Toyota and Microsoft?

how can i debate about something when youre completely missing the point?
You wanted to put forward the point that a car's brakes could not stop it while the engine was at WOT. You refuted the Car and Driver test. The closest car that would be in line with your claim was a Roush Mustang which:

1) Has questionable brakes
2) Is significantly more powerful than any affected Toyota's
3) Is not the car in question, the car(s) in question were in all practicality almost unaffected by WOT.

You also claimed that they probably just tapped the brakes. Sorry, but I find that pretty unlikely when someone is in dangerous circumstances. Even if they don't know much about how to drive or control a car they do know one thing. STOP.
 
How do you figure they 'lied about it?'

agreed, when someone posts something about an idiotic article, I make an effort to not click into the article and reward them with another hit
 
do you have any idea how conflicting and wrong you are? have you even changed a pair of pads in your life? once you burn them theyre fucked. you must be thinking of ceramic brakes needing an optimal temperature but even those can overheat and loose friction in seconds. if you dont know that you shouldnt be driving a car.

Actually you are wrong. All the pad needs to do is cool down, and then it'll work.

All brake pads have an optimum range of operating temperatures.
Most oem "street pads" are designed to operate at "cold" temperatures. At higher temps their "bite" is not as strong (known as brake fade) but they will still work. Even then the loss of friction is not as sudden as you infer.

Here is a good whitepaper as to the workings of brake systems.
http://www.stoptech.com/tech_info/wp_brakesystems_upgradeselections.shtml
 
only hardocp... where a lifetime of experience means nothing if youre up against a couple web links. if you guys had any idea the condition most people's cars are in... just any clue at all... i swear its like im talking to google :(
 
Here is a good whitepaper as to the workings of brake systems.
http://www.stoptech.com/tech_info/wp_brakesystems_upgradeselections.shtml

im not going to click that link, i just want to know if it explains why the toyota's cant stop and people are dying. they are finding these people with both feet on the pedal, and according to all these web articles you guys are posting, the brakes should have no problem whatsoever stopping the cars. if that article explains that then ill concede.
 
im not going to click that link, i just want to know if it explains why the toyota's cant stop and people are dying. they are finding these people with both feet on the pedal, and according to all these web articles you guys are posting, the brakes should have no problem whatsoever stopping the cars. if that article explains that then ill concede.

It probably gives more evidence to support the theory that the car *CAN* stop. People crash into stationary things and run off the road all the time due to human error and not mechanical error, why do you think this is any different? Hell, I bet that most of the 100mph+ deaths were the result of people speeding and simply lost control, which is not at all uncommon. Even with a closed throttle it still takes a Camry 350 feet to come to a stop from 100mph, not to mention human reaction speed. Run off the road onto grass at that speed and you're stopping distance is going to skyrocket.
 
only hardocp... where a lifetime of experience means nothing if youre up against a couple web links. if you guys had any idea the condition most people's cars are in... just any clue at all... i swear its like im talking to google :(

I have real life experience with overheating brakes as I autocross and track my car regularly. I have only experienced brake fade once. I was surprised at how hard I was able to push my brakes before the fade occurred. It took 5 laps of braking from 90mph to 20mph for a sharp right hairpin. Even then I was still able to brake fairly well (enough not to wreck) I just had to take it easy to let them cool. It is not a sudden loss of braking power.

I think it's kind of funny that you say this. Usually when someone posts real life experience they are blown off with others asking for proof.


It probably gives more evidence to support the theory that the car *CAN* stop. People crash into stationary things and run off the road all the time due to human error and not mechanical error, why do you think this is any different? Hell, I bet that most of the 100mph+ deaths were the result of people speeding and simply lost control, which is not at all uncommon. Even with a closed throttle it still takes a Camry 350 feet to come to a stop from 100mph, not to mention human reaction speed. Run off the road onto grass at that speed and you're stopping distance is going to skyrocket.

