AMD Exec Who 'Would Never Buy' AMD

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This is definitely not the type of statement you want to be made public in any court case, let alone one of this magnitude.

Near the top of the document is the most condemning statement against AMD--an excerpt of a 2004 internal AMD communication from former AMD Executive Vice President Henri Richard, the company's then-highest-ranking sales executive: "If you look at it with an objective set of eyes, you would never buy AMD. I certainly would never buy AMD for a personal system, if I wasn't working here."
 
Kind of a silly statement considering it was made at a time when AMD products were as good or better than those offered by Intel.
 
"If you look at it with an objective set of eyes, you would never buy AMD. I certainly would never buy AMD for a personal system,

I dunno, I was pretty happy with my old 6000+

For me, personal system maybe but corporate, no way. To be fair though it's because AMD always gets stuck in the bargain basement systems with supporting hardware that's mostly low end of the value/quality scale.

Still, it shows how useless AMD's management has been over the past 5 years.
 
So if AMD Exec won't buy AMD for their own personal use, it is OK for Intel to pay the OEMs not to buy AMD chips? I don't understand why this statement has anything to do with Intel defense?
 
I have a feeling this statement is severely taken out of context too. AMD was on top back then.
 
Ah, yes, the Core 2 chips didn't come out and wtfpwn AMD until 2006, did they.

Actually the first dual core Intel chips weren't the Core 2's they were the Core Duos like the 800 and 900 series. I know my old 820 had emd 64, 2 cores and was the equal of the Athlon 64 based systems I had around at the time.

:)
 
Kind of a silly statement considering it was made at a time when AMD products were as good or better than those offered by Intel.

1st thing that came to my mind as well. I think I was rockin' an Opty 170 at about that time.

I have a feeling this statement is severely taken out of context too. AMD was on top back then.

Once again, I agree. Makes no sense. Has to be taken out of context.

I would imagine as the head of AMD sales, though, you might just be tempted to say some stupid shit because your tired of the boss calling and asking WTF. How many did we sell today???
 
Actually the first dual core Intel chips weren't the Core 2's they were the Core Duos like the 800 and 900 series. I know my old 820 had emd 64, 2 cores and was the equal of the Athlon 64 based systems I had around at the time.

:)

Don't forget about the Pentium D processors. 2 P4s glues together! Then the A64 X2 game out and pwned them hardcore.
 
Yeah, this is a WTF statement for so many reasons. In 2004, AMD had the better CPUs overall plus as much as you might like the honesty I CERTAINLY wouldn't want this guy working for my company.

And what does this really have to do with the issue at hand? Just so much WTF about this.
 
Don't forget about the Pentium D processors. 2 P4s glues together! Then the A64 X2 game out and pwned them hardcore.

The 820 was a P4 D with emt64. It was still badly outperformed by socket 939 processors in the same price range at the time.
 
Actually the first dual core Intel chips weren't the Core 2's they were the Core Duos like the 800 and 900 series.

Nothing to do with my point, sorry. The Core 2 chips were where Intel went from lagging somewhat behind AMD's offerings to being way the heck out in front...and AMD hasn't really caught up since.
 
i agree on context too.

he was probably asked how good amd was doing from a marketing standpoint. his response: "if i was just a regular guy and didnt know much about the two, i would follow the masses and blindly believe Intel is that much better". just a guess though, it makes a lot more sense anyway.
 
This is just as dumb as the MS exec complaining about their underpowered laptop not running Vista they used in that stupid Vista capable laptop. Once again proving execs generally don't know shit.
 
Old school AMD ruled, I think they got lost in the hype around the madness of the Core line of Intel. Too bad the guy isn't a current employee, he would have gotten OWNED :D
 
There is a link to the pdf in the story. If you read it, it gives a bit more "context" to the statement. Not surprisingly, he make reference to platforms.
 
[H]ocusPocus;1035183007 said:
There is a link to the pdf in the story. If you read it, it gives a bit more "context" to the statement. Not surprisingly, he make reference to platforms.

Yeah they took him out of context more than a little bit. And being honest, while at the time AMD processors rocked, the platform was wobbling around at the mercy of Via, Nv, and Sys. AMD did not have a complete solution like Intel did at the time. They do have one now, and well they also have greater market penetration now with slower tech than they did then with the fastest tech going. Go figure...
 
i was still in the socket a days at that time...sigh. i totally missed the 939 and went to core 2 duo.
 
Full block of text from the PDF:

In 2004, AMD Executive Vice President Henri Richard, the company's highest ranking sales executive, declared internally that "(i)f you look at it, with an objective set of eyes, you would never buy AMD. I certainly would never buy AMD for a personal system if I wasn't working here." Mr. Richard also declared that [TEXT BLACKED OUT]".

