(wannabe) 10TB+ server: sata connectors problem

darkbasic

n00b
Joined
May 5, 2010
Messages
25
Hi, the motherboard has no vertical sata pcm mounts, instead it has angle ones. See the photo attached:
http://darkbasic.homelinux.com/images/P1010979.JPG

The problem is I have to mount a 6 HDD cage in front of the sata ports and there isn't enough space :(
I can't mod the case (it's a yeong yang rack 4U) because on the other side there are two fans and there is no space left to shift the cage.

See the second photo:
http://darkbasic.homelinux.com/images/P1010980.JPG

What can I do? I can't use angle sata connectors because I need all 6 sata ports (I can use only 3 ports with angle connectors).

Thank you,
Darkbasic
 
Is a new board out of the question? Getting a decent ($200 range) server board will do two things for you. First, it will give 6+ vertical SATA connectors, usually around the bottom edge of the board (if it was mounted in a standard ATX tower case). Second, it will change your memory orientation so that airflow will go through the spaces between the memory. Bonus is if you get IPMI or something like that included also.

I'm fairly sure those horizontal connectors came about in consumer boards because people got very into cable management on the enthusiast side in the IDE/ATA/SCSI days, just before SATA hit. After SATA came out, it just became easier to route the smaller cables through cases than the old ribbons. For consumer cases, this works well, for server cases, this is can be less than optimal for reasons you are seeing.
 
You are right, it is a workstation board, not a server one. It also doesn't have integrated graphic and it has only one ethernet, but are you sure I can buy a decent server board for a Xeon W3520, with 8 GB of DDR3 ECC ram in triple channel, at least 1 pci and 4 pci-express (8x, 8x, 4x, 1x minimum) with only 200$?
 
In the photo it doesn't seem, but the gap is very small (less than 1 cm) and it's just enough for an angle sata cable.
 
Hmmm.....thats a tight spot. Are you sure you can't dremel out part of that cage? If not, then i'd say you would need to get a new motherboard as well. It's a shame because it looks like a sweet setup too! If I were you, i'd cut out whatever I needed to make it work unless you could return the motherboard.
 
did a quick google

how about a left-hand and a right-hand sata cable?

http://www.specialty-cables.com/mini_sas_sata_adapter.html

SATA_Right_Angle_connector__2.jpg

SATA_Right_angle_connector.jpg
 
Unfortunately I can't return the motherboard. I can save only 0,5mm with the dremel (remember there will be the HDDs in the cage) which is just not enough.
One possible solution is to use only 3 of the 6 sata ports (I can do it using angle connectors) and replace the pci-express video card with a pci one to save one pci-express slot for a sata controller, but which one? I don't want to spend 800$ for a eight-port sata controller...

I can mount up to 11 hard disks, so I'dd like to buy and eight port controller (8+3=11).
 
how about a left-hand and a right-hand sata cable?

You mean using a left hand connector for the lower port and a right hand connector for the upper (or viceversa, I'm not sure)? The motherboard is not high enough from the bottom of the case...
 
surely the motherboard not being high enough depends on the length of the sata connector housing
if the housing were too long it might be possible to trim shorter

just a thought
 
Off topic, but what PCI/PCIe cards do you have? I recognize the PCIe video card, but I'm surious what the others are. I've never seen one like the right hand one with a card edge connector on the end of the card.
 
if the housing were too long it might be possible to trim shorter

I want to be sure we are talking about the same thing: the idea is to use two angle sata connectors (one right angle and one left angle) like in this photo:
http://darkbasic.homelinux.com/images/sata_angle_updown.jpeg

Unfortunately I can't plug it in the lower port such a way because the port isn't high enough, I can barely plug it into the upper port (see http://darkbasic.homelinux.com/images/P1010982.JPG). Trimming the angle sata connector (you meant that?) will be very difficult because it isn't a matter of half millimeter.

Off topic, but what PCI/PCIe cards do you have? I recognize the PCIe video card, but I'm surious what the others are.
Because they are telephony cards :)
http://darkbasic.homelinux.com/images/P1010984.JPG
First (from the top) is a Sangoma ISDN card, second is the video card, third and fourth are Sangoma PSTN cards, latest is a quad gigabit ethernet interface (well, my network is 100Gb/s, but 100Gb/s cards are too much expensive, network switches even more). I will upgrade the network interface later, for the moment it is enough.

I've never seen one like the right hand one with a card edge connector on the end of the card.
It's because with one pci/pci-express connector you can connect up to 24 daughterboard ;)
In this photo you can see such a connection: http://darkbasic.homelinux.com/images/P1010986.JPG

to save one pci-express slot for a sata controller, but which one? I don't want to spend 800$ for a eight-port sata controller...
I can mount up to 11 hard disks, so I'dd like to buy and eight port controller (8+3=11)
Let's talk about the controller: I was going to buy an LSI 1068E, but then I read it doesn't have open source drivers :eek:
I need something cheap with 8 sata ports. It has to work out of the box with the linux kernel (Debian GNU/Linux) and it has to be pci-express (no PCI-X controllers).
 
Last edited:
Let's talk about the controller: I was going to buy an LSI 1068E, but then I read it doesn't have open source drivers :eek:
I need something cheap with 8 sata ports. It has to work out of the box with the linux kernel (Debian GNU/Linux) and it has to be pci-express (no PCI-X controllers).

