New Anti Global Warming Scheme

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I’m no expert but, does this plan sound like it will even work? What next? Running a hose up there and pumping all the pollution into space? Actually, that sounds better than the original idea.

Nathan Myhrvold also thinks that he has found a cheap and reliable way to solve global warming, which does not involve upending and perhaps destroying the world's economy. The global warming solution proposed by Nathan Myhvold involves running a hose up to the stratosphere with balloons and using that hose to pump out enough sulfur particles to dim the sun's heat just enough to counteract the effects of global warming.
 
I think "Global Warming" is just something that is to big for us to even understand, and even more problamatic if we think we can control it. People forget that the climate on this planet has been changing for the entire life of the planet, not just in the last few thousand years. if we were headed into another ice age there would be nothing we could do about it and I would bet that the efforts to stop it would just make things worse.
 
Well, if he has $250 million to burn, it's his call.
 
I think "Global Warming" is just something that is to big for us to even understand, and even more problamatic if we think we can control it. People forget that the climate on this planet has been changing for the entire life of the planet, not just in the last few thousand years. if we were headed into another ice age there would be nothing we could do about it and I would bet that the efforts to stop it would just make things worse.

Yep. Let's forget the sun and the global dynamo. Everything is caused by pollution. Ugh...
 
The current science behind global warming has not even faced peer review outside of their religion, let alone been proven.

If they are too afraid to allow proper peer review and attempt to ruin any publication publishes a dissent or any peer that disagrees with them, then I really don't want those sort of people taking ACTIVE steps to alter our climate.
Scream about reducing carbon emissions and green house gasses until someone believes them and passes laws to placate them, fine. ACTIVELY try and alter our climate, HELL NO to that.
 
Yes, I'm sure these scientists with 20+ years of experience working in this field have forgotten that the earth goes through climate cycles. That or maybe, just maybe, they're slightly more informed than you on this issue.
 
I think I'd rather put my trust in people who have an agenda involving saving the world instead of those that are interested in saving their money.

Anyways, this plan is kinda nuts. Lets sort out the science first and get a better idea of what exactly is going on before trying to fix it. This really sounds a lot like a "scorch the sky" approach, and last I checked that turned humanity into batteries living in a large virtual reality for 1 great movie and 2 crummy ones.
 
Yes, I'm sure these scientists with 20+ years of experience working in this field have forgotten that the earth goes through climate cycles. That or maybe, just maybe, they're slightly more informed than you on this issue.

Money does wonderful things... are you really that naïve to think otherwise?
 
All I can say is Climategate. Tell these morons where they can shove it.
 
Are these fucking people kidding me? Save the planet?

We don't even know how to take care of ourselves yet! We don't know how to care for one another and we're going to save the fucking planet?

- George Carlin
 
Nice to see the truth has been revealed enough that someone on this board knows about climategate..There may be hope for humans yet!
 
I don't think he has to worry about securing that I.P.

Also, the debate is about whether or not man created global warming. The global climate is warming despite all the banter. Man might have not put the polar bears in jeopardy, but they're not doing so well right now either way. There's also a few cities that might beg to differ concerning rising water levels.

To me the threat is more about people ignoring what is going to change rather than focusing on meaningful changes. Companies buying green points... probably not as important as reducing the use of fossil fuels (smog sucks). Water levels will rise more and cities all over the world will have problems. That's a financial issue to many countries in our life times. So, not so much about the poor pandas and more about the welfare of our lives as we live them now. Change happens (except people arguing about silly stuff).
 
good idea, pump enough that us humans will start getting poisoned and die off.
 
I've heard of a similar scheme, but they got the sulfur into the stratosphere by adding it to jet fuel.
 
Is the planet warming? Maybe

Is it our fault? No.

Should developed countries be "held responsible" for their "evil carbon dioxide producing ways of life"? NO.

Should we give money to countries because they (falsely) guilt trip us into believing it's our fault? NO.

If the earth is warming, I suggest you get air conditioning. Because there's no way in hell we can stop it.
 
Is the planet warming? Maybe

Is it our fault? No.

Should developed countries be "held responsible" for their "evil carbon dioxide producing ways of life"? NO.

Should we give money to countries because they (falsely) guilt trip us into believing it's our fault? NO.

If the earth is warming, I suggest you get air conditioning. Because there's no way in hell we can stop it.
BINGO!!!
Thank you for making my day.
Merry Christmas to you sir.
 
