Looking for backup external HD's, opinions?

NathanP2007

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Dec 17, 2007
Messages
1,697
So i have currently a Seagate FreeAgent Pro 500 GB USB 2.0/FireWire 400/eSATA Desktop External Hard Drive ( http://www.amazon.com/Seagate-FreeAgent-FireWire-External-ST305004FPA1E3-RK/dp/B000ND93DE ) And it is running perfectly. I currently have 221 gigs free, it holds some backup data and lots of torrented movies/shows. BUT its seagate driver doesnt support windows 7 64 bit, so any programming (auto syncing) doesnt work. Its all drag and drop.

Soon i will be getting a MBP and down the road this PC (in sig) will be my HTPC, and i will build a new Gaming Rig (i7). So storage (external) and backup (auto and drag and drop) is a investment i am desiring.

First off i am curious anyones opinions on good External Hard drives 500 gigs or more, for Mac. I plan on keeping a external next to where i keep the MBP and when not using the laptop, i will have the external hooked up and the laptop running Time Machine (auto backing up program).

Second, any opinions on great external HD's for Windows? I already have a 16 gig thumb drive on my wish list that i will buy for the small time backing up and portability.

The external HD's for Windows preferably would be flat laying (example of style: http://www.seagate.com/www/en-us/products/external/freeagent/freeagent_go/ ) , not standing like my Freeagent Pro. Not because i plan on being super portable with them, but because i don't want 3 standing Hard drive's all around my room.

As for the reason for the external hard drives for PC, my idea right now is to have one eventually have movies on it, so i can watch the movies on my gaming rig or my HTPC, the other be to backup one of my PC's or both. Idk if i will clone the drives of my PC's or if i will just backup important files or what...but it will be a safety backup.

Basically i just need advice on good quality, high rated (by you/others) external hard drive opinions , ones for Macs and ones for PC.

Thanks guys.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I like my ReadyNAS coupled with WD Green 1TB drives in Raid1.

You could go with WD Black 1TB in Raid1 for more performance, and a better warranty too. This thing can be a media server too, and also can plug in USB Ext HDs too for more backup options.

For the price I like it, you can also hack it and make it more too.. iirc it's linux flavor of sorts.
 
Wow that was more tech speak than i am fluent in haha.

I've never heard of ReadyNAS and from their website, it looks like their stuff is like mini servers. As for WD green/black, thats a internal hard drive am i right? Im looking for externals only. Also i have tried to read up on RAID but it goes over my head so i dont know anything bout it.

Idk how media servers are setup.

Haha you pretty much hit the spot of the few things left i havent learned. Media servers (servers in general) and RAID.
 
Last edited:
ReadyNas DUO on amazon I think is <$200.
2x 1TB drives <$200

Those 2 go inside the ReadyNas. The readynas is PLUG and PLAY+ Their forum/site has tons of great info.

Raid1 = both hds have identical data, it does this automatically too.

Basically mount HDS on trays, slide into ready nas, run software from CD (step by step 10min install or less), and then use windows to map a network drive, and its just like another drive on your system.

You can if you want, use advanced features like media server, ftp, remote web access, etc, etc. but you do not need to.
 
Let me break down a little bit about what ToddW2 said:
The ReadyNAS is a network attached storage device or a NAS. It's essentially an external hard drive that you can hook up to the router/network and share data among multiple computers. It does not come with any hard drives. Hence why ToddW2 recommended the WD drives. You buy the ReadyNAS, a few drives, put them together, and then there you go. Since you're planning on having a gaming rig, HTPC, and a Mac, a NAS would make a lot more sense and easier than having multiple external hard drives. And yes, many NAS will work with Macs.

As for what the RAID he's talking about, some links:
http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/2007/06/11/understanding_raid/1
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAID

EDIT: Damn I type slow. What ToddW2 said.
 
I did miss explaining NAS you covered that ;) :D

A popular one among mac users id DROBO.

Although when I checked them out it seemed over priced and less features but that may have changed now, not too sure.

LIke I said though you can always EASILY hack the ReadyNAS into a mini-linux server and do whatever you want with it too!

