PS3 and x360s GPU how do they compare to current GPU's?

dwilson041781

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 10, 2004
Messages
1,761
Im curious as far as specs such as eg:

Core Clock 576MHz
Stream Processors 216 Processor Cores
Memory
Effective Memory Clock 1998MHz
Memory Size 896MB
Memory Interface 448-bit
Memory Type GDDR3

Theres a discussion on another forum about the visual quality of the BFBC2 PS3 demo and how the graphics seem crappy compared to the vids that have been shown, I pointed out firstly its the demo and I dont think the "high" textures were included for the demo. Secondly I said the GPU in either current next gen console is dated, but still powerful, so the question came to my mind...How does the PS3 and X360s GPU stack against say GTX260/275/280/285/295?

Figured Id ask the Vid card section vs the Gaming section.
 
The PS3 has a 7800GTX, the XBox 360 has something a bit better than an X1800XT thanks to it having Unified Shaders.

Both suck balls compared to even a 9600GT or 4670, hence why in the more demanding games they don't even render internally at 720p (1280x720), they are just too slow.
 
I know I don't post much and am a "noobie" and all but come on...it isn't just about the power of the GPU unless you want to feel good that, on paper, a modern GPU has a bunch more transistors and shaders etc. Optimization and all games made around the same platform help a ton. My 8800GTX shows just slightly better "graphics" in COD MF2 as compared to the 360 version. Virtua Fighter 5 is running on a 6800 Ultra or GT if I remember correctly because the GPU is optimized around that sole arcade game. So ya, modern GPU's are better but that doesn't mean that a 7800 GTX (ps3 equivalent) will play COD MF2 or L4D 2 at the same settings.....so really not a question easily answered...
 
I know I don't post much and am a "noobie" and all but come on...it isn't just about the power of the GPU unless you want to feel good that, on paper, a modern GPU has a bunch more transistors and shaders etc. Optimization and all games made around the same platform help a ton. My 8800GTX shows just slightly better "graphics" in COD MF2 as compared to the 360 version. Virtua Fighter 5 is running on a 6800 Ultra or GT if I remember correctly because the GPU is optimized around that sole arcade game. So ya, modern GPU's are better but that doesn't mean that a 7800 GTX (ps3 equivalent) will play COD MF2 or L4D 2 at the same settings.....so really not a question easily answered...

The day of hyper optimizations on consoles is pretty much over. A console will get *slightly* better graphics out of roughly the same hardware, but not much (which has more to do with finer tweaking of the game's settings so that it never drops below 30 FPS than platform optimizations). A 7800 GTX pretty much will play MW2 or L4D2 at the same settings as a console. The difference is that consoles render at 1280x720 or LOWER and have pretty good scalers to upscale that to 1080p or whatever output format you want whereas PC gamers always try to play at native resolution which is often significantly higher than 1280x720.

Your 8800GTX will utterly destroy the graphics output of either the PS3 or 360 - and I don't mean theoretically, I mean practically. Drop your resolution to 1280x720 in MW2 and I bet that even with 8xMSAA you will still be well above 60 FPS.
 
.....but that doesn't mean that a 7800 GTX (ps3 equivalent) will play COD MF2 or L4D 2 at the same settings.....so really not a question easily answered...

Actually it does.

Infact I would say the 7800GTX or x1800XT in a PC would run games better than a PS3 or xbox360. I know Mass Effect ran 1650x1080 2xAA on my 1950pro (~1800XT) when the xbox360 version struggled at 1280x720.
 
Your 8800GTX will utterly destroy the graphics output of either the PS3 or 360 - and I don't mean theoretically, I mean practically.

The sad part is that the 8800GTX was released a few days before the PS3. Nvidia either really screwed over Sony, or Sony knew about it and made a really bad choice.

If Sony went with G80 -> G90 (die-shrunk revision of G80) the PS3 slim would have had the equivalent of a Nvidia GTX 250 as its GPU, but I digress.
 
The sad part is that the 8800GTX was released a few days before the PS3. Nvidia either really screwed over Sony, or Sony knew about it and made a really bad choice.

