of Call of Duty, 150+ Battlefield: Bad Company 2, 100+ Left 4 Dead, Left 4 Dead 2, 100+ of the Halos, etc.
 
I have pretty much switched from Pc to 360 gaming, the headache of Pc gaming just wasn't worth the effort, not to mention sitting on my couch with Monsters all over the coffee table makes for a better gaming session. I feel that games that traditionally were Pc games have a better feel on the controller for me vs games that were console games from the start. So games like battlefield and cod games feel easier to aim and control vs games like farcry(console) or mass effect etc etc... And anyone who says that they aim just as good with a controller as a mouse isn't proving anything, you may aim just as good as yourself with both but "good" with a mouse is way better than "good" with a controller.
 
I'm pretty good with a controller now a days mainly because I forced myself to learn it so I could kick all my friend's asses who bragged about being good at X fps for 360/Ps3.

The reason the console game's feel smoother and more precise is because of the auto-aim feature. The reason that feature is there, is because an analog stick will never be as precise as something like a mouse or even the wii mote.
 
The Valve games control amazingly well with an analog stick...even playing the PC version with the 360 pad. Whatever they're using to map that right analog stick is absolutely the best around. Killzone 2 could've used that driver...
 
The Valve games control amazingly well with an analog stick...even playing the PC version with the 360 pad. Whatever they're using to map that right analog stick is absolutely the best around. Killzone 2 could've used that driver...

Killzone 2 was absolutely terrible with that, I agree. I believe it was patched to fix the dead zone issues but I'm not too sure as I haven't touched it since launch.
 
The reason that feature is there, is because an analog stick will never be as precise as something like a mouse or even the wii mote.


whats more precise is your opinion...

and don't even bring up the abomination that is named the WIImote
 
Last edited:
Pretty much true with the mouse really being pretty pointless for anything besides aiming or pointing with a cursor.
In terms of accuracy, it's technically no less accurate, but it's definitely slower. No matter how sensitive you have things set, a mouse is going to be quicker to line things up. Analog sticks will always be speed limited, especially when you're looking to something that isn't near the middle of your screen. However, I think it forces people to play smarter. Because you can't turn 180 degrees in a millisecond, you're forced to use your environment a little more.

thanks for admitting the obvious and not going on a "PC players are almighty" troll rage.
you must have not had a lot of experience with a controller, cuz i can turn a 360 in a millisecond and land a head shot, so since PC players say its harder to aim with a contoller than it must take more skill then.
 
thanks for admitting the obvious and not going on a "PC players are almighty" troll rage.
you must have not had a lot of experience with a controller, cuz i can turn a 360 in a millisecond and land a head shot, so since PC players say its harder to aim with a contoller than it must take more skill then.

I don't think PC players are any better, but I can flat out guarantee you that you're not able to turn as fast as someone who's using a mouse simply because it isn't possible. You're limited by the turn speed of the analog sticks. I'm sure you're great, but there are hardware limitations at work. It's like trying to make a U turn in an F-250 vs. a Honda Civic.
You can take a look at the highest level of console shooter players (T-Squared and the like) and they're very strategic to always keep everything in their line of view so they aren't forced to turn far. It takes a lot of practice to know where to turn and how to keep your aiming reticle in the areas that allow you to aim without being forced to turn to the side.
With some practice I think the high level console players could keep up in many/most games just because they are so good...but they're always going to have to deal with making that F-250 U-turn. Hence why they play the way they do to overcome that handicap.
 
OP,

You will get accustom to it but if your an avid PC gamer it is definitely not the same. Much worse IMHO. As I grow older my hands feel very uncomfortable trying to use a game pad.

I have all the current consoles. I tried playing FPSers with a game pad and pretty much hated it. I thought why waste my time playing with a control scheme that feels worse than a keyboard/mouse. So I stick to PC gaming. Every once in a while I venture out and play an exclusive like Fable 2 or Uncharted 2 but for the most part when playing a FPS I stick to the PC. Also hate auto-aim.
 
I don't think PC players are any better, but I can flat out guarantee you that you're not able to turn as fast as someone who's using a mouse simply because it isn't possible. You're limited by the turn speed of the analog sticks. I'm sure you're great, but there are hardware limitations at work. It's like trying to make a U turn in an F-250 vs. a Honda Civic.
You can take a look at the highest level of console shooter players (T-Squared and the like) and they're very strategic to always keep everything in their line of view so they aren't forced to turn far. It takes a lot of practice to know where to turn and how to keep your aiming reticle in the areas that allow you to aim without being forced to turn to the side.
With some practice I think the high level console players could keep up in many/most games just because they are so good...but they're always going to have to deal with making that F-250 U-turn. Hence why they play the way they do to overcome that handicap.

the thing that i love most about console gaming is the fact that nobody has better hardware or a faster analog stick, which really proves who is actually good, and is not good cuz they get more fps and has higher mouse dpi, i pretty much prohibit fps pc gaming in my house cuz its just full of cheaters.

and thanks again for not saying that pc gamers are better than console gamers like most of them do.
 