Supermicro SASLP-MV8? I'm not sure about the open source driver front, but it's probably the PCIe non-RAID HBA of choice around here. There's a thread about it in this sub-forum somewhere.
 
I know, don't worry ;)
I will buy an 8 port controller (I'm actually googling the MV8) and I will try to trim the connectors housings as you told (I was wrong, I can mount 13 hard disks so I need 5 of the six sata ports of the motherboard). It means 24 TB + the 80 GB Intel X25-M GEN2 SSD for the OS.

ignore the use of the supermirco CSE-M35TQ bays

Damn, it is something I was searching for, it is just too long... (see http://darkbasic.homelinux.com/images/P1010987.JPG).
As you can see I have 3x 5.25" Drive Bays, but it has to be shorter than 17 cm. Any suggestion?
 
Um, I dont get it. You want 10Tb, I see a SSD laying there, and you wont buy another case because you already spent a ton of money on a fancy rackmount, yet youre looking to buy $200 sata controller cards??? I understand not wanting to waste money, but sometimes when you make these kinds of mistakes youre basically "buying experience" IE bet next time you go to build a PC youll be sure to look for where those sata connectors come off of the MOBO ,lol.

If it were me, I would shift the whole HD cage out of the way ( fans be damned) OR I would dremel thru it for my sata connections and build a standoff for my HD so it didnt go all the way into the cage, at least for those last 2 or 3 in the way. Or build a custom HD cage out of sheet metal.

Im not meaning to sound like a jerk, but it seems you dont have many good choices.. Its like when my kids ask some of those oddball questions and the answer is "Just because"
 
and you wont buy another case because you already spent a ton of money on a fancy rackmount
Sorry, I didn't see your post.
I don't want to buy a TOWER case, because I need a 4U RACK case.
Buy another 4U RACK case is out of question because it will cost much much much more than $200 (this one was the cheapest I found).

IE bet next time you go to build a PC youll be sure to look for where those sata connectors come off of the MOBO ,lol.

This mobo was the only one which supported Nehalem-based XEONs with ECC memory at a decent price and this case was the only one affordable. Also the cage was optional and there were very few photos. You can imagine how hard it had been to foresee such a problem and how few alternatives there were. A pre-assembled server like this was about €2.500 and I paid it €800 (SSD included but without the telephony cards).


Im not meaning to sound like a jerk, but it seems you dont have many good choices..
Well, you are right. I'm trimming the sata cable connector's housing, I hope to solve it this way.
 
If you would be willing to entertain buying a different 4U case, the Norco 4020/4220 are very popular for DIY rackmount servers.
 
Grats man, that will work, although I would be very careful not to accidentally cut one of those wires you have exposed. Maybe put a strip of black electrical tape over it just to add a little insulation back ( I understand their not totally bare, but that sheathing looks awful thin there now, and better safe than fried.....)

I wasnt trying to be a jerk, just saying sometimes, no matter what you have , you can always make it work together to get what you want. IE, no matter how many times I try, 3+2 is not ever gonna equal 6.
 
You are right, it is a workstation board, not a server one. It also doesn't have integrated graphic and it has only one ethernet, but are you sure I can buy a decent server board for a Xeon W3520, with 8 GB of DDR3 ECC ram in triple channel, at least 1 pci and 4 pci-express (8x, 8x, 4x, 1x minimum) with only 200$?

How are you getting 8GB in triple channel?

I thought you were running LGA1156 (like an X3430 or something). In which case you could get a board for dual channel 8GB DDR3 pretty easily for $200. LGA 1366 and that many drives and a Supermicro X8ST3-F ($330 ea but with integrated LSI 1068E, IPMI, and lots of vexpansion slots) might be a good option since you get 14 SATA connectors without even installing an expansion card. Since that controller is out, and you fixed the problem, moot thought.
 
How are you getting 8GB in triple channel?
Whoops, 6 GB I'm sorry :D

Supermicro X8ST3-F ($330 ea but with integrated LSI 1068E, IPMI, and lots of vexpansion slots) might be a good option since you get 14 SATA connectors without even installing an expansion card.

LSI 1068E is VERY cheap because it is SHIT: it hasn't open source drivers and so it is not a viable option. About the mobo, I paid it only 100$ ;)


I had a look at the Supermicro SASLP-MV8: do I need an expander or maybe a special cable? It hasn't 8 sata ports onboard and I do not want to waste slots with expansion cards...
I was also looking at Dell Perc 5/i and Dell Perc 6/i which are quite cheap. What do you think about?
 
1068E has drivers inclded with most Nix distros and they work fine, including raid capable 1/0 driver. May not be open source but they work fine which is 90% of it for most people.
 
Surely not Debian. Also binary blobs mean problems. This is not the only complaint I found, there are plenty of them unfortunatey.
 
I had a look at the Supermicro SASLP-MV8: do I need an expander or maybe a special cable? It hasn't 8 sata ports onboard and I do not want to waste slots with expansion cards...
I was also looking at Dell Perc 5/i and Dell Perc 6/i which are quite cheap. What do you think about?

The SASLP has SFF-8087 connectors and does not require a SAS expander. You can hook up 8 drives directly with 8087->SATA breakout cables.
 
Back
Top