Panasonic Plasma Lawsuit

Greeink

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 15, 2009
Messages
64
Didn't see this posted anywhere on here, so I thought I would share for those who may not know....

http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-10462551-1.html

http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-10462551-1.html

What do you fellas think?

First reports I've seen were through AVS...

I've been holding off on a plasma, and have been leaning towards Panasonic for quite some time... Was really looking forward to the 2010 models.

Sounds like 'normal' aging of a television, but for those who own a plasma model... seeing any huge differences in the contrast/ratio department?
 
Black deepness is one of the most important feature and Panasonic's (well documented) issue with black loosing deepness overtime is a deal breaker.
I was about to recommend the G10 Panasonic plasmas for two friends and I changed my mind after reading the reports at AVSforums.

Panasonic issue is not inherent with plasma technology. It seems that Panasonic screwed up in the voltage control of the firmware.
I own two Pioneer Kuro Plasmas and black has been as good as the first day for both. My eyes and my Chroma 5 meter both agree on this.
 
I gotta say anyone could see this coming a million miles away and frankly they deserve to be sued.

No amount "its a normal for the voltage to increase overtime in order to increase the lifetime of the phos inside the panel to its rated design" bullshilt will make up for it. Plasma's are sold as super high contrast TV sets and its what they are known well for .. to have the contrast goto shit as a "design" feature to "increase the lifespan" of the panel is shit.
 
Ya,

I was considering getting a larger 1080P plasma later this year. I know the problem seems to be with the 2009 models, i'm hoping the 2010 models will be better (?).

I know panasonic released some statements pertaining to the 2010 models, can't remember the details or where i read it though.

I'd prefer a panasonic plasma over the samsung plasma, but not if the 2010 has the same issues as 2009.

I'll find out soon enough i guess.
 
You guys can hate Panasonic all you want for this, but for $1250, even if the black levels double, or triple, what better TV can you buy than the 50G25?

There isn't one.

KURO is better, yeah, great, but they were also $6-7k a pop and still sell for three times as much as the new G/VT series do.

So, you can enjoy your superior-to-every-brand-new-set-sold black levels (even after doubling or tripling) on your ultra affordable HDTV in your living room, watching blurays with PQ that cannot be matched by anything but a handful of sets in existence, or you can spend your time whining on the internet about how Panasonic sucks, how KURO is better, and how you will never buy a Panasonic plasma while you continue to wait, and wait, and wait for this mythical TV with perfect everything to come out, still squinting at your 32" SD Sony Trinitron 12 feet across your living room. Which is it?

I keep seeing the same posts over, and over, and over again on avs forum, people who have been waiting years to purchase a new set, constantly being put off by people who blow every single little problem out of proportion, continually posting about it until every forum user seems to think that the sets are crap, and will have gray blacks after a week, but this simply isn't the case. The G/VT still remain to be the absolute best new sets you can buy, being extremely cheap AND having superior PQ to every set but the KURO.

I gotta say anyone could see this coming a million miles away and frankly they deserve to be sued.

No amount "its a normal for the voltage to increase overtime in order to increase the lifetime of the phos inside the panel to its rated design" bullshilt will make up for it. Plasma's are sold as super high contrast TV sets and its what they are known well for .. to have the contrast goto shit as a "design" feature to "increase the lifespan" of the panel is shit.

Posts like these. Except there aren't just one, there are hundreds, if not thousands of them over on avs forum. So your blacks rise, what does that give you? Shit contrast? Gray blacks? No, not at all. It gives you blacks that are still deeper than any set you can walk into a store and buy.

That said, there is absolutely no evidence that there are any issues with black levels rising on the 2010 G/VT models, only speculation.
 
Last edited:
Posts like these. Except there aren't just one, there are hundreds, if not thousands of them over on avs forum. So your blacks rise, what does that give you? Shit contrast? Gray blacks? No, not at all. It gives you blacks that are still deeper than any set you can walk into a store and buy.

That said, there is absolutely no evidence that there are any issues with black levels rising on the 2010 G/VT models, only speculation.
Sounds like you've been keeping track, and if that's the case then i'll keep the 2010 models on my short list till i'm ready to research and buy. If i wanted an LCD i'd consider the Samsung, but for plasma i'd prefer going with a good panasonic.

Some of those posts at AVS are FUD purposely created by industry insiders with their own silly interests and petty loyalties, i'd say they did a hellava job too. I spotted one of them spreading FUD in this thread (Post # 32), and even called him out on it (minor insider, petty loyalties).


Still can't say i blame 2009 panny owners that can actually notice the quality degradation though.
 
Last edited:
You guys can hate Panasonic all you want for this, but for $1250, even if the black levels double, or triple, what better TV can you buy than the 50G25?

There isn't one.

