New Anti Global Warming Scheme

Very few people on this forum have any knowledge beyond propaganda they hear - be it in TV, magazines, huffington post, drudge report, whatever.

Uh, pretty much everything you see in the media is actually PRO global-warming.

Rarely do you see anyone question it out of fear of being called an idiot.
 
Regardless of whether "global warming" is caused by us or not, reducing pollution and emissions is a benefit to everyone anyway. Pollution smells like shit.
 
Uh, pretty much everything you see in the media is actually PRO global-warming.

Rarely do you see anyone question it out of fear of being called an idiot.

and by Pro global warming I mean "man made global warming"

sorry, no edit button.
 
Truth is independent of who's getting paid, fools

And here my teachers always told me "Perception is reality".

Fucking liars
 
Regardless of whether "global warming" is caused by us or not, reducing pollution and emissions is a benefit to everyone anyway. Pollution smells like shit.

The problem is they are going FAR, FAR beyond pollution concerns. It's now almost become a religion. It's about saving the earth and punishing the carbon dioxide sinners.
 
Oh and I suppose the Glaciers aren't melting and the North Pole has lots of ice and houses up near the Arctic Sea aren't falling in cause the permafrost is melting into goo.
If anyone here questioning Global Warming (mind you, not man made, just warming), go to Glacier National Park, look at a depictions of the glaciers 100/75/50/25 years ago, and then hike up to a glacier. Not only is it one hell of a good time, it's a pretty persuasive argument.
 
The problem is they are going FAR, FAR beyond pollution concerns. It's now almost become a religion. It's about saving the earth and punishing the carbon dioxide sinners.

Almost a religion?
Shit, these "scientists", and I use that term loosely, act more like inquisition era priests than men of science. "Burn the unbelievers, and blasphemers at the stake. We have proven global warming, why because we say so. No you can't see the data, only the high priests of the Global Warming Church have the intelligence and holy right to survey and interpret such knowledge."

And to top it off, without peer review, publishing complete methodology and all data, hiding contrary evidence, and actively attempting to silence dissenting views, they are essentially asking us to take it on faith. I can't say one way or the other if man is causing global climate change. But how am I to believe their view point on it when they behave in such ways?
 
The problem is they are going FAR, FAR beyond pollution concerns. It's now almost become a religion. It's about saving the earth and punishing the carbon dioxide sinners.

Then start learning how to drink salt water, depending on where You are, I'm sure It's coming to a cliff near You, In fact Its 12' from one apartment building, their putting 4-8 ton boulders in by crane to save those apartments, If that's propaganda then I'm sure there's a bridge in Alaska that's for sale.
 
Erosion happens. Those houses are fucked due to shitty urban planning moreso than any kind of climate change.
 
Then start learning how to drink salt water, depending on where You are, I'm sure It's coming to a cliff near You, In fact Its 12' from one apartment building, their putting 4-8 ton boulders in by crane to save those apartments, If that's propaganda then I'm sure there's a bridge in Alaska that's for sale.

Like I said before, I don't have a problem with anyone saying the earth is warming up. It's when people start saying it's OUR (every country that doesn't live in a mud hut) fault.
 
Erosion happens. Those houses are fucked due to shitty urban planning moreso than any kind of climate change.

Oh yea, and this.

Who the hell would build their house on the edge of a cliff? Especially a cliff with water beneath it.
 
If anyone here questioning Global Warming (mind you, not man made, just warming), go to Glacier National Park, look at a depictions of the glaciers 100/75/50/25 years ago, and then hike up to a glacier. Not only is it one hell of a good time, it's a pretty persuasive argument.

And guess what? Those Glaciers didn't just materialize out of thin air either, they've been growing, and receding, for millennia. Look at many of the great river valley systems in the world and you'll find that glaciers did the bulk of the work cutting the land. Why did the glaciers recede in the past when there were no Hummer's spewing CO2?

My point is, that your point of "look at it now, compare it to 100 years ago" is a specious argument. Lots of glaciers are actually growing today, but they don't make the news because that doesn't fit the template. Glaciers are always growing and receding, just like climate is always changing. To think that we live in a utopian stasis of climate that has always been like this is to ignore at our own peril the voluminous data that shows climate has been changing dramatically on this planet since the dawn of time. To think that we could, in a matter of years somehow alter that process is the height of arrogance. It is the same arrogance that lead us to believe 500 years ago that the Earth was at the center of the universe. Everything has to be about us, doesn't it?
 