I think a big problem is that the drivers weren't hitting the brakes hard enough. Say 80% of braking power is needed to bring the car to a stop. If the driver only uses 50% eventually the braking system will overheat and not be able to provide the 80% needed to stop.
 
these people are touching their pedals to try and get what they think is cruise control to turn off. that doesnt work, so they are sharply jamming the brakes to try to get the cruise to come off. at this point, the brakes are hot and theyre still going 100mph. and at THIS point is when they bury the pedal into the floor and of course the brakes dont do shit. its exactly like i was trying to explain, but i get thrown back a whole bunch of "disc brakes 101" links as if i am retarded. people are arguing that something wont happen, when the whole reason we are even talking is because it IS happening. its absurd.
 
Most of the people are probably pumping the brakes to come to a stop. At WOT, the power braking system loses its vacuum with multiple depressions, and after pumping you effectively have no power brakes. I'd imagine this is what's causing all these people to "lose their brakes"
 
I understand what you are saying. But do you know how much of "sharply jamming the brakes" it requires before the brake fade is severe enough to cause a complete brake failure?

It took me stopping from 90mph to 20mph 5 times within 5 minutes before I even had the slightest hint of brake fade.
 
I understand what you are saying. But do you know how much of "sharply jamming the brakes" it requires before the brake fade is severe enough to cause a complete brake failure?

It took me stopping from 90mph to 20mph 5 times within 5 minutes before I even had the slightest hint of brake fade.

are you responding to me? I'm not talking about brake fade, I'm sure the brakes themselves are fine after pumping them. But at WOT, the brake booster cannot maintain the vacuum needed to assist the brakes for more than a couple pumps. After that is used up, the brakes become very difficult to press since there is no power-assist.
 
are you responding to me? I'm not talking about brake fade, I'm sure the brakes themselves are fine after pumping them. But at WOT, the brake booster cannot maintain the vacuum needed to assist the brakes for more than a couple pumps. After that is used up, the brakes become very difficult to press since there is no power-assist.

Sorry. I was talking to krupted.
 
these people are touching their pedals to try and get what they think is cruise control to turn off. that doesnt work, so they are sharply jamming the brakes to try to get the cruise to come off. at this point, the brakes are hot and theyre still going 100mph. and at THIS point is when they bury the pedal into the floor and of course the brakes dont do shit. its exactly like i was trying to explain, but i get thrown back a whole bunch of "disc brakes 101" links as if i am retarded. people are arguing that something wont happen, when the whole reason we are even talking is because it IS happening. its absurd.

If all they do is lightly tap the brakes to get cruise control to turn off then the brakes won't even be warm much less so extremely hot that they start to lose effectiveness :rolleyes:

And you seem to keep ignoring the point that brakes still work when they're super hot. I've also done auto-cross and some peoples brakes get so hot they start glowing red - and guess what? They still work.
 
these people are touching their pedals to try and get what they think is cruise control to turn off. that doesnt work, so they are sharply jamming the brakes to try to get the cruise to come off. at this point, the brakes are hot and theyre still going 100mph. and at THIS point is when they bury the pedal into the floor and of course the brakes dont do shit. its exactly like i was trying to explain, but i get thrown back a whole bunch of "disc brakes 101" links as if i am retarded. people are arguing that something wont happen, when the whole reason we are even talking is because it IS happening. its absurd.
Point is, you don't know that's what they're doing. In my first accident (and thankfully only) I thought I hit the brakes and would swear up and down that I did, but fact of the matter was that I didn't.

And trust me, I do know the condition of people's brakes. I hear terrible sounding brakes all the time. I've personally seen sets of rotors where the caliper has seized on only one side and worn the rotor surface all the way down to where it's just vents. Where they look like this
http://media.photobucket.com/image/rotor vents/cchen1/SSBCrotorviews.jpg

I know a fair bit about this topic, ;)
 
I know a fair bit about this topic, ;)

hey those are still round! shave em down and slap those back on :p but i think i finally found out exactly why you and me can't come to an agreement... its about loosing vacuum when the engine is redlined, i talked about it in the laptop thread.... were kinda both right and wrong at the same time, which is not surprising.
 
