OnLive Game Service Preview

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The crew at PC Perspective have put together an OnLive Game Service preview that is definitely worth checking out. The side by side comparison videos used in the article are cool and a great way to showcase the differences between local PC play and the OnLive Game Service.

I don't want to harp on anything longer than I have to here; after all if you read my detailed analysis on the previous pages, you probably already know what I am going to say here. Based on my experience with the OnLive gaming service, it appears to work well for certain types of games. In my testing I found that games that were slower paced, or at least had slower paced input mechanisms, played well enough that I could be fooled into thinking I was playing on a modestly configured local gaming system.
 
The loss of resolution with the compression is just bad. It may be running 720p, but the real resolution really looks to be SD or less. :eek:
 
The possibility of having Onlive built into DVRs, new HDTVs, and a host of other set top devices sounds promising.

However, the system builder in me wants nothing to do with this. But in the end I suppose there are a lot of people that would be brought into the PC gaming world that would otherwise avoid it and to me that is a good thing.
 
The loss of resolution with the compression is just bad. It may be running 720p, but the real resolution really looks to be SD or less. :eek:

720p compressed is still 720p. The resolution does not change. It will have plenty of fidelity loss because of the compression, but that is totally different than a resolution drop. As the service throttles the compression based on the internet connection, the clarity of the game will throttle up and down. On average, it is still a way better gameplay image than anything SD.

The response time to control input is shockingly low. I thought for sure that was going to be the downfall of this service, but they appear to have got it working really well.

The whole question of "Can it play Crysis?" kind of just got tossed out the window. My old P4 might be able to pull it off with this service.
 
This seems like a good service for the casual player. The person who plays 10hrs a week in a non-competitve enviroment. They don't need to spend much and can game on near anything.

But for those of us who play more, there are just too many issues.

A big concern which wasn't mentioned in the article too much is modding and addons. For example, Any WoW player who is even remotely interested in endgame has at least some addons. They are near vital. Also the whole modding experience the PC gets you is out the window.

I definately see this appealing more to the console crowd.
 
Neat technology, that isn't relevent in the market, yet.

It really is the kind of thing that will require more power than the company can showcase.
If this sells for say $199 + monthly fee.

You can buy a local PC for $500-600 that will perform better. Its a toss up then if the line between the two will be wide enough.

Its never something I could adopt personally, but I haven't gamed on a console in probably 4-5 years.
 
Neat technology, that isn't relevent in the market, yet.

It really is the kind of thing that will require more power than the company can showcase.
If this sells for say $199 + monthly fee.

You can buy a local PC for $500-600 that will perform better. Its a toss up then if the line between the two will be wide enough.

Its never something I could adopt personally, but I haven't gamed on a console in probably 4-5 years.

When it was announced I remember them saying the console/box was planned to be cheap and a monthly fee would support the costs. I believe they had even joked about giving the box out for free since there's hardly any hardware in it.
 
I expect this to be a very large thing, once it gets going. It will be used by cable companies as another monthy service they can tack onto your bill, and port directly to your TV through an intergrated box.

For gamers like us? These people will be nothing more then road kill in multiplayer twitch games.
 
I'm having trouble getting past the fact that guy had 89 processes running. I kinda want to take his PC away from him and give him a mac
 
Neat technology, that isn't relevent in the market, yet.

It really is the kind of thing that will require more power than the company can showcase.
If this sells for say $199 + monthly fee.

You can buy a local PC for $500-600 that will perform better. Its a toss up then if the line between the two will be wide enough.

Its never something I could adopt personally, but I haven't gamed on a console in probably 4-5 years.

The little set top box is suppose to be cheap enough to manufacture the CEO has said they could give it away for free if they wanted. For a computer I think it'll be purely monthly fee. Keep in mind you have to buy the games themselves as well in addition to the onlive fee.

Personally I'm a hardware enthusiast so I probably won't be using it, you can forget about it being on the cutting edge of what's possible. (like Novint Falcon compatibility, or Eyefinity)
 
Interesting. Seems 1mbps is going to be sufficient, which is much less than I was anticipating. Hopefully OnLive eventually offers full HD res gaming for those with 5mbps or greater connections.
 