KURO is better, yeah, great, but they were also $6-7k a pop and still sell for three times as much as the new G/VT series do.

So, you can enjoy your superior-to-every-brand-new-set-sold black levels (even after doubling or tripling) on your ultra affordable HDTV in your living room, watching blurays with PQ that cannot be matched by anything but a handful of sets in existence, or you can spend your time whining on the internet about how Panasonic sucks, how KURO is better, and how you will never buy a Panasonic plasma while you continue to wait, and wait, and wait for this mythical TV with perfect everything to come out, still squinting at your 32" SD Sony Trinitron 12 feet across your living room. Which is it?

I keep seeing the same posts over, and over, and over again on avs forum, people who have been waiting years to purchase a new set, constantly being put off by people who blow every single little problem out of proportion, continually posting about it until every forum user seems to think that the sets are crap, and will have gray blacks after a week, but this simply isn't the case. The G/VT still remain to be the absolute best new sets you can buy, being extremely cheap AND having superior PQ to every set but the KURO.



Posts like these. Except there aren't just one, there are hundreds, if not thousands of them over on avs forum. So your blacks rise, what does that give you? Shit contrast? Gray blacks? No, not at all. It gives you blacks that are still deeper than any set you can walk into a store and buy.

That said, there is absolutely no evidence that there are any issues with black levels rising on the 2010 G/VT models, only speculation.

First single me out all you want , its an issue that Panasonic spent a good amount of time denying. You wanna know there are thousands of posts on this issue on avsforums? Because people are angry that there wonderful plasma sets with the best picture for the price suddenly is getting lighter and lighter, contrast is without a doubt the easiest thing for nearly anyone to spot on a TV set and the differences between plasmas that have the problem and don't are pretty big. Infact the measured difference from more than few well liked websites states the static contrast gets cut in HALF .. thats a pretty serious dip.Also you can easily buy a local dimming LED LCD set that has deeper blacks then most plasma's now so your statement on "still deeper than any set you can walk into a store and buy" comment is just not true.

The reason why people are truly angry? This issue can be fixed with supposed simple firmware update and Panasonic has refused PUBLICLY to offer one. If its so easy to increase the voltage regulation to smaller increments over time and still retain the long lifespan advertised then why not offer a firmware update and just avoid the lawsuit? Might it be something far more complicated than that and Panasonic is not willing publicly come clean about it?

Its posts like yours that for seeminly no other reason than to just defy someone elses opinion on the matter you offer up little to your arguement other than "plasma's have the best blacks ever so stop complaining" jargon.

And in response to SJetski71 , the newer 2010 panels will not have the same issues , the voltage regulation requiring small adjustments overtime will be done in smaller increments instead of large ones like the 2009 sets so this issue will not be nearly as dramatic however overtime it seems the contrast will take a dip due to wear from what Panasonic has stated.
 
Also you can easily buy a local dimming LED LCD set that has deeper blacks then most plasma's now so your statement on "still deeper than any set you can walk into a store and buy" comment is just not true.

nope

lol
 
Also you can easily buy a local dimming LED LCD set that has deeper blacks then most plasma's now so your statement on "still deeper than any set you can walk into a store and buy" comment is just not true.
LCD's aren't quite there yet last i checked, they got close from what i've been reading though, but maybe i'm confusing "blacks" and "contrast ratios" or something (?)

Some professional feedback: http://hdtvbychadb.com/reviews.htm

And in response to SJetski71 , the newer 2010 panels will not have the same issues , the voltage regulation requiring small adjustments overtime will be done in smaller increments instead of large ones like the 2009 sets so this issue will not be nearly as dramatic however overtime it seems the contrast will take a dip due to wear from what Panasonic has stated.
Gotcha, i'll keep an open mind come research time. Any plasma deemed "winner" in it's respective price category will earn my purchase, when the time comes that is.
 
Last edited:
I bought a G10 last year. I'm interested in joining the class action lawsuit but I'll buy the Panasonic again. Panasonic screwed up. But you also need to spend double or more to get the equivalent in LCD quality. And no there's nothing else in the plasma realm that comes close to the Panasonic (besides the KURO).
 
exactly how good are the panasonic blacks compared to other display devices?

I own a epson tw700 720p projector that I'm satisfied with, however the blacks is something that maybe need improvements.

mainly in dark areas as alot of horror movies have.

I haven't calibrated it, I would assume calibration would help alot too.
 
LCD's aren't quite there yet last i checked, they got close from what i've been reading though, but maybe i'm confusing "blacks" and "contrast ratios" or something (?)

Some professional feedback: http://hdtvbychadb.com/reviews.htm

Gotcha, i'll keep an open mind come research time. Any plasma deemed "winner" in it's respective price category will earn my purchase, when the time comes that is.