We've taken on a lot of other things on faith, what's the problem with taking on one more?
 
We just need to buy Earth some really nice UV protective sunglasses. I suggest Oakley's. Now the real question is, which style fits Earth...do we do the Flak Jacket or maybe the Nanowire?
 
And guess what? Those Glaciers didn't just materialize out of thin air either, they've been growing, and receding, for millennia. Look at many of the great river valley systems in the world and you'll find that glaciers did the bulk of the work cutting the land. Why did the glaciers recede in the past when there were no Hummer's spewing CO2?

My point is, that your point of "look at it now, compare it to 100 years ago" is a specious argument. Lots of glaciers are actually growing today, but they don't make the news because that doesn't fit the template. Glaciers are always growing and receding, just like climate is always changing. To think that we live in a utopian stasis of climate that has always been like this is to ignore at our own peril the voluminous data that shows climate has been changing dramatically on this planet since the dawn of time. To think that we could, in a matter of years somehow alter that process is the height of arrogance. It is the same arrogance that lead us to believe 500 years ago that the Earth was at the center of the universe. Everything has to be about us, doesn't it?
Yeah... I'm talking more about the rapid increase in how quickly they're receding. And were you talking about all those glaciers that formed during the ice age and aren't here anymore? Think that has something to do with them being near the equator, so they receded before we ever entered the picture? The glaciers I'm talking about are mid-latitude that receded quite smoothly until the 20th century when they started disappearing rapidly.

I really hope the rest of your post wasn't inspired by mine, because I'm not sure where the fuck you were going with it. Especially since I said "(mind you, not man made, just warming.)"
 
The nut job wants to create acid rain? WTF!!!!!

The USA has been removing SO2 for over 40 years from our coal fired power plants to prevent acid rain. About 60% of the coal fired power plants in the USA have SO2 scrubbers and in 20 years the rest will have the pollution equipment installed.

Let's not give the nut case tax dollars money for his terra forming project let's just shut down the pollution control systems. WTF!!!!!!
 
Global Warming arguments aside, the premise that 'tinting' the atmosphere will somehow help us is rather ill advised.

Following 9/11, when air traffic was grounded, it was found that sun intensity reaching the surface peaked in the northern hemisphere. Following this surprise, studies into evaporation rate and sun intensity over the years were initiated. The conclusion, thanks to decades and decades of evaporation rate records kept by farmers worldwide, was that the smog in the northern hemisphere has been 'putting off' some of the effects of global warming because by acting as a sunscreen. Recently, it has been found that there is a northern 'ring' of pollution around the northern hemisphere, and as a result, average/cumulative sun intensity in the southern hemisphere is actually higher than in the north (less industry in the southern half of the world, and the two airstreams dont cross).

While this might be seen as a good thing by some, its causing problems elsewhere. Most of the life on this planet, most of the oxygen production, most of the CO2 consumption, etc... is BELOW SEA LEVEL. 'Global Dimming' is contributing to the death and decline of corals, and inhibiting photosynthetic organisms' ability to consume CO2. This contributes to a nasty cycle where the end result is more and more CO2, and less and less biomass to handle it. Put it this way... less light = less photosynthesis = less CO2 uptake = more problems.

I could care less about Global Warming. I think its too political and that makes it a disadvantage to even bring up. The fact that even arguing it seems to make it lose credibility is tragic. The 'anti' crowd often uses the argument that 'you cant tell what will happen in the future' as a valid argument (where was that argument during the arms race?), and even stooping to any level to respond to that idiotic logic drags you down enough to let them win. No, we CANT predict the future, but I hardly call that a valid reason to throw caution to the wind and start acting like idiots. This apparent 'wining argument' then gets tossed around as proof of all environmental awareness being a scam.