If Sony went with G80 -> G90 (die-shrunk revision of G80) the PS3 slim would have had the equivalent of a Nvidia GTX 250 as its GPU, but I digress.

True and you'd think since they were already losing money on every console sold, it wouldn't matter much if they lost an extra $30.00 to upgrade the bulk 7800s to 8800s. It would have made the PS3 a clear graphical winner versus the 360 whereas currently its a competitor that sometimes loses, sometimes wins. Sony could even then taut the better graphics as being due to the magic power of the mighty fairy-tale that is the Cell Processor. 'Therrroooettically its betterrrrr'.

It would also make that whole ten year plan seem more reasonable. Right now, the PS3 is in its third year. So supposibly, we'll still be seeing new PS3 games seven years from now. Already, PC games are starting to fairly impressively blow away the graphics of the xbox 360 and PC versions. I'd love to see what happens in '4' generations of PC video cards from now(assuming an 18th month release cycle for new generations) versus the PS3s current graphics which won't change much over the next seven years. It'll probably look as dated as the PS2 does now as it's about 10 years old. March 4th, 2000.

IE, If you compare the best looking RPG on PC atm which would probably be Mass Effect 2 with maxed settings on dual or triple monitor compared to say one of the better or best looking RPGs on the PS2 ( ....FFX? X-2?), that's probably how big the difference will be between PS2's best rpg and what the PC has to offer in 7 years if computer technology's development and innovation keeps up at the same rate.
 
Last edited:
The sad part is that the 8800GTX was released a few days before the PS3. Nvidia either really screwed over Sony, or Sony knew about it and made a really bad choice.

If Sony went with G80 -> G90 (die-shrunk revision of G80) the PS3 slim would have had the equivalent of a Nvidia GTX 250 as its GPU, but I digress.

The PS3 was greatly delayed thanks to waiting for Blu-Ray. Even if it was planned to be released then, there is no way Nvidia would have had enough 8800GTX chips for the PS3 launch, nor would Sony have had time to design and implement the new GPU. It also would have cost significantly more.

Remember, the RSX isn't a straight 7800GTX, it was modified. Also, its much harder to switch GPUs in a console - they aren't exactly PCI-E cards after all ;)
 
It would have made the PS3 a clear graphical winner versus the 360 whereas currently its a competitor that sometimes loses, sometimes wins.

<.< It never loses, only ties, and the reason for that is when games are being designed multi-platform for the least common denominator.
 
<.< It never loses, only ties, and the reason for that is when games are being designed multi-platform for the least common denominator.

No, it still loses. The PS3 has a slightly weaker GPU, so unless the devs really try and use the SPEs (which isn't easy), then the 360 will have the graphical edge.
 
The PS3 seems to play almost as good as my computer did when it had the 8800GTS 320mb, which is one step above a 7800GTX. Though I used to play at 1680x1050 instead of 720p like on most console games (80% more pixels)
 
True and you'd think since they were already losing money on every console sold, it wouldn't matter much if they lost an extra $30.00 to upgrade the bulk 7800s to 8800s.

Sure, with consoles you don't have to complete the design months/years before launch. You can just drop in any old GPU at the last minute and it will all work perfectly...... ;)
 
PS3 may have a weaker GPU but now toss in the cell processor that developers are finally starting to use and get get a heck of alot more power out of that console, some games i have been playing i must say look pretty dam sweet, althought some could use more AA (raw vs smack down 2010 anyone)

Also, doesn't matter if the 8800GTX came out days before, it is not like Sony could just said "switch the gpu!" there is planning, power needs, heat, design of the system, it isn't your normal pop in PCIe vid card, it is integrated into the motherboard, total different design.
 
The PS3 seems to play almost as good as my computer did when it had the 8800GTS 320mb, which is one step above a 7800GTX. Though I used to play at 1680x1050 instead of 720p like on most console games (80% more pixels)

Yes, that's the point. Your driving 50% more pixels and getting the same performance with the 8800 GTX 320mb and the pc ports were often poorly coded. Thus 8800 GTS gpu is substantially PS3s GPU.
 
Yeah drop your resolution down to to 1024x600, cap your FPS at 30 and turn your draw distance down to zero and tada you can now run games like a console with ease.
 
