With today's high capacity drives, hard drive failure happens more frequently then it was 5-10 years ago. Is Raid5 still better than non-raid?
Consider these two scenarios:
case 1: with full external backup
case 2: no external backup
In either case, the non-raid appears to be a better solution. I understand you can use RAID6, but RAID6 will have same problem. What if 3 drives die at the same time?....
What do you think?
Consider these two scenarios:
case 1: with full external backup
1) 10 x 2TB RAID5
With this setup,
-- losing 1 drive will require a time consuming rebuild
-- losing 2 drives, all data is lost and I need to replace the 2 drives and then copy the data over from my backup.
2) 10 x 2TB non-raid
With this setup
-- Regarless of how many drive dies, I only need to replace the dead drive and then copy the lost data from my backup. It is fast and efficient
With this setup,
-- losing 1 drive will require a time consuming rebuild
-- losing 2 drives, all data is lost and I need to replace the 2 drives and then copy the data over from my backup.
2) 10 x 2TB non-raid
With this setup
-- Regarless of how many drive dies, I only need to replace the dead drive and then copy the lost data from my backup. It is fast and efficient
case 2: no external backup
1) 10 x 2TB RAID5
With this setup,
-- losing 1 drive will require a time consuming rebuild
-- losing 2 drives, all data (18TB) is lost
2) 10 x 2TB non-raid
-- With this setup, I only lose data on the hard drive that is dead.
With this setup,
-- losing 1 drive will require a time consuming rebuild
-- losing 2 drives, all data (18TB) is lost
2) 10 x 2TB non-raid
-- With this setup, I only lose data on the hard drive that is dead.
In either case, the non-raid appears to be a better solution. I understand you can use RAID6, but RAID6 will have same problem. What if 3 drives die at the same time?....
What do you think?