But put 'Global Warming' aside... hell, lets just say that the doubters are right... fine. I can give them that because its just ONE issue. They are forgetting all of the other environmental issues that demand our attention... oceanic acidification, rising sea levels, smog, pollution, etc... hundreds of other CLEAR AND PRESENT DANGERS to our environment and mankind that can be directly linked to our actions and are documented. Just because the doubters could seemingly win one argument about global warming does not mean that the environment is fine otherwise. Not every bit of pollution is as obvious as Charnobyl. Perhaps we 'environmentalists' should have kept our mouths shut and let the oil burn dirty for longer to have an even more obvious problem now that more would feel is a real concern... but humans have done a good job of 'masking' pollution over the years. Its a bit like the druggie who wont admit there is a problem until they get to the point of no return, or the teenage kid who leave clothes over the floor but wont do laundry until you can no longer see the floor in the room. Still, to those IN THE FIELD, those WE SHOULD LISTEN TO, the environmental pollution concerns are spread across a very wide area and are very real. So fine, lets put global warming aside... maybe 'we will see' is a better way to approach it. In the meantime, anyone want to tackle oceanic acidification or one of a hundred other environmental issues and tell me its 'all just a farce' still? I have a Marine Biology and Engineering background; IMO, I think the human race will hang itself on oceanic acidification long before we cook ourselves to death. Destruction of our oceanic life is a current problem that usually has sudden and catastrophic consequences... as in 'one day I woke up and it was all dead' type of consequences. If the oceans die (or more so, the reefs), the planet is done. If we ignored the ocean all together... I give us a couple decades until there isnt enough oxygen left for us to breathe.

Even if you are not very 'environmental' (hell, maybe you prefer concrete to trees and smoke to fresh air), the economic and resulting political impact of sending a billion dollars a day to the middle east (a place where these people who dont like America seem to always come from and get their money from for some reason) for oil has put the nation at risk. There is an assumption that 'green tech' means lost jobs and more expense for businesses. Really? What about all the jobs that green tech creates? Those same people that say 'you cant tell what will happen in the future' should realize that that same argument applies to their assertion that 'going green' will hurt business. Its an 'assumption' and it 'sounds good', but its not all 'sound & good'. It is more likely that 'going green' could actually create more jobs and be the 'next big boom' than anything. Businesses had to buy computers in the past few decades to compete... you dont see them bitching about spending all that money now, do you? So now green tech is their 'next great investment'... so what?!?!

Here is an interesting article by a peer of mine. Good readin'...
http://reefbuilders.com/2009/12/16/eric-borneman-pussyfoot-issues-global-climate-change/
 
The current science behind global warming has not even faced peer review outside of their religion, let alone been proven.

Understanding of PEER review fail train boarding in 3...2...1

Maybe we can have medical research vetted by atstronomers. And structural engineering work reviewd by neurologists! That would be AWESOME!
 
And one more thing: hasn't this 'tard seen Highlander 2? If this idea (roughly) was used in such a monsterously shitty movie, then how can it even be considered?
 
"Burn the unbelievers, and blasphemers at the stake. We have proven global warming, why because we say so. No you can't see the data, only the high priests of the Global Warming Church have the intelligence and holy right to survey and interpret such knowledge."


Here folks is the perfect example of the loon rant: imaginary quotes used to back their position. Next up: cherry picking snippets of science they do not have the experience/education to understand, followed by expert quotes from AM radio hosts.:rolleyes:
 
All of the volcanoes that erupt on earth create more CO2 than we could ever create as a species.
 
So I don't see why people are running around headless trying to "fix" it.
 
its all about the money.. you really think how much government funding some of these scientists are getting.. this whole global warming crap has become way to commercialized thanks to Al Gore's sorry ass..

as for the idea.. its a good short term fix.. until 60 years down the road when all that sulfur starts falling back to the earth..

the day the temps actually rise where i live ill believe global warming is actually happening.. in the last 6 years the avg temp in northern california has dropped.. not gone up.. 6 years ago we had 32 days of 100+ degree temps during the summer.. last year we had 5 days of 100 or more.. year before it was 8 days.. 11 days the year before that and 14 the year before that.. so if this is global warming.. i hope it keeps happening..

In Phoenix we've been getting less rain and more 100 degree days that start popping up in April. This year was no different with the last 100 degree day showing up on October 2nd. We've been in a drought for roughly 10 years so if we get 2 inches of rain everyone acts like Noah should be waxing up his boat.

