Toyota and Microsoft?

Automatic OR standard: Shift in to neutral - problem solved ;)
Makes sense to me. Though, I can think of some cases where a computer controlled auto might not shift out of gear. But for my 84 sport coup,( I still own it) that would work just fine. I have done it before on accident.:D
 
That is the whole reason I like old school cars.

The ignition shuts OFF when you turn the key...because it is manual/physical switch that cuts thep power. The tranny shifts into neutral when you shift it because actual rods / levers / cables connect you to the transmission...not a sensor. Brakes apply when you apply them because the pedal moves an actual rod that controls the power booster / master cylinder and so on.

All the internet experts that say anything about new cars "shifting into / turning off / braking" are overlooking the fact that these are all controlled by computers now, nothing but wires and a sensor....if they are malfunctioning, there is NOTHING you can do to make them stop your car / shift into neutral / turn off the car.

Besides, raise your hand if you've ever been in a 100mph speeding out of control car and tried any of these MacGuyver moves successfully ;)

I can think of some cases where a computer controlled auto might not shift out of gear.

That is what most people that had issues are claiming. The one lady that testified said the car actually lurched (like it was in gear) when the tow truck driver put it in neutral.
 
its not bad advice, but honestly in that situation most people would end up just throwing it in reverse or park by flying right past the nuetral position. it would still do about the same thing, but you can tear up your tranny too. i still think shutting off the ignition is the first thing you should do- then brake and go to nuetral if you can. even if you cant do that latter two things, youll roll to a stop eventually.
Most transmissions will not shift to reverse or park while the gears are spinning the opposite direction, unless at very low speeds. But still not a good idea to test yourself.

There's just a looooooot of people out there that think they know how to handle a car professionally, but don't. They have no clue about the effects of weight bias, driveline layout, fastest line, elevation changes, weight transfer, or ANYTHING that pertains to how the car behaves. They just hop in the car and go, and they haven't had an accident lately, so they must be a skilled driver, right? /rant

A lot of this is probably driver error.
 
its not bad advice, but honestly in that situation most people would end up just throwing it in reverse or park by flying right past the nuetral position. it would still do about the same thing, but you can tear up your tranny too. i still think shutting off the ignition is the first thing you should do- then brake and go to nuetral if you can. even if you cant do that latter two things, youll roll to a stop eventually.

In an automatic you can go straight from drive to neutral without pushing the button - it will drop right into neutral, no risk of going too far. Turning off the ignition is a *bad* idea as you'll lose power brakes and power steering, making it that much harder to safely stop. Hell, shifting straight into park is better than killing the ignition.

Automatics have a piece of hardware called a park pawl, which prevents the transmission from actually engaging park and locking the wheels at speed—it creates a disturbing grinding sound, but the car essentially coasts freely.
 
All the internet experts that say anything about new cars "shifting into / turning off / braking" are overlooking the fact that these are all controlled by computers now, nothing but wires and a sensor....if they are malfunctioning, there is NOTHING you can do to make them stop your car / shift into neutral / turn off the car.

Nothing prevents the mechanical link in your old car from simply breaking, either. The computers in cars aren't haphazardly thrown together with the same "patch it later" mentality as desktop programs.

Besides, raise your hand if you've ever been in a 100mph speeding out of control car and tried any of these MacGuyver moves successfully ;)

If you let your car accelerate from ~70 to 100 unintentionally then you're either drunk or asleep at the wheel. We're talking about Toyotas here, they don't accelerate THAT fast.
 
In an automatic you can go straight from drive to neutral without pushing the button - it will drop right into neutral, no risk of going too far. Turning off the ignition is a *bad* idea as you'll lose power brakes and power steering, making it that much harder to safely stop. Hell, shifting straight into park is better than killing the ignition.

im well aware what happens when you throw a car into reverse while at speed. i didnt mean to imply the gears grind, but in any case its not good for the tranny. i also dont mean to make it sound like the tranny is worth more then human life:D its just something i would think about because ive replaced so many of them heh.

loosing your power steering and power booster is not a big deal. if you try, they still work fine without any engine rpm's.
 
I do not know all the details but I thought the whole point of the investigation was because toyota has had these problems since 2002 and not solved them yet nor addressed it fully, many think the floor mat replacement was just to find a cost effective way to get people off their backs.

A funny side not that would probably piss off Americans if they knew is that in foreign countries Toyota dealers and reps are telling everyone that their cars do not have the same problem because they are made by Japanese workers not Americans.
 
All the internet experts that say anything about new cars "shifting into / turning off / braking" are overlooking the fact that these are all controlled by computers now, nothing but wires and a sensor....if they are malfunctioning, there is NOTHING you can do to make them stop your car / shift into neutral / turn off the car.

are they claiming the engine wouldnt shut off though with the ignition though? i just havent seen that in the claims... they all say the brakes dont work and they cant shift, then theyre dead. besides, who doesnt know where their fuel pump inertia switch is!?! well, i guess im lucky enough to have mine in the cabin and not the trunk:p
 
Personally I understand why fly by wire throttle is needed, its for mileage and emissions reasons, they are also switching to electric steering and braking..

