I just don't get the guys that think that they can organize and find things faster on a computer FASTER than the computer itself. It really is the ultimate case of denial. In krotch's case where he has little textual data though I can kind of understand a bit his point but still I agree with you. Typing "She Wolf" versus navigating directories is going to be faster.
You are correct about 7 indexing, its very smart about about idling and doesn't affect performance when the the machine is in use.
I think it's because a lot of people have seen XPs indexing and hated it. I was one of them. At work, a co-worker's new laptop had terrible performance. I asked if he'd turned of indexing and he said he had, so I was stumped, because the HD was constantly grinding away...turned out he'd turned off something else....it still isn't great (our IT department somehow manages to f**k up all the PCs we get), but at least the HD isn't grinding all the time.
OTOH, Vista/7 are awesome. About the only bad thing I can say is that MS should index more directories by default. I personally like to have my program directories indexed, as well as all data directories (which are generally indexed by default).
The turning point for me, however, wasn't Vista....it was when that same co-worker convinced me to install Copernic at work. I could organize my email and documents all day long, and I'd never get it to the point where it's as fast as Copernic....I even got it to index network locations (had to map folders to drives, but it worked).
I'll never go back....people ask what happened to WinFS? By most accounts, the current NTFS+Search is far better than WinFS ever was.