I'm no meteorologist but it's a hell of a lot hotter and drier more often than it was 20 years ago. A big part of it are all these moron developers that put up concrete tombs and subdivisions everywhere creating huge heat islands that just make a hot day hotter. That's where your 100 degree night temperatures come from. All that asphalt and concrete is pumping heat it absorbed during the day back into the atmosphere at night.

So to some degree, yeah we are responsible for our own hell but I don't completely buy the global warming alarmist argument either. What I DO buy is the argument to get off of an addiction to oil that we're forced to buy from people who still believe beheading is humane capital punishment.

If switching to renewable forms of energy does nothing more than get rid of the brown cloud, put our own people back to work and get us off OPEC's tit then I'm all for it. Saving the atmosphere is just a bonus.
 
There is no global warming......duh!

It's obvious that going to either extreme is childish and irresponsible. The next glaciation is close. That doesn't means we're not speeding it up. Earth had never been exposed to this input before. If you look at its history you'll realize it is an Underdamped system and that it will stabilize itself. That's the problem with both points of view, they're both stupid.
 
Here folks is the perfect example of the loon rant: imaginary quotes used to back their position. Next up: cherry picking snippets of science they do not have the experience/education to understand, followed by expert quotes from AM radio hosts.:rolleyes:

I don't need to see the data. I just need to remember, which is the same reason why people never learn from their mistakes and screw it up.Let's say 80% of Intelligence is using your memory.
 
If we are to do this, I'm sure 20 years down the road we'll discover that it is really bad to pipe stuff out of our atmosphere... there has to be some "side effects" for doing something like that.
 
Understanding of PEER review fail train boarding in 3...2...1

Maybe we can have medical research vetted by atstronomers. And structural engineering work reviewd by neurologists! That would be AWESOME!


Maybe we could have it looked at by other scientist in the field that have not already made up their mind, or as it seems to be anymore, have not had grant money make up their minds for them. This thing they have going on where only other believers get to peer review them, or they throw a fit and hide the research, (take their ball and run home), makes me wonder. They are giving the appearance of a impropriety. That does not make you wonder at all?

As for the FAIL comment, well, it fails. Don't stand on the tracks.


Here folks is the perfect example of the loon rant: imaginary quotes used to back their position. Next up: cherry picking snippets of science they do not have the experience/education to understand, followed by expert quotes from AM radio hosts.:rolleyes:

It was meant to be funny, I failed. However, can you say they are not acting like that? If they think there is a possibility of dissent, they run away with the data, or strong arm. I have already said, I have no clue whether or not humans are contributing in any serious way to climate change on a global level. Only that these supposedly respectable scientists are not acting the role, but instead are acting like this is some kind of church where any dissent is blasphemy. It makes it difficult for me accept what they say with out the proverbial grain of salt.
And I most certainly do not want people, I have come to seriously doubt, to ACTIVELY attempt to alter our climate. Reduce CO2 emissions, and pollution, sure why not, it's a great idea, perhaps even needful. Attempt to alter our climate intentionally, with some crazy contraption that shoots crap into the air, uhh no thanks.
 
All of the volcanoes that erupt on earth create more CO2 than we could ever create as a species.

Considering you dont take into consideration anything with respect to time with that argument... yes, you could argue that if all the volcanoes in the world erupted in one day that yes... there would be more CO2 put into the atmosphere that day by volcanoes than by mankind... sure... you could somehow make that statement true. However, volcanoes dont erupt every day like we drive our cars every day. Also, that argument lacks a logical base other than personal opinion. The Earth has mechanisms to handle the CO2 that it is used to encountering, a system developed over thousands of years... so to use volcanoes as an excuse doesnt work unless you are asserting that there was no balance before mankind started adding more and more. Volcanoes didnt just pop up in since the industrial revolution you know... Even if human pollution was say, responsible for only 1/10th of what volcanoes contribute, if it is that 1/10th that tips the balance to cause problems I fail to see how a comparison to volcanoes is relevant.