My thoughts are if you are going to disconnect people from these systems, you need to have a standardized system for using this technology, go and ask the aircraft industry and ask them how they would do it then apply it to cars that's what I think.
 
I do not know all the details but I thought the whole point of the investigation was because toyota has had these problems since 2002 and not solved them yet nor addressed it fully, many think the floor mat replacement was just to find a cost effective way to get people off their backs.

A funny side not that would probably piss off Americans if they knew is that in foreign countries Toyota dealers and reps are telling everyone that their cars do not have the same problem because they are made by Japanese workers not Americans.

youre correct, but i think the whole idea that car's computers aren't designed to compensate for normal human behavior or emergency situations is quite frightening. there are very basic ideas they can implement that would eliminate these 100mph deaths, and you know for sure they will change things now.
 
most cars could not stop themselves with full acceleration... only a few mainly European models can do that.

No, every car can stop itself (barring a brake system failure). Go buy the current issue of Car and Driver. They actually tested a number of cars, everything from the aforementioned Roush to family sedans.

these people that died are mostly stupid anyway. one was even a COP! and he couldnt pull the key out of the ignition and stand on the brakes? i just dont get it.... they have time to call 911 but they dont have time to do anything to the car? gimme a break

The Lexus in question had a push-button starter, not a key. Most people don't know how to shut down such a car while it's in motion-- just tapping the button won't do it; you have to hold it down for a while.
 
All the internet experts that say anything about new cars "shifting into / turning off / braking" are overlooking the fact that these are all controlled by computers now, nothing but wires and a sensor....if they are malfunctioning, there is NOTHING you can do to make them stop your car / shift into neutral / turn off the car.

The only problem with your assertion is that it's, well, wrong.

Only one car sold in this country has ever had a completely drive-by-wire braking system. And it doesn't any more. Every car you can buy here has a physical connection between the brake pedal and the master cylinder. EVERY SINGLE ONE.
 
No, every car can stop itself (barring a brake system failure). Go buy the current issue of Car and Driver. They actually tested a number of cars, everything from the aforementioned Roush to family sedans.



The Lexus in question had a push-button starter, not a key. Most people don't know how to shut down such a car while it's in motion-- just tapping the button won't do it; you have to hold it down for a while.

ill have to check that out. surely that is for new cars with all the brakes working properly... which is almost never the case with most cars on the road... but it sounds like i stand corrected i guess!

and i suppose if i was in that lexus i would be dead too, because i didnt know you have to hold the button down if its in motion. i would have to imagine if i owned that car it would be something i know though...
 
The only problem with your assertion is that it's, well, wrong.

Only one car sold in this country has ever had a completely drive-by-wire braking system. And it doesn't any more. Every car you can buy here has a physical connection between the brake pedal and the master cylinder. EVERY SINGLE ONE.

same with power steering afaik. its just electric pumps now instead of pulley driven....
 
All of Toyota's electronic problem shouldn't be such a shock... In 2002, BMW came out with the 745i and it was a disaster until they worked out the problems a few years later. Check the BBB or car reviews and you can see they're the exact issues Toyota is being blamed for now. Coincidentally, in 2002 BMW switched to an electronic ignition, transmission and everything else you can imagine. I'm assuming since the car was priced out of the mainstream range, you don't have as many on the road and as a result it's not a "widespread" problem. BMW also still denies there was a problem with those cars. If you run a Carfax on a 2002 (through 2004 even) 745i you can see a long list of recalls as the norm and possibly a Lemon Law buyback.
 
I like how there is so much bias towards an asian company when an american company had the exact same thing years ago.
 
I like how there is so much bias towards an asian company when an american company had the exact same thing years ago.

All of the car companies have this "problem". Its more commonly referred to as "stupid drivers" though ;)

ill have to check that out. surely that is for new cars with all the brakes working properly... which is almost never the case with most cars on the road... but it sounds like i stand corrected i guess!
The article is here: http://www.caranddriver.com/features/09q4/how_to_deal_with_unintended_acceleration-tech_dept

Basically brakes easily win - no contest.

and i suppose if i was in that lexus i would be dead too, because i didnt know you have to hold the button down if its in motion. i would have to imagine if i owned that car it would be something i know though...