You are confusing black levels and contrast ratios. LED backlit LCDs can get extremely bright, giving the best LCDs a high contrast ratio because of their ridiculous white levels, but that doesn't mean that they have black levels anywhere near that of plasmas.

Give a modern plasma the white levels of a modern LED backlit LCD and you would see native contrast in the range of 50,000:1 or something ridiculous like that

exactly how good are the panasonic blacks compared to other display devices?

The only sets out there that have black levels that are better (lower) than the Panasonics are the 8G and 9G KUROs.
 
exactly how good are the panasonic blacks compared to other display devices?

I own a epson tw700 720p projector that I'm satisfied with, however the blacks is something that maybe need improvements.

mainly in dark areas as alot of horror movies have.

I haven't calibrated it, I would assume calibration would help alot too.

It depends on your point of reference and the model number you choose. Generally, higher end models will have better blacks than lower end models, so it's not just the brand name.

Generally, CRTs will have the best blacks. After that, I'm not so sure there is anything inherent in the technology that gives one an edge in blacks over another. In the past, plasmas generally had better blacks than LCD displays, but LCD has come a long way especially with the higher end LED displays that are being released. What makes the Panasonics so good is that they keep dropping the price per inch on their plasmas. It's not so much that Panasonics have blacks that blow away any LCDs on the market. That's not the case. It's that an LCD with comparable black levels tend to cost almost double what the Panasonics go for.

Home Theater Projectors generally will not have the same black level as plasmas or LCD displays. But unless you can afford 100inch+ plasmas, you're either going to go with a projector or you don't.
 
If I want to see horror movies perfectly, meaning that in dark and shadow spots all that is supposed to be seen.

Should I look for good blacks or something else?

black/white contrast ratio maybe?

Is there any articles on this subject, does hardware/software calibration help alot?
 
You guys can hate Panasonic all you want for this, but for $1250, even if the black levels double, or triple, what better TV can you buy than the 50G25?

There isn't one.


Are you being serious with this comment? Please say you were joking.
 
Yep. Prove me wrong. Show me a better TV than the 50G25 for $1250.

If the black levels double or triple over a short period of time then yes there will be tons of better TV's @ $1250 ,I dont understand your logic. Black levels / Contrast ratio are practically the most important aspects of picture quality.
 
If the black levels double or triple over a short period of time then yes there will be tons of better TV's @ $1250 ,I dont understand your logic. Black levels / Contrast ratio are practically the most important aspects of picture quality.

I think you hit the nail in the head, but Steal is also not wrong absent new evidence to the contrary. Black levels getting brighter and brighter is a serious concern. But keep in mind that both Plasmas and LCDs dim over time. There's also the fact that Panasonics were far and away better than anything at its price point last year that even with brighter black levels, Panasonics will likely remain the best sets at its price point.
 
I think you hit the nail in the head, but Steal is also not wrong absent new evidence to the contrary. Black levels getting brighter and brighter is a serious concern. But keep in mind that both Plasmas and LCDs dim over time. There's also the fact that Panasonics were far and away better than anything at its price point last year that even with brighter black levels, Panasonics will likely remain the best sets at its price point.

Yes but people are seeing increased black levels with only 400 hours of use on these Panasonics, Thats a serious problem... I would rather buy another TV than deal with that.

Lots of info here on the issue: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1167339
 
Thats a serious problem... I would rather buy another TV than deal with that.

Fair enough. Honestly, the value quotient has increased every year. I really can't see too many people being unhappy with their sets if they did their price research.

Since this is hardforum, panasonic plasmas also happen to have the lowest input lag out there, so that's also a consideration.
 
Since this is hardforum, panasonic plasmas also happen to have the lowest input lag out there, so that's also a consideration.
Unfotunately that seems to be outdated info.

People at AVS are claiming that all 2009 model plasmas have input lag scores of 30ms or higher. From the discussions i was reading, they used to have the lowest input lag in previous generations, but not anymore for whatever reason(s).

The consolation prize? There are barely any current LCD TV's that have less than 30ms of input lag, a small handful at best.
 
Unfotunately that seems to be outdated info.

People at AVS are claiming that all 2009 model plasmas have input lag scores of 30ms or higher. From the discussions i was reading, they used to have the lowest input lag in previous generations, but not anymore for whatever reason(s).

The consolation prize? There are barely any current LCD TV's that have less than 30ms of input lag, a small handful at best.

Its because the newer generations have more video processing involved. Likely more software processing in the backround. My 2008 panny has really nothing in terms of input latency.

I feel bad for those effected but its a real shame Panasonic won't admit its fault and make good on it. Its even worse that there is a growing group of "disbelievers" that say its quite acceptable to have contrast ratio's cut by more than half when it never accured in previous generations of Panasonic plasma's.

I hope the court rules in favor of those effected.
 