OTOH, if that statement were significant enough to be relevant then we would not be seeing the highest recorded CO2 levels in the past 100,000 years in just the past few decades. Glacier core samples provide a 'sealed historic record' of thousands of years worth of CO2 buildups and declines.
 
I don't need to see the data. I just need to remember, which is the same reason why people never learn from their mistakes and screw it up.Let's say 80% of Intelligence is using your memory.

Dont bother. Read that link that I posted and you will see why...
"I could offer personal data, personal observations, but there is no convincing some people. The real crux of the matter is largely one that exists in the US. Our understanding and level of science education is so low, and the topics of anthropogenic climate change so diverse and complex, that I have found arguing to actually give credence to debate that doesn’t exist. Those who don’t “believe” in climate change or think there is actually “another side” are generally beyond reason."

Now, I dont think that as a whole, the US is just a bunch of dumbasses (speaking for the north where I live at least :p ) but I would cite the money trail and motivations to create 'doubt' in the first place. I note the recent 'Climategate hoax' hoax, or the whole 'my Hummer is greener than your Prius because the nickel used in the batteries (even though the huge frame of the Hummer uses about 5x as much as the whole Prius)'. I will also note that for the most part, these 'conspiracy theories' only exist and survive in the US. Why would that be?

Well, as the world's #1 oil consumer (by a wide margin), and home to some big oil companies, its no shocker that THIS would be the country they would try to keep from 'jumping on the bandwagon'. These companies spend billions on marketing and propaganda... so sending a few million to some shell-corporation that in turn hires some fake scientists and starts a misinformation campaign to generate doubt seems easy enough to me. You 'doubters' may think you are so 'non conformist', but you were spoon fed those ideas by marketing. You think that 'icecap' website that claims to give honest 'doubter' science isnt indirectly funded by oil companies? Think again. Follow the money... that alone might change your mind.
 
Like the old adage, the best way to make the people disbelieve something, is to get the village idiot to shout that it's true.
 
Plus, thanks for your posts undertheradar, though once you start trying to convince anti-conspiracy theorists about conspiracy theories, it gets messy :p

As it is now, the only thing we ever seem to hear is "We're tackling global warming". This of course brings in the whole debate on the extent of man made global warming. I think it'd generally be more productive if we tackled the whole environmental impact we have on the planet, and included greenhouse emissions into the problem, regardless of whether it effects global warming or not.

The planet is a very complex organism, with a lot of individual cycles all working to maintain a balance. Until we understand it further, we should treat it with a bit of respect.
 
This article was in the Australian newspaper about a month or 2 ago, and was explained in far more detail and with more logic than now. The idea itself is sound. The fact that it will reduce the amount of solar radiation that enters the atmosphere is sound. The only barrier for this project is getting public approval, and this requires far more alarmist techniques of spreading information, as the original AGW idea has shown.
 
Dont bother. Read that link that I posted and you will see why...
"I could offer personal data, personal observations, but there is no convincing some people. The real crux of the matter is largely one that exists in the US. Our understanding and level of science education is so low, and the topics of anthropogenic climate change so diverse and complex, that I have found arguing to actually give credence to debate that doesn’t exist. Those who don’t “believe” in climate change or think there is actually “another side” are generally beyond reason."

Now, I dont think that as a whole, the US is just a bunch of dumbasses (speaking for the north where I live at least :p ) but I would cite the money trail and motivations to create 'doubt' in the first place. I note the recent 'Climategate hoax' hoax, or the whole 'my Hummer is greener than your Prius because the nickel used in the batteries (even though the huge frame of the Hummer uses about 5x as much as the whole Prius)'. I will also note that for the most part, these 'conspiracy theories' only exist and survive in the US. Why would that be?

Well, as the world's #1 oil consumer (by a wide margin), and home to some big oil companies, its no shocker that THIS would be the country they would try to keep from 'jumping on the bandwagon'. These companies spend billions on marketing and propaganda... so sending a few million to some shell-corporation that in turn hires some fake scientists and starts a misinformation campaign to generate doubt seems easy enough to me. You 'doubters' may think you are so 'non conformist', but you were spoon fed those ideas by marketing. You think that 'icecap' website that claims to give honest 'doubter' science isnt indirectly funded by oil companies? Think again. Follow the money... that alone might change your mind.