I know! Let's get to the root of the problem. The sun. We should NUKE THE SUN!
 
Yes, I'm sure these scientists with 20+ years of experience working in this field have forgotten that the earth goes through climate cycles. That or maybe, just maybe, they're slightly more informed than you on this issue.


its all about the money.. you really think how much government funding some of these scientists are getting.. this whole global warming crap has become way to commercialized thanks to Al Gore's sorry ass..

as for the idea.. its a good short term fix.. until 60 years down the road when all that sulfur starts falling back to the earth..

the day the temps actually rise where i live ill believe global warming is actually happening.. in the last 6 years the avg temp in northern california has dropped.. not gone up.. 6 years ago we had 32 days of 100+ degree temps during the summer.. last year we had 5 days of 100 or more.. year before it was 8 days.. 11 days the year before that and 14 the year before that.. so if this is global warming.. i hope it keeps happening..
 
I think I'd rather put my trust in people who have an agenda involving saving the world instead of those that are interested in saving their money.

Not sure what you are trying to say here. Everyone who meets the first criteria, those in a position to garner trust that "have an agenda involving saving the world", by definition also meets the second criteria, "those that are interested in saving their money." Indeed, almost everyone that meets the first criteria take it a step further into the realm of "those looking to make lots more money."

Examples:

If by your first criteria you meant climatologists, as a group they are making a ridiculous amount of money from government grants and other sources as long as they keep the climate change issue front and center. This carries out to a large number of related scientific and engineering groups as well, just look at GE and their various "climate saving" projects.

If by your first criteria you meant politicians, as a group they gain power through fear. The fear of man made climate change gives them tons of power over everyone, especially over private companies that create any form of pollution (meaning all of them).

If by your first criteria you meant Al Gore, well he makes a ridiculous amount of money from his books and speaking engagements. He spent years trying to find some political issue that he could grab hold of and use to suck the life out of the common man. He finally got lucky and has been sucking at the teat of "global warming/climate change" ever since.

If by your first criteria you meant the "common man" who is trying to lower his CO2 emissions... Anyone will tell you putting your trust in the "common man" as a group is just stupid. The "common man" will let you down almost every time, unless you chose the clearly most profitable option to trust him on.
 
The earth is getting colder so what? Is it really our fault? No way. Do you really thing we can breed enough Brontosarus' to make enough methane to heat up the earth? Maybe.

Dinosapien

P.S. OH Crap it going too hi
 
I find it really funny that you think the world is not warming, do you ever watch politicians(Especially Obama) these days, they're releasing more carbon dioxide then anything else.

Trust me, it's warming!!!!!

"According to a new U.N. report, the global warming outlook is much worse than originally predicted. Which is pretty bad when they originally predicted it would destroy the planet." --Jay Leno





But in all seriousness, the problem isn't global warming or climate change. It's a government getting out of hand and trying to become a global government.

We forget the lessons of history at our peril. In the midst of plenty, the Roman people forgot what freedom entailed. They forgot "The Essence of Freedom is the proper limitation of government". When government grows peoples' freedoms recede.For those who have not fully grasped that successful western nations are founded on Republican principles, why total democracy is bad for you. An old saying - Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner.(Note: Reps and Dems both got too greedy and ate the sheep as well)
 
Yes, I'm sure these scientists with 20+ years of experience working in this field have forgotten that the earth goes through climate cycles. That or maybe, just maybe, they're slightly more informed than you on this issue.

Or maybe they are cooking the books, and dissenters aren't getting grants
 
Should we give money to KLEPTOCRACIES because they (falsely) guilt trip us into believing it's our fault? NO.

Nice post, but had to fix that to reflect that any such socialist schemes would enrich dictators, not people.
 
The real scary thing is when clueless assholes with more money than brains like Nathan Myhrvold think they can build a real-world version of Mr. Burns sun blocking machine in some vain attempt to save us all from ourselves. They have no idea what all of the natural processes are that drive climate change (and it is always changing). And yet they have this grand plan for altering a process they don't understand and then have the balls to claim that they can do so without any unintended consequences. These are the real villians, they will ultimately kill us all in their vain quest to "save the planet".
 
I guess this guy missed the lecture on how acid rain works...

What's next? Run a hose over Australia and pump ozone up there too?
 
I think I'd rather put my trust in people who have an agenda involving saving the world instead of those that are interested in saving their money.