Yes, actually I do know what I'm talking about. Yes, I do all the work on my daily driver and am rebuilding another car from the ground up with a lot of analysis during parts selection. I've done a lot of brake work, and I've done quite a bit of high speed driving (and thus, braking). I'm not trying to be cocky, but I'm a pretty quick and competent driver on a track.

No, your pads can still be used after overheating. What you're referring to is called "glazing" the surface of the pad material basically liquefies. It's easily fixed by removing the pads and taking a small amount of material off of the friction surface through some manual means, or even letting the brakes cool a bit and then doing some braking runs on an empty road will remove the material.

Not just ceramic pads have optimal temperature. Optimal friction temperature (on a friction-temperature graph) is a property of pretty much all materials, not just certain materials that are used in brake pads. The temperature range is different, but it exists.

All your posts give me the impression that you think brakes a lot more delicate than they actually are. Brakes are very, very tough. If the brakes fade because of a gaseous barrier (continually being reduced in modern brake pads) you can simply lift off for a split second to vent the gas out, and reapply brakes. If the brakes fade because of heat, the friction of the pads will begin to pass the peak of their curve and start diminishing. But the friction doesn't suddenly go to 0. And it takes a lot of braking to boil fluid. I've done multiple laps with tight corners without doing so on pretty standard disk brakes.

Also, the only car that falls in line with your assumptions (the Mustang) is also not the car that's in question. The Camry basically shrugged off the extra burden of stopping the motor at WOT too.

Today's pads won't really glaze at all. What will happen is brake fluid will get hot enough to melt the seal on the master cylinder. Then your brakes don't work at all. These aren't race car brakes on these things. Lets face it. Any time you have a pedal stick or just plain go haywire you are gonna freak out for at least a second. More so if it has never happened to you before. At the best of times your doing 20 on a deserted road. At the worst of times your doing 75 and just floored it to get around a big rig in dense traffic. It's a crappy situation to be in.

I have always been leery of start buttons in cars. I mean neat as they are, you never know exactly what that button goes to unless you built it yourself. When you look at the traditional key system, you see that there are two switched states. Run and start. The luxury cars these days just don't work like that anymore. Some cars you don't even have to take the keys out of your pocket. I really don't know who they build those things for anyway. The last thing I want is a computerized female voice nagging me about crap. I would've brought the wife along if I was looking for that.
 
Speaking of Toyota and brakes, this just happened:

.Runaway Prius driver: Brakes were 'almost burned'

me and friends are laughing our asses off at this one. forget the fact the guy was not very bright (scared to put it in neutral) its just the timing of this for toyota- and that picture of the cop car trying to stop the toyota. japanese car makers were climbing an impossible ladder, they successfully rose above american automakers, and now they can pretty much forget having a hold in our markets for a good couple decades now at least. :D fine by me, go america!:p
 
Speaking of Toyota and brakes, this just happened:

.Runaway Prius driver: Brakes were 'almost burned'

Neibert told Sikes after the CHP caught up with him to shift to neutral but the driver shook his head no. Sikes told reporters he didn't go into neutral because he worried the car would flip.

What. The. Fuck? What a complete idiot. Yeah, it sucks that something went wrong, but when you are too stupid to listen to advice given to you by 911 you're pretty much asking for it.
 
Show me where that has happened then (assuming the brake pads weren't completely worn out beforehand). There's been studies that show that people often can't distinguish between the accelerator and brake pedals when in a panic. Despite firmly believing they were applying force to the brakes, the only thing firmly pushed in was the gas pedal.
 
then why are people found dead with both feet buried in the brake pedal and the pads completely disintegrated?

You keep saying that, but you have yet to back that up. I haven't heard anything like that.
 
Back
Top