Apple Sued Over Multitouch Patent

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Apple has been sued again, this time around it is over alleged multitouch patent infringement. I was going to make a joke about Apple being accused of inappropriately touching but this quote from the actual complaint is gross enough as it is:

Elan Microelectronics filed a complaint accusing Apple of violating an Elan-owned patent that covers "touch-sensitive input devices with the ability to detect the simultaneous presence of two or more fingers."
 
I only need one finger to say what I think of Apple *and* patent law! :p I really fail to understand patent law anyways. How can you patent something so basic?
 
I only need one finger to say what I think of Apple *and* patent law! :p I really fail to understand patent law anyways. How can you patent something so basic?

*Ahem* Excuse me sir but i have a patent on common sense and reasoning, either i sue or you send me a $5 royalty every time you infringe on my patents.
 
*Ahem* Excuse me sir but i have a patent on common sense and reasoning, either i sue or you send me a $5 royalty every time you infringe on my patents.

Feh thats nothing. I have a patent on "The use of an internal diaphragm to draw air into a body". Every time you breathe you're infringing on my patent.
 
A patent that describes the use of a touch-sensitive device that reacts to not ONE, but TWO or more touches at THE SAME TIME

Somebody needs to burn down all the patent offices in existence and permanently close them
 
I hold the true multi touch patent, two in the pink, one in the stink. So I think everyone needs to get in line and start paying up. :p
 
Elan already sued Apple regarding multi-touch on the iphone/ipod. They're just extending this to the ipad now. Funny, because Apple is currently suing HTC over ... yep, multi-touch.

And we all know basically what will happen. They'll get together, do some settlement and cross patent licensing thing, and everyone's on their merry way. Only question is how long can they (the tech industry) before the whole patent system blows up in their face.

Bilsky, anyone? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Bilski
 
I have a copyright on every ANSI and Unicode character. Everybody shut up right now.
 
A day without "Apple" and "sued" in the same sentence is like a day without sunshine!!

apple-sued-again.jpg
 
lol and wasn't apple threatening to sue nokia of multitouch when they started releasing touchscreen phones :D:D:D
 
Guys, lets not forget Synaptics too.

I'm enjoying my delicious patent-infringing two finger scrolling, and not only in the vertical direction, but also the horizontal.

Yeah, I got balls.
 
Elan already sued Apple regarding multi-touch on the iphone/ipod. They're just extending this to the ipad now. Funny, because Apple is currently suing HTC over ... yep, multi-touch.

And we all know basically what will happen. They'll get together, do some settlement and cross patent licensing thing, and everyone's on their merry way. Only question is how long can they (the tech industry) before the whole patent system blows up in their face.

Bilsky, anyone? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Bilski

you mean your not supposed to do that? I guess that is where SCO went wrong with their suit then.
 
Doesn't Apple do the two-finger scrolling and stuff with their Macs? I know in Adobe Reader on a Mac, you can flip the page orientation by pressing two fingers on the mousepad and turning your fingers.
 
Doesn't Apple do the two-finger scrolling and stuff with their Macs? I know in Adobe Reader on a Mac, you can flip the page orientation by pressing two fingers on the mousepad and turning your fingers.

Yes, all the devices now have a pretty uniform multi-touch interface; phone/ipod touch screen, macbook multitouch trackpad, and magic mouse for desktops. Apple thinks they're covered because their patent specifies capacitive multi-touch is their unique domain, so the concomitant gestures are also covered so long as they're done on their own patented technology. That's how I understand it, anyway.
 
Back
Top