Adobe Behind Apple Antitrust Complaints?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
MacNN, citing anonymous sources, claims that Adobe is behind the complaints to U.S. antitrust enforcers. To be honest, who really cares where the complaint come from if you end up being investigated. Am I right?

An Adobe complaint is the main cause behind reported federal interest in antitrust charges against Apple, according to Bloomberg sources. Apple recently changed the rules for developers, forbidding the use of third-party tools in the creation of iPhone and iPad apps. In doing so, Adobe's complaint is said to suggest, Apple has actively interfered with companies' ability to compete.
 
I think its a valid point to assume some complaint came from adobe, but that complain is also very valid.
 
Not shocked in the least that Adobe might have had some part in this. Will be interesting to see what happens.
 
This makes me so happy. Go DoJ! Put the hurt on that parasitic piece of shit company.

Apple, you shouldn't be able to claim to be the most innovative company when all you do is buy innovations and lock them down so no one else can use them. Now your market is enormous and you think you can tell us how to walk and talk? You're now worse than Microsoft ever was, holding back consumer electronic innovation around the world, and you can't even pretend to be ashamed of it! Walk the plank, Apple!

As for Adobe... meh. If anyone had the motivation it was them.
 
Honestly I don't care who's behind it since Apple deserves to be investigated for its single supplier system. If this happened a couple months earlier, MS may have released a more open WP7... now once WP7 gets released, MS may get into the DoJ's sights for their copy-cat version of the iPhone model.
 
jobs flat said this was a security and a stability issue. adobe's products create the biggest vulnerabilities on any operating system theyre installed in.

now... look at this....

http://www.oneitsecurity.it/01/03/2010/interview-w
...


thats an interview with charlie miller. the infamous pwn2own contest stud and former nsa security expert.

to quote charlie "the main thing is to not install flash!". he wasnt talking about just mac's either. he was talking about all platforms that have a browser. flash and java are the greatest attack surfaces out there.

charlie isnt in anyone's pocket. flash is the greatest attack surface in the browser or on the desktop today.

flash = screen door on a submarine when it comes to security

jobs making the decision to walk away from a company that causes millions of dollars in damages with its inability to keep its operating system safe isnt anti competitive. its just smart, and responsible.
 
To be honest, who really cares where the complaint come from if you end up being investigated. Am I right?

I would care, because then I would know which of my competitors were whiney douchebags who hide behind mommys (Feds) skirts, so after the investigation was over I could turn my attention to them and crush them like the worms they are.
 
Maybe so, but it should be user's choice to decide whether or not they want Adobe products on THEIR device, not Apple's. Apple is a big bunch of control freak and douche bags and you're defending their lock downs. As for pwn2own contest, Apple's own Safari among things was one of the easiest systems to hack and gasp, Apple as usual ignores everything and fixes nothing.

jobs flat said this was a security and a stability issue. adobe's products create the biggest vulnerabilities on any operating system theyre installed in.

now... look at this....

http://www.oneitsecurity.it/01/03/2010/interview-w
...


thats an interview with charlie miller. the infamous pwn2own contest stud and former nsa security expert.

to quote charlie "the main thing is to not install flash!". he wasnt talking about just mac's either. he was talking about all platforms that have a browser. flash and java are the greatest attack surfaces out there.

charlie isnt in anyone's pocket. flash is the greatest attack surface in the browser or on the desktop today.

flash = screen door on a submarine when it comes to security

jobs making the decision to walk away from a company that causes millions of dollars in damages with its inability to keep its operating system safe isnt anti competitive. its just smart, and responsible.
 
Maybe so, but it should be user's choice to decide whether or not they want Adobe products on THEIR device, not Apple's. Apple is a big bunch of control freak and douche bags and you're defending their lock downs. As for pwn2own contest, Apple's own Safari among things was one of the easiest systems to hack and gasp, Apple as usual ignores everything and fixes nothing.

if you rtfa you'd see that the way he exploited a mac has always been via flash and because of the way adobe implemented flash on the mac, THATS where he was always able to exploit the browser.

alternatively, silverlight for mac doesnt seem to have those same security holes.

which is probably why silverlight for iphone is still under development. from both microsoft as well as the open source implementation of it from novell. if something id done right, apple wont have a problem with it.

as far as defending a closed architecture. its not about that. closed architecture systems have been around for a long time. nobody freaked out about it when atari sold their closed architecture computers, or timex, or commodore, or texas instruments. nobody is forcing anyone to buy apple's products. theres also plenty of alternatives out there. theres android, who i might mention, has about the same phone market share as the iphone does now. as far as their computers go. if i have to inform you of what the alternatives are there, then im really at a loss.


its not about being a "control freak" but i guess if you like to react like a 9 year old, stomp your foot and say "its not fair". then i guess thats your rationale. but closed architecture systems are as old as the computer industry dating back to the first punch card computers.

my complements on being completely reactionary though. for a second there, i thought glen beck was hanging out on the hardocp forums.
 
jobs making the decision to walk away from a company that causes millions of dollars in damages with its inability to keep its operating system safe isnt anti competitive. its just smart, and responsible.

Flash has some major holes that need to get fixed asap but what Jobs is doing is far from smart.

Whatever market share Apple has left in the desktop PC business can be attributed directly to Adobe's creative software. If not for their continued support of the OS9/OSX platforms over the years Jobs' company would not have ever had the cash to develop the iPhone or iPad.
 
Whatever market share Apple has left in the desktop PC business can be attributed directly to Adobe's creative software.
Untrue. Historically, Macs have been fairly successful with respect to use in professional media creation. This does not just include graphic design (where Adobe dominates), but also in film/video (where Apple does very well with Final Cut Pro as well as Macs in use as Avid workstations) and audio (where Digidesign has dominated in the past decade with Pro Tools). Adobe has little stake in either of these markets (in my experience, Premiere is rarely found in post-production facilities). Digidesign and Avid — now the same company — certainly have nothing to do with Adobe.

Walk into any music- or post-production facility and count how many Windows PCs you see operating in a media production capacity. It has become more common in the past five years, certainly, but it's still relatively uncommon. Audio production has always revolved very heavily around Mac OS. Video less so, but Apple does particularly well there as well.
 
Back
Top