FTC Sues Intel for 'Anticompetitive Tactics'

I think in all fairness after that, for this sake of the thread, this topic should be dropped. Lollipop is obviously entitled to his own opinion, which he feels emphatically about, and no one is going to shift their political, philosophical, or economical views after reading a couple paragraphs on a tech site. At this point further argumentation by all groups will just be a bunch of guys fuming at a keyboard and raising their blood pressure for no reason. Stress kills (and I can cite that!), so don't let someone else's fairly entitled opinion ruin your mood.
 
Kinda reminds me of some of the piracy suits i hear about. You know, the ones where people get fined thousands of dollars for 1 song and yet people here complain that it's to much to pay. But yet it's OK that Intel has to keep paying BILLIONS to all these countries to which none of that money will help AMD nor consumers?

…then who's driving the prices in the market place up and stifling innovation? ;)
 
I think in all fairness after that, for this sake of the thread, this topic should be dropped. Lollipop is obviously entitled to his own opinion, which he feels emphatically about, and no one is going to shift their political, philosophical, or economical views after reading a couple paragraphs on a tech site. At this point further argumentation by all groups will just be a bunch of guys fuming at a keyboard and raising their blood pressure for no reason. Stress kills (and I can cite that!), so don't let someone else's fairly entitled opinion ruin your mood.

Whatever happened to "what doesn't kill you stronger" and "adversity builds character”? :D
 
…then who's driving the prices in the market place up and stifling innovation? ;)
Stifling innovation? Like i said, AMD seemed to had enough money to acquire ATI but not enough to put into R&D to put out better chips? Come on.


Your right alexthebored, except I'm not stressed about it :), in the end it's just a tech site and nothing more :).
Either way, some people agree with this and some don't, we are all entitled to our opinions and nothing is going to change that.
 
This suit has more to do with nvidia than AMD.
Intel sells Atom+chipset for *less* than they sell just Atom. OEMs have to pay a tax for not using their shitty IGP.
They are obviously abusing their strong position in CPUs to avoid competing with ION on technical merits.
Its disgusting and undefendable.
 
Stifling innovation? Like i said, AMD seemed to had enough money to acquire ATI but not enough to put into R&D to put out better chips? Come on.


Your right alexthebored, except I'm not stressed about it :), in the end it's just a tech site and nothing more :).
Either way, some people agree with this and some don't, we are all entitled to our opinions and nothing is going to change that.

Wow. I was joking and I agree with you. Read my post above yours. I said the same thing
 
I'm not loosing sanity over any of these posts either, but I have sacrificed and served this nation for twenty years and I feel strongly enough not to stop defending her honor and her freedom’s. And I love a good debate. The funny thing is the nastiness did not originate with me. I thought it was getting kind of petty as well so I backed off until I could see if some of the vitriol had validity. It did not.
 
If you assume that AMD would have had greater innovation and market share in the absence of Intel's market manipulation, you would also have to assume that to take advantage of the fair market AMD would have to have a CEO who could pour piss out of boot with instructions on the heel....oops.
 
Those damn EuroCommies always going after good honest American companies who do nothing wrong
Europe should learn to innovate rather then steal cash from american companies

Europe is after a quick buck that is all
 
This suit has more to do with nvidia than AMD.
Intel sells Atom+chipset for *less* than they sell just Atom. OEMs have to pay a tax for not using their shitty IGP.
They are obviously abusing their strong position in CPUs to avoid competing with ION on technical merits.
Its disgusting and undefendable.

exaclty this has very little to do with AMD. It's all about nvidia, thats when intel got back on the FTC radar. They were idoits plain and simple and I said at the time, and any lawyer that is compentent, should have inform intel of thier foolishness.

They simple had no good justification for denying nvidia the license. the only reason they had was to stiffle competetion period.

They better pray, that the FTC does not seek the obvious remedy, which is to break the company up and seperate the cpu part from the chipset part.

So stupid by intel, and totally unneccassary thier ego got in the way of common business sense.
 
That funny, I could have sworn that I bought an HP laptop with an AMD processor during that period of time. Oh and my wife's Sony VAIO with an AMD Duron didn't exist either? I must have REALLY been on something heavy to make me hallucinate about the several dozen AMD Sempron, Athlon 64, Athlon X2 systems from 1st and 2nd tier OEM's that I've worked on in the last five years.

If Intel was paying these companies not to use AMD processors in their products, then why in the world were these companies still making products with AMD processors?

Maybe not every company followed through with it. Maybe they are speaking of some companies that YOU havent worked on their brand computers. No one said they completely stopped buying AMD. They are saying Intel was basically threatening the companies to buy MORE from Intel or else was going to screw over their current supplies by sandbagging shipments. It really isnt that hard of a concept to understand.


I dont agree with the everything the FTC is saying, but I do believe it is wrong to threaten companies in order to keep the majority of the business.
 
Holy crap Lollipop, do you really believe all that drivel you posted?
 
I'm not loosing sanity over any of these posts either, but I have sacrificed and served this nation for twenty years and I feel strongly enough not to stop defending her honor and her freedom’s.