PS3 may have a weaker GPU but now toss in the cell processor that developers are finally starting to use and get get a heck of alot more power out of that console

Don't get too hyped on the cell processor. Theoretically it can do a lot but you have to remember that 1 SPE is disabled to increase yields and a 2nd SPE is dedicated to the PS3 OS. So you lose 2/8ths of your theoretical processing power right there. Even then, those theortical processing power amounts are based of a white paper that was made a while ago that involves matrix transformations of 16x16 entries. So how real-world those stats are, still remain in debate.

The PS3's 8 cell processors if working at peak efficiency are twice as powerful as the xbox 360's intel processor, but, its hard to say who would ultimately win when you account for -2 cell processors. If you divide those processing capabilities between graphics to make up for the slower gpu and cpu processing, its arguable whose 'on top' and the mighty cell processor becomes more of a mighty mythical beast.

If you add in the xbox 360 has an additional 12MB memory buffer used to providing AA/post processing effects with little to no cost and UMA(unified memory architecture) such that the cpu or gpu can access the entire 512MB of ram and devide it up as needed, gives more advantage to the 360. Verus the PS3 which doesn't have the said memory buffer and the PS3's non-shareable 256MB for CPU and 256MB for GPU equivilent. There is technically a work-around to get the two memory banks to be shared but involves a reasonable performance hit as there's several extra operations involved each time you load/remove something from memory.

All things being fair, the xbox 360 does have its 'issues' with heat/hardware reliability so it might not matter much if its 5 or 10% faster if its being repaired 5% to 10% of the time.

That being said, both the xbox 360 and ps3 still don't compare to PC gaming graphical wise. So arguing which is better is like two elementary school kids arguing which pokemon is the 'bestest'!
 
Yes, that's the point. Your driving 50% more pixels and getting the same performance with the 8800 GTX 320mb and the pc ports were often poorly coded. Thus 8800 GTS gpu is substantially PS3s GPU.

Meh he said GTS8800 320mb and by the way it was a dog, a 7800gtx is close if not better in performance....your thinking GT or GTX of the 8xxx series but whatever IDC!
 
The PS3's 8 cell processors if working at peak efficiency are twice as powerful as the xbox 360's intel processor, but, its hard to say who would ultimately win when you account for -2 cell processors. If you divide those processing capabilities between graphics to make up for the slower gpu and cpu processing, its arguable whose 'on top' and the mighty cell processor becomes more of a mighty mythical beast.

The PS3 has 1 PPE core + 6 SPEs for developers to use. The XBox 360 has 3 PPE cores (don't know where you got Intel from, but you are mistaken). SPEs aren't really "cores" in typical sense in that they are specialized for FP work, and aren't as general purpose as a PPE or x86 core.

The 360 and PS3 both use roughly the same design for the PPE. Yes, IBM sold Microsoft the design for part of the Cell processor.

Meh he said GTS8800 320mb and by the way it was a dog, a 7800gtx is close if not better in performance....your thinking GT or GTX of the 8xxx series but whatever IDC!

The 8800GTS 320mb dominates the 7800GTX, it isn't even in the same neighborhood as close. You are probably thinking of the 8600 GTS
 
No, it still loses. The PS3 has a slightly weaker GPU, so unless the devs really try and use the SPEs (which isn't easy), then the 360 will have the graphical edge.

You haven't played uncharted 2 have you?
 
You haven't played uncharted 2 have you?

It has fantastic artwork. It isn't using any advanced graphical features the 360 couldn't handle. It looks so good because the artists working on the game are seriously talented.
 
You haven't played uncharted 2 have you?

Uncharted 2 is cross platform and/or is the PS3's only game? News to me :rolleyes:

Since you seem to have a very short memory, here is what you said (you know, for context - its kind of important)
<.< It never loses, only ties, and the reason for that is when games are being designed multi-platform for the least common denominator.
(Emphasis added)
 
It isn't using any advanced graphical features the 360 couldn't handle.

It is using a bunch of processor related featuers that the 360 couldn't handle. Not to mention the feature of blu-ray, increased size capacity resulting in more room for better/more graphics.