I suggest the WD Blacks, the Greens are noticeably slower.
 
First off, that sounds awesome. I am guessing that the two hard drive setup, but both having the exact same thing on both drives is a contingency plan? That what ever you put into the NAS is put onto one drive, then copied onto the other, incase one fails you still have everything? Thats what RAID 1 is?

Maybe it can do more than one of these things, but im curious does the NAS only hook up via ethernet for storage through my router? Or it can also be hooked up straight to the PC (via USB or Firewire) or it can be wireless or what?

Yeah it would be awesome to get a NAS that works both with the MBP laptop and my windows PC's.
 
First off, that sounds awesome. I am guessing that the two hard drive setup, but both having the exact same thing on both drives is a contingency plan? That what ever you put into the NAS is put onto one drive, then copied onto the other, incase one fails you still have everything? Thats what RAID 1 is?

Maybe it can do more than one of these things, but im curious does the NAS only hook up via ethernet for storage through my router? Or it can also be hooked up straight to the PC (via USB or Firewire) or it can be wireless or what?

Yeah it would be awesome to get a NAS that works both with the MBP laptop and my windows PC's.

Yea that's the basic gist of RAID 1.

Most NAS will only provide storage via ethernet through your router. There are some, although very expensive ones, that can be hooked up straight to the PC via USB, Firewire or eSATA. It's generally not advisable to connect the NAS wirelessly due to the slow transfer speeds needed from a NAS.
 
My solution is a little less fancy but I love it.
I just use a USB Thermaltake BlacX and plug drives into it as needed. When it's not being used I shove it into a little cubby on my desk.
While a drive is in it it certainly does not lay flat though. It is compatible with both PC and Mac.
 
Yea that's the basic gist of RAID 1.

Most NAS will only provide storage via ethernet through your router. There are some, although very expensive ones, that can be hooked up straight to the PC via USB, Firewire or eSATA. It's generally not advisable to connect the NAS wirelessly due to the slow transfer speeds needed from a NAS.

Yeah thanks, i was just curious cause my room is not where the router is. And i already have one ethernet coming to my room from the router (to my xbox) so idk my chances of getting another, but idk maybe i can.
 
You can use a Gigabit switch to give you more Ethernet ports in your room with only one connection to the router. A decent one, such as a Dell PowerConnect 2708 is probably sub $50 at this point (I just got a 24 port one, the 2724 for under $85 shipped).

NAS storage is great because you can share files across computers without having to manually plug in drives. Also, decent NAS systems will allow you to remotely access data on the NAS.
 
You can use a Gigabit switch to give you more Ethernet ports in your room with only one connection to the router. A decent one, such as a Dell PowerConnect 2708 is probably sub $50 at this point (I just got a 24 port one, the 2724 for under $85 shipped).

NAS storage is great because you can share files across computers without having to manually plug in drives. Also, decent NAS systems will allow you to remotely access data on the NAS.

Oh ok that sounds great. Any recommendations on specific (and highly rated) NAS systems? (maybe on that works with PC and Mac) and recommendations on a ethernet port switch?
 
You can use it on a mbp and a windows system that should not be a problem.

NAS - Network Attached Storage

If you want an external enclosure on one pc get an eSata setup. But it's requires that PC to be on if you want to share with your MBP.
 
You can use it on a mbp and a windows system that should not be a problem.

NAS - Network Attached Storage

If you want an external enclosure on one pc get an eSata setup. But it's requires that PC to be on if you want to share with your MBP.

No NAS seems like the way to go for me once i get a ethernet port switch. I might though just to be old school get one portable external hard drive to use Time machine on.

EDIT: Customer reviews seem to be very sketchy on the ReadyNAS duo. Hmmmm. Specifically it going down a lot and that its not plug and play.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductReview.aspx?Item=N82E16822122029


EDIT: Just curious , kinda on topic, how do you have to have a sever set up to run this http://www.engadget.com/2010/04/26/windows-home-server-vail-beta-now-available-for-download-brin/ ? What type of server do you have when you are someone that can install a whole OS onto it?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top