Hence why you should just go for neutral - its much easier and quicker to do in a panic. No fumbling about, just reach down to the shifter and shove forward.
 

actually that is more in line with what i thought. brakes DONT easily win. they barely do, and thats only if theyre new.
We also tried one go-for-broke run at 120 mph, and, even then, the car quickly decelerated to about 10 mph before the brakes got excessively hot and the car refused to decelerate any further. So even in the most extreme case, it should be possible to get a car’s speed down to a point where a resulting accident should be a low-speed and relatively minor event.

these people ARE hitting 100mph, and i can assure you they didnt just stand on the brakes- they probably tapped them, rode them on and off for a bit and then tried holding them.... all building up massive heat quickly without slowing down. it only takes seconds to each that thermo limit of your pads and shoes (used worn ones at that!)... so just standing on your brakes likely will not stop you without other action first.
 
same with power steering afaik. its just electric pumps now instead of pulley driven....

More cars are moving to electrically boosted steering-- where the steering rack is actually a linear electric motor-- rather than the old-style hydraulic pump system because it's more efficient: it only consumes power when you're turning the wheel, as opposed to a belt driven pump that is a parasitic drag all the time.

Note, though, that there is no "drive by wire" steering (yet). All power steering systems merely reduce effort, you still have a direct mechanical connection between the steering wheel and the front wheels. If either system fails, it just gets harder to steer.
 
and i suppose if i was in that lexus i would be dead too, because i didnt know you have to hold the button down if its in motion. i would have to imagine if i owned that car it would be something i know though...

Actually, in an interesting case of "good user interface design", Nissan had the right idea: pressing the Start button rapidly several times (as someone might do in such a situation) will shut the car down.
 
36 people die in horrific deaths and this guy turns it into a joke? That's one sick MF
 
actually that is more in line with what i thought. brakes DONT easily win. they barely do, and thats only if theyre new.


these people ARE hitting 100mph, and i can assure you they didnt just stand on the brakes- they probably tapped them, rode them on and off for a bit and then tried holding them.... all building up massive heat quickly without slowing down. it only takes seconds to each that thermo limit of your pads and shoes (used worn ones at that!)... so just standing on your brakes likely will not stop you without other action first.
No. The only car that falls closely in line with your preconception is the Roush Mustang. Which is well known for having an absolutely atrocious brake and suspension package. Roush just jumped up the motor and left the suspension basically stock. Everything else is virtually the same. That car does not have an adequate braking package for itself.

First you were adamant that a car could not stop while the under full throttle. Which is a point you were proven wrong on, even by a car with a lot of power (particularly in the low-mid rpm range where the braking would be occurring at) and poor brakes. How did you go from being pretty much clueless about brakes back to being able to tell the world what brakes can and cannot do?

Brakes don't heat up within a few seconds, the pad and rotor surface will heat up to optimal temperature (best friction coefficient) within a few seconds, but it takes a bit longer to heat up to the point that they're useless. The point that they're useless isn't even the hardware of the brakes, they can keep on chugging -- it's that the brake fluid boils. When the fluid boils it becomes partially compressible (brakes are hydraulic systems).
 
Are you implying that people are naive for buying Toyotas?

I think he's implying that the majority of the buying public are morons who'll believe anything the commercial tells them no matter what it is.


;)
 
Brakes don't heat up within a few seconds, the pad and rotor surface will heat up to optimal temperature (best friction coefficient) within a few seconds, but it takes a bit longer to heat up to the point that they're useless. The point that they're useless isn't even the hardware of the brakes, they can keep on chugging -- it's that the brake fluid boils. When the fluid boils it becomes partially compressible (brakes are hydraulic systems).

do you have any idea how conflicting and wrong you are? have you even changed a pair of pads in your life? once you burn them theyre fucked. you must be thinking of ceramic brakes needing an optimal temperature but even those can overheat and loose friction in seconds. if you dont know that you shouldnt be driving a car.
 
I could just be out of the loop here, but isn't this Toyota thing being blown out of proportion? Weren't they like the biggest car manufacturer in the world? And out of all those cars they sold since 2000ish they had how many deaths because of this? How many serious injuries? I mean the ratio is pretty low there, unless I am missing something. Sounds much more like a problem that seriously got missed than "a company that caused the deaths of entire families and lied about it". Also why couldn't these people put the cars in neutral or simply turn them off?


How is this epic evil instead of a screw up like the Firestone tires, MGs catching fire, or Pintos with exploding gas tanks? I don't want to diminish the fact that people got hurt / died here, but when you sell a gagillion cars and in a decade only that many problems come up it sounds more like a mistake that wasn't caught.


I am a Honda driver, not a Toyota, so I haven't followed it too closely. However, it seems to be a huge deal about something tragic, but not SECRET OMG COVERUP WE WANT TO KILL YOU ALL like the news portrays.
 
Uh, Tom, think you could tone down the rhetoric just a touch ? 15 people died from accidents due to Toyota's current problem. Over 200 died as a result of Ford Explorer roll-over problems in the early 2000s. You can't sell a couple million cars without some going bad. Its not possible.