I wanted to be a Marine Biologist, but I became an Electrical Engineer instead. After living in 4 different countries throughout the American continent I have arrived at the conclusion that at any given time 80% of the people are stupid 80% of the time(even the smart ones) Einstien's relativity theory's history is proof of that. And that nationality(that involves all sorts of experiences and conditions) does not determines that. It's just the availability and the power smart people(mostly being realizing they have been stupid) can get which can save our future.
 
Dont bother. Read that link that I posted and you will see why...
"I could offer personal data, personal observations, but there is no convincing some people. The real crux of the matter is largely one that exists in the US. Our understanding and level of science education is so low, and the topics of anthropogenic climate change so diverse and complex, that I have found arguing to actually give credence to debate that doesn’t exist. Those who don’t “believe” in climate change or think there is actually “another side” are generally beyond reason."

Now, I dont think that as a whole, the US is just a bunch of dumbasses (speaking for the north where I live at least :p ) but I would cite the money trail and motivations to create 'doubt' in the first place. I note the recent 'Climategate hoax' hoax, or the whole 'my Hummer is greener than your Prius because the nickel used in the batteries (even though the huge frame of the Hummer uses about 5x as much as the whole Prius)'. I will also note that for the most part, these 'conspiracy theories' only exist and survive in the US. Why would that be?

Well, as the world's #1 oil consumer (by a wide margin), and home to some big oil companies, its no shocker that THIS would be the country they would try to keep from 'jumping on the bandwagon'. These companies spend billions on marketing and propaganda... so sending a few million to some shell-corporation that in turn hires some fake scientists and starts a misinformation campaign to generate doubt seems easy enough to me. You 'doubters' may think you are so 'non conformist', but you were spoon fed those ideas by marketing. You think that 'icecap' website that claims to give honest 'doubter' science isnt indirectly funded by oil companies? Think again. Follow the money... that alone might change your mind.
I'm gonna apply here the same logic Glenn beck(I saw part of the video) used for the Socialization of the U.S. If human industry affects the planetary system with inputs which were not estimated on the original design, Does it matter?

While stupids on both sides argue who is green or not, the planet keeps crumbling away. Let's be social, let's fight!!
Same shit happened in history over and over again, first thing comes to mid. Fidel Castro and his way to power. It was predicted all he wanted was absolute power and since Hitler was gone he was gonna become an ally of the Russians. Yet, they released him
from prison, ergo: Cuba got screwed by short sighted morons who only know how to argue.
 
Plus, thanks for your posts undertheradar, though once you start trying to convince anti-conspiracy theorists about conspiracy theories, it gets messy :p

As it is now, the only thing we ever seem to hear is "We're tackling global warming". This of course brings in the whole debate on the extent of man made global warming. I think it'd generally be more productive if we tackled the whole environmental impact we have on the planet, and included greenhouse emissions into the problem, regardless of whether it effects global warming or not.

The planet is a very complex organism, with a lot of individual cycles all working to maintain a balance. Until we understand it further, we should treat it with a bit of respect.

That's easy. WWIII reduce the population to 1/3. Problem solved....
 
Maybe we could have it looked at by other scientist in the field that have not already made up their mind, or as it seems to be anymore, have not had grant money make up their minds for them. This thing they have going on where only other believers get to peer review them, or they throw a fit and hide the research, (take their ball and run home), makes me wonder. They are giving the appearance of a impropriety. That does not make you wonder at all?

It was meant to be funny, I failed. However, can you say they are not acting like that? If they think there is a possibility of dissent, they run away with the data, or strong arm. I have already said, I have no clue whether or not humans are contributing in any serious way to climate change on a global level. Only that these supposedly respectable scientists are not acting the role, but instead are acting like this is some kind of church where any dissent is blasphemy. It makes it difficult for me accept what they say with out the proverbial grain of salt.

Would it not be reasonable that a grouping of people by profession would tend to agree with reasonably well made arguments about topics within their field? To insinuate that they're somehow all attempting to perpetrate some worldwide fraud is a rather extraordinary claim based upon your general speculation. Imagine a room full of Ph D physicists. By your reason, wouldn't it be highly suspicious that they all tend to believe the Ehrenfest theorem? Or for that matter, doesn't it seem devious that there seems to be a consensus of truth among mathematicians regarding Stokes' theorem?