Hi Lollipop,

Much to your chagrin I'm sure, the law in pretty much every developed country states that anti-competitive behaviour by a company in a monopoly position is illegal. People don't really care to defend a company's freedom to bone over consumers.
 
No Azhar and jimmyb, I think we should all follow the failed policies of socialism in America as well. And saying they boned over consumers is like saying all the prettier and more talented singers deserve something from record producers because they got passed over for the likes of Britney Spears.
 
Yes Azhar, he really does believe all the drivel he just posted. Thats what happens when you take arbitrary and nebulous terms like "free-market capitalism" and "socialism" from ideas to full blown ideologies. You start to sound crazy.
 
this is not the first time intel has crossed paths with the FTC as a result of their actions --> just over ten years ago the FTC and intel went at it: http://www.ftc.gov/opa/1998/06/intelc.shtm

anyone remember that? here's some snips:

The FTC alleged Intel illegally used its market power when it denied three of its customers continuing access to technical information necessary to develop computer systems based on Intel microprocessors, and took other steps to punish them for refusing to license key patents on Intel’s terms. These three companies -- Digital Equipment Corporation, Intergraph Corporation and Compaq Computer Corporation -- hold important patents on microprocessor and related technologies. When they sought to enforce those patents against Intel or other computer companies who buy Intel products, Intel retaliated by cutting off the necessary technical information and threatening to cut off the supply of microprocessors...

In November 1994 Compaq sued another computer systems manufacturer, Packard Bell Electronics, Inc. for using patented Compaq technology in Packard Bell motherboards. Intel, the supplier of the motherboards, intervened on Packard Bell’s side, because Intel had an obligation to indemnify Packard Bell. In response to Compaq’s assertion of its intellectual property rights in motherboards, Intel cut off technical information that Compaq needs in order to design systems based on Intel’s newest chips, even though that technical information is widely available to similarly situated computer manufacturers. Intel restored Compaq’s access to technical information only after Compaq agreed to cross-license its patents with Intel.

here's another funny bit from the same go around: http://www.cnn.com/TECH/computing/9903/03/moreintel.idg/index.html

The accusation that Intel prevented OEMs from differentiating their products was first raised by archrival Advanced Micro Devices in a 1997 government regulatory filing, Intel's brief notes. Intel rejected the "AMD-manufactured claim" as a "bizarre theory" that can be discredited by evidence.

ten years later you pay AMD $1.25 billion for that "manufactured claim" and "bizarre theory" to go away. not to mention giving them whatever they want including the going fabless option of which you at one point threatened as a means for you to rightfully strip their x86 privileges.. all the while you have been long dealing with the FTC behind the curtain to make the chances of this suit occurring in public unlikely.

i can't see why anyone would find any other ruling than not guilty.

- Robert (PmR)DeathInJune

 
No Azhar and jimmyb, I think we should all follow the failed policies of socialism in America as well. And saying they boned over consumers is like saying all the prettier and more talented singers deserve something from record producers because they got passed over for the likes of Britney Spears.

You seem to be falsely equating socialism and competition laws; they are in fact two orthogonal concepts. One is an economic system,and the other law governing the conduct of businesses.
 
No Azhar and jimmyb, I think we should all follow the failed policies of socialism in America as well. And saying they boned over consumers is like saying all the prettier and more talented singers deserve something from record producers because they got passed over for the likes of Britney Spears.

Do you think it's ok for a company to tell it's vendors, if you do business with our competitor we will withhold our parts from you?

That's what this is about. Socialism has nothing to do with this law suit.
 
I agree with you to a point. I only agree with whatever country the OEM main offices are in that Intel strong armed into using there chip over AMD, not every frigging country on the face of the planet(as it seems to be now).


Funny how AMD wasn't worried about this when they decided to acquire ATI, at a time when they supposedly didnt even have money for R&D ;).


A few billion times how many countries before it's all over? I'm not aying they arent guilty, but come on this shit is getting out of control.

Kinda reminds me of some of the piracy suits i hear about. You know, the ones where people get fined thousands of dollars for 1 song and yet people here complain that it's to much to pay. But yet it's OK that Intel has to keep paying BILLIONS to all these countries to which none of that money will help AMD nor consumers?

You sound like you're saying "sure, they should be punished, but they shouldn't be punished". The fact is, if they should be punished, then they should be punished according to prescribed documentation (see: law). If they shouldn't be punished, then they shouldn't be punished at all. There's only one right way to punish, and that's underlined above. There's none of this "oh, I have pity for you, let's settle for something in between".
 
Thats what they get for ruining amd. They were telling all pc manufacturers to use their cpus over amds or else for the longest time.
 
Speaking of all the PC manufacturers,what's their responsibility in all this? After all,if big companies like Dell didn't play along with Intel,none of this would have happened.Assuming the bottom line played the major role in their decision,and when hasn't it in the world of business,maybe they did so because Intel's products are what sold the best.And if Intel's tactics were responsible for preventing AMD from coming up with a better product,why was their partner ATI,facing equally tough opposition from Nvidia,able to come up with superior graphics cards?
 