Buying into the Government Motors narrative about big, bad Toyota is for losers.
 
@MattyC
I was thinking the same thing. Toyota's sold millions of cheap cars, what's their accident/cars produced ratio? And how does it compare to other manufacturers?
 
You have to be kidding me. It is a FACT that Ford intentionally underinflated the tires INSTALLED AT THE FORD FACTORY on their Explorers and as a result 250 people died.

Now I want to see your irrational outrage aimed at Ford. AND because the number of deaths is an order of magnitude higher, I expect to see real outrage.

Really try to stop a car at 100 MPH with the accelerator pedal all the way down chances are you get one try before the brakes take a shit on you.

Also ford does not make tires it makes cars.
 
No fair, facts are not allowed. Only giant freak outs.

Car and Driver came to the conclusion that most likely in all cases the crashes and deaths were due to driver error, and that the reason Toyota is even doing a recall at all is simply to avoid public backlash. Audi faced a similar problem in the 80s, and it was determined that the causes were all driver error. Despite that, Audi sales tanked for 5 years.

Hell, if your Toyota starts accelerating and you panic - hit the brakes. That would be my first reaction, and it would work:
Camry V-6:
70-0 no throttle: 174 ft
70-0 full throttle: 190 ft

http://www.caranddriver.com/news/ca...dal_media_circus_and_stupid_drivers-editorial
http://www.caranddriver.com/features/09q4/how_to_deal_with_unintended_acceleration-tech_dept
 
Nothing prevents the mechanical link in your old car from simply breaking, either.

You are 100% correct. A broken $3 throttle return spring can cause wide open throttle the same as a $3 electronic sensor.

are they claiming the engine wouldnt shut off though with the ignition though? i just havent seen that in the claims...

Yes, people are claiming that.

36 people die in horrific deaths and this guy turns it into a joke? That's one sick MF

That was the whole point of this post...until the internet experts killed the thread. :(
 
What kind prick compares Toyota, a company that caused the deaths of entire families and lied about it, to Microsoft who at best causes people a minor inconvenience on the grand scale of things?

Seriously.. why do you need to use such language? Aren't you educated enough to not have to resort to using street ghetto language?
There is some called a thesaurus if your brain has a lack of proper words to use.
 
do you have any idea how conflicting and wrong you are? have you even changed a pair of pads in your life? once you burn them theyre fucked. you must be thinking of ceramic brakes needing an optimal temperature but even those can overheat and loose friction in seconds. if you dont know that you shouldnt be driving a car.
Yes, actually I do know what I'm talking about. Yes, I do all the work on my daily driver and am rebuilding another car from the ground up with a lot of analysis during parts selection. I've done a lot of brake work, and I've done quite a bit of high speed driving (and thus, braking). I'm not trying to be cocky, but I'm a pretty quick and competent driver on a track.

No, your pads can still be used after overheating. What you're referring to is called "glazing" the surface of the pad material basically liquefies. It's easily fixed by removing the pads and taking a small amount of material off of the friction surface through some manual means, or even letting the brakes cool a bit and then doing some braking runs on an empty road will remove the material.

Not just ceramic pads have optimal temperature. Optimal friction temperature (on a friction-temperature graph) is a property of pretty much all materials, not just certain materials that are used in brake pads. The temperature range is different, but it exists.

All your posts give me the impression that you think brakes a lot more delicate than they actually are. Brakes are very, very tough. If the brakes fade because of a gaseous barrier (continually being reduced in modern brake pads) you can simply lift off for a split second to vent the gas out, and reapply brakes. If the brakes fade because of heat, the friction of the pads will begin to pass the peak of their curve and start diminishing. But the friction doesn't suddenly go to 0. And it takes a lot of braking to boil fluid. I've done multiple laps with tight corners without doing so on pretty standard disk brakes.

Also, the only car that falls in line with your assumptions (the Mustang) is also not the car that's in question. The Camry basically shrugged off the extra burden of stopping the motor at WOT too.
 
Well, truth be told as a US Citizen I'm more of a GM/Chrysler owner than anything else. I understand and appreciate the natural bias of you guys trying to keep your taxes low, but do you really think the extra $100B you'll save us is worth your dignity? :D

Yes, I drive a 2010 Prius - I have experienced the ABS issue (and I can tell you that it is not significant enough to cause an accident unless the accident was already inevitable).


Haha, you drive a Toyota Prius with a "Eat your Greens" Hybrid under the hood. Thanks for polluting just as much as having a normal car as what goes into making such gerbal cars makes more pollution than sticking with the one you got. No thanks


Eco Mentalist are just Stupid people!!!:mad:
 
blah blah blah.

i caught the part about the pads glazing so you just stop your 100mph runaway car by magic and sand the pads down so you can stop... then i fell asleep sorry. points are best said in brief terms.
 
Back
Top