This was a great review in that they showed how the system can perform in the worst case scenario.

The guy's connection to OnLive's servers had higher latency than OnLive would like. It is not the fault of the reviewer and there was nothing he could correct from his location to improve this, but this is the worst case scenario where OnLive still allows the person to play games. I'd like to see this review done in Chicago, Kansas City, Dallas, Orlando, New York, LA, and Seattle. The quality of this service will vary by location. Broad reviews like this are of little value, IMO.

I hope OnLive to works well in Kansas City. I'd love to be able to play games on a cheap netbook while I'm away from the house. I have no expectations that I'll ever be able to play Counter Strike competitively with that lag handicap, but I fully expect to be able to play Half Life 2, Mass Effect, etc. If it doesn't work for that... than I won't have much more interest.

This technology could revolutionize MMOs, though. This is the future of mobile gaming, IMO.
 
720p compressed is still 720p.

No not really. There are multiple reasons why it can appear as a lower rez. One is that almost all compression these days operates through chroma subsampling. The idea is that our eyes are generally less sensitive to colour (chroma) than to brightness. So, sample the colour less. 4:1:1 is a very common chroma subsampling format. What that means is take a 4x4 grid of pixels and sample the brightness of each, however have only one horizontal color sample, and one vertical. Ok that works somewhat, but does give a lesser resolution appearance, and is particularly noticeable for hard transitions like with menus or text and so on.

Also in general, compression can cause smearing of details in movement, because of the way it works with differences between frames. That can lead to an appearance of lower resolution.

This is really an unavoidable problem. The only way to deal with it is to compress less. The higher the bandwidth for your stream, the more detail you get. However for a service like that it means less customers that can use it, more lag (the larger each frame is the longer the transfer takes) and higher encoder requirements.
 
onlive.PNG

:(
 
As long as publishers don't look at this as a one-size fits all solution I can see there being a market for this without it hurting the traditional PC gaming market.
 
This technology could revolutionize MMOs, though. This is the future of mobile gaming, IMO.

I think that this is a very valid prediction as in general the cloud has a mobile aspect to it. Mobility is one of the huge benefits of the cloud.

But there is always going to be technical benefit from powerful local hardware. We now see AMD and nVidia pushing ultra high def gaming with their multi-monitor and now 3D gaming technology.

I think people are look at cloud computing a little simplistically. Will it replace a lot of the desktop? In many important ways it already has. Twitter and Facebook anyone? But now we keep getting more and more technology in local computing as well and there's advantages there and probably always will be. We're going to have a mix of distribution systems, OnLive is just one. But people are still going to want and need raw power, not the least of which would be OnLive itself, and some people are going to want that as well.

For me I'll take a look and then probably pass on it but might reconsider over time.
 
The one thing I am impressed by as far as their beta process and subsequent development goes is their willingness to minimize the test size in order to eliminate external factors. At this point, they're using hardware that is obviously more than powerful enough to do it (as witnessed by the reviewer not being able to use a netbook) and OnLive's beta being restricted to people close to their data centers. In the end, this will allow them to roll out the beta in a tiered process that allows them to properly concentrate on working on single areas of their service at one time with as minimal a set of potential factors causing conflicts.
 
Just like I thought-- input lag is absolutely noticeable. Still looks promising though, but I know for a fact that input lag will ALWAYS be a part of this type of service. It just isn't possible to eliminate it.
 
possible, yes. with radio waves and electricity, no. well figure out quantum communication, dont worry ;)
 
I have no real problem with the idea of OnLive and think it would be pretty neat if the concept worked out eventually... but I'd rather spend money on my own hardware until Onlive can deliver much higher quality video with much less latency. Somehow I don't think that's ever going to happen unless they can get their datacenters into every major city in the world...
 
It doesn't make any sense, because the hardware required to run games at 720p would cost less in the long run than an OnLive subscription...
 
It doesn't make any sense, because the hardware required to run games at 720p would cost less in the long run than an OnLive subscription...

This is another thorn in the side of the cloud. So now I got to pay a middle man for everything instead of owning my own hardware. This is definitely convenient and has its use but it also has to be cost effective as well.
 