I have a panasonic g10 and I for one feel as though I have been swindled. For those that say it's not a big deal, why don't you drop $1250 on a tv after hours and days of research only to find that one of the biggest selling points of the product you bought is a lie? Tell me you wouldn't be pissed?

And don't tell me that for $1250, it's still a great value. I bought a certain product for a certain amount, and regardless of it's initial 'great value' it should live up to it's promise.
 
Last edited:
I have a panasonic g10 and I for one feel as though I have been swindled. For those that say it's not a big deal, why don't you drop $1250 on a tv after hours and days of research only to find that one of the biggest selling points of the product you bought is a lie? Tell me you wouldn't be pissed?

And don't tell me that for $1250, it's still a great value. I bought a certain product for a certain amount, and regardless of it's initial 'great value' it should live up to it's promise.

Completely agree. I came soooo close to buying the 54V10 (is the issue also with that line, or only with the G?)
 
I have a panasonic g10 and I for one feel as though I have been swindled. For those that say it's not a big deal, why don't you drop $1250 on a tv after hours and days of research only to find that one of the biggest selling points of the product you bought is a lie? Tell me you wouldn't be pissed?

And don't tell me that for $1250, it's still a great value. I bought a certain product for a certain amount, and regardless of it's initial 'great value' it should live up to it's promise.

Those are good points. I think what's often lost in these forums is the fact that value is such a personal thing. Is value based on what you paid for the set vs what others paid for the set? Is value based on whether the set lives up to your expections regardless of how low or high the expectations? What's the value in getting something you're not happy with?

Seriously, why can't we buy a product that just works? If you look at the owners threads for any TV at AVS, or even the monitor threads here, you'll find that there are problems with almost every set/monitor. It's even worse for projectors. Some people try to tell you not to worry because there's warranty and you know what? The warranty may very well be a good one. But I don't want to have to use the warranty. I want a product that just works as advertised. What's the value in having to exchange the units a few times to a get a perfect one?

The Panasonic sets throw a beautiful picture and offers tremendous value. With brighter black levels is it still a good value? I don't know. If it would still throw a better picture than any sets in its price range then the answer may be yes. But for some people, it will always be a no.
 
Steal's first post in this thread pretty much hit the nail on the head. I've owned an s58 for over half a year now and have put quite a few hours on it. If it broke, I'd buy another one in a heartbeat. Not because I'm somehow loyal to panasonic, but because it was a fantastic deal for what I got. For those of you who own a panny and are upset at the black level issue - at what point did you "notice" your black levels rise? When you were actually sitting there watching tv or when you read about it on the internet and decided to grab your torch and pitchfork?

A clear case of people making a mountain out of a molehill. But for those of you who will never ever buy another panasonic product again because of this grievous crime commited by them, best of luck finding that perfect tv.
 
You guys can hate Panasonic all you want for this

Thanks. I will.

Whether the affected models are still *good* or even the best on the market (which they aren't) after the degradation isl no excuse.

The price point is completely irrelevant, as is the value for money for the now defect displays.

And the icing is how panasonic handles this.

For those of you who own a panny and are upset at the black level issue - at what point did you "notice" your black levels rise? When you were actually sitting there watching tv or when you read about it on the internet and decided to grab your torch and pitchfork?

You obviously haven't read the reports...
 
this was my exchange with customer service. doesn't look like they are going to fix this.

Thank you for your inquiry,
? Panasonic has incorporated a feature in our VIERA Plasma TVs that makes adjustments periodically to maintain our excellent picture quality.

? One aspect of this feature results in very small changes to black levels.

? The VIERA Plasma TVs work as they were designed and, even with the designed-in changes, provide outstanding performance.


Thank you for contacting Panasonic




On March 24, 2010 at 4:05 AM, cnewthschool@hotmail.com wrote:

To Whom It May Concern: I purchased this product last year after reading several profesisonal review sites, conducting in-store research, and consulting several relevant Internet forums. It has come to my attention that a black level issue is occurring whereby voltage is increased to the set over time, resulting in a diminishing contrast ratio and much 'greyer' blacks. I understand that Panasonic's response to this issue has been to explain that the TV is functioning 'normally'. I, along with many other angry customers, disagree. Please resolve this issue as soon as possible.
 
The news according to that thread is disappointing.

Having black levels go up that much in 400 hours, to levels as bad or WORSE than some two year old LCD TVs I've seen is disheartening. I don't care about those LED TVs with local dimming gimmicks. I'm talking regular old CCFL LCDs like an older Samsung 750 or 850 series that gave better black levels and contrast than that.

I was seriously thinking of getting a "G" series plasma after my new entertainment room is done, but no way now.

And I could see why people who bought these TVs are pissed. I definitely would notice a change in black levels like that as soon as I turned off the lights to watch a movie.

Not sure if it warrants a law suit, but some form of consumer action would help wake them up.
 
Back
Top