Adobe Not Happy With iPad

They don't support flash because of the cost, and the fact that it can't be compiled on arm/custom processors right?

The Arm processor is a issue but there's a couple of more.

1. Flash crashes. A lot. While they didn't directly call Adobe out Apple has mentioned in a WWDC meet a few years back that plugins was the biggest cause of crashes in OSX. Granted it could just be because flash is used often, but hell look at windows. People rag on Firefox and most of it's crashes and memory problems are from Flash, but at least with Chrome it's shielded so that only Flash crashes and not the entire program.

2. Apple wants to own the entire OS. Let's say that Apple wants to drop Arm and go Intel with the Iphone 4G. Then it's only up to them to make sure that everything works in the transition. Adobe's been working on Arm support for Flash for what, two years now? And what Arm devices it does runs on runs it like shit.

People love to forget, Apple in the end is pushing HTML 5 and H264, both a lot more open then Flash. What has that closeness gotten us? exploits every other month that Adobe takes three months to fix and promises that they will support product X later. I admit, Apple has it's problems but I gotta give them props for being basically the only ones taking a stand on Adobe's laxness.
 
They do, Microsoft's global marketing budget is greater than Apple's marketing and R&D budgets combined. As you say, its about effectiveness, and its a side effect of being so massive, just like "big brother" IBM in the 80s that was blindsided by Microsoft. Microsoft spends over 5 billion a year on amazing R&D but the products that they actually release to market generally end up following what Google and Apple are doing.

Whatever they did with the entertainment division behind the XBox 360, they did right. Its lean and nimble and the first real home run with a consumer device that they've ever had. It would be great if the rest of the company could function as nimbly, but at the same time it doesn't really matter to their bottom line because they're going to make a fortune from businesses selling high profit margin Windows and Office licenses to them no matter what.
 
Flash games are the only legit argument here. Website design and interfaces are truly beside the point because similarly robust web interfaces can be made with good AJAX and CSS right now in standard HTML. No web designer worth his salt is going to go with an all Flash interface instead of well coded AJAX or CSS.

Those web interface applications have been going the way of the dodo over the last two years, and this is before we even get to HTML5 which adds video embedding, etc. Vimeo and Youtube already use HTML5, its just a matter of time before other big sites like Hulu also jump on board.

My own portfolio page only has Flash for web video because it has to. The moment enough browsers support video embedding without the need of that piece-of-crap software, its gone.

For now that's simply not being realistic. There are tons of streaming and media sites besides YouTube that are still on it and aren't probably going to change anytime soon. And there's tons of Flash widgets in pages these days. I know that there is an aversion by many to Flash. But I think and honest person could also see that a lot of people also have not major problems with it either, ie, they use develop and deploy Flash UIs.
 
The Arm processor is a issue but there's a couple of more.

1. Flash crashes. A lot. While they didn't directly call Adobe out Apple has mentioned in a WWDC meet a few years back that plugins was the biggest cause of crashes in OSX. Granted it could just be because flash is used often, but hell look at windows. People rag on Firefox and most of it's crashes and memory problems are from Flash, but at least with Chrome it's shielded so that only Flash crashes and not the entire program.

2. Apple wants to own the entire OS. Let's say that Apple wants to drop Arm and go Intel with the Iphone 4G. Then it's only up to them to make sure that everything works in the transition. Adobe's been working on Arm support for Flash for what, two years now? And what Arm devices it does runs on runs it like shit.

People love to forget, Apple in the end is pushing HTML 5 and H264, both a lot more open then Flash. What has that closeness gotten us? exploits every other month that Adobe takes three months to fix and promises that they will support product X later. I admit, Apple has it's problems but I gotta give them props for being basically the only ones taking a stand on Adobe's laxness.

^^^ This. I can support an aggressive push towards open standards that function well over a locked-down standard that doesn't. Ubiquity doesn't automatically mean that a product is deserving of support.
 