OP,

You will get accustom to it but if your an avid PC gamer it is definitely not the same. Much worse IMHO. As I grow older my hands feel very uncomfortable trying to use a game pad.

I have all the current consoles. I tried playing FPSers with a game pad and pretty much hated it. I thought why waste my time playing with a control scheme that feels worse than a keyboard/mouse. So I stick to PC gaming. Every once in a while I venture out and play an exclusive like Fable 2 or Uncharted 2 but for the most part when playing a FPS I stick to the PC. Also hate auto-aim.

HTF is the gamepad Control Scheme worse?, all the buttons you have to use are right there and you don't have to worry about pressing the wrong key and logging out, gamepad also feels more natural.
 
the thing that i love most about console gaming is the fact that nobody has better hardware or a faster analog stick, which really proves who is actually good, and is not good cuz they get more fps and has higher mouse dpi, i pretty much prohibit fps pc gaming in my house cuz its just full of cheaters.

and thanks again for not saying that pc gamers are better than console gamers like most of them do.

A nice gaming mouse, or a better computer won't make somebody a better player. Good hardware, pc and peripheral wise, will make a good player better but it certainly won't make a bad player good.
 
I honestly think anyone who claims that PC shooter players are "better" is kidding themselves.
They're both doing the same things and just using whatever is available to them. Yes, some PC players might be more experienced since analog stick gaming isn't as old - but that's really it.
Watch a high level Halo tournament and you'll see the exact same skills shown in a typical Quake or Unreal Tournament event. Certain functions are slower, but it's because of the nature of the game and the controller rather than the skill levels of the players. The same strategies and skills are employed by both. The crazy pinpoint shots employed by really good console players would probably impress PC players if they took the time to look. With many, I doubt you'd notice a difference between their aiming and someone using a mouse with the exception of the lack of quick turns.
 
I honestly think anyone who claims that PC shooter players are "better" is kidding themselves.
They're both doing the same things and just using whatever is available to them. Yes, some PC players might be more experienced since analog stick gaming isn't as old - but that's really it.
Watch a high level Halo tournament and you'll see the exact same skills shown in a typical Quake or Unreal Tournament event. Certain functions are slower, but it's because of the nature of the game and the controller rather than the skill levels of the players. The same strategies and skills are employed by both. The crazy pinpoint shots employed by really good console players would probably impress PC players if they took the time to look. With many, I doubt you'd notice a difference between their aiming and someone using a mouse with the exception of the lack of quick turns.

That's an apples to oranges comparison. All you really have to do is play the same game on both a console and a PC and you'll notice the difference immediately. The PC guys seem to be a lot more accurate with their shots, which can be attributed to the input method.

This alone can change the nature of the game. I think someone mentioned Battlefield BC2... I was watching a friend of mine play this on console, and a lot of people were pretty much just running around in the open and jumping everywhere. I'm not saying that people on the PC don't do this... but the ones that do die a lot quicker :)
 
If you look at casual play...sure there are probably a lot more casual players on the console.
Still, I'd say good players are good players. For example you can't just pop in Street Fighter 4 and assume and assume that console players do nothing but choose Ken and try to uppercut everything while arcade players are all using Fuerte and 100% combo'ing left and right.

There's no way to really say who is more skilled, but take a look at some console tournament footage and I think you'll see that the high level players are doing the exact same things. The main difference is that their crosshairs will almost never leave certain areas just because it's impossible to line up shots fast enough if you do.
 
A nice gaming mouse, or a better computer won't make somebody a better player. Good hardware, pc and peripheral wise, will make a good player better but it certainly won't make a bad player good.

there is pretty much no balance whatsoever in PC gaming
 
I have tried for years to get comfortable playing FPS on consoles, but I just can't do it with the controller. I wish I could for those times when friends want to play, but I tend to get frustrated since the game just feels slow to me. I especially have a difficult time being accurate though I think that is more to lack of good thumb control since I get the shakes.

The best FPS game I ever played on the console and actually enjoyed not to mention could play well was Goldeneye on the N64. Something about that controller I could just easily play and play well even though my friends would tell me I hold the controller wrong.

I borrow my brother's 360 FPS games all the time, but I just can't get it. I keep trying and maybe one day it will click.
 
Back
Top