Do you think it's ok for a company to tell it's vendors, if you do business with our competitor we will withhold our parts from you?

That's what this is about. Socialism has nothing to do with this law suit.

And the socialist ideology of "it's not fair to best the other guy" is running rampant in a once competitive economic environment. No company was ever refused free will. The Socialistic mindset is what stifles competition through regulations that prevent innovation and merit driven growth. Sometimes winning is about working harder and sometimes it’s about working smarter or more shrewdly. The funny thing is you guys sit your whole lives all high and mighty behind your keyboards second-hand theorizing while I have seen these effects with my eyes. Nothing stifles growth like government intervention by trying to handicap the leaders. This just like when you guys didn’t get picked on the playground as kids and crying because it wasn’t fair. Cry me a river.
 
You sound like you're saying "sure, they should be punished, but they shouldn't be punished". The fact is, if they should be punished, then they should be punished according to prescribed documentation (see: law). If they shouldn't be punished, then they shouldn't be punished at all. There's only one right way to punish, and that's underlined above. There's none of this "oh, I have pity for you, let's settle for something in between".
I guess you failed to read this part below, that i posted.
03grandam said:
I only agree with whatever country the OEM main offices are in that Intel strong armed into using there chip over AMD, not every frigging country on the face of the planet
I agree with punishment, but only from the countries who hold the main offices of said OEM's. Not every frigging country out there that wants a piece of the pie.
 
Thats what they get for ruining amd. They were telling all pc manufacturers to use their cpus over amds or else for the longest time.

It's amazing that 8 pages in and you still haven't read what the lawsuit is about. Hint: It's not just about AMD...
 
Do you think it's ok for a company to tell it's vendors, if you do business with our competitor we will withhold our parts from you?
That's what this is about. Socialism has nothing to do with this law suit.
And the socialist ideology of "it's not fair to best the other guy" is running rampant in a once competitive economic environment. No company was ever refused free will. The Socialistic mindset is what stifles competition through regulations that prevent innovation and merit driven growth. Sometimes winning is about working harder and sometimes it’s about working smarter or more shrewdly. The funny thing is you guys sit your whole lives all high and mighty behind your keyboards second-hand theorizing while I have seen these effects with my eyes. Nothing stifles growth like government intervention by trying to handicap the leaders. This just like when you guys didn’t get picked on the playground as kids and crying because it wasn’t fair. Cry me a river.

I asked a one sentence question, and you manged to type a paragraph and never answer that question.

Care to try again? Hint: it's a yes or no question.
 
I asked a one sentence question, and you manged to type a paragraph and never answer that question.

Care to try again? Hint: it's a yes or no question.

To simpify things with a short bus answer: I would say yes, but then again I thought that would be apparent. My response was to the second question in your post--which also answered the first with a little effort on your part. Silly me for assuming. :rolleyes:
 
To simpify things with a short bus answer: I would say yes, but then again I thought that would be apparent. My response was to the second question in your post--which also answered the first with a little effort on your part. Silly me for assuming. :rolleyes:

OK, so there you go. You don't believe that companies have to follow the laws. Fair enough. Most people in this country believe that we're all supposed to follow the law. And considering the Sherman Antitrust act has been around for 120 years and Clayton Antitrust Act has been around for almost 100 years, it's safe to say this is settled law.
 
OK, so there you go. You don't believe that companies have to follow the laws. Fair enough. Most people in this country believe that we're all supposed to follow the law. And considering the Sherman Antitrust act has been around for 120 years and Clayton Antitrust Act has been around for almost 100 years, it's safe to say this is settled law.

It is fairly safe to say that in the egomaniacally, covetous, "nanny-state" world we live in almost everything one does can be found to be illegal somewhere, but that doesn't make it commiserate with free markets or free will.
 
It is fairly safe to say that in the egomaniacally, covetous, "nanny-state" world we live in almost everything one does can be found to be illegal somewhere, but that doesn't make it commiserate with free markets or free will.

Preventing illegal monopolies =! nanny state.

But it's obvious to us by now you have no idea what you're talking about.
 
Preventing illegal monopolies =! nanny state.

But it's obvious to us by now you have no idea what you're talking about.

Why are you people still talking to him? He's obviously a troll, he rants and he rants while ignoring responses completely. Just block him and get it over with, there's a certain kind of stupid you just can't fix.
 
Why are you people still talking to him? He's obviously a troll, he rants and he rants while ignoring responses completely. Just block him and get it over with, there's a certain kind of stupid you just can't fix.

It's a slow morning here at work and he amuses me ;)

After tomorrow I'm on vacation for 2 weeks, so in the meantime I need entertainment.
 
It is fairly safe to say that in the egomaniacally, covetous, "nanny-state" world we live in almost everything one does can be found to be illegal somewhere, but that doesn't make it commiserate with free markets or free will.

Dude, you're wrong. These laws existed long before there was this so-called nanny state.
Your arguments hold no weight, unless you manage to change a couple of 100+ year old laws.

Then again, this topic has nothing to do with the nanny state.
 
Back
Top