Mr. Richard described AMD as "pathetic" or "selling processors rather than platforms (as Intel did) and exposing a partial story, particularly in the commercial segment, that is clearly inferior to Intel's, if we want to be honest with ourselves." He added that AMD is saddled with a reputation that "we're cheap, less reliable, lower quality consumer type product."

So he's talking about what AMD's strategy was at that time, along with consumer perception. Sadly, it can be taken way out of context with just the one line.
 
And being honest, while at the time AMD processors rocked, the platform was wobbling around at the mercy of Via, Nv, and Sys.

The chipsets from that time weren't bad. Up until recently my mom was still using a system I built around then with a socket 939 Athlon 64 3000+ and a VIA Chipset motherboard. Rock solid system and dirt cheap to build, never had a problem with it.

I'd say the real problem (and what this marketing clown may have been referring to) is their mobile segment. I've never been terribly impressed with any Turion notebook.
 
The chipsets from that time weren't bad. Up until recently my mom was still using a system I built around then with a socket 939 Athlon 64 3000+ and a VIA Chipset motherboard. Rock solid system and dirt cheap to build, never had a problem with it.

I'd say the real problem (and what this marketing clown may have been referring to) is their mobile segment. I've never been terribly impressed with any Turion notebook.

My mother actually inherited a system just like that one about 6 months ago (yeah I rocked s939 and AGP 'till then). To be honest I was wary of going w/a Via mobo when I bought it (rather than NV), but that ASUS A8V was rock solid... I think it had more to do w/ASUS' implementation than VIA's chipset tho.

Maybe Fusion will have some potential in the mobile market, where AMD has always been lacking.
 
So if AMD Exec won't buy AMD for their own personal use, it is OK for Intel to pay the OEMs not to buy AMD chips? I don't understand why this statement has anything to do with Intel defense?

no one was making an intel defense. you simply projected right here.
 
Kind of a silly statement considering it was made at a time when AMD products were as good or better than those offered by Intel.
2004 was before the A64 X2. The A64s were nice, but it wasn't until the X2s that AMD had the clear lead.
 
2004 was before the A64 X2. The A64s were nice, but it wasn't until the X2s that AMD had the clear lead.

I thought they pretty much had the lead in performance/watt, performance/Hz, and performance/$ from the original Athlon back in '99 up until the Core's started coming out?
 
2004 was before the A64 X2. The A64s were nice, but it wasn't until the X2s that AMD had the clear lead.

The Athlon 64 was cheaper, cooler, and more powerful clock-for-clock than the P4. I'd call that a lead.

I built my first computer completely on my own around the time socket 939 came out. I remember being surprised at how much people here complained about Intel sucking, that's what pushed me into building a socket 939 system. My dad had always been something of an Intel fanboy and I had been taught that AMD only made cheap knock-offs. :D
 
The chipsets from that time weren't bad. Up until recently my mom was still using a system I built around then with a socket 939 Athlon 64 3000+ and a VIA Chipset motherboard. Rock solid system and dirt cheap to build, never had a problem with it.

I'd say the real problem (and what this marketing clown may have been referring to) is their mobile segment. I've never been terribly impressed with any Turion notebook.

He may have been talking about the mobile segment, and I was not implying that all the made for AMD chip sets sucked. I just took it more along the lines of AMD not being able to make any credible guaranties regarding availability, pricing, or fitness for a task on products they did not make. Like Sys, Via, or Nv chip sets. AMD's own chip sets were few and far between back then. Intel could make promises and give guaranties that were believable because they had control of the chip sets, and even motherboards for their processors.
 
Full block of text from the PDF:



So he's talking about what AMD's strategy was at that time, along with consumer perception. Sadly, it can be taken way out of context with just the one line.

Thanks for providing that. Really shows how far out of context that single line was. And in that respect he was correct, AMD as a platform was more confusing and less appealing looking than Intel's wholly integrated platform. And, yeah, really AMD was selling chips at the time and not a platform. It's really good they have their own in-house platform again now as that makes it much more appealing.
 
lol, fantastic example of Foot in Mouth disease.
Muppet.
 
The Athlon 64 was cheaper, cooler, and more powerful clock-for-clock than the P4. I'd call that a lead.
And the original K7 Athlons before them are not to be forgotten.

AMD produced a pretty solid technological advantage throughout that era and while they grew the business, they weren't privy to the sort of dominance that their technology could have offered. The reference to selling platforms, not just processors is, with context, very accurate to the problem they faced once they had acquired a sizable market share. They had charmed the gamers and enthusiasts, but they'd long had their fans. What of regular consumers, of OEMs and businesses? What about selling two products instead of one? To really compete with the big dog, they had to master the big sales.
 
I thought they pretty much had the lead in performance/watt, performance/Hz, and performance/$ from the original Athlon back in '99 up until the Core's started coming out?
The original Athlons were little furnaces. It was only when Prescott bombed that AMD was able to start handing out oven mitts.

Nobody cared about performance/Hz besides AMD fanboys. I don't care what frequency the chip runs at, as long as I have more performance.

