Google Toolbar Violates Privacy Policy

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Some guy says that Google Toolbar still tracks your browsing habits even after being disabled. :eek:

In this article, I provide evidence calling into question the ability of users to disable Google Toolbar transmissions. I begin by reviewing the contents of Google's "Enhanced Features" transmissions. I then offer screenshot and video proof showing that even when users specifically instruct that the Google Toolbar be “disable[d]”, and even when the Google Toolbar seems to be disabled (e.g., because it disappears from view), Google Toolbar continues tracking users’ browsing.
 
Wow, well, my suspicions of their data mining habits are well founded. I'm glad I installed firefox without the toolbar.
 
3rd party browser toolbars are just evil. I dont care who makes them. I uninstall them every time I work on a PC, regardless of actual symptoms.
 
3rd party browser toolbars are just evil. I dont care who makes them. I uninstall them every time I work on a PC, regardless of actual symptoms.

Yeah I never understood the employees who installs Google, MSN, Ask.com, Yahoo and a slew of other toolbars like it makes them top dog or something.

When they complain about their browsers slowing down, I roll my eyes and disable the toolbars and they get all upset "I was using those!"

yeah ok it's like 70% of your screen is toolbars and 30% website.
 
Ughhh I wish there was a way to disable people from installing that crap. I have seen one lady lets call her Earla that had MSN, Yahoo, and Google all installed on the same browser.
 
Just one more reason why I use Google less and less. I use Bing as my default but still use Google since both Bing and Google look certain things up better then the other but the more Google does the crap the less I use them.

"Do no evil" my ass. :mad:
 
I hate toolbars with a passion. This is why I never install them and often remove them from any machines I come across...
 
Yeah I never understood the employees who installs Google, MSN, Ask.com, Yahoo and a slew of other toolbars like it makes them top dog or something.

When they complain about their browsers slowing down, I roll my eyes and disable the toolbars and they get all upset "I was using those!"

yeah ok it's like 70% of your screen is toolbars and 30% website.

Tell me about it. Worse yet, are the clueless users who have like 6 f'in toolbars installed at once (my mother for instance). Yahoo, Google, msn/bing, a coupon toolbar, some crapware toolbar no one has ever heard of, etc...

When asked about it, they state "I dont know how I got it, it just appeared one day".

Isn't IT fun!?!?!
 
I only run one extra toolbar, and that's Stopzilla. Mostly because I'm too lazy to go through the control panel to switch the popup options.

I had to uninstall 5 different toolbars from my mother-inlaw's browser because it looked similar to the jpg above. Their crappy 1024x768 display was half-covered when they were browsing the web.
 
I know how they get installed.
Just go install Adobe flash from Adobe's site. You'll notice that there is a check mark to install a Google toolbar. If you didn't know any better, you would just installed it along with Flash. Same with other programs I've seen out there. It installs the toolbar before it finishes installing the main program.
 
This guy's "comprehensive" testing doesn't include restarting the browser. I wonder what would happen if, perhaps, he had decided to actually restart the browser after disabling the toolbar? Why doesn't it say?
 
I know how they get installed.
Just go install Adobe flash from Adobe's site. You'll notice that there is a check mark to install a Google toolbar. If you didn't know any better, you would just installed it along with Flash. Same with other programs I've seen out there. It installs the toolbar before it finishes installing the main program.

Trouble is the Adobe selection doesn't appear until about 5 seconds after the page loads. You can easily click the "download" button before the toolbar option shows up, which is conveniently checked by default.

Now that's sneaky.
 
Just one more reason why I use Google less and less. I use Bing as my default but still use Google since both Bing and Google look certain things up better then the other but the more Google does the crap the less I use them.

"Do no evil" my ass. :mad:

If you don't think every single thing on the internet tracks you in some way, boy do I feel sorry for you. Yes Google is evil and they are the head of a secret organization to force you to buy more Hot Pockets :rolleyes:
 
This guy's "comprehensive" testing doesn't include restarting the browser. I wonder what would happen if, perhaps, he had decided to actually restart the browser after disabling the toolbar? Why doesn't it say?

Nooooo
Thats laughable!!
 
This guy's "comprehensive" testing doesn't include restarting the browser. I wonder what would happen if, perhaps, he had decided to actually restart the browser after disabling the toolbar? Why doesn't it say?

If you check an option to "turn it off for this window", then close the window, when you open a new window it'll just be back. And it shuldn't require restarting the browser if it doesn't say "changes apply after restarting the browser".
 
If you don't think every single thing on the internet tracks you in some way, boy do I feel sorry for you. Yes Google is evil and they are the head of a secret organization to force you to buy more Hot Pockets :rolleyes:

Oh I know lots of stuff tracks you, but you can also limit the amount of data being mined.

Crap like what Google is apparently doing is flat out bullshit though and I won't support it by seeing their ads go by when I use their search engine. Nor will I turn a blind eye by being a sheep and saying "if you don't think every single thing on the internet tracks you in some way".
 
If you check an option to "turn it off for this window", then close the window, when you open a new window it'll just be back.
As one would expect.

And it shuldn't require restarting the browser if it doesn't say "changes apply after restarting the browser".
Because the changes do apply without restarting the browser. Internally, though, the toolbar keeps sending out requests containing the URL (but with no other personally identifiable information, so it makes no real difference), assumably until you restart the browser.