I'll say it again, this is MainFrame 2.0 - for somethings works ok, for others, not so good. Honestly - I see more of Quake Live type of system working better as time goes forward.

Sure, most low power netbooks can't run any games today, but as time goes on and hardware get's cheaper and more powerful, that will come to pass. Look at low at low end laptops now - even those can run games now that came out a couple years ago, when the laptops of the day couldn't (in general) when the games originally came out.
 
This is super cool technology. It certainly isn't for me and I actually question whether games are the right application for it, but the fact that its there and that it works reasonably well is pretty cool.
 
I don't really see this going much of anywhere, no matter what, sending this over current IP broadband is not going to be the best. General broadband speed is just not there for most people.
 
Broad reviews like this are of little value, IMO.

This review offers a lot of value. I'm not near an onlive server, so I found the information quite useful. I wouldn't want someone to review that is right down the street and would not offer an experience that I would share also. This offers a worse case scenario and therefore allows me to see what I should expect from this service.
 
What happened to the claims that they violated the laws of physics to make latency not a problem? Guess those didn't pan out? Surprise surprise.
 
This technology could revolutionize MMOs, though.

MMOs actually present number of additional stumbling blocks for OnLive.

MMOs thrive on a large community of players, where there are enough players to populate a server to a healthy number, and the ability to play on a server that is suitable for your play schedule.

This conflicts with OnLive's restricted regional servers. Imagine being locked into a single OnLive-Run server on an MMO, unable to play with any of your buddies who have real computers and are playing on the main MMO servers. The alternative is to ditch the regional server concept for MMOs. The very concept that makes the whole thing viable.

If you're rocking a 200ms ping because you are a West Coaster who plays with a guild on an East Coast server... well... you won't be using OnLive for very long before you've thrown it out the window.

If they go with regional servers, they must deal with the fact that in all likelyhood each region would have one underpopulated server, owing to the niche marketability of the platform itself, and the restricted area from which to draw a player base.

If they let people on the regular servers, or host their own servers accessible by anyone in the country, then they run into quality of service issues.

This is ignoring the bandwidth consumption of prolonged MMO play on the service. Playing an MMO 20 hours a week would eat up 50-70 gigs a week at the bandwidth usage listed in this article and put Comcast customers clearly over their generous 250GB cap, from ONE game. Other ISPs with more restrictive caps would have even bigger problems.

I think that bandwidth caps are the biggest enemy of OnLive, even more than poor performance. A lot of people can look past poor performance, but they can't look past getting their Internet access canned for excessive use.
 
WTB Edit Function. Triple Post for the lose...

Anyway: The other issue with MMOs and OnLive comes to subscription fees. Who gets the fee? Does OnLive run a server? If OnLive is running the servers, does Blizzard/whoever get ANY money out of the deal? What's in it for them? If they are allowing people on the regular servers then it's not as big a deal. People will simply have to pay two subscription fees. The OnLive fee, and the MMO fee.
 
we do not want the industry to move this way. Do not support this!

I certainly don't want this to replace my home rig... but being able to play wow or other games on a phone or super-cheap netbook while on break at work would be an awesome option to have.

It doesn't make any sense, because the hardware required to run games at 720p would cost less in the long run than an OnLive subscription...

Except it doesn't. The chip that decodes the 720p video so quickly cost's OnLive only ten dollars to manufacture. Purpose built hardware can easily decode the 720p content... much easier than a regular CPU.

This review offers a lot of value. I'm not near an onlive server, so I found the information quite useful. I wouldn't want someone to review that is right down the street and would not offer an experience that I would share also. This offers a worse case scenario and therefore allows me to see what I should expect from this service.

This is the problem with the review. Half the servers aren't online yet! By the time OnLive launches, they may have a server with much less lag available in the author's area. For example, right now there is a server in Dallas. I live in Kansas City and my ping to Dallas is around 50ms. However, my ping to Chicago is around 12ms. Distance as-the-crow-flies is not important when computing the amount of lag you'll experience, it's the distance of the pipes in the ground and how much hardware the data has to travel through. This reviewer tested the service without permission from OnLive and is generating very negative press based on data that was obtained without following the guidance of OnLive. It's too early for this guy to make any claims to the performance of the streaming service.