Performance/$ was AMD's saving grace. Cash-strapped kids could buy them and build a decently performing PC, and get further value by overclocking it. The P4 still held a performance lead until the A64, especially with the Northwood-Cs.

The Athlon 64 was cheaper, cooler, and more powerful clock-for-clock than the P4. I'd call that a lead.

I built my first computer completely on my own around the time socket 939 came out. I remember being surprised at how much people here complained about Intel sucking, that's what pushed me into building a socket 939 system. My dad had always been something of an Intel fanboy and I had been taught that AMD only made cheap knock-offs. :D
For single-task, single-threaded workloads that required raw speed (read: gaming circa 2003), the A64 did hold an impressive lead - and that was good enough for most people here, because game benchmarks were generally all they looked at. The P4, however, still held its own in areas like video and audio encoding and multitasking, and especially anything multi-threaded. Intel's chipsets were also hands-down more reliable than anything ATi, nVidia, VIA, or SIS had to offer.

I used the PC of a friend who got a 3000+ or a 3200+ (can't remember), and everything was much less smooth than my aging 2.6C. This was a fresh installation of XP, without any crap installed on it. I'm sure his PC pwned mine at SuperPi, and enjoyed a slight FPS lead with the same graphics card, but for daily use my desktop was much smoother to use. Hyperthreading really was the Pentium 4's saving grace.

I remember when the Intel forum was so dead you could see the tumbleweeds blowing, and someone would pop in and ask a few questions about an Intel build they were making. It would go something like this:

OP: Hi guys. I'm building a computer which will primarily be used as a video encoding workstation, and I have a few questions about which chipset would be best...

User1: Have you been living under a rock? The A64 has had the lead for months now...

User2: Yeah dude my games all got twice as fast when I upgraded to AMD!

User3: Here's some benchmarks so you can decide for yourself... <link to game benchmarks>

OP: That's all really nice, guys, but I'm building this PC for video encoding. The P4 still has a lead over the A64 with the codec I plan to use: <link to supporting benchmarks>

User4: The chipset you want is i875. Don't get a Prescott, as they're slightly slower and produce much more heat.

OP: Thanks!

User5: OMG U NOOB DONT U KNOW THAT AMD PWNS INTEL IN EVERY GAME EVER MADE EVEN SOLITAIRE???

Then the A64 X2 came out and there wasn't a single benchmark Intel won. Intel's lead in video encoding and the other few benchmarks they still won was gone. AMD's single-die dual-core solution vastly outperformed Intel's dual-die solutions. They even implemented hyperthreading on the Extreme Editions, but the return was sharply diminished from their single-core solution.

And then Intel, having fully realized by now that leakage heat and other engineering difficulties had scrapped their plans to reach 10 GHz, they took a step back, threw all their engineers at the Pentium-III derivative their Israeli team had created for the mobile sector, and the beast known as Conroe was born. The rest is history.
 
that was the time when my a64's was rocking the p4's.

Still remember my 754 2nd sys at 2.8 g air :D certanly pissed off some with p4's at twice the price.

Still, i dont know how to make cheaper ESXi servers than A II X4 620! :D
 
The guy probably just doesn't know fuck about processors and was just like every slowpoke on the intel wagon in those years. Things have changed of course, but that's the only thing I can think of that explains someone saying, essentially, that AMD wasn't as good as Intel in 2004.
 
The chipsets from that time weren't bad. Up until recently my mom was still using a system I built around then with a socket 939 Athlon 64 3000+ and a VIA Chipset motherboard. Rock solid system and dirt cheap to build, never had a problem with it.

I'd say the real problem (and what this marketing clown may have been referring to) is their mobile segment. I've never been terribly impressed with any Turion notebook.

I loved my AMD64 3800+, built with the nForce 2 chipset. Also about the last time nvidia still had their shit completely together.

Went to Core2Duo. Was never really wowed. Wasn't enough of an improvement over what I had before considering the cost.

Went back to AMD with the Athlon II. Quadcore for under $450? Sold!

AMD may not be on top right now, but they're still making solid chips. I'm not the type to spend an extra $2500 on a setup for bleeding edge... especially when I can wait 12 months and build something similar for about 6 times less.
 
The chipsets from that time weren't bad. Up until recently my mom was still using a system I built around then with a socket 939 Athlon 64 3000+ and a VIA Chipset motherboard. Rock solid system and dirt cheap to build, never had a problem with it.

I'd say the real problem (and what this marketing clown may have been referring to) is their mobile segment. I've never been terribly impressed with any Turion notebook.


they didnt start using the turion brand name til 2006-7 i believe.. before it was the socket A xp mobile processors.. they went from socket A to am2 in the mobile market.. the old xp-m processors were bad asses though.. i still have an old compaq presario 2100 with an athlon xp-m 2400+.. that laptop refuses to die.. they sure dont make laptops like they use to..
 
Back
Top