Uncharted 2 is cross platform and/or is the PS3's only game? News to me

You realize that rhetorical question makes zero sense, right? PS3 exclusives look better than 360 games, and cross platforms look the same on both.
 
It is using a bunch of processor related featuers that the 360 couldn't handle. Not to mention the feature of blu-ray, increased size capacity resulting in more room for better/more graphics.

Source for the "processor related features"? There was an offhand comment from a Naughty Dog exec about that, but never any actual information.
 
That was my source, actually. lol; Combined with the statement that it uses 90+% of the cells power, and seeing as the cell has twice as many SPE's.. Then add the blu-ray's increased storage capabilities on top of that.

Also, I should say that I definitely went a little overboard when I said "never loses" before. :3
 
Are we really going to stoke up a console war on a PC hardware forum?

The PS3 and 360 are close enough to be basically equivalent, with actual performance based on how well each console's hardware is put to use. The 360 gets better performance in some cases (i.e. Bayonetta) when the port is handled by someone not able to code the PS3 as well. The opposite may be true in some cases (although no examples come to mind).

Both consoles are blown out of the water by even a gaming PC from several hardware generations ago. A modern PC is in a different league entirely.
 
Both consoles are blown out of the water by even a gaming PC from several hardware generations ago. A modern PC is in a different league entirely.

I'm sure we can all agree on this, at the very least. XD It's the reason I'm putting together one to replace my currently 6 year old 2.8Ghz P4, Radeon 9600 Pro Vaio desktop. (I'm sure I'm going to implode after it's built. i7 920, 5850, etc.)
 
I think the Xbox 520 (announced next console by MS about a year ago) should at least have a GTX 285.
 
That was my source, actually. lol; Combined with the statement that it uses 90+% of the cells power, and seeing as the cell has twice as many SPE's.. Then add the blu-ray's increased storage capabilities on top of that.

I'd love to see proof of that 90+% CPU usage claim.

Also, the 360 doesn't have *ANY* SPEs - as I stated earlier, the 360 has 3 PPEs, the PS3 has 1 PPE and 6+1 SPEs (1 reserved for OS). PPEs > SPEs.

It is using a bunch of processor related featuers that the 360 couldn't handle. Not to mention the feature of blu-ray, increased size capacity resulting in more room for better/more graphics.

Or so you claim.

You realize that rhetorical question makes zero sense, right? PS3 exclusives look better than 360 games, and cross platforms look the same on both.

Correction, several cross platform games look *better* on the 360. Also, my rhetorical question makes perfect sense in the quoted context. For the love of god, man, stop ignoring context. Context is extremely important.
 
I think the Xbox 520 (announced next console by MS about a year ago) should at least have a GTX 285.

thankfully for us MS will most likely continue to use ATi since after all ATi did not try to give MS the shaft like nVidia did with the original xbox
 
I'd love to see proof of that 90+% CPU usage claim.
It was said by the same person, unless I'm mistaken.. which apparently may be since I keep screwing up today.

Also, the 360 doesn't have *ANY* SPEs - as I stated earlier, the 360 has 3 PPEs, the PS3 has 1 PPE and 6+1 SPEs (1 reserved for OS). PPEs > SPEs.
Yeah, I really can't see how I made that mistake. I specifically remember reading over it again to make and even fixing a mistake a made.. I think I'm going crazy. :/

Correction, several cross platform games look *better* on the 360. Also, my rhetorical question makes perfect sense in the quoted context. For the love of god, man, stop ignoring context. Context is extremely important.
Yeah, ok it's official; I definitely had a spot of crazy. Reading the same exact sentence without context magically makes sense now. I was using a ps3 exclusive at that point to demonstrate how the ps3 can run superior games that the 360 can't handle; cross platforms are usually dumbed down to the least common denominator, or badly ported. I've yet to see a cross platform game that ran better on the 360; but I guess I could be wrong- due to bad porting and etc? Regardless, the difference then shouldn't be noticeable at all.
 
Well yes, but this would of been better perhaps in the console subforum.

When I posted this question, that came to mind, but I figured I would get much more detailed/better info from the Hardware guys Vs Gamers. My question was answered=me happy. :)
 
Back
Top