Anyways, this plan is kinda nuts. Lets sort out the science first and get a better idea of what exactly is going on before trying to fix it. This really sounds a lot like a "scorch the sky" approach, and last I checked that turned humanity into batteries living in a large virtual reality for 1 great movie and 2 crummy ones.

They aren't interested in that. They are interested in getting rich off of ridiculous ideas.
 
Nice to see the truth has been revealed enough that someone on this board knows about climategate..There may be hope for humans yet!

Oh, there was quite the discussion about it in the SoapBox.

the day the temps actually rise where i live ill believe global warming is actually happening.. in the last 6 years the avg temp in northern california has dropped.. not gone up.. 6 years ago we had 32 days of 100+ degree temps during the summer.. last year we had 5 days of 100 or more.. year before it was 8 days.. 11 days the year before that and 14 the year before that.. so if this is global warming.. i hope it keeps happening..

Please stop debating a subject you know nothing about. All scientists agree that global warming (whether humans are causing it or not) means the global average temperature is going up - although by a very small amount of less than ten degrees. You certainly wouldn't feel the increase. The main effects of global warming we will "feel" are increased sea levels and an increased moisture level in the atmosphere, both caused by melting polar ice. This abundance of water will result in a more extreme climate: colder in some places, warmer in others, and more volatile everywhere.

But seriously: to not believe the climate is warming at all because the number of 100+ degree days in Northern California has dropped over the past six years means you know nothing about climate. Sorry. :(

Not sure what you are trying to say here. Everyone who meets the first criteria, those in a position to garner trust that "have an agenda involving saving the world", by definition also meets the second criteria, "those that are interested in saving their money." Indeed, almost everyone that meets the first criteria take it a step further into the realm of "those looking to make lots more money."

So let me propose to you a scenario that, you must agree, is at least a possibility. What if the scientists are right - the Earth is warming due to human causes - and we have the ability to stop it? As you say, these scientists would stand to make a lot of money in their efforts to save the world. Would that invalidate their research? Does that mean we should all ignore them?

It isn't fair to automatically assume a scientist is lying because he stands to profit from his ideas.

I say we just let the "green revolution" run its course. A switch to renewable energy is achievable with our current technology and will significantly boost the economy, reduce pollution everywhere, save various forms of wildlife and the industries they power, prevent resource scarcity problems down the road, and, specifically for the United States, reduce dependence on unstable foreign resources. If it ends up saving the planet in the process, let that be icing on the cake. There are plenty of reasons to move toward sustainable environmental practices other than global warming.

As for trying to directly influence the climate with sun-dimming projects of a massive scale; yeah, that couldn't possibly go wrong. :rolleyes: Not worth the risk; not even close.
 
What if the scientists are right - the Earth is warming due to human causes - and we have the ability to stop it?

The problem with this entire Global Warming thing is that there's NEVER been evidence that points to us as being the source of Global Warming, Climate Change, Global Change, Climate warming, whatever.

All of the "evidence" thus far has been either misinterpreted or severely "tweaked".
 
Calm down guys, it's getting a little "warm" in here!
"Warm"....get it....hehhee....anyone....Bueller......Bueller.....

Whether global warming/cooling is real or not, doesn't matter as it's either too late or we've already doomed ourselves (humans) in other ways.
 
I think the only way scientists can motivate the general public to clean up the environment is by telling everyone the world is going to end if they don't stop polluting it. Global warming is probably a sham but perhaps the ends justify the means.
 
I think the only way scientists can motivate the general public to clean up the environment is by telling everyone the world is going to end if they don't stop polluting it. Global warming is probably a sham but perhaps the ends justify the means.

Pollution is under control and getting better as we create new technologies. They don't need to lie about Global Warming to reduce pollution.
 
To add to my previous statement, I had no intentions of siding with either party. The fact is, maybe.. 1/10 people here have actual experience with lab research of any kind. This means 9/10 people are just blowing smoke out their ass and banging out conjectures.

Truth is independent of who's getting paid, fools. If I gave Al Gore 2 billion dollars to say your mothers not a whore, does that make it a lie? No, the fact is, funding comes for a reason. It's not always Dr. Evil in his volcano lair - sometimes it is, but not always. Very few people on this forum have any knowledge beyond propaganda they hear - be it in TV, magazines, huffington post, drudge report, whatever.

This isn't to say we shouldn't comment on news like this but come up with something better than "OMG STUPID GLOBAL WARMING SCIENTISTS AREN'T THEY DUMB."
 
Back
Top