Think Verizon is Overhyped???

kdw1975

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 11, 2005
Messages
142
I have had AT&T/SBC for around 9 years and before that had given Sprint a try after initially having SBC. I constantly read how much better Verizon is but since they had always had such poor coverage in my area never gave them much consideration. Recently though I had the chance to play around with one of their newer smart phones in Kansas City. I have to admit that as far as data I wasn't too impressed. I tried doing some speed tests and only got around 800kbs download speeds. On my AT&T phone I get between 1.8-4Mbps.

Admittedly I don't know how it works as far as voice compared to AT&T but even my dad's sprint phone gets slightly better download speeds.
 
Just depends on the area. The area where I live the coverage is amazing and beats all other providers.

I get great speeds 98% of the time.
 
While I overall pretty happy with AT&T I do think their call quality is pretty crappy, but that may be my iPhone partly to blame. I am anxious to get the iPhone on other networks and see how things pan out.
 
I wouldn't say overhyped as I would say the best of a bunch of bad options. My experience with AT&T was absolutely lousy. Dropped calls all the time, dead zones in both my office and at home. I know it's subjective to where you live, but that's my experience. I switched to Verizon about 6 months ago and it's been a huge improvement.
 
I wouldn't say overhyped as I would say the best of a bunch of bad options. My experience with AT&T was absolutely lousy. Dropped calls all the time, dead zones in both my office and at home. I know it's subjective to where you live, but that's my experience. I switched to Verizon about 6 months ago and it's been a huge improvement.

I can agree with that. I have a feeling though that people around the net bashing AT&T and praising Verizon are going a little overboard. It may be a step better in some departments but far from what it could be.
 
Verizon 3G is pretty good. I can travel a in car through most of North Carolina except the ultra rural areas and get decent speeds. Works great in motion for web surfing and email, not so much for video though in the right spots even SD video can stream decently in motion.

If there's something better I'm in but I've not seen or heard that there is.
 
Never had AT&T. Only used Sprint & Verizon. I think I switched to Sprint to save a little $$. Didn't like it as much 'cause of some dead zones in specific places which were never an issue with Verizon. It could have been the phone itself though.

Anywaste, I switched back to Verizon 'cause I wanted the Motorola Droid.
 
I live in San Francisco which supposedly is covered by all the majors but I have friends on every network complaining about this or that.

AT&T probably has the most complaints in SF, Verizon has a pretty good reputation around my group of friends. T-Mobile is probably second worst after AT&T and Sprint isn't mentioned much but I think its OK...
AT&T has the potential to be the fastest, but if 4G rolls out in SF I am guessing Sprint/Verizon will take that crown away so..plus AT&T is only fast when it actually works :p

I would say right now in SF
Verizon - Sprint/T-Mobile - AT&T

But they all suck sometimes
 
The sprint everything plan for $69 is pretty hard to beat. Not sure what T-Mobile has though.
 
I can agree with that. I have a feeling though that people around the net bashing AT&T and praising Verizon are going a little overboard. It may be a step better in some departments but far from what it could be.

Verizon has far better 3G coverage than AT&T. So even if AT&T is faster in your area, Verizon is far more likely to be fast enough. In the area I'm in now, for example, only gets 3G from Verizon. Nobody else has 3G at all. Verizon's 3G is fast enough to stream Pandora, watch Youtube videos in HQ, browse the web with reasonably quick loads, etc... Since I don't download files, as long as its fast enough I'm perfectly happy with it. 2G is unbearably slow.
 
You have to look at the overall picture. To the guy living in one spot that never moves around and has excellent coverage from AT&T, he'll claim AT&T are best. It's all anecdotal evidence. I'm pretty sure though that Verizon does have the largest network, didn't they even get taken to court by AT&T for their commercial saying that and AT&T lost because that claim was proven? Either way, Verizon just refunded me $150 on my bill due to my own mistake when changing plans (I had dropped unlimited text) so I'm still quite happy with them (yes that's anecdotal :) ).
 
i've had had just about every carrier Sprint, T-Mobile, AT&T(when it was Cingular), MetroPCS and Verizon.

Sprint, Great service never dropped a call data would sometimes be spotty when i was traveling but when i was in and around home and work i never had a complaint. Had to give this one up because it was a work phone.

AT&T had them for years first when it was bell-south then it turned into Cingular up until right when it changed to AT&T and the coverage was absolutely horrendous i would say on average 25% of my calls would drop or never connect to begin with. (didn't have a choice as it was another work provided cell)

T-mobile only had them for 6 months same issues as AT&T the problems were so bad after 6 months they gave me the option to return my phone for a full refund and refunded all the money i spent on the bills.

Left T-Mobile for Metro PCS and the service and quality was leaps and bounds better then i got with AT&t and T-Mobile. Data was fast never dropped a call. The only gripe i really had was you had to dial the area code even when calling a number in the same area code. Left them because i needed a blackberry and this was before they offered one.

Verizon, Been with them for about 2+ years now and i don't think i have ever dropped a single call i have driven from south Florida all the way to Michigan several times and did not loose a 3G connection once. Data is consistently faster then my friends on any other network.

over hyped? ehh its possible but they have the reliable network and speed to back it up. I live in south florida but travel through out the united states ALOT 15+ days a month im out of town and always have nothing but spectacular service with verizon. No other carrier has been able to offer that.
 
From what I understand, Sprint roams on Verizon's network, so Sprint should be very similar to Verizon...just costing less. Not sure how that works with data though.
 
From what I understand, Sprint roams on Verizon's network, so Sprint should be very similar to Verizon...just costing less. Not sure how that works with data though.

Sprint doesn't have 3G roaming for Verizon, so I wouldn't recommend them if you live in an area without native coverage. However, for those who are worried about having a functional cellphone when you travel around in non-urban areas, you are totally covered through roaming.
 
where i live (north westchester, ny) verizon wireless gets close to no reception at all. AT&T gets 5 bars and 3g.

the towns are battling with verizon over franchise issues because verizon wants more kickbacks than cablevision has in the area and are not providing tower service until their demands are met. i'm also not getting fios tv while the deal is held up.

bastards.
 
Like others said it depends on your area.

At my house my iPhone would always get 2.9mbs when running the speed test and my Verizon phone only does 1.2ish. Verizon has a better overall faster speed I've noticed since I've gotten my Droid a couple months ago.

I speed test my iPad all the time and then run the same speed test on my Droid and that's how I've figured this out. I travel all over the D.C./Maryland area for work.
 
You have to look at the overall picture. To the guy living in one spot that never moves around and has excellent coverage from AT&T, he'll claim AT&T are best. It's all anecdotal evidence. I'm pretty sure though that Verizon does have the largest network, didn't they even get taken to court by AT&T for their commercial saying that and AT&T lost because that claim was proven? Either way, Verizon just refunded me $150 on my bill due to my own mistake when changing plans (I had dropped unlimited text) so I'm still quite happy with them (yes that's anecdotal :) ).

It wasn't that AT&T was contesting that Verizon was bigger, it was that the commercials didn't make the distinction that they were talking about 3g coverage, and thus much worse than it really was. thus the AT&T covers 97% of Americans coverage.

Anyhow, every provider has high points and low points for coverage, and it's not a one company putting money into upgrades and the other skimping on it (if you do the math, capital expenditures for AT&T grew faster than net income from 2005 to now) The key is to correctly determine if the info you hear is valid or BS and buy what's best for you.
 
the 3G on my HTC Incredible is amazing. I was surfing the web next to my friend with an iPhone and his jaw dropped and was like "wtf hacks!"
 
Back
Top