For now that's simply not being realistic. There are tons of streaming and media sites besides YouTube that are still on it and aren't probably going to change anytime soon. And there's tons of Flash widgets in pages these days. I know that there is an aversion by many to Flash. But I think and honest person could also see that a lot of people also have not major problems with it either, ie, they use develop and deploy Flash UIs.

People that develop and deploy Flash UIs can (and have!) done well transitioning to doing the same things with AJAX. I understand what you're saying but Adobe has had years to improve their product and it is still as problematic as ever. Browsers like Chrome and Safari have taken proactive steps to prevent Flash cockups from taking down the whole browser. I don't think the browser developers were happy to try and band-aid the problems that an extremely popular third-party plug-in has. :)

It clearly won't happen overnight but it will happen, its inevitable, especially with companies like Apple taking such an aggressive stance against it in their extremely popular mobile devices.
 
They do, Microsoft's global marketing budget is greater than Apple's marketing and R&D budgets combined. As you say, its about effectiveness, and its a side effect of being so massive, just like "big brother" IBM in the 80s that was blindsided by Microsoft. Microsoft spends over 5 billion a year on amazing R&D but the products that they actually release to market generally end up following what Google and Apple are doing.

I think this is selling Microsoft a bit short. They had hand held touch screen devices out YEARS before iPods in the form on the Pocket PC, which to this days is actually fairly functional. Great little MP3 player for instance. One has a remote control interface that's kind of slick but hell their old and collecting dust.

But Microsoft has been a bit lazy and unfocused. I think actually right they have some pretty solid technology and vision going forward. In a way I think the market has defined Microsoft's vision for it and its simple. Excel, no pun intended.

I think Microsoft needs to wow people like it used to. A super Windows 7 release is a good start. A wow bang Windows Mobile 7 release would be awesome as well. Maybe Microsoft is getting its grove back.
 
I think this is selling Microsoft a bit short.

I don't, they lead one category in consumer devices, the XBox 360. They're a distant 3rd/4th/5th when it comes to devices like portable media players (look at SanDisk's Sansa) and smartphones (Apple/Blackberry/Nokia). Culturally and financially, PocketPCs, tablets, etc, have amounted to very little.

There's no question that Windows 7 is a great OS and has been a hit for them, but that and Office are in a different category from their closed-end consumer devices and hardware. I don't think its selling MS short at all to say that they have one hit in that area (the 360, and they killed it) among many misses.

They can do much better given their massive financial and R&D resources, that should be the take-away from my post above. Hopefully they will, competition only makes for better products.
 
There's a body that 'governs' web standards called the W3C. If they haven't published it, it's not a web standard.

W3C doesn't have some sort of supernatural power to decree what is a standard and what isn't. Indisputably, Flash is a de facto standard for web games and other media, regardless of whether some governing body has recognized it.
 
WAIT GUYS!! DO NOT BUY THIS YET!! VERSION 2 IS ALREADY IN THE MAKING!! Reports are out that they have a prototype out right now... at this VERY moment, there are people in YOUR town already trying them out.... ready for this??

The specs....

1. Smaller form-factor(small enough to fit in your pocket) now you won't have to worry about carrying the things!
2. Comes with a camera built-in!
3. Comes STANDARD with sim card slot and allows you to make and receive calls.
4. Does everything Version 1 does, but in this smaller form-factor.

OH SNAP! :p
 
WAIT GUYS!! DO NOT BUY THIS YET!! VERSION 2 IS ALREADY IN THE MAKING!! Reports are out that they have a prototype out right now... at this VERY moment, there are people in YOUR town already trying them out.... ready for this??

The specs....

1. Smaller form-factor(small enough to fit in your pocket) now you won't have to worry about carrying the things!
2. Comes with a camera built-in!
3. Comes STANDARD with sim card slot and allows you to make and receive calls.
4. Does everything Version 1 does, but in this smaller form-factor.

OH SNAP! :p


So...its an iphone? lol
 
People that develop and deploy Flash UIs can (and have!) done well transitioning to doing the same things with AJAX. I understand what you're saying but Adobe has had years to improve their product and it is still as problematic as ever. Browsers like Chrome and Safari have taken proactive steps to prevent Flash cockups from taking down the whole browser. I don't think the browser developers were happy to try and band-aid the problems that an extremely popular third-party plug-in has. :)

It clearly won't happen overnight but it will happen, its inevitable, especially with companies like Apple taking such an aggressive stance against it in their extremely popular mobile devices.

But see I think this kind of serves Apple's self intrest. It's simple, lock out the device to CERTAIN things that will benefit your software and services. Half of these iPhone apps could be written to be cross-platform in Flash.

And despite all of the belly aching, full Flash is going to be on ALL the major smartphones like Windows and Android and certain Symbian devices as well, All but the iPhone.

I think that Apple's stance is simply good business. Sure this is why you have jailbreaking but still Apple is making money on that App Store and I guess AT&T ain't doing that bad sans the on going iPhone service publicity fiasco.
 
W3C doesn't have some sort of supernatural power to decree what is a standard and what isn't.
I'd say they have more authority than us as to what entails a "web standard" and what does not :)
 
I'd say they have more authority than us as to what entails a "web standard" and what does not :)

From a legal standpoint only a governmental body can enforce a legal stand for the most part. Parties can enter into private agreements and that sort of thing but there is no rule of law power there. That said standards committees do play a vital role of getting everyone one the same page but they are slow and lets not forget that there commercial interests involved here as well, no matter how well meaning a standard might be.

As in the case of Flash on the iPhone. As I have said before, Apple's objection to Adobe is a bottom line business decision, just as other companies don't have a lot of love for Adobe as well, like Microsoft, which is now in direct competition with Flash with Silverlight. No business interest there! </sarcasm>

Just keeping it real. I know that Flash content has risk but with the way I see people handle their PCs these days, Flash is the least of their concern. As long as you stay on top of patches and security updates and in general just don't go about installing junk from everywhere not knowing what the hell you're installing. This is the number one source of problems I see. People VOLUNTARILY installing stuff that if they had a virus scanner running (expired Norton subscriptions don't count as protection BTW) would have never been allowed to install without warning.
 
Yeah..well i'm not happy either that my iphone doesn't have FLASH. So if your read this apple....just because your guys hate flash/adobe doesn't mean we don't want to use it.
 
they should really just tell apple to go screw and release it in the jailbreak community instead.

I don't know why they haven't yet done this. They shouldn't need their blessing to get it done if Adobe really wants it. Same with firefox

I think the problem is that Adobe probably shares as much of the blame for the lack of Flash support as Apple does... It might be easier to implement on the iPad, but on less powerful devices it can be iffy, and even if you do it tends to eat battery life like nothing else (which would clash w/Apple's design specs). Flash, as much as we tend to depend on it these days, just isn't a very efficient content format.

I'm pretty sure the reason apple doesn't want flash is they don't want all those flash games and apps taking profit way from the apple appliction store or whatever you call it.

Then there's that as well... But how much money (if any?) does Apple make off each individual App sale, I'm not familiar w/the agreements you enter into as an app developer but I doubt it's much of a money maker for them...The app store, just like iTunes, is there to sell more iPods and iPhones (and keep people from switching to an alternative after they've built up a media collection or the habit of using certain apps).

Flash would still subvert that to an extent I guess... On the iPhone at 'least, but on the iPad there's just no excuse, it has to be fast enough to support it. The problem's probably more OS-based than anything there.
 
The Arm processor is a issue but there's a couple of more.

1. Flash crashes. A lot. While they didn't directly call Adobe out Apple has mentioned in a WWDC meet a few years back that plugins was the biggest cause of crashes in OSX. Granted it could just be because flash is used often, but hell look at windows. People rag on Firefox and most of it's crashes and memory problems are from Flash, but at least with Chrome it's shielded so that only Flash crashes and not the entire program.

2. Apple wants to own the entire OS. Let's say that Apple wants to drop Arm and go Intel with the Iphone 4G. Then it's only up to them to make sure that everything works in the transition. Adobe's been working on Arm support for Flash for what, two years now? And what Arm devices it does runs on runs it like shit.

People love to forget, Apple in the end is pushing HTML 5 and H264, both a lot more open then Flash. What has that closeness gotten us? exploits every other month that Adobe takes three months to fix and promises that they will support product X later. I admit, Apple has it's problems but I gotta give them props for being basically the only ones taking a stand on Adobe's laxness.

This is a great point, and I am a big fan of newer, better, more open standards, but that doesn't change the fact that Apple is still doing simply what Apple does best. There are some educated users who would take the bugs and crashes just to be able to see certain content, but rather than leave it up to the user (such as an advanced option in the settings menu you can turn on only when you need it), Apple decides for you. This is the part I have the problem with.

Put a disclaimer. Say it's buggy at best, and not recommended. But at least let the user decide one bloody thing about the device THEY BOUGHT (or are buying via a data/cell plan)!!!

For crying out loud. You still can't change the background behind your program icons without hacking the device and voiding warranties? Not every Apple user is still in kindergarten.
 
I hate flash but still think you need it for a complete internet experience. Some sites actually use it for more than just annoying ads or stupid flash games...

I agree. I also agree that Flash is not a standard in the dry technical sense of the word, but it's all we've got for now... Until HTML5 and other formats take root, you need Flash support in this kind of device. (not gonna be Silverlight imo, as cool as it is)
 
Its just like when apple put out the iphone and didnt support MMS, sure there was a better option (email), but come on, flash is what, 70% of the web based games and 75% of web based video? MMS had a higher percentage than that and apple didnt support it for years

typical apple, forcing something down our throat. It may be technologicaly better but if you're one of a few that use it while millions use something else, get with the game.

I don't know if they omitted MMS originally because it didn't fit their design theory (or because AT&Tasked them to, or because of some other limitation), but I agree w/the general idea. There's no way around that tho, it's part of the reason some people love Apple devices... They may force standards and proprietary connectors down your throat (along w/the cost), but at the same time they probably do make it easier to use (as long as you use the device how they want you to use it anyway ;) ).

It's also part of the reason why I don't think the iPad will succeed as anything more than a novelty. The market for it is kinda limited imo. Compared to the iPhone at 'least, almost everyone needs a phone these days, not everyone needs a $500 device that does mostly the same thing that a $200-300 device can already do (and a netbook/laptop isn't a necessity for most people either).

P.S. I own an iPod touch (16GB 2nd gen), which I like, and hate at times; and I did pay $5 for the updated OS so I could get Bluetooth (had to wait a whole day after I purchased it too because Apple took the servers down to put up a new version)... And I despise Flash-heavy sites or sites that are based entirely around Flash for navigation (nothing more annoying than hitting a link and watching a status bar for 10s as the entire Flash-based page loads).

I still think the iPad should've had Flash support out of the box, for better or worse.
 
^^^ This. I can support an aggressive push towards open standards that function well over a locked-down standard that doesn't. Ubiquity doesn't automatically mean that a product is deserving of support.

Let's be clear here tho, that may be your reason for deeming Flash support unnecessary, but it's definitely not Apple's, heh. If anything Apple's decision is probably based 90% around the technical limitations of Flash (and that's no one's fault but Adobe's)... It's not efficient, it's not open so it's not hardware agnostic, it's not reliable or secure, etc. I'm pretty sure it also rapes battery life whenever it's implemented in underpowered devices like these.

Those issues are all mostly transparent to the end-user tho, the end-user still wants to view all the video content that's out there now, and play w/e lil' silly flash game he's just been linked to... So in essence Apple is looking out for themselves and the purity of their design, not the consumer.
 
$500 and no flash? jeez.

A $300 netbook has flash. And it also has a webcam, faster processor, more storage, and more expandability...

oh wait, the iPad is "cool"... sorry I forgot
 
A $300 netbook will also sometimes choke while opening Flash content and multi-tasking, now try to imagine how much harder it is to implement on a device that's even less powerful and has a battery that's a fraction of the size... That's the real reason why Apple (and others) have avoided Flash support, period.

To the consumer it still makes sense to have Flash support on their smartphone (let alone on something like the iPad), but Adobe's just as much to blame for the lack of said support as anyone else... And if/when HTML5 (or anything else) overtakes Flash, they'll have no one to blame but themselves too. Until then the consumer's caught in the middle.
 
i don't really care for apple or adobe (corel pwns u) the only win win situation is where they both fuck themselves over
 
I hate flash, I won't use a browser that doesn't have flashblock installed.
 
From a legal standpoint only a governmental body can enforce a legal [standard] for the most part.
I'm not talking about legal standards, heatless.

That said standards committees do play a vital role of getting everyone one the same page but they are slow and lets not forget that there commercial interests involved here as well, no matter how well meaning a standard might be.
Yes, there's a strong commercial interest in enhancing our experience with the web, from which many parties stand to benefit. Adobe apparently no longer has any such interest.
 
I hate flash, I won't use a browser that doesn't have flashblock installed.

So I take it you, and the people like you who hate flash are going to stop coming to hardocp and hardforums right?

Cause if you block flash, you block the advertising on these websties. The advertising which enables Kyle to run these forums free of charge for us. (sans a couple offtopic ones).
 
It's too bad the iPad isn't 64-bit so Apple could tell Adobe to get off their ass.
 
So I take it you, and the people like you who hate flash are going to stop coming to hardocp and hardforums right?

Cause if you block flash, you block the advertising on these websties. The advertising which enables Kyle to run these forums free of charge for us. (sans a couple offtopic ones).

I just checked by running Opera and FF. Ads are the same with flash blocked and not blocked. At least at the moment. I see no Flash based ads on the forum pages.

Other than that it is pretty silly to suggest it's my duty to subject myself to annoying flash adverts.

IMO it's the advertisers duty to get the message and produce less annoying ads, Google picked up on that message years ago and made Billions of dollars annoying people less.

Do you dutifully watch every annoying commercial on TV? Following your logic you should, no channel surfing or FFWD on VCR/PVR.
 
I just checked by running Opera and FF. Ads are the same with flash blocked and not blocked. At least at the moment. I see no Flash based ads on the forum pages.

Other than that it is pretty silly to suggest it's my duty to subject myself to annoying flash adverts.

IMO it's the advertisers duty to get the message and produce less annoying ads, Google picked up on that message years ago and made Billions of dollars annoying people less.

Do you dutifully watch every annoying commercial on TV? Following your logic you should, no channel surfing or FFWD on VCR/PVR.

It's random. Sometimes this forum and the main site gets Flash ads and sometimes it gets AdSense.
 
Do you dutifully watch every annoying commercial on TV? Following your logic you should, no channel surfing or FFWD on VCR/PVR.

I have TiVO (one of the most intuitive DVRs as far as skipping commercials, since it has 30s skip and the FF/RW is very smooth), and I still watch the occasional commercial... If anything the creators of said commercial did something very right in managing to catch my attention even as I FF thru it... A lot of the commercials I end up watching are those that come right at the start of the commercial break too, I wonder if advertisers have picked up on that.

Frankly I've no idea how web advertising has turned into such a cash cow for Google. I don't even have any ad blocking software installed, and I don't think I've ever clicked on a Google AdSense ad. I click the occasional banner ad when it's about a product that really interests me, but that's about it. I've clicked the ad that OCZ has been running for their SSD for instance (and discovered that it takes you right to their Newegg selection of SSD, so I keep clicking it on occasion just to eyeball current prices).
 
It's random. Sometimes this forum and the main site gets Flash ads and sometimes it gets AdSense.

Sites like Tom's are so annoying with their myriad flash adverts on a single page. And it seems like you always have to wait for the flash ads, which are sometimes very large (video, photo slideshows, sound, etc.), to load before you can read the simple text that you're trying to read. Makes browsing on sub par internet very painful on such sites.

Nevertheless, there is a lot of video content out there that you couldn't watch without flash, thus I still wish devices such as iPods/iPhones/iPads at least had some basic flash capabilities.
 
Back
Top