MMOs actually present number of additional stumbling blocks for OnLive.

MMOs thrive on a large community of players, where there are enough players to populate a server to a healthy number, and the ability to play on a server that is suitable for your play schedule.

This conflicts with OnLive's restricted regional servers. Imagine being locked into a single OnLive-Run server on an MMO, unable to play with any of your buddies who have real computers and are playing on the main MMO servers. The alternative is to ditch the regional server concept for MMOs. The very concept that makes the whole thing viable.

If you're rocking a 200ms ping because you are a West Coaster who plays with a guild on an East Coast server... well... you won't be using OnLive for very long before you've thrown it out the window.

If they go with regional servers, they must deal with the fact that in all likelyhood each region would have one underpopulated server, owing to the niche marketability of the platform itself, and the restricted area from which to draw a player base.

If they let people on the regular servers, or host their own servers accessible by anyone in the country, then they run into quality of service issues.

This is ignoring the bandwidth consumption of prolonged MMO play on the service. Playing an MMO 20 hours a week would eat up 50-70 gigs a week at the bandwidth usage listed in this article and put Comcast customers clearly over their generous 250GB cap, from ONE game. Other ISPs with more restrictive caps would have even bigger problems.

I think that bandwidth caps are the biggest enemy of OnLive, even more than poor performance. A lot of people can look past poor performance, but they can't look past getting their Internet access canned for excessive use.

I disagree. First, the OnLive subscribers will game on is located in the lowest latency available to them. For example, in Kansas City, my lag to the soon-to-be-opened Chicago server would be between 10ms and 15ms. If I were playing on a WoW server, I would probably be playing on a server with good latency to Kansas, right? Well, servers with good latency to Kansas also have good latency to Chicago. Sure, if I were trying to play on a server in New York City, I would expect there to be lag. But I wouldn't expect to notice an additional 20ms lag if I were already experiencing a 200ms lag to New York City. I don't believe OnLive will make a difference in MMOs, unless you were competing in some seriously hardcore PvP.

However, I completely agree with your concern for bandwidth caps. I downloaded over one terabyte from TWC this both, but they haven't done anything to my internet connection. I downloaded nearly 500gb/mo from Comcast for three months without issue. However, I don't expect this to last much longer. If cable providers start cracking down on OnLive users, OL is going to be in deep shit.

Not only that, but I am concerned that MMO players would put a very large stress on the service at peak times that would not be worthy compensating for. For example, let's say there are 100 OnLive subscribers. Between 3am and 6pm, there are 10 users at a time on the network. However, between 6pm and 9 pm there are 90 subscribers on, and from 9pm to 3am there are 70 subscribers on. Can we really expect OnLive to have the capacity to run 90 games of Crysis at once if they're only collecting $25/mo from 100 subscribers? I can't imagine that would ever work. However, I want to believe it will and the guys heading this up have the perfect attitude, breaking down every obstacle with a 50lbs sledge of brain power / engineering.

I want to be able to play intricate games on my phone or netbook.
 
Except it doesn't. The chip that decodes the 720p video so quickly cost's OnLive only ten dollars to manufacture. Purpose built hardware can easily decode the 720p content... much easier than a regular CPU.

He's talking about the long-term subscription cost, not the set-top box cost.

I want to be able to play intricate games on my phone or netbook.

Is there any indication they are going that way with the service? They currently don't allow either WiFi or netbooks, according to the review.
 
Is there any indication they are going that way with the service? They currently don't allow either WiFi or netbooks, according to the review.

The service isn't ready to roll out, so it doesn't really matter what it says in the review. The guy borrowed the account from someone breaking the NDA, the test is not run in a way OnLive intended it to be run on their current configuration.

OnLive has already demoed the service on both an iPhone and a Mac laptop. I don't know for sure, but I'm betting WiFi will be permitted eventually.
 
possible, yes. with radio waves and electricity, no. well figure out quantum communication, dont worry ;)

How would quantum communication help? Information cannot travel faster than the speed of light - the speed of radio waves.

Of course, electricity is slower as it cannot approach c.

Regardless, there will be input lag - how noticeable it will be i do not know.
 
Back
Top