This is not something to get worked into a frenzy over.

Oh I know lots of stuff tracks you, but you can also limit the amount of data being mined.
No personally identifiable information is being distributed to Google with these requests. Your IP address is not submitted as far as I can tell (looking at the details of the transmission). All Google knows is that a toolbar user visited a URL with a specific browser on an specific operating system.

I don't understand why this is an issue.
 
Google just issued a response to this article, by the way:
"To be clear, this is only an issue until a user restarts the browser, and it only affects the currently open tabs for a small number of users.
Specifically it affects those using Google Toolbar versions 6.3.911.1819 through 6.4.1311.42 in Internet Explorer, with enhanced features enabled, who chose to disable Toolbar without uninstalling it. Once the user restarts the browser, the issue is no longer present. A fix that doesn't require a browser restart is now available on www.google.com/toolbar and in an automatic update to Google Toolbar that we are starting today."
 
Google just issued a response to this article, by the way:

Is it cynical that I just don't believe a word they say? It's not that I'm calling him a liar but I've seen how semantics get twisted in the convoluted chain between the developers, the management and the marketers, and the PR people.
 
Is it cynical that I just don't believe a word they say? It's not that I'm calling him a liar but I've seen how semantics get twisted in the convoluted chain between the developers, the management and the marketers, and the PR people.

You can say the same of reviewers with a vendetta. Remember Vista?
 
Shocker!!! Water is wet: News at 11.

Most toolbars and addons track you. How do you think they pay for development? YOU are the product. Same goes with flash cookies, ip logs, etc etc.
 
Ughhh I wish there was a way to disable people from installing that crap. I have seen one lady lets call her Earla that had MSN, Yahoo, and Google all installed on the same browser.

the problem is people download say Yahoo messenger , or msn, or google somethig and they dont bother to read the installers and click yes yes yes to everything instead of choose to not install the added toolsbars.

Pisses me off more when companies like adobe are asking if i want this crap installed with flash and reader.
 
Pisses me off more when companies like adobe are asking if i want this crap installed with flash and reader.


yeah...it shouldnt be checked as default. ive accidentally installed the yahoo toolbar because of that...never again!
 
phide, the IP address doesn't need to be in the query string for them to track your IP. The HTTP GET is enough.
 
Is it cynical that I just don't believe a word they say?
It's up to you whether you want to believe them or not.

phide, the IP address doesn't need to be in the query string for them to track your IP. The HTTP GET is enough.
I guess you're right. According the toolbar privacy policy:
Any time you use the Google Toolbar to contact Google, such as by sending a search query to Google, the Toolbar sends standard, limited information including your machine's IP address and one or more cookies . This data is retained in Google's server logs and protected according to our general Privacy Policy.
Which means the IP address is stored for 9 months and then "anonymized".
 
Shocker!!! Water is wet: News at 11.

Most toolbars and addons track you. How do you think they pay for development? YOU are the product. Same goes with flash cookies, ip logs, etc etc.
Read the article - it's about the Toolbar continuing to track you even after disabled. That'd be like saying water is wet after it evaporates. :)

Google gets its money through advertisements. You are the potential customer for their customers' products. (They could share usage data, I suppose, but their privacy policy explicitly excludes that.)

Is it cynical that I just don't believe a word they say? It's not that I'm calling him a liar but I've seen how semantics get twisted in the convoluted chain between the developers, the management and the marketers, and the PR people.
There's not a lot of spin possible in what phide quoted. Google calls out the affected versions, provides a workaround, and points to fixed code. Either it works or it doesn't. The original article provides the test. Belief is irrelevant.
 
Read the article - it's about the Toolbar continuing to track you even after disabled. That'd be like saying water is wet after it evaporates. :)

Oh I rtfa'ed it. Point still stands. Nobody should trust the application to do what it the UI says if it was sneaky getting on there in the first place. Just because you click disable or uninstall doesn't mean squat. Any monkey can grey out a box and still collect data in the background.

It is like trusting someone in charge of the treasury who can also give themselves a raise. Oh wait...
 
Toolbars make browsing a nightmare for people who don't know how to disable them. Lucky we all know how and therefore there's no problems with toolbars. On the other hand, google has always tracked us and so have may others. no surprise here.
 
Tell me about it. Worse yet, are the clueless users who have like 6 f'in toolbars installed at once (my mother for instance). Yahoo, Google, msn/bing, a coupon toolbar, some crapware toolbar no one has ever heard of, etc...

When asked about it, they state "I dont know how I got it, it just appeared one day".

Isn't IT fun!?!?!

Thing is, they do attach themselves to other installers and if you're not careful, they can slip in.
 
Thing is, they do attach themselves to other installers and if you're not careful, they can slip in.

Ha! I just had the Java installer default to including the Google Toolbar. Maybe that will stop with Oracle's takeover of Sun.
 
Ha! I just had the Java installer default to including the Google Toolbar. Maybe that will stop with Oracle's takeover of Sun.

It's Google again? The updates 15 through 18 has been Bing and MSN Toolbar for me.
 
I haven't figured out how Sun does it. I installed Update 18 two days ago and it was Yahoo. :eek:

hmm.. random download mirror probably. I just grab the standalone install so I can put it on my thumb drive because I install a lot of computers. Its probably coincidence I always grab the MSN version.
 
Back
Top