That's down right creepy if you ask me :p.

I would recommend giving this a read:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climatic_Research_Unit_e-mail_hacking_incident

Several of the emails were selectively released (ones that would have put other seemingly damning messages into context were conveniently withheld). The believed breach was larger than the information leaked to the public, which suggests that it was filtered beforehand to maximize its effect.

As for the allegations of collusion and scientific fraud in the peer review process,

"An 8 July 2004 e-mail from Phil Jones to Michael Mann said in part:
'The other paper by MM is just garbage. [...] I can't see either of these papers being in the next IPCC report. Kevin and I will keep them out somehow — even if we have to redefine what the peer-review literature is!'

Defenders of CRU say the papers mentioned in this email were Kalnay and Cai (2003) and McKitrick and Michaels (2004), which were cited and discussed in Chapter 2 of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) AR4 report.[39] Peter Kelemen, a professor of geochemistry at Columbia University's Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, said that "If scientists attempted to exclude critics' peer-reviewed papers from IPCC reports, this was unethical in my view." Dr. Rajendra Pachauri, chairman of the IPCC, responded that the IPCC has "a very transparent, a very comprehensive process which ensures that even if someone wants to leave out a piece of peer reviewed literature there is virtually no possibility of that happening.

The University of East Anglia's commission will evaluate whether CRU's peer-review practices comply with best scientific practice."

Take it as you will, I'm not entirely familiar with the long personal history between these individuals, but it obviously seems contentious. However, the personal ranting to a friend in an email one has a reasonable expectation of privacy within can hardly be construed as a massive global effort by all people in a similar field to systematically engage in massive fraud. It is much more reasonable to believe they would follow some procedure to discourage the inclusion of the paper by pointing out fatal flaws (which is generally how a peer review process works, in a very basic sense), rather than suppressing valid data. He just said that more angrily :)

What I've found the most fascinating about this whole event is that it underscores a general inadequacy in our population to understand the scientific process, rather than some global conspiracy. We are either intimidated by things we don't know, or are shifting to be untrusting of those who do have knowledge we lack. While skepticism is healthy, denial without reason is only damaging. I'm not a climatologist, so I can't assert that I fully understand all the issues at play in their conclusions, but given access to enough digestible information for their arguments to remain consistent on a high level, I tend to believe professionals, particularly when other unassociated members of their field certify their work as correct. While not the best method (the best would be learning it all myself), it is fairly solid ground. For this same reason, I believe doctors and the treatments they recommend for illness. Of course you can find a bad doctor, one that either lies out of apathy, greed, or malice, but that is hardly representative of the field as a whole (where medical advances have saved and extended all of our lives). The same applies to every field, including Climatology.

For example, is not proof.


And I most certainly do not want people, I have come to seriously doubt, to ACTIVELY attempt to alter our climate. Reduce CO2 emissions, and pollution, sure why not, it's a great idea, perhaps even needful. Attempt to alter our climate intentionally, with some crazy contraption that shoots crap into the air, uhh no thanks.

To be fair, Nathan Myhrvold, while a smart man in his own right just by his previous accomplishments, isn't really an expert in the field. I've not been able to find further information, but I don't believe this is a particularly popular solution (I think it's in the fringe category, but someone should correct me if you find anything about it). I'm not losing any sleep over this :)

I think the lesson many of us miss is not that we should fear that the end of the world will be brought swiftly based upon the seemingly innocuous activities of man, but rather that we should be ever vigilant of the impact our rapidly expanding and energy hungry population is having upon our environment; and I don't argue this out of some save the world kind of sense, I'm looking out for my own ass, 100% self interest here. Consider that only recently in our history have we begun to really emit a volume of gases (pollutants or otherwise) that could change the percent composition of our atmosphere. Whether you believe this will have no, a beneficial, or a detrimental effect is not the point. What I think we all can agree on is that this new set of conditions that have never been present on earth before (a species capable of influencing global atmospheric composition by something other than breathing and producing bodily waste) has the potential to generate unforeseen events, and we would want to be prepared